This publication contains the written answers to questions tabled by Members. The content of the responses is as received at the time from the relevant Minister or representative of the Assembly Commission and has not been subject to the official reporting process or changed in any way.

Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister
Agriculture and Rural Development
Culture, Arts and Leisure
Education
Employment and Learning
Enterprise, Trade and Investment
Environment
Finance and Personnel
Health, Social Services and Public Safety
Regional Development
Social Development
Assembly Commission

Monday 04 August 2008

Written Answers to Questions

Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister

Hate Crime

Mr Elliott asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail the action the department is taking to reduce the incidents of hate crime.

(AQW 4967/08)

The First Minister and deputy First Minister (Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness): The Executive is committed to tackling hate crimes wherever and however they occur.

While criminal justice matters remain to be transferred, we will work closely with the police service and criminal justice agencies to tackle all aspects of hate crime.

We are engaged with a wide range of partners to tackle hate crime and its causes. We support actions including promoting respect for rights for people with disabilities, youth projects, community bonfire initiatives, flags protocols, conflict resolution, research and reducing sectarian and racist tensions by summer diversionary actions, maintenance of mobile phone network for interface workers. We also support groups working to help minority ethnic people and migrant workers integrate with host communities. We are also currently working on a strategy to deal with discrimination and hate crime on the basis of sexual orientation.

We will shortly bring forward detailed proposals for the "Programme of Cohesion, Sharing and Integration for a shared and better future' which was detailed in the PfG. At the core of these proposals will be action primarily to tackle sectarianism, racism and intolerance. The programme will build on some of the excellent work, particularly at the local level, to address the challenges which local communities are facing.

Sexual Orientation Strategy

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister for an update on the development of a sexual orientation strategy.

(AQW 8237/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: Officials are currently working on a draft Equal Opportunity and Anti-discrimination Strategy on Sexual Orientation to be presented to Ministers and the Assembly Committee for consideration in Autumn 2008.

Sexual Orientation Strategy

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what plans it has to link the sexual orientation strategy with the programme for cohesion, sharing and integration.

(AQW 8238/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness:

The Programme of Cohesion, Sharing and Integration (CSI) is currently being considered by Ministers and we plan to present our proposals in the near future. The CSI strategy for a shared and better future will deal primarily with sectarianism and racism. The strategy will however cover all groups in our society with an overarching aim to achieve a shared and secure future for all.

Post-Primary Transfer Arrangements

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister for its assessment of whether matters relating to the issue of post-primary transfer arrangements are significant and controversial in accordance with Article 2.4 of the Ministerial Code.

(AQW 8317/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: In relation to whether matters relating to the issue of post-primary transfer arrangements are significant and controversial in accordance with Article 2.4 of the Ministerial Code, we would refer you to the provisions of Assembly Standing Order 19(3).

In addition, the Minister of Education brought a paper to the Executive on a range of issues relating to post-primary transfer for consideration at its meeting on 15 May 2008. The Executive has not yet taken a decision on these issues.

Post-Primary Transfer Arrangements

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what aspects of post-primary transfer arrangements need to be considered and agreed by the Executive, on the basis of Article 2.4(v) of the Ministerial Code, given that the issue was not addressed within the Programme for Government.

(AQW 8318/08)

Employment Opportunities for People with Learning Disabilities

Ms S Ramsey asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what action it is taking to ensure that Departments and public bodies are providing equality of employment opportunity to people with learning disabilities.

(AQW 8397/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness:

The Disability Discrimination Act 1995 (DDA 1995, as amended), requires all public authorities when carrying out its functions to have due regard to the need to:

promote positive attitudes towards disabled people; and

encourage participation by disabled people in public life (‘the disability duties’).

The DDA 1995, as amended, further required all public authorities, by 30 June 2007, to submit to the Equality Commission for Northern Ireland (ECNI) a Disability Action Plan showing how it proposed to fulfil these duties in relation to its functions. In support of this, each public authority is required to report on progress achieved to date (July 2007 to March 2008). ECNI has requested that this should be done via the Section 75 Annual Progress Report. This is currently being completed by all designated public authorities.

Further, Section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 places a statutory obligation on all designated public authorities to ensure that they carry out their various functions having due regard to the need to promote equality of opportunity across 9 social categories, including: persons of different religious belief, political opinion, racial group, age, marital status or sexual orientation; men and women generally; persons with a disability and persons without; and persons with dependants and persons without.

The Equality Commission for Northern Ireland is required to keep under review the effectiveness of the duties imposed by Section 75, including the requirement to investigate complaints of failure to comply with Section 75; and, in certain circumstances, to make referrals to the Secretary of State.

As an employer, the Northern Ireland Civil Service is subject to the DDA 1995. In addition to its statutory objectives, it regularly reviews its employment policies and practices to ensure they provide equal opportunity for employment and advancement to all, including those with a disability. Departments make reasonable adjustments across the range of employment practices including recruitment and selection, training and development, and working arrangements, to ensure people with disabilities are not disadvantaged compared to non-disabled people. Such adjustments are agreed on a case by case basis to meet the specific needs of individuals, including those with learning disabilities.

Representation in EU Structures

Mrs Long asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to outline the level and nature of representation of Northern Ireland within the various structures of the European Union, in addition to the 3 MEPs; and the level of engagement of Ministers of the Executive with the European Union in the last 6 months.

(AQW 8530/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness:

Northern Ireland’s representation, excluding MEPs, within the European Union is:

European Body

Northern Ireland Representatives

Committee of the Regions

Councillor Edwin Poots MLA

Councillor Lord Morrow MLA

Councillor Sue Ramsey MLA*

Councillor Bernice Swift

European Economic and Social Committee

Jane Morrice

Michael Smyth

* Sue Ramsey has been nominated to replace Conor Murphy MP, MLA

The level of engagement of Executive Ministers with the European Union over the last six months is:

Date	Details
10 January	Minister Gildernew met with Commissioner Fischer Boel and President Barroso in Brussels.
14 March	Minister Gildernew met with Commissioner Fischer Boel in Brussels.
1 April	Minister Gildernew met with Commissioner Joe Borg in Brussels.
23 June	Minister Gildernew attended an Agriculture and Fisheries Council meeting in Luxembourg and met with Commissioner Vassilou.
24 January	Minister Dodds attended a reception to promote Aerospace NI in Brussels.
14 April	Minister Robinson and Commissioner Hübner launched the 2007-13 European Regional Development Fund Programmes in Belfast.
23 April	Minister Empey addressed the European Commission’s Employment and Social Policy Seminar in Belfast.
5 June	Minister Empey delivered the opening address at the 5th Annual Anti-Discrimination Conference "Communicating Equality and Non-Discrimination in the EU" in Belfast.
9/10 January	First Minister and deputy First Minister met with President Barroso in Brussels to discuss the Commission’s Northern Ireland Task Force. The visit also included meetings with Commissioners Hübner and Fischer Boel.
14 April	Commissioner Hübner formally launched the Northern Ireland Report of the Task Force in Belfast with the First Minister and deputy First Minister.
28 April	The First Minister and deputy First Minister in conjunction with the European Economic and Social Committee paid tribute to the PEACE Programme founders in the University of Ulster, Jordanstown. This event preceded an evidence gathering session by the EESC for an ‘own initiative opinion’ on the PEACE Programmes.

In addition, the Junior Ministers within OFMDFM have engaged with the European Union as follows:

9/10 January	Both Junior Ministers accompanied the First Minister and deputy First Minister when meeting President Barroso and Commissioners Hübner and Fischer Boel in Brussels.
14 March	Junior Minister Donaldson accompanied Minister Gildernew when meeting Commissioner Fischer Boel in Brussels.
2 April	Both Junior Ministers met with Commissioner Hübner in advance of the publication of the Barosso Taskforce report
14 April	Both Junior Ministers attended the formal launch of the Northern Ireland Report of the Task Force in Belfast with Commissioner Hübner.

Definition of Cohesion

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what is its understanding of the concept of 'cohesion' within the context of the forthcoming programme for cohesion, sharing and integration.

(AQW 8531/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Programme for Government’s overarching aim is ‘to build a peaceful, fair and prosperous society in Northern Ireland, with respect for the rule of law and where everyone can enjoy a better quality of life now and in years to come’.

In support of this aim one of PfG’s cross cutting themes is ‘A shared and better future for all with equality, fairness, inclusion and the promotion of good relations’ as the watchwords for policies and programmes across government. The Programme of Cohesion, Sharing and Integration (CSI) will be the overarching strategy to provide a good relations, good race relations and racial equality policy context to achieve the aim.

Development of the CSI Programme is at an advanced stage and will be published for consultation as soon as possible. It will explain in more detail what we mean by the terms ‘cohesion’, ‘sharing’ and ‘integration’. This Strategy aims to build on very significant work, which has been ongoing for a long time, to develop cohesion within and between communities to enhance the already growing mutual respect and to foster integration of new communities.

The terms are used in a manner fully consistent with their dictionary definition.

Definition of Sharing

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what is its understanding of the concept of 'sharing' within the context of the forthcoming programme for cohesion, sharing and integration.

(AQW 8532/08)

The terms are used in a manner fully consistent with their dictionary definition.

Definition of Integration

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what is its understanding of the concept of 'integration' within the context of the forthcoming programme for cohesion, sharing and integration.

(AQW 8533/08)

The terms are used in a manner fully consistent with their dictionary definition.

Programme of Cohesion, Sharing and Integration

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what factors have contributed to the delay in publishing a draft report of the programme for cohesion, sharing and integration.

(AQW 8534/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness:

We are now at an advanced stage of development of the detailed proposals for a ‘Programme of Cohesion, Sharing and Integration for a shared and better future’, which was signalled in the Programme for Government. The specific objective (PSA 7.5) commits us to implement the programme during this current year 08/09.

OFMDFM officials briefed the Committee of the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister on the position regarding development of the proposed Programme in early April. The consultation document will be put to the Committee of the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister shortly.

The new programme will tackle the complex and longstanding issue of sectarianism as well as the more recent issue of racism which is affecting both the established communities as well as new arrivals. It will build on the excellent work which is already being done, particularly by district councils and community organisations, to address the challenges which local communities are facing. Action to tackle sectarianism, racism and intolerance will be at the core of these proposals. As this policy is pivotal to achieving ‘a peaceful, fair and prosperous society with respect for the rule of law’ we are ensuring that the Programme proposals will contribute to this aim.

We have repeatedly stated our commitment to working towards building a society at ease with itself – a society that is integrated, cohesive and where everyone who lives here is regarded as of equal status and is treated as such – the new programme will work towards this.

Painting of Flags and Kerbstones

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister for its assessment of the proliferation of flags and kerbstone painting during the summer on attracting investment to (i) Northern Ireland as a whole; and (ii) particular localities where the displays occur.

(AQW 8709/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: Reports on the nature and quantum of flag flying in the summers of 2006 and 2007 were published by OFMDFM in January 2007 and March 2008 respectively. The research is currently being conducted on behalf of OFMDFM, by Queen’s University of Belfast, for July and September of this year. The initial findings should be available in November 2008.

The public display of flags and emblems remains a very widespread issue. However, it is not possible to fully quantify the potential impact that the proliferation of flags and kerbstones painted during the summer has on the economy, or in particular localities where displays occur.

Deprivation and Segregation Linkage in Society

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister for its assessment of the correlation between high levels of deprivation and poverty, and high levels of sectarian tensions and segregation in society.

(AQW 8743/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Programme for Government recognises that continuing evidence of sectarianism; racism and intolerance are blights on our economic prospects and have a corrosive effect on our society. In order to achieve the PfG aim of "a peaceful, fair and prosperous society" it is the goal that "everyone can enjoy a better quality of life now and in years to come"

OFMDFM continues to be committed to addressing the issues of deprivation and poverty and of sectarian tension and segregation. The forthcoming Programme for Cohesion, Sharing and Integration will set out proposals for good relations and good race relations

In addition, in line with the statutory commitment under Section 28 E of Northern Ireland Act 1998 the Executive Committee will shortly consider and agree the adoption of an overall strategy to tackle poverty, social exclusion and patterns of deprivation here based on objective need.

Relocation of Revenue and Customs Jobs

Mr McGlone asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what representation has been made to Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs in relation to the proposed downsizing and relocation of jobs from their offices in Craigavon, Newry and Banbridge.

(AQW 8801/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: Changes to the HMRC estate are an internal matter for HM Revenue and Customs. However, following representations from local HMRC employees we have written to the Treasury Minister, the Rt Hon Jane Kennedy MP, raising their concerns.

Halloween Bonfire Complaints

Mr Moutray asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister how many complaints it has received in relation to the possible adverse effect on community relations of Halloween bonfires in each of the last five years.

(AQW 8807/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister has no record of any complaints relating to the possible adverse effect on community relations of Halloween bonfires.

Equality Legislation and the Right to Religious Expression

Mr Storey asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister, pursuant to his answer to AQO 4118/08, if it will consider amending all existing equality legislation to include guaranteeing the right to religious expression.

(AQW 8823/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: There are no plans to amend current equality legislation to provide for such a right. The Human Rights Act 1998 provides certain rights in relation to freedom of religion and freedom of expression. In addition, considerable anti-discrimination legislation currently protects the right not to be discriminated against on the basis of religious belief.

Planning Appeals Commission

Mr Weir asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister how many cases were submitted to the Planning Appeals Commission on the grounds of non-determination in each of the last five years.

(AQW 8828/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness:

The Planning Appeals Commission is a tribunal Non-Departmental Public Body. Given its independent tribunal status, it is appropriate for its Chief Commissioner to provide a response directly to you, and we understand she has written to you in the following terms:

"I have provided in the table below, figures for the intake of appeals which were submitted to the Planning Appeals Commission on the grounds of non-determination in each of the last five financial years.

Year

03/04

04/05

05/06

06/07

07/08

Appeals received

111

261

250

416

35

I would be happy to provide any further information you require arising out of this response or to meet with you to discuss the matter if that would be more suitable."

Changing Times Stormont Magazine

Mrs D Kelly asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister how much money has been spent on the Changing Times Stormont magazine.

(AQW 8848/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Executive Information Service has not incurred any expenditure in relation to this document to date. However the indication is that the cost of the preparatory work is likely to be between £7,000 and £8,000. The exact figure has yet to be agreed with the service provider and we will be invoiced accordingly.

2008 Belfast Gay Pride Parade

Mr Kennedy asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister how much funding it is allocating to the 2008 Belfast Gay Pride Parade.

(AQW 8860/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Coalition on Sexual Orientation (CoSO) has contributed to the 2007 and 2008 Belfast Gay Pride Parade, awarding £5,750 and £5,000 respectively, from a short term fund of £230,000 which was awarded by the previous Direct Rule administration.

The broad purposes of the fund include improving community relations, helping build capacity, and helping others understand the issues faced by lesbian, gay and bisexual people, such as social exclusion and marginalisation. The Fund is administered by the Coalition on Sexual Orientation, an umbrella group for the sector.

Emerald Fund

Mr O'Loan asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister if it is encouraging Departments and their Agencies to seek funding from the Emerald Fund.

(AQW 8907/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: While we very much welcome the creation of the Fund, it is important to note that it would not be an additional source of funds that Departments can simply access to top-up public expenditure allocations contained in the Budget.

The precise operation of the Emerald Fund is still under development, but we understand that this could also include areas of infrastructure provision that fall within the private sector such as energy and telecommunications.

Emerald Fund

Mr O'Loan asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister if the Executive has taken a decision on the merits of Departments bidding for additional resources from the Emerald Fund.

(AQW 8908/08)

Emerald Fund

Mr O'Loan asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister if it has issued guidelines to other Departments in relation to bidding for additional resources from the Emerald fund.

(AQW 8909/08)

Planning Appeals

Mr Shannon asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister what action it is taking to expedite extensions and dwelling applications for disabled people, referred to the Planning Appeals Commission, to ensure that these cases are dealt with as soon as possible.

(AQW 8927/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Planning Appeals Commission is a tribunal Non-Departmental Public Body. Given its independent tribunal status it is appropriate for its Chief Commissioner to provide a response directly to you, and we understand she has written to you in the following terms:

"I have been asked to provide you with information requested in the above Assembly Question.

The Planning Appeals Commission deals with appeals in the order in which they are received. By adopting this approach it ensures that all appellants are treated equally and fairly. The procedures used by the Planning Appeals Commission are available via the Commissions website at www.pacni.gov.uk.

I would be happy to provide any further information you require arising out of this response or to meet with you to discuss the matter if that would be more suitable "

Cost of Living Sub-Committee

Mr Shannon asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister for its assessment of the role a Cost of Living Sub-Committee would play in eradicating child poverty.

(AQW 8931/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: We recognise that recent, well publicised increases in fuel and energy costs are having an impact on the cost of living for all of us. We also recognise that it is to be expected that those most vulnerable and less well-off in our society will feel the effects of these price increases more acutely.

The Executive will soon consider proposals in respect of its adoption of a strategy to tackle poverty and social exclusion and patterns of deprivation, in line with its statutory obligation. These considerations will take account of the recommendations of the OFMDFM Committee following its inquiry into child poverty here.

The proposals include the establishment of an Executive Sub-Committee to agree and monitor key actions in relation to poverty. These actions will be taken forward in a co-ordinated way across Departments to deliver our commitments within the Programme for Government, to eliminate poverty.

Within its considerations the Executive will look at any proposals to establish a sub-committee.

Mixed Workplaces

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister the proportion of (i) Protestants; and (ii) people from mixed or other backgrounds, who would avoid working or applying for a job in an area perceived as Catholic/Nationalist, based on the Northern Ireland Life and Times Survey and other reports.

(AQW 8951/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: In the results of the Northern Ireland Life and Times Survey, 9% of Protestants said that, if applying for a job they would definitely avoid workplaces situated in a mainly Catholic area and a further 20% said that they would probably avoid such workplaces. The figures for Catholics who said that they would avoid workplaces situated in a mainly Protestant area were 9% (definitely) and 25% (probably).

It is not possible to provide figures for the second part of either of these questions because firstly, the number of respondents falling into the mixed or other background is too small for meaningful analysis.

Figures are available for those respondents who described themselves as having no religion; 3% within this group said that when applying for a job they would definitely avoid workplaces situated in a mainly Catholic area and a further 16% said that they would probably avoid such workplaces. The equivalent figures for workplaces situated in a mainly Protestant area were 3% and 5%, respectively.

We are unaware of any other reports that have specifically investigated the likelihood of the general public to avoid working or applying for a job in areas that are perceived to be Protestant/Unionist or Catholic/Nationalist.

Mixed Workplaces

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister the proportion of (i) Catholics; and (ii) people from mixed or other backgrounds, who would avoid working or applying for a job in an area perceived as Protestant/Unionist, based on the Northern Ireland Life and Times Survey and other reports.

(AQW 8952/08)

Mixed Workplaces

Dr Farry asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister for its assessment of the desire for mixed workplaces, based on the Northern Ireland Life and Times Survey and other reports.

(AQW 8953/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: The Programme for Government commits us to "A shared and better future for all". It also makes the commitment that "equality, fairness, inclusion and the promotion of good relations will be watchwords for all of our policies and programmes across Government". It is our policy to promote a society that is integrated and one that is based on tolerance and respect for cultural diversity. Successful integration in the workplace would go someway toward achieving such a society.

Land and Property Vested at the Maze Site

Mr Gardiner asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail all the land vested in 1941 and 1942 by the Secretary of State for Air and administered by the then Northern Ireland Ministry of Finance, to build the airfield at Long Kesh/Maze, including (i) names of the previous owners; (ii) acreages vested; (iii) details and references of the land registry folios; (iv) the date of vesting; and (v) the compensation paid in each case.

(AQW 8976/08)

Mr P Robinson and Mr M McGuinness: Only limited information is available within the Department in relation to the land and property vested at the Maze/Long Kesh site. The majority of the detailed information requested is held at the Land Registry Office (LRO).

Folio No 28613 County Down contains the details of all registered and unregistered land vested between 7 October 1941 and 18 November 1942 to create the Maze/Long Kesh site.

Details of the previous owners, acreage vested, and compensation paid is held on the Land Certificates and Transfer Deeds which are available from the Land Registry Office (LRO) at a small cost. There were 48 vestings and upward of 56 transfer deeds involved in the process.

Concerning land vested after 1942, Folio No 29420 County Down and Folio No 30155 County Down respectively contains details of a north western corner of the site acquired by the Ministry of Supply on 16 November 1950 and two very small pieces of land acquired by the Ministry of Supply in 1951.

All buildings and structures currently on the site form part of the vested property.

Some of the original land vested has been resold and Folio Numbers DN 62786, 29420 and 30155 County Down specify the current land holding for the Maze/Long Kesh site.

Land and Property Vested at the Maze Site

Mr Gardiner asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail all the previously unregistered land vested in 1941 and 1942 by the Secretary of State for Air and administered by the then Northern Ireland Ministry of Finance, to build the airfield at Long Kesh/Maze, including (i) names of the previous owners; (ii) acreages vested; (iii) details and references of the land registry folios; (iv) the date of vesting; and (v) the compensation paid in each case.

(AQW 8977/08)

Folio No 28613 County Down contains the details of all registered and unregistered land vested between 7 October 1941 and 18 November 1942 to create the Maze/Long Kesh site.

All buildings and structures currently on the site form part of the vested property.

Some of the original land vested has been resold and Folio Numbers DN 62786, 29420 and 30155 County Down specify the current land holding for the Maze/Long Kesh site.

Land and Property Vested at the Maze Site

Mr Gardiner asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail any land vested by any Northern Ireland or Whitehall Government Department, subsequent to 1942, which was incorporated into the Long Kesh/Maze site, including (i) names of the previous owners; (ii) acreages vested; (iii) details and references of the land registry folios; (iv) the date of vesting; and (v) the compensation paid in each case.

(AQW 8978/08)

Folio No 28613 County Down contains the details of all registered and unregistered land vested between 7 October 1941 and 18 November 1942 to create the Maze/Long Kesh site.

All buildings and structures currently on the site form part of the vested property.

Some of the original land vested has been resold and Folio Numbers DN 62786, 29420 and 30155 County Down specify the current land holding for the Maze/Long Kesh site.

Land and Property Vested at the Maze Site

Mr Gardiner asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail all properties, with relevant folio references, which make up the entirety of the Long Kesh/Maze site.

(AQW 8979/08)

Folio No 28613 County Down contains the details of all registered and unregistered land vested between 7 October 1941 and 18 November 1942 to create the Maze/Long Kesh site.

All buildings and structures currently on the site form part of the vested property.

Some of the original land vested has been resold and Folio Numbers DN 62786, 29420 and 30155 County Down specify the current land holding for the Maze/Long Kesh site.

Land and Property Vested at the Maze Site

Mr Gardiner asked the Office of the First Minister and deputy First Minister to detail any facilities vested in 1941 and 1942 by the Secretary of State for Air and administered by the then Northern Ireland Ministry of Finance, to build the airfield at Long Kesh/Maze.

(AQW 8982/08)

Folio No 28613 County Down contains the details of all registered and unregistered land vested between 7 October 1941 and 18 November 1942 to create the Maze/Long Kesh site.

All buildings and structures currently on the site form part of the vested property.

Some of the original land vested has been resold and Folio Numbers DN 62786, 29420 and 30155 County Down specify the current land holding for the Maze/Long Kesh site.

Agriculture and Rural Development

Bio-Fuel Production

Mr Gardiner asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what acreage of the total agricultural land available is under cultivation for bio-fuels and what does this represent as a percentage of the total available agricultural land.

(AQW 8582/08)

The Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development (Ms M Gildernew): In relation to liquid bio-fuel production, agriculture within the North is predominantly grass based, with only 3 per cent devoted to cereal and oilseed crops in 2007. However, areas of both cropping and oilseed rape have been considerably higher in the past than at present.

The last two Farm Census Surveys indicate that 470 hectares of oilseed rape was planted in June 2006 and this dropped slightly to 397 hectares in June 2007. A very small proportion of this will have been used for the production of bio-fuel and mainly used to fuel on farm vehicles.

Current market conditions are more attractive to the arable sector for the growing of cereal crops rather than energy crops.

In the absence of any significant change in land use patterns, the quantities of cereals and oilseeds grown in the North could not support significant biodiesel/bio-ethanol production.

In relation to biomass production, DARD estimates that in the region of 800 hectares of SRC willow have been established. This represents less that 0.1% of the total available agricultural land.

Flood Defence Programme

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development to outline her flood defence programme; how the programme will be extended over the next ten years; on what evidence her plans are based; and what budgetary provision she has made, or plans to make, to meet these obligations.

(AQW 8596/08)

Ms M Gildernew: Rivers Agency’s Flood defence programme within its current Business Plan includes the following main activities:-

Undertaking a prioritised programme of viable capital works to provide accepted standards of flood protection;

Planned inspection of all designated man made flood and sea defences and culverts;

Assessment of the adequacy of rivers, streams and culverts to carry increased flows where new housing, industrial or commercial development is proposed;

Emergency response to watercourse-related flooding incidents as part of co-ordinated Government response;

The development of Asset Management Plans relating to the condition of culverts, flood defences etc.

The Agency has a detailed 5 year programme of Capital expenditure, with current funding at £6m, per year which contains projects associated with the main elements mentioned above. The Agency has a prioritised programme of capital works schemes which comprise River and Coastal Flood Defence, Drainage infrastructure and Repair Schemes.

The Agency’s programme also encompasses broader Flood Management – the requirement for more sustainable approaches to managing flood risk. These include production of strategic Flood Mapping for use in the identification of areas at risk from flooding and, as a consultee of DOE Planning Service, the prevention of development taking place in such areas.

The EU Directive on the Assessment and Management of Floods (Floods Directive) has been adopted and is creating a significant impact and new obligations for Rivers Agency as the competent authority under the Directive as transposed in Northern Ireland. These include assessment of areas at risk of flooding, mapping and the production of Management Plans by 2015. This Directive is key to the future direction of the Agency’s management of flooding and its constituent parts. Appropriate budgetary provision will be made to meet these obligations.

Environmental protection and adaptation to climate change are also important issues for the Agency in taking forward its flood defence programme.

Rural White Paper

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development when will she initiate the Rural White Paper and when will the consultation process be completed.

(AQW 8668/08)

Ms M Gildernew: On 24 April, the Executive agreed my proposal to develop a Rural White Paper. I am in the process of establishing a Rural Policy Committee, chaired by myself and made up of senior officials from all Departments, to develop the Rural White Paper. A new team is also being established in DARD to progress this important piece of work. I am also currently considering how best to involve stakeholders in the development of this paper.

Preparation of the paper will take time if we are to aim for a meaningful outcome, and it is my intention to produce initial proposals for the Executive by the end of 2008. If agreed, these proposals will then be developed during 2009 into a wide ranging Rural White Paper with subsequent full public consultation on the document.

Cycle Trail at Cairn Wood

Mr B Wilson asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development if the Forestry Service allows access to cyclists at Cairn Wood near Bangor.

(AQW 8671/08)

Ms M Gildernew: No access is permitted at Cairn Wood for cyclists. This is a small area of forest that has not been developed for cycling. Cairn Wood has not been considered suitable for development for cycling due to its small size, existing levels of public access, steep slopes and limited infrastructure.

Cycle Trail at Cairn Wood

Mr B Wilson asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development if she will direct the Forestry Service to investigate the possibility of providing a family cycle trail at Cairn Wood near Bangor.

(AQW 8672/08)

Ms M Gildernew: Considerable work has already been undertaken by interested parties and government agencies, including Forest Service, to establish a strategic approach to the development of off- road cycling, including the provision of family cycle trails.

This work has considered a wide range of factors relating to the suitability of sites for development. Family cycle trails have been constructed within three of the Department’s forests, taking account of these factors, which offered sufficient scope to accommodate a suitable trail of reasonable length, whilst avoiding safety issues arising from steep slopes. Cairn Wood, due to its size and topography and lack of general infrastructure, is considered to be not suitable and Forest Service has no further plans for such provision.

Rural Childcare Opportunities in Northern Ireland

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what action she is taking to ensure that rural childcare opportunities are widely available across Northern Ireland.

(AQW 8678/08)

Ms M Gildernew: In July 2007 I initiated the Rural Childcare Stakeholder Group and was pleased to present its report "Rural Childcare, Investing in the Future" to the Ministerial Sub Committee on Children and Young People in March 2008. This Sub-Committee is considering the cross cutting recommendations of this report.

My officials are developing a Rural Childcare Programme to be open for applications before the end of 2008. This will be funded from the Department’s budget for Anti-Poverty and Social Inclusion Measures.

Further childcare funding opportunities will be available from the NI Rural Development Programme, 2007-2013 under Axis 3 "quality of life in rural areas and diversification of the rural economy" measures. It will be open to the Local Action Groups in developing strategies for their areas to propose appropriate childcare measures.

Local Postal Services

Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by her Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.

(AQW 8690/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ Report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of Postal Services and the Post Office network.Junior Minister Donaldson and Junior Minister Kelly wrote to Executive Ministers on 21 April asking them to consider whether any further public services could be delivered through post offices.

Within the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development we have been unable to identify any services that could be delivered through Post Offices. We will continue to look at opportunities as they arise to consider whether any new public service could be delivered through the Post Office although these would be subject to the appropriate NI procurement policy.

Grants to Assist the Farming Community

Mr Doherty asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development (i) for an inventory of grants which are available from the Department to assist the farming community; and (ii) the purposes, objectives and eligibility criteria for these grants.

(AQW 8802/08)

Ms M Gildernew: A table listing the grants available to assist the farming community has been placed in the Assembly Library (subsidy schemes have been excluded from this information).

Safety on Farms

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what discussions she has had with Farmers' Unions to improve safety on farms.

(AQW 8827/08)

Ms M Gildernew: I have not had specific discussions with the Farmers’ Unions regarding the improvement of safety on farms, because responsibility for farm safety lies with the Health and Safety Executive for NI within the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment.

I am however, very conscious of the risks and dangers faced by farmers as they carry out their work. Improving safety and preventing accidents on farm is included as an integral component of the further and higher education programmes delivered by my Department through the College of Agriculture, Food and Rural Enterprise, (CAFRE).

Students enrolled on these programmes receive training in the safe use and operation of farm machinery, safe movement and handling of livestock, safe use of pesticides, emergency first aid procedures and safe lifting techniques.

CAFRE also offers a similar range of health and safety related training courses for farmers and family farm members. These courses are delivered at the CAFRE Campuses and at local outreach centres throughout the North.

Development Service of the College of Agriculture, Food and Rural Enterprise

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what strategies she is considering to encourage young people to stay at work on the farm.

(AQW 8890/08)

Ms M Gildernew: My Department, primarily through the Development Service of the College of Agriculture, Food and Rural Enterprise (CAFRE), provides support and assistance to those farmers of all age groups who wish to develop their farm business and secure their future in the industry.

CAFRE’s team of Development Advisers, who are located throughout the North, work with farmers through delivery of tailored Development Plans for their businesses. Through this process, business objectives and development needs are identified and the appropriate support agreed. Development Advisers provide support to these farmers through delivery of: -

Benchmarking which enables farmers to compare their business / farm enterprise performance with other similar businesses.
Knowledge and Technology Transfer – through a diverse range of projects, CAFRE encourages farmers to adopt world-class, leading edge technology.
Training – CAFRE has developed a wide portfolio of short courses and Challenge programmes to meet the competence development needs of those within the industry.

For those young people wishing to pursue a career in farming, CAFRE also provides Further and Higher Education programmes in agriculture. Courses ranging from NVQ level 2 to Honours Degree level, (which is delivered in partnership with The Queen’s University of Belfast), are available at CAFRE’s Greenmount Campus in Antrim. The NVQ part-time programmes are also available at CAFRE’s Enniskillen Campus.

As well as its considerable education programme, my Department offers financial assistance to new entrants to the farming industry. The New Entrants Scheme is open to young farmers under 40 who possess adequate competence and are setting up as head of holding for the first time. The scheme provides an interest rate subsidy on loans for eligible projects that add value and make a positive impact on the farming industry and the NI rural economy.

There are also a number of measures within the NIRDP which are designed to support farmers who wish to stay at work on the farm. For example, benchmarking, focus farms, and supply chain measures, as well as the reskilling/upskilling measure which has been aligned with the NIRDP.

Damage to Wind Turbines

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development how many wind turbines have broken and caused damage; and what steps she is taking to prevent further damage and possible injury.

(AQW 8901/08)

Ms M Gildernew: My Department provided financial assistance to 26 applicants to the Wind Energy for Rural Business scheme under the E.U. Programme for Building Sustainable Prosperity. I am very concerned that serious problems have occurred, primarily with regards to the make of turbine supplied to 11 of these applicants. It is my understanding that when damage to property was reported, the manufacturers of the machines in question immediately requested that all 11 applicants with these turbines cease to operate them until the problems were rectified.

I further understand that the manufacturer has committed to resolving the problems under warranty and that a test turbine has been installed with the aim of identifying and rolling out modifications, to all problem turbines. This has, regrettably become a protracted process.

While my Department has no legal standing in the contractual relationship between the supplier/manufacturer and the rural businesses, it is nevertheless keen to assist further, if possible, in helping to bring about a satisfactory resolution to this situation. To that end, a review has been commissioned, by the Department, to investigate the roles and responsibilities of all parties involved in the scheme, with the intention of identifying potential options for resolution.

As part of the review a professional engineer will be employed to assess technical aspects of the project, the compliance of parties to their contract obligations, and to provide advice on whether these turbines can be made operational.

It is intended that the review will report in September.

Sale of Crossnacreevy site

Mr Elliott asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development if she intends to proceed with the sale of the Crossnacreevy site, in light of its much reduced value.

(AQW 8929/08)

Ms M Gildernew: No final decision has yet been taken regarding the possible sale of the Crossnacreevy site. That decision will be guided by an overall assessment of the costs and benefits of re-locating the AFBI functions currently undertaken at Crossnacreevy, AFBI’s future estate needs across its entire business and the possible proceeds from the disposal of the Crossnacreevy site. AFBI is currently developing a business case that will inform this assessment.

Crossnacreevy Site Devaluation

Mr Elliott asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what effect the reduced value of the Crossnacreevy site will have on her budgetary plans.

(AQW 8930/08)

Ms M Gildernew: DFP has been advised that the sale of the Crossnacreevy site would be unlikely to generate a receipt of £200m in 2010/11 but there has been no amendment to the Department’s budgetary plans to date. An assessment of the position of Departments in relation to Capital requirements and receipt targets is to be carried out in the context of a Strategic Stocktake in the autumn. This will consider the position at NI Block level and take into account the ten year ISNI programme of some £1,900m.

Crossnacreevy Site Valuation and Farmers' Grants

Mr Elliott asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development will there be any affect on the delivery of promised grants to farmers as a result of the devaluation of the Crossnacreevy site.

(AQW 8932/08)

Ms M Gildernew: There are no indications at this stage that there will be any effect on the delivery of grants to farmers. DFP has been advised that the sale of the Crossnacreevy site would be unlikely to generate a receipt of £200m in 2010/11 but there has been no amendment to the Department’s budgetary plans. An assessment of the position of Departments in relation to Capital requirements and receipt targets is to be carried out in the context of a Strategic Stocktake in the autumn. This will consider the position at NI Block level and take into account the ten year ISNI programme of some £1,900m.

Pig Producers

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development how many pig producers were operating in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 8954/08)

Ms M Gildernew: Number of Pig Farms operating in the last 3 years

Year	Number of Pig Farms
2005	438
2006	452
2007	490

As most pig farmers only have one pig holding, the number of farms is a good approximation to the number of pig producers.

Pig Meat Imports

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development how much pig meat was imported in each of the last three years.

(AQW 8955/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The Department of Agriculture and Rural Development does not maintain this information centrally. Pig meat of EU origin can move freely between Member States. Information does exist in relation to imports from a Third Country direct to here. However, information does not exist in relation to indirect importations. This is due to the fact that once imports from countries outside the European Union enter through the Border Inspection Post (BIP) in any Member State, they are issued with a Common Veterinary Entry Document which permits them to move freely within the EU. Under EU Trade rules, these products are permitted to move freely within the EU.

Table A below details the imports of pig meat directly from Third Countries to here.

The Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board maintain figures for pig meat imports into the UK as a whole. These figures are detailed in Table B below.

TABLE A- PIG MEAT IMPORTED DIRECT FROM THIRD COUNTRIES.

(‘000 Tonnes)	2005	2006	2007	Jan-June 2008
	23.9	0.0	0.0	0.0

TABLE B- UK PIG MEAT IMPORTS

(‘000 tonnes)	2005	2006	2007	Jan-April 2008
	432.0	458.8	465.1	147.3

Source: Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board

Red Meat Imports

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development how much red meat was imported in each of the last three years.

(AQW 8956/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The Department of Agriculture and Rural Development does not maintain this information centrally. Red meat of EU origin can move freely between Member States. Information does exist in relation to imports from a Third Country direct to here. However, information does not exist in relation to indirect importations. This is due to the fact that once imports from countries outside the European Union enter through the Border Inspection Post (BIP) in any Member State; they are issued with a Common Veterinary Entry Document which permits them to move freely within the EU. Under EU Trade rules, these products are permitted to move freely within the EU.

Table A details the imports of red meat directly from Third Countries to here.

The Livestock and Meat Commission monitor and maintain figures of beef imports to the UK. Similarly the Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board maintain figures for lamb imports into the UK as a whole. The composite figures are detailed in Table B and C below respectively.

TABLE A –RED MEAT IMPORTED DIRECTLY FROM THIRD COUNTRIES

(‘000 Tonnes)	2005	2006	2007	Jan-June 2008
Lamb	2391.2	550.1	1,450.4	543.4
Beef	0.0	49.6	124.5	73.1
Venison	0.0	28.6	0.0	16.7

TABLE B- UK BEEF IMPORTS

(‘000 tonnes)	2005	2006	2007	Jan-April 2008

Total imports	239.9	235.7	238.3	79.2

from EU-27	176.4	180.1	184.8	62.9
from non EU-27	63.5	55.5	53.5	16.3

Main Sources
ROI	136.5	145.0	145.9	48.7
Brazil	32.2	28.6	25.9	5.5

Other Sources
Germany	9.2	11.0	12.9	3.9
The Netherlands	12.7	12.8	15.3	5.1
Uruguay	7.0	7.6	9.3	6.6
Australia	4.7	6.2	4.0	0.9
Namibia	5.9	3.5	4.8	**
Botswana	3.5	2.4	3.9	**
Argentina	9.1	5.0	3.5	1.7

Source: Meat and Livestock Commission

** No figures available

TABLE C-UK LAMB IMPORTS

(‘000 tonnes)	2005	2006	2007	Jan-April 2008
Lamb	110.1	113.8	114.1	44.7

Source: Agriculture and Horticulture Development Board

Sale of Red Meat

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what percentage of total meat sales has red meat sales represented in each of the last three years, and what steps are being taken to increase the sale of red meat.

(AQW 8957/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The most up to date information which DARD has available on meat sales relates to 2005. I can therefore provide the figures for 2005 and the two previous years. The value of red meat sold in the North as a percentage of the total value of all meat sold here in 2003, 2004 and 2005 was 58.5%, 57.3% and 58.7% respectively.

With regard to your point about increasing red meat sales, you should note that EU State Aid Rules place severe constraints on the use of Government funds for promotional activities, therefore DARD cannot provide direct funding for marketing or advertising of red meat in the North of Ireland.

The Livestock and Meat Commission (LMC) is responsible for the promotion of red meat in the domestic and export markets. Promotional activities aimed at the domestic market include; a press and television campaign highlighting the importance of red meat as part of a balanced diet; provision of advertising posters for butchers’ shops and promoting Farm Quality Assured beef.

For the export market, the LMC is heavily involved in major international red meat trade shows, such as ANUGA in Germany and SIAL in France.

I understand also that Invest NI has developed a focused export trade model to target specific export markets and facilitate trade visits by red meat processing companies. Invest NI work closely with the LMC in delivering this initiative and have arranged trade missions to Italy, Sweden, Norway and Spain.

Loughs Agency Employees

Mr McElduff asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development what action her Department is taking to bring about a resolution to the current industrial action which has been undertaken by Loughs Agency field staff.

(AQW 8984/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The Loughs Agency has advised that it has provided two proposals to Field Staff to address issues related to the current industrial action and met union officials on Tuesday 8^th July 2008 to discuss these.

At that meeting it was agreed that the Agency would write to each of the field staff detailing these proposals and their impact on each individual to enable full consideration to be given to them.

The Agency and the representatives of the field staff have agreed to meet again when the Trade Unions have consulted further with their members.

Loughs Agency Employees

Mr McElduff asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development if Loughs Agency field staff are entitled to pay and conditions similar to those of the Northern Ireland Civil Service.

(AQW 8987/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The staff of the Agency are not NI Civil Servants and the Conditions of employment are different from those of the NI Civil Service.

At a meeting of the North South Ministerial Council, Foyle Carlingford and Irish Lights Commission Sector Meeting on 5^th July 2000 it was confirmed that the pay of the staff of the Loughs Agency would continue to be linked to the appropriate pay scales in the NI Civil Service.

The July 2000 decision also confirmed the maintenance of the then conditions of employment, but agreed that these could be reviewed on completion of a staff review. The review of staffing was undertaken and implementation was completed in early 2007. At this point a review of the conditions of service of the Loughs Agency was implemented.

Loughs Agency Employees

Mr McElduff asked the Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development if she will include fisheries officers in the Loughs Agency on the list of employees who are entitled to an all hours worked allowance.

(AQW 8988/08)

Ms M Gildernew: The proposals which the Loughs Agency has made to recognise the unsocial hours worked by staff will apply to all of their field staff.

Culture, Arts and Leisure

Paramilitary Murals

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what finance the Arts Council has made available to assist in the removal of paramilitary murals in estates in 2008.

(AQW 8437/08)

The Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure (Mr G Campbell): On 10 July 2006 the Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure launched the Re-imaging Communities Programme. The objective of the initiative was to help people feel part of and pride in the communities in which they live by enhancing the physical and natural environment and removing displays of sectarian aggression and intimidation from the public realm.

The Arts Council has allocated £750k from its Lottery budget to the Re-imaging Communities programme in the 2008/09 financial year. The funds are not simply for the removal of paramilitary murals, but include the replacement of these with artworks which express community pride and aspirations.

Paramilitary Murals

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure how much money the Arts Council set aside for the removal of paramilitary murals in the last 3 years.

(AQW 8438/08)

Mr G Campbell: The value of the Re-Imaging Communities programme is £3.3m over 3 years, 2006 to 2009. It includes a Lottery allocation of £750k from the Arts Council of Northern Ireland.

The Arts Council allocation will be awarded in full in July 2008.

The funds are not simply for the removal of paramilitary murals, but include the replacement of these with artworks which express community pride and aspirations.

Promoting Interest in Genealogy

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what action he is taking to promote interest in genealogy, especially for people from the USA, Canada, South Africa, Australia and New Zealand.

(AQW 8439/08)

Mr G Campbell: A major project the Electronic Catalogue for Northern Ireland [eCATNI], to make the detailed catalogues of the Public Record Office of Northern Ireland (PRONI) available and searchable on-line will be available by the end of this year; this will open up PRONI’s archives to a world-wide audience and particularly for genealogical research.

In addition, PRONI has re-designed its website which now includes specific pages on genealogy to guide the overseas visitor to the archives available in PRONI for genealogical research as well as lots of helpful advice to potential customers wanting to use the archives in PRONI.

In addition, PRONI has re-designed its website (launched in January 2008) which now includes specific pages on genealogy to guide the overseas visitor to the archives available in PRONI for genealogical research. It also has lots of helpful advice to potential customers wanting to use the archives in PRONI as well as details of our enquiry service which makes PRONI more accessible to overseas enquirers.

PRONI’s Public Service Agreement targets include the production of databases to a wide range of archives that will assist overseas customers to access the wealth of archival resources held in PRONI.

A number of overseas engagements in recent times have provided unique opportunities to promote interest in genealogy including the Smithsonian Folklife Festival in Washington DC last year.

Bookstart Scheme

Mr Beggs asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure the percentage uptake of the Bookstart Scheme to date; what plans his Department has to improve the uptake of the scheme; and how the scheme can play a role in raising literacy standards.

(AQW 8557/08)

Mr G Campbell: My Department provided additional funding of £312k in March 2008 for the marketing, support and distribution of Bookstart packs. The Education and Library Boards purchased enough Baby packs and Bookstart Treasure Chests to enable 100% coverage across Northern Ireland in 2008/09 for both schemes. I understand that Bookstart Plus is delivered in partnership with Surestart, in selected areas, with Surestart funding.

I understand that DE is currently reviewing its literacy and numeracy strategies which will include the promotion of reading materials for pre-school children. DCAL can make a positive contribution to improving pre-school children’s literacy through its network of public libraries and will continue to support the Department of Education, as lead Department, in progressing this aim.

Research evidence shows children who have been introduced to books from an early age attain higher literacy standards by the time they reach school age. The Bookstart scheme promotes early language development and a love of books by encouraging parents to share books with their children.

Northern Ireland Events Company

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure, pursuant to the answer to AQW 2449/08, when his department was made aware of discrepancies in PAYE, National Insurance, and VAT payments at the Northern Ireland Events Company; and to outline what action officials took as a result.

(AQW 8619/08)

Mr G Campbell: The draft independent review report of the circumstances involved in the deficit at the Northern Ireland Events Company contains a number of matters of some public concern. Although, there is no specific reference to discrepancies in PAYE, National Insurance and VAT payments within the Company, reference is made to a then ongoing VAT inspection and the requirement by Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs to clarify certain information. The Department has only subsequently been made aware of possible VAT issues within the Company.

Northern Ireland Events Company

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure, pursuant to the answer to AQW 2452/08, what the extent of the Northern Ireland Events Company overspend was at the end of the 2005-06 financial year; and to outline what action was taken by departmental officials as a result of that overspend.

(AQW 8620/08)

Mr G Campbell: In November 2006, the Department received Northern Ireland Events Company accounts for 2005-2006 showing net current liabilities at 30 March 2006 of £88,763. This figure was arrived at by deducting the amount owed to creditors (£631,302) from current assets (stated as £542,211). Departmental officials examined the accounts and no action was deemed to be necessary.

KPMG were commissioned by the Department to carry out a comprehensive review of all the circumstances surrounding the deficit accumulated by the Company. This review has identified a different deficit figure for that period. As these are matters of a sensitive legal and financial nature, I am unable to comment further in order to avoid prejudicing further investigations.

Northern Ireland Events Company

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure, pursuant to the answer to AQW 2410/08, to provide full details of the work undertaken by accountants Finnegan and Gibson during their visit to the offices of the Northern Ireland Events Company for a period of three days, and then for a further period of five days, during the 2006-07 financial year.

(AQW 8621/08)

Mr G Campbell: I have been informed by the Northern Ireland Events Company that its accountants, Finegan Gibson, visited its premises during 2006-2007 to carry out fieldwork on the audit of the Company’s accounts for year ending 31 March 2007.

KPMG were commissioned by the Department to carry out a comprehensive review of all the circumstances surrounding the deficit accumulated by the Company. This report contains matters of a sensitive legal and financial nature. I am unable to comment further on this matter in order to avoid prejudicing further investigations.

Appointment of the Chairman for Sport NI

Lord Browne asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure when he intends to announce the appointment of the Chairman for Sport NI.

(AQW 8684/08)

Mr G Campbell: The appointment process for the position of Chair of Sport Northern Ireland is ongoing and I would hope to make an announcement in the near future.

Windsor Park

Lord Browne asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure if future Northern Ireland soccer matches are to be played at a venue other than Windsor Park; what are the consequences for the agreement between the Irish Football Association and Linfield Football Club; and who would be responsible for any financial compensation to Linfield Football Club.

(AQW 8685/08)

Mr G Campbell: The Irish Football Association (IFA) is responsible for determining the venue at which Northern Ireland home international soccer matches are to be played. The consequences for the agreement between the IFA and Linfield FC over the staging of such matches at a venue other than Windsor Park are for the IFA and Linfield to decide in the first instance. The question of financial compensation to Linfield FC, if due, would be a matter for the IFA in the first instance.

2012 Olympics

Lord Browne asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure if any of the existing Irish League soccer grounds meet the criteria to host the 2012 Olympics soccer games.

(AQW 8686/08)

Mr G Campbell: No existing Irish League soccer grounds meet the criteria set by the International Olympic Committee to host soccer games at the 2012 Olympics.

2012 Olympics

Lord Browne asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what assessment he has made of the financial viability of bringing an Irish League Club ground up to the standard to meet the criteria for hosting soccer games in the 2012 Olympics.

(AQW 8687/08)

Mr G Campbell: The only stadium which is presently under consideration for hosting soccer games in the 2012 Olympics is the proposed multi-sports stadium. No assessment has therefore been made of the financial viability of bringing other grounds up to the standard required for the 2012 Olympics.

Local Postal Services

Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by his Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.

(AQW 8691/08)

Mr G Campbell: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ Report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of Postal Services and the Post Office network. Junior Minister Donaldson and Junior Minister Kelly wrote to Executive Ministers on 21 April asking them to consider whether any further public services could be delivered through post offices.

DCAL indicated that it currently sells angling permits through a distribution network including fishing tackle shops, hotels and tourist information outlets. While there are no obstacles to Post Offices selling DCAL permits or FCB and Loughs Agency angling licences, to replace the current distribution network would require careful consideration and planning. It may be more appropriate to strategically identify where there are geographical gaps in the current distribution network and consider distributing permits and licenses through Post Offices in those areas. The planned transfer of the FCB functions to the Department (early 2009) will provide an opportunity to review the distribution systems with regards to both licenses and permits.

Ulster Scots Academy

Mr Bresland asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what financial assistance has been provided to the Ulster Scots Academy in each of the last three financial years.

(AQW 8734/08)

Mr G Campbell: Funding granted to the Ulster Scots Academy is as listed below:

2005/06: £134,413

2006/07: £392,412

2007/08: £405,189

Departmental Funding to Sports Clubs

Mr Bresland asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what financial assistance has been provided to Cricket, the Gaelic Athletic Association, Hockey and Football in each of the last three financial years, broken down by (i) district council area; and (ii) club.

(AQW 8735/08)

Mr G Campbell: Sport Northern Ireland (SNI) is responsible for the development of sport in Northern Ireland including the distribution of funding. The tables below detail the amount of exchequer and lottery funding awarded to Cricket, the Gaelic Athletic Association, Hockey and Football in each of the last three financial years broken down by district council area and club.

2005/2006

CLUB	AWARD AMOUNT (£)	DISTRICT / COUNCIL	SPORT	FUNDING PROGRAMMES
St John's GAC	108,183	Down	Gaelic Sports	Lottery\Capital\Club Sport
Steelstown GAC	225,000	Derry	Gaelic Sports	Lottery\Capital\Building Sport
Cliftonville FC	800,000	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Stadia Safety Programme

2006 / 2007

CLUB	AWARD AMOUNT (£)	DISTRICT / COUNCIL	SPORT	FUNDING PROGRAMMES
Ballymena United FC	168,326	Ballymena	Association Football	Facilities\Stadia Safety Programme
Ards FC	458	Ards	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Cliftonville FC	4,023	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Armagh City FC	3,365	Armagh	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Glentoran FC	11,706	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Newry City FC	2,179	Newry & Mourne	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Dungannon Swifts FC	2,402	Dungannon	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Portadown FC	4,995	Armagh	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Linfield FC	11,628	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Enniskillen Gaels GAA	407,572	Fermanagh	Gaelic Sports	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Donegal Celtic FC	3,150	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Crusaders FC	2,134	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme

2007 / 2008

CLUB	AWARD AMOUNT (£)	DISTRICT / COUNCIL	SPORT	FUNDING PROGRAMMES
Kickhams Creggan GAC	240,000	Antrim	Gaelic Sports	Lottery\Capital\Building Sport
Lisnaskea Emmetts GAC	220,000	Fermanagh	Gaelic Sports	Lottery\Capital\Building Sport
Bready Cricket Club	1,817,451	Strabane	Cricket	Lottery\Capital\Building Sport
St Mary's GAC	235,000	Derry	Gaelic Sports	Lottery\Capital\Building Sport
Portadown FC	800,900	Craigavon	Association Football	Facilities\Stadia Safety Programme
Linfield FC	4,425	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Cliftonville FC	900	>Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Donegal Celtic FC	938	Belfast	Association Football	Facilities\Safety Management Programme
Na Magha Hurling Club	238,274	Derry	Gaelic Sports	Lottery\Capital\Building Sport
Newry Olympic Hockey Club	200,000	Newry & Mourne	Hockey	Exchequer\Capital\Building Sport
St Colmcille's GAC	245,000	Armagh	Gaelic Sports	Exchequer\Capital\Building Sport
Waringstown Cricket Club	40,000	Craigavon	Cricket	Exchequer\Capital\Building Sport
St Colm's GAC	100,000	Derry	Gaelic Sports	Exchequer\Capital\Building Sport
O'Brien's GAC	245,000	Derry	Gaelic Sports	Exchequer\Capital\Building Sport

Northern Ireland Athletes

Mr Ross asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what discussions he has held, or intends to hold, with the Great Britain Olympics Organisation to ensure that athletes from Northern Ireland can compete with the British team at the Olympic Games.

(AQW 8750/08)

Mr G Campbell: Responsibility for ensuring Northern Ireland athletes can compete for the Great Britain team rests, in the first instance, with the relevant sports governing bodies and the British Olympic Association (BOA). I would support any opportunities provided by the relevant sports governing bodies and the BOA to assist Northern Ireland athletes in qualifying and competing for the Great Britain Team at the Olympic Games.

Sports Events in Northern Ireland

Mr Ross asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure what action his Department has taken to attract sporting events to Northern Ireland, given the impact that this would have on tourism.

(AQW 8776/08)

Mr G Campbell: The promotion of sporting events is primarily the responsibility of the governing bodies of sport. However, it is consistent with the commitment of Government, through the draft Northern Ireland Strategy for Sport and Physical Recreation 2008-2018 produced by the Department and Sport Northern Ireland, to establish Northern Ireland as a world class venue for sporting events. The contribution to tourism of sport, including sporting events, emerged as an important issue in the development of the draft Strategy.

The Department’s Events Unit operates two grant funding programmes for events which: impact positively on the image of Northern Ireland, in particular its external image, create opportunity for social cohesion and bring direct and indirect benefits to Northern Ireland.

2008 Belfast Gay Pride Parade

Mr Kennedy asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure how much funding his Department is allocating to the 2008 Belfast Gay Pride Parade.

(AQW 8861/08)

Mr G Campbell: My Department has not allocated any funding to the 2008 Belfast Pride Parade.

From 1 April 2008 the delivery of the Community Festivals Fund was devolved to Local Authorities and festival organisers may apply to their local council for support.

The Northern Ireland Strategy for Sport and Physical Recreation 2007-2017

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure for his assessment of the desire for mixed leisure and sporting activities, based upon the Northern Ireland Life and Times Surveys and other reports.

(AQW 8866/08)

Mr G Campbell: The findings of the Northern Ireland Life and Times Survey in respect of the desire for mixed leisure and sporting activities is consistent with the proposals for the future development of sport and physical recreation in Northern Ireland set out within the recently published draft of "The Northern Ireland Strategy for Sport and Physical Recreation, 2007-2017". This draft Strategy was developed by the Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure in partnership with Sport Northern Ireland. It contains a number of proposals that are designed to promote and encourage community cohesion and community integration in sport and physical recreation in Northern Ireland.

Halloween Bonfires

Mr Moutray asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure how many complaints his Department has received in relation to the negative contribution to cultural expression of Halloween bonfires, in each of the last five years.

(AQW 8906/08)

Mr G Campbell: The Department has received no complaints in relation to the negative contribution to cultural expression of Halloween bonfires in each of the last five years.

Ulster Grand Prix

Mr Craig asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure for his assessment of the success of the Ulster Grand Prix and the value of the funding provided from his Department.

(AQW 8945/08)

Mr G Campbell: I recognise that the Ulster Grand Prix annual road race is one of the most important road races in the Northern Ireland motor sports’ road race calendar. Sport Northern Ireland (SNI) is responsible for the development of sport in Northern Ireland including the distribution of funding. SNI has provided the Ulster Grand Prix, via the 2 & 4 Wheel Motor Sport Steering Group Ltd, with an Exchequer award of £10,186. This will assist the organisers of the race implement essential safety improvements for the 2008 event.

The Ulster Grand Prix submitted an application to the Major Events Fund requesting £70,000. The application was assessed by DCAL Events Unit. The event scored 43.7% exceeding the required 40% threshold to permit funding. The Ulster Grand Prix submitted a detailed development plan prepared in partnership with Lisburn City Council. The internal assessment of the potential economic benefit of the event was estimated at £5.13 to every £1 of public sector investment.

The Grant Approval Panel, comprising two senior Departmental officials and an independent member from the NI Tourist Board met on the 18^th June and agreed that an offer of £40,000 on a revenue basis to support specific costs related to the preparation of the venue and the marketing of the event.

Architecture and the Built Environment Ministerial Advisory Group

Mr Newton asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure to detail the remit of the Architecture and the Built Environment Ministerial Advisory Group in terms of planning applications; and if it is within the remit of the advisory group to offer advice to Planning Service on planning applications.

(AQW 8989/08)

Mr G Campbell: The policy on ‘Architecture and the Built Environment for Northern Ireland’ (A+BE policy) published in June 2006 made provision for the establishment of a Ministerial Advisory Group (MAG) to advise the Minister of Culture, Arts and leisure on the implementation and development of the A+BE policy. In August 2007 the Minister announced the appointment of the chair and eight members of MAG. The A+BE policy provides MAG with the remit to offer advice to Planning Service on planning applications. It is also written into the Terms of Appointment that MAG shall review design aspects of significant projects including projects referred by Planning Service for comment.

Architecture and the Built Environment Ministerial Advisory Group

Mr Newton asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure how many members of the Architecture and the Built Environment Ministerial Advisory Group were invited to the meeting of the group on 18 April 2008; how members were notified of the meeting; and why less than half of the members of the group were present at the meeting.

(AQW 8990/08)

Mr G Campbell: The purpose of the meeting on 18 April 2008 was to carry out design reviews of two separate applications for planning approval. The first, a tall building proposal was reported to MAG members in December 2007. In February 2008 MAG members agreed to set up a subgroup to consider that scheme and to make a request to view the plans for a second scheme involving another tall building and to consider it alongside the first. The intention was that the subgroup should form the panel that would review the design of both schemes. Initially the proposed panel consisted of five, the chair and four members of MAG. The date was agreed and an open invitation issued to the three remaining MAG members but none accepted (At that time there was one vacancy in the MAG membership). Subsequently, one member of the proposed panel declared a conflict of interest in relation to one scheme which resulted in that member not attending either of the two reviews. As a result the chair and three members of MAG attended the meeting on 18 April 2008.

Architecture and the Built Environment Ministerial Advisory Group

Mr Newton asked the Minister of Culture, Arts and Leisure under what guidelines or constitution the Architecture and the Built Environment Ministerial Advisory Group operates.

(AQW 8991/08)

Mr G Campbell: The MAG operates within a mandate which is detailed in the Terms of Appointment (TOA). The TOA specifies the terms of appointment for the chair and members of MAG. The TOA incorporates procedures and operational guidelines as well as advice on public service standards of conduct and behaviour. A copy of the TOA is attached for the Member’s convenience.

APPENDIX A

ARCHITECTURE AND THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT FOR NORTHERN IRELAND MINISTERIAL ADVISORY GROUP

TERMS OF APPOINTMENT

Mandate The Architecture and the Built Environment - Ministerial Advisory Group for (A+BE MAG) shall:

Advise the Ministerial Design Champion and the Department of Culture, Arts and Leisure (DCAL) on the implementation and development of the policy on Architecture and the Built Environment for Northern Ireland (A+BENI) published in June 2006. DCAL is the sponsor Department;
Champion good design in all sectors of the built environment and challenge accepted guidance, policy and standards relevant to design, which are considered to fall short of expectations;
Collaborate with key stakeholders in the development of knowledge and skills concerning design of the built environment. Facilitate good design by disseminating research evidence, information and advice to those in the public and private sectors who have a role in the procurement and delivery of construction projects;
Help give effect to A+BENI policy objectives in the public interest whilst working within the policy and statutory framework and acting with professional integrity;
Review design aspects of significant projects including projects referred by the Planning Service for comment; and
Review the implementation of A+ BENI policy objectives. Through consultation with stakeholders assess its impact on design quality. Produce an annual report which incorporates evidence of progress and other relevant findings.

2.0 Aspirations The A+BE MAG shall seek to:

Establish a reputation as a respected source of advice on architecture and built environment issues pertinent to Northern Ireland;
Win recognition as a champion for good design whilst encouraging developers and policy makers to raise design standards in an ongoing way;

Membership and Appointments

The A+BE MAG shall consist of a Chair and up to 8 members appointed by the Minister for DCAL in accordance with the guidelines set out in the Commissioner for Public Appointments for Northern Ireland Code of Practice.

Appointments shall be for a term of 3 years with an option - dependent on satisfactory performance - for a further term of no greater than 3 years which shall be specified at the time of reappointment.
The post requires an average input of up to 2 days per month depending on business needs.
Appointments to fill interim vacancies shall be for the unexpired portion of the vacant post.
The Chair shall receive an annual fee of £6,000 from the Department.
The posts of member of the A+BE MAG are unremunerated.
Departmental procedures for appraising the performance of appointees apply.
Reasonable travelling and subsistence expenses incurred through carrying out official duties and certain dependant carer expenses determined in accordance with the Northern Ireland Civil Service Handbook shall be reimbursed by the Department.

Procedures and Operational Guidelines

The A+BE MAG shall meet quarterly. In the absence of the Chair the members of the Group shall agree for one of the members to deputise as Chair as a temporary measure. If the Chair or a member does not attend 2 consecutive meetings, his/her appointment shall be reviewed by the Department.

Design Review panels shall be chaired by either Chair or member of the A+BE MAG. The proceedings and recommendations shall be recorded.

Procedures are built into the appointments process to identify, discuss and record any real or perceived conflict of interest. Thereafter each member must declare any personal or business interests including any private, voluntary, charitable or political interest which might be material and relevant to the work of the A+BE MAG and which may, or may be perceived to, influence their judgement in performing their functions. Any conflict of interest whether real or perceived must be dealt with appropriately. These interests shall be recorded in a register of interests maintained and kept up-to-date by the A&BE MAG. Such procedures apply routinely to Design Review sessions and likewise any conflict of interest real or perceived shall be dealt with appropriately and documented.
Task groups chaired by members of the A+BE MAG shall provide advice in specific areas for example public housing, sustainable development or urban regeneration. Individuals with specialist expertise and experience drawn from a Call-off List shall support and contribute to the work of the A+BE MAG.
All formal meetings including sub-committee meetings are required to have an agenda and shall be recorded to include where appropriate review of action items, those responsible and the date action is completed. Design Review sessions shall be recorded to include all relevant issues, opinion and recommendations.
The Chair shall report regularly or on request to the Department.
The Department’s Press office will be available to assist the

A+BE MAG in all requests for press statements and media interviews.

Where authorised by the Department, costs associated with the activities of A+BE MAG will be paid by the Department.

Public Service Standards of Conduct and Behaviour

The Chair and members must be seen to act in the public interest at all times. Their conduct and behaviour must be beyond reproach. The Chair and members must be committed to the principles defined in the first report of the Committee on Standards in Public Life published in 1995.

Compliance with these principles requires holders of public office to:

Selflessness Take decisions solely in terms of the public interest. They should not do so in order to gain financial or other material benefits for themselves, their family or their friends;
Integrity Not place themselves under any financial or other obligation to outside individuals or organisations that might influence them in the performance of their official duties;
Objectivity In carrying out public business, including making public appointments, awarding contracts, or recommending individuals for rewards and benefits, make choices on merit;
Accountability Submit themselves to whatever scrutiny is appropriate to their post because they are accountable to the public for their decisions and actions;
Openness Be as open as possible in the decisions they make and actions they take. They should give reasons for their decisions and restrict information only when the wider public interest clearly demands;
Honesty Because they have a duty to declare any private interests relating to their public duties, take steps to resolve any conflicts arising in a way that protects the public interest; and
Leadership Promote and support these principles by leadership and example.

The requirement for probity applies equally to the Chair and Members of the A+BE MAG as well as those who are drawn from the Call-off List when participating in Design Review panels or contributing to the work of task groups.

Education

Ballywalter Primary School

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education to give a timescale within which the replacement of Ballywalter Primary School will commence.

(AQW 6065/08)

The Minister of Education (Ms C Ruane): Following a request from the South Eastern Education and Library Board, a site visit was undertaken by the Department’s technical advisors in 2007 and Ballywalter Primary was identified as having significant accommodation deficiencies. Earlier this month, the Department agreed the appraisal submitted by the South Eastern Education and Library Board for a new school on an alternative site.

De bharr nach bhfuil aon dáta leagtha síos don chéad fhógra eile i dtaobh cistiú caipitil, níl aon amscála ann ag an phointe seo maidir le leanúint ar aghaidh leis an scéim seo.

As there is currently no date set for the next capital funding announcement, there is no timescale at this stage for proceeding with this scheme.

Use of School Facilities by the Local Community

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education to detail, for each parliamentary constituency, (i) the number of schools that make their facilities available for (a) sporting clubs; and (b) community organisations, out of school hours; and (ii) the proportion of the total number of schools that this represents.

(AQW 6591/08)

Ms C Ruane: The Department does not collect information on the use of school premises outside of school hours.

Under Article 140 of the 1989 Education Order schools are encouraged to make premises available (when not required by or in connection with the school) for use by members of the community.

Through the Department’s Extended School programme almost 400 of our most socially disadvantaged schools have been identified for funding.

Our policy seeks to establish each extended school as the hub of its local community engaging positively and actively with neighbouring schools, statutory, voluntary and community sector organisations in an effort to meet the needs of the pupils in the school. As part of the process of preparing their Action Plans schools were asked to consult with local community and statutory organisations to establish if there are particular community needs which could be met by the school.

Ar ndóigh, ní féidir linn bheith ag súil le scoileanna bheith ábalta freagra dearfach a thabhairt ar gach iarratas ach tá naisc níos deise idir an scoil agus a pobal mar phríomheilimint den pholasaí, eilimint a bhfuilimid ag iarraidh forbairt a dhéanamh uirthi.

Of course we cannot expect schools to be able to respond positively to all requests but closer links between the school and its community is a key element of the policy and one which we are seeking to develop.

Funding for Irish Language

Ms S Ramsey asked the Minister of Education to detail the funding available to promote Irish language schools and Irish language education, broken down by parliamentary constituency.

(AQW 6800/08)

Ms C Ruane: The information is not readily available by Parliamentary constituency and an exercise to obtain it would result in disproportionate costs.

Under Article 89 of the Education Order 1998 the Department of Education funds the Comhairle na Gaelscolaíochta to encourage the development of Irish medium education in the north of Ireland. The Comhairle’s budget for 2008/09 is £581,000.

Sa bhliain airgeadais 2007-2008, ba é £7.9m an maoiniú a leithdháileadh ar Ghaelscoileanna neamhspleácha faoin Fhoirmle Chomh-mhaoinithe. Leithdháileadh Caipiteal £487,000 chomh maith.

In the 2007- 2008 financial year, funding allocated to free standing Irish medium schools under the Common Funding Formula was £7.9m. Capital amounting to £487,000 was also allocated.

Criterion Changes to Extended Schools Budget Allocations

Mr S Wilson asked the Minister of Education what consultation was carried out on changes to the criterion for the extended schools budget allocations.

(AQW 7113/08)

Ms C Ruane: The main difference to the criteria has been the move to more accurate, post-code based data for special and primary schools which draw over half their pupils from Neighbourhood Renewal Areas (NRA). It was always our intention to use that more accurate data once it became available. We have, additionally and necessarily, targeted the available resources directly at schools serving the most socially disadvantaged communities. This is in line with the aim of the Extended Schools programme.

B’ábhar pléite le Painéal Idirbhoird na Scoileanna Forleathnaithe agus le CSCC na critéir cháilitheachta agus na leithdháiltí buiséid faoi seach.

The eligibility criteria and respective budget allocations were the subject of discussions with the Inter-Board Extended Schools Panel and CCMS.

Extended Schools Programme

Mr Campbell asked the Minister of Education when the Extended Schools Programme began; and how long it was envisaged to last.

(AQW 7187/08)

Ms C Ruane: Seoladh na Scoileanna Sínte i Meitheamh 2006 mar pháirt den Phacáiste Maoinithe i gcomhair Páistí agus Daoine Óga; cuireadh £10m ar fáil i ngach ceann de na blianta airgeadais, 2006/07 agus 2007/08.

The Extended Schools was launched in June 2006 as part of the Children and Young People Funding Package with £10m made available in each of the 2006/07 and 2007/08 financial years.

It was envisaged that the programme would be a key vehicle for contributing to the strands across the Ten Year Strategy for Children and Young People and accordingly our understanding was that when funding was allocated to DE during direct rule that it was to be mainstreamed i.e. a baseline allocation and not a short term programme. However contrary to that understanding the funding for the programme was removed from the DE baseline from 2008-09 onwards and as a consequence I have only been able to continue funding at 60% of the level available to schools over the last two years meaning a substantial reduction from £10m to £5.8m.

I have raised the difficulties and registered most strongly my concerns, as far back as 20 September 2007 in a meeting with the Finance Minister and through correspondence on 8 separate occasions since, that the shortfall in funding presents. I will continue to press at every available opportunity during the year for additional resources, given the endorsement by the Assembly during the motion on 20 May, to restore this important programme.

Use of School Premises for the Local Community

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education what steps are being taken to make school premises available for use as community facilities outside of school hours.

(AQW 7225/08)

Ms C Ruane: Under Article 140 of the 1989 Education Order schools are encouraged to make premises available (when not required by or in connection with the school) for use by members of the community.

Through the Department’s Extended School programme almost 400 of our most socially disadvantaged schools have been identified for funding.

Ar ndóigh ní thig linn a bheith ag súil go mbeidh scoileanna in ann freagairt go dearfach do gach iarratas ach is príomhghné den bheartas naisc níos dlúithe idir an scoil agus a pobal agus is gné í atáimid ag iarraidh a fhorbairt.

Playboard

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education to detail the outcome of discussions with Playboard for frontline children's services.

(AQW 7304/08)

Ms C Ruane: Playboard were advised by my officials that the Department of Education had no responsibility for these projects which are currently funded by DHSSPS. OFMDFM has organised further meetings with DE and DHSSPS to discuss the future funding of these services. DE officials are due to meet with OFMDFM on 5 August 2008.

Integrated Development Funding

Mr Butler asked the Minister of Education what Integrated Development Funding was received by each primary school in (i) North Belfast; and (ii) West Belfast, in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 7331/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

Details are also provided for the West Belfast Greater Shankill Taskforce Initiative which was also funded from IDF resources.

School Name	Renewing Communities Funding 2006/07 (£)	Renewing Communities Funding 2007/08 (£)

Ballygolan PS	6,445	9,137
Ballysillan PS	24,740	29,306
Carr's Glen PS	27,600	29,125
Cavehill PS	5,000	5,000
Cliftonville PS	25,855	21,948
Currie PS	27,392	39,053
Edenbrooke PS	48,590	52,869
Glenwood PS	59,870	68,080
Grove PS	17,780	17,953
Ligoniel PS	16,885	22,235
Lowwood PS	22,235	26,234
Seaview PS	25,060	31,900
Wheatfield PS	29,235	45,323
Hazelwood Integrated PS	1,200	0
Blackmountain PS	20,480	22,347
Forth River PS	21,125	25,528
Harmony PS	29,235	37,285
Malvern PS	29,030	32,107
Springfield PS	15,500	17,500
Springhill PS	25,755	29,670
Suffolk PS	800	2,400
Totals	479,812	565,001

Colin IDF project

School Name	2007/08 (£)
St Kieran’s PS	8,620
Good Shepherd PS	8,620
St Luke’s PS	8,620
Scoil na Fuiseoige	8,620
St Mark’s PS	8,620
Our Lady Queen of Peace PS	8,620
Christ the Redeemer PS	8,620
Totals	60,340

Departmental Grants

Mr Easton asked the Minister of Education for the details of all grants available through her Department.

(AQW 7360/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá roinnt cineálacha éagsúla deontais a leithdháiltear trí mo Roinn agus tá siad seo liostaithe thíos.

There are a number of different types of grants allocated through my Department and these are listed below.

Grant-in-aid to provide general support to each of the Department’s Arms Length Bodies

The Belfast Education and Library Board

The North-Eastern Education and Library Board

The South-Eastern Education and Library Board

The Southern Education and Library Board

The Western Education and Library Board

The Council for Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment

The Council for Catholic Maintained Schools

The Staff Commission

Middletown Centre for Autism Limited

Middletown Centre for Autism (Holdings) Limited

Boards of Governors of Grant Maintained Integrated Schools

Boards of Governors of Voluntary Grammar Schools

Current grant provided for specific purposes

Comhairle na Gaelscolaiochta

NI Council for Integrated Education

Prince’s Trust XL Programme

KidsStop after Schools Club

Millennium Volunteers

Bytes Project

Barnardo’s

Save The Children

Include Youth

NSPCC/Childline

The Gaelic Athletic Association

The Irish Football Association

Music for Youth

The Queen’s University, Belfast

Amnesty International

The University of Ulster

Early Years, The Organisation for Children

NI Child Minding Association

Northern Health and Social Services Board

Southern Health and Social Services Board

Eastern Health and Social Services Board

Western Health and Social Services Board

Charter Work Experience

Foyle Schools and Employer Connections

Business Education Partnerships

Sentinus

Young Enterprise Northern Ireland

Capital Grants for approved Capital Works

Trustees of Voluntary Grammar Schools

Trustees of Grant Maintained Integrated Schools

Community Relations Core Funding Scheme

Belfast YMCA

Bytes Project - Community Relations

Childrens Project

Community Relations in Schools

Co-operation Ireland

Corrymeela

Creggan Education & Research Services

Forthspring Inter-Community Group

Harmony Community Trust

Kilcranny House

National Trust

Nerve Centre (The)

Childrens Enterprise

Childrens Holidays Scheme

NUS/USI (National Union of Students

Panarts

Public Achievement

REACT

St Patrick’s Centre

Spirit of Enniskillen Trust

Ulster Folk & Transport Museum

Verbal Arts Centre (NI) Ltd.

Wildfowl & Wetlands Trust

Youth Link

Voluntary Youth Projects – Capital Grants

St Columbanus College, Bangor

St Peter’s Immaculata Youth Club, Belfast

St Bronagh’s Youth Club, Rostrevor

Clonard Monastery Youth Centre

Patrician Youth Centre

St Joseph’s Youth Club

Ogras Club

St Mary’s Youth Centre

Corpus Christi Youth Centre

Boys’ Brigade Belfast Battalion

Corrymeela Community

Belfast & Lisburn Women’s Aid

Share Discovery ‘80’ Ltd

Downpatrick Group Scouting Ireland

Scout Council

WAVE Trauma Centre

Ederney Youth Club

Trillick & District YFC

Goalline Youth Centre

Belfast Circus School

Long Tower Youth & Community Centre

Pennyburn Youth Club

Scouting Ireland/Down & Connor Scouts

St Macartan’s Guide Unit

All Saints Youth Club

St John Bosco Youth Club

Seagoe Youth Group

Rosario Youth Club

St Mary’s Youth Club

YMCA -Lurgan

Challenge for Youth

Greenhill YMCA

St Oliver Plunkett Youth Club

1^st Warrenpoint Scouts Group

Lisburn YMCA

The Scout Association

Darkley Clubhouse/Crossfire Trust

St John’s Scouts

Ebrington Church Youth Council

St John Vianney Youth Centre

RNIB Northern Ireland

The 6^th Belfast Scout Group

Girlguiding Ulster

Belfast Activity Centre

Artibility (NI) Ltd

Youthcom

Langley Youth Club

Portstewart Guides

Donaghadee High School

Mr Cree asked the Minister of Education if she still intends to close Donaghadee High School, given the current provision for secondary school places in the North Down constituency.

(AQW 7634/08)

Ms C Ruane: Cuireadh deireadh leis an tréimhse chomhairliúcháin ar 30 Meitheamh; tréimhse comhairliúcháin a bhain leis an Togra Fhorbartha le dúnadh na scoile a cheadú. Agus an cinneadh á dhéanamh agam, cuirfidh mé na fachtóirí cuí uile san áireamh, lena n-áirítear leibhéal na bunscolaíochta a sholáthraítear sa cheantar.

The consultation period for the Development Proposal to allow for the closure of the school ended on 30 June. In making my decision I will take all relevant factors into account, including the level of post-primary provision in the area.

Siting of Schools Near Power Lines

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of Education what steps she is taking to ensure that during the proposed future school building programme new schools will not be sited close to overhead power lines.

(AQW 7664/08)

Ms C Ruane: The department has not had any consultations with the British Government or other devolved administrations in relation to the siting of schools near overhead power lines.

Tá roinnt rudaí le meas a dhéanamh orthu nuair a bhítear ag cuartú suímh do scoil nua, ceann acu seo is ea a chóngaraí is atá línte cumhachta don suíomh. Má bhíonn aon líne cumhachta ann cóngarach do shuíomh atá molta fá choinne scoile úir lorgaíonn an fhoireann deartha atá freagrach as pleanáil na scoile comhairle ó Leictreachas Thuaisceart Éireann agus más gá déantar na línte cumhachta a chlaonadh nó a chur faoi thalamh.

There are a number of factors to be considered when identifying a site for a new school of which the proximity of power lines to the site is one. If there are any power lines near the site of a proposed new school, the design team responsible for the planning of the school seek advice from NIE and if required the power lines are either diverted or buried underground.

Employment of Retired Teachers

Mr Elliott asked the Minister of Education how many retired teachers have been employed in (i) primary; and (ii) post-primary schools, in the last 12 months.

(AQW 7695/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

Primary

Post-Primary

Both

Primary

Nursery

Grammar

Secondary

Peripatetic*

Special*

975

90

157

738

18

186

1065

895

204

* Peripatetic and Special Schools can be either primary or post-primary schools

Schools Near Overhead Power Lines

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of Education what consultations her Department has had with the UK Government and other devolved administrations in relation to the siting of new schools near overhead power lines.

(AQW 7701/08)

Ms C Ruane: The department has not had any consultations with the British Government or other devolved administrations in relation to the siting of schools near overhead power lines.

Reading Recovery Programme

Dr McDonnell asked the Minister of Education (i) for her assessment of the effectiveness of the Reading Recovery programme and its ability to take children, particularly boys, out of underachievement; and what plans she has to reinstate funding for this programme.

(AQW 7734/08)

Ms C Ruane: Dearbhaíonn measúnuithe a rinneadh ar Bhreith ar an Léitheoireacht anseo agus in áiteanna eile araon gur idirghabháil éifeachtach í Breith ar an Léitheoireacht ag páistí óga a bhfuil deacrachtaí léitheoireachta acu.

Evaluations of Reading Recovery both here and elsewhere confirm that Reading Recovery is an effective intervention for young children with reading difficulties.

The arrangements for the future funding and delivery of Reading Recovery are tied into the literacy and numeracy strategy which issued for consultation in June 2008. The strategy recognises the importance of identifying problems in literacy and numeracy at an early stage and taking steps to resolve these. We envisage Reading Recovery as one of a number of approaches which will be supported once the strategy is finalised. In the meantime, the Literacy Steering Group has been asked to consider the arrangements for Reading Recovery as part of the process of drawing up the Regional Action Plan for Literacy from September 2008 and which is expected to be submitted shortly.

Car Park at Derryboye Primary School

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education when the building work will start on the car park at Derryboye Primary School; and what date will the car park be completed.

(AQW 7736/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá sé beartaithe ag Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlann an Oirdheiscirt tús a chur leis an obair ar charrchlós Bhunscoil Dhoire Bhuí san fhómhar agus táthar ag súil go gcríochnófar an obair faoi mhí an Mhárta 2009.

The South Eastern Education and Library Board is planning to start work on the Derryboye Primary School car park in the autumn and it is anticipated that work will be completed by March 2009.

Review of Community Relations Policy

Miss McIlveen asked the Minister of Education what are the terms of reference of the working group set up to review the community relations policy.

(AQW 7808/08)

Ms C Ruane: Shocraigh mé go gcuirfí cóip de na Téarmaí Tagartha i Leabharlann an Tionóil.

I have arranged to have a copy of the Terms of Reference placed in the Assembly Library.

Extended Schools Programme

Mr Butler asked the Minister of Education to detail the reduction in the amount of Extended Schools funding for primary schools in the Colin area; which schools will have a reduction in their Extended Schools funding; and whether the 'carry forward' funding for these schools will be withdrawn from their budgets.

(AQW 7810/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.


DENI Ref	School name	Ward name	2006/07	2007/08	2008/09
4036134	ST MARK'S PS	TWINBROOK	£35,972	£35,294	£21,070
4036285	THE GOOD SHEPHERD PS	POLEGLASS	£32,028	£31,223	£18,508
4046600	SCOIL NA FUISEOIGE	TWINBROOK	£18,314	£17,883	£11,186
Totals			£86,314	£84,400	£50,764

In respect of Extended School ‘ carry forward’ funding, all schools with underspends from 2007/08 will have full access to this funding in 2008/09.

In light of the very positive indications given by the Finance Minister to the Assembly on June Monitoring about the importance of the Extended Schools programme to the Executive I am very hopeful that additional in year resources will be allocated for the programme which will allow the Department to widen the eligibility criteria and restore previous funding levels.

Permanent Teaching Posts

Mr Savage asked the Minister of Education how many teachers, qualified within the last 5 years, are still without a full-time permanent teaching post.

(AQW 7841/08)

Ms C Ruane: The Department does not employ teachers nor does it hold this information. However, the General Teaching Council has been registering initial teacher education graduates on an annual basis since April 2004. The Council also seeks information, annually, from all grant-aided schools on teachers employed on a permanent or significant temporary nature (i.e. excluding supply/substitute teachers). The Council has provided the following information:

	(1) 2003/04	(1) 2004/05	(1) 2005/06	(1) 2006/07	(1) 2007/08
NI Graduate Records	705	792	816	807	801
Currently Registered	635	672	671	708	683
Currently Employed (see note 2)	535	490	413	337	187

Notes:

1. The years stated refer to the GTC Registration Year, i.e. 1 April to

31 March.

2. "Currently Employed" includes teachers who are employed on a permanent or significant temporary basis (i.e. excludes substitute/supply teachers).

Tá iarrtha agam ar mo Roinn tuilleadh oibre a dhéanamh ar phatrúin fostaíochta mhac léinn ag baint céime amach as oideachas tosaigh múinteoireachta.

I have asked my Department to undertake further work on the employment patterns of students graduating from initial teacher education.

New Senior High School in Lurgan

Mr Moutray asked the Minister of Education what plans she has to build a new senior high school in Lurgan.

(AQW 7905/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá scéim chaipitil fhaofa ann do Choláiste an Lorgain. Bhí gá le Breithmheas Eacnamaíochta de bharr gur moladh athruithe ar na bunphleananna; chuir Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlann an Deiscirt an cháipéis sin faoi bhráid na Roinne ní ba luaithe i mbliana agus tá comhairleoirí gairmiúla na Roinne á bhreithniú faoi láthair.

There is an approved capital scheme for Lurgan College. A revised Economic Appraisal was necessary due to proposed changes to the original plans, and this was submitted by the Southern Education and Library Board earlier this year and is currently with the Department’s professional advisers for consideration.

Special Educational Needs

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of Education what level of funding is provided to pupils of primary schools where the pupil has (i) no statement of educational need; and (ii) a statement of special educational need.

(AQW 8040/08)

Ms C Ruane: The information requested is not available.

Average funding in primary schools under the delegated formula funding arrangements in 2008/09 was £2,646 per pupil. Primary schools budgets may include funding for nursery class pupils as well as funding for pupils with statements of educational need within mainstream class and special unit settings.

Eisíonn Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlainne ráiteas de Riachtanais Speisialta Oideachais chun soláthar speisialta oideachais a chur ar fáil bhunaithe ar mheastachán riachtanais. Déantar an soláthar seo a chomhoiriúnú le riachtanais aonaracha an dalta, ar féidir leo a bheith an-éagsúil maidir leis an chineál soláthair atá de dhíth agus costas an tsoláthair sin, agus níl aon mheánchostas nó costas tipiciúil ann. Níl costais iomlána daltaí ar ráiteas, i suímh speisialta agus i bpríomhshuímh araon, ar fáil ar leithligh óna chéile don bhunoideachas agus don iarbhunoideachas.

A statement of Special Educational Needs is issued by an Education and Library Board to make special educational provision based on an assessment of need. This provision is matched to the individual needs of a pupil, which can vary widely in the nature of provision required and the cost of that provision, and there is no average or typical cost. The overall costs for statemented pupils, both in special and mainstream settings, are not available separately for primary and post-primary.

Capital Development Proposals

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education to detail the number of (i) new build capital development proposals; and (ii) capital development proposals, currently with her Department, for which valid economic appraisals have been accepted; the length of time they have been with her Department; and how many site meetings were granted by her officials as part of the process towards the submission of valid economic appraisals, in relation to all capital development proposals in each of the last 5 years.

(AQW 8045/08)

Ms C Ruane: All capital schemes which have been announced for funding have agreed economic appraisals. In all cases they were preceded by a site visit to the school and in the case of a potential amalgamation on a new site or relocation to a new site, a visit to the proposed new site.

Tá eolas faighte ag an Roinn ar 80 scéim chaipitil atá beartaithe faoi láthair; fuair an Roinn an t-eolas sin ón údarás oideachais chuí. Tá breithmheas eacnamaíochta ag ceithre scéim is fiche faoi láthair; tá 5 cinn acu ceadaithe ag an Roinn.

There are currently 80 proposed capital schemes which have been identified to the department by the relevant education authority. Twenty-four of these currently have economic appraisals, 5 of which have been approved by the Department. Of the 5 one was approved in October 2006, one June 2007, one January 2008 and two in June 2008. All of these schemes were the subject of site visits which are requested by the relevant authority in advance of the appraisal work.

The number of site visits in each of the past 5 years was as follows:

Year	Number of Visits
2003/04	15
2004/05	44
2005/06	29
2006/07	2
2007/08	2

Ballywalter Primary School

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how long Ballywalter Primary School has been listed as a priority scheme by her Department; when her Department accepted the findings of the economic appraisal submitted by the South Eastern Education and Library Board; and the timescale for completion of this scheme.

(AQW 8050/08)

Ms C Ruane: Following a request from the South Eastern Education and Library Board, a site visit was undertaken by the Department’s technical advisors in 2007 and Ballywalter Primary was identified as having significant accommodation deficiencies. Earlier this month, the Department agreed the appraisal submitted by the South Eastern Education and Library Board for a new school on an alternative site.

De bharr nach bhfuil aon dáta leagtha síos don chéad fhógra eile i dtaobh cistiú caipitil, níl aon amscála ann ag an phointe seo maidir le leanúint ar aghaidh leis an scéim seo.

As there is currently no date set for the next capital funding announcement, there is no timescale at this stage for proceeding with this scheme.

Ballywalter Primary School

Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Education when she expects to bring forward a capital build programme that includes a replacement school building for Ballywalter Primary school.

(AQW 8055/08)

Ms C Ruane: Following a request from the South Eastern Education and Library Board, a site visit to Ballywalter Primary School was undertaken by the Department’s technical advisors in 2007.

An mhí seo caite, thug an Roinn breithmheas eacnamaíochta chun réitigh; ba é Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlann an Oirdheiscirt a chuir isteach é. Ní dhearnadh aon chinneadh go fóill ar thráthúlacht an chéad fhógra eile i dtaobh cistiú caipitil.

Last month, the Department agreed an economic appraisal submitted by the South Eastern Education and Library Board. No decision has been made on the timing of the next capital funding announcement.

New Build Project at Academy Primary, Saintfield

Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Education what plans there are for a new build project at Academy Primary in Saintfield and what is the timescale for any proposal.

(AQW 8056/08)

Ms C Ruane: Following a request from the South Eastern Education and Library Board for a site visit to this school in May 2008, the Department has requested further information on the accommodation at the school to help inform the consideration of the necessity for a capital scheme. This information will be assessed by the Department on receipt and, if necessary, a site visit will be arranged.

Go dtí go gcomhaontaítear riachtanas le scéim chaipitil leis an Bhord ní féidir cur in iúl cá huair a rachadh tionscadal do Bhunscoil an Acadaimh ar aghaidh.

Until a need for a capital scheme has been agreed with the Board, it is not possible to give any indication as to when a project for Academy Primary School would proceed.

Entry to Controlled Nursery Schools

Mr O'Loan asked the Minister of Education whether a controlled nursery school can give entry preference to children who have an older brother or sister currently attending, or has previously attended, the school; and what is her assessment of the discriminatory impact of this criterion on (i) a child who is the eldest in a family; and (ii) the parents in terms of age.

(AQW 8078/08)

Ms C Ruane: The Pre-School Education in Schools (Admissions Criteria) Regulations 1999 apply to the admissions criteria used by nursery schools and nursery classes in primary schools. These Regulations state that priority must be given, in the following order, to:

children from socially disadvantaged circumstances who will be aged 4 before September in their final pre-school year

children from socially disadvantaged circumstances who will be aged 3 before September in their final pre-school year

children not falling within i. or ii. who will be aged 4 before 1 September in their final pre-school year

children not falling within i. or ii. who will be aged 3 before 1 September in their final pre-school year.

These Regulations also require that further criteria be set to reflect the Board of Governors’ priorities for admission to each school. Responsibility for drawing up these criteria rests entirely with the Board of Governors of each school. If the Governors’ wish to give entry preference to children who have an older brother or sister currently attending, or has previously attended, that is entirely a matter for the Board of Governors.

Nuair a chuirtear critéir iontrála i bhfeidhm mar is ceart, bíonn rogha le déanamh idir iarratasóirí áirithe thar iarratasóirí eile. Dá thairbhe sin, b’fhéidir go mbraithfeadh na daoine úd nár éirigh leo gur caitheadh go leatromach leo ar dhóigh éigin

The application of admissions criteria by definition involves the prioritisation of some applicants above others, and as such this may be perceived by those who are unsuccessful as being in some way discriminatory. However, provided the criteria employed are not in breach of either education or other relevant law, this should not be the case.

Capital Works Schemes

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education to outline the capital schemes that have been approved by her Department and the start date for each, broken down by parliamentary constituency.

(AQW 8099/08)

Ms C Ruane: Léiríonn Tábla A thíos na mórscéimeanna oibreacha caipitiúla a ceadaíodh agus na háiteanna ina bhfuil obair thógála á déanamh faoi láthair.

Table A below identifies major capital works schemes which have been approved and where construction is currently underway.

TABLE A

PARLIAMENTARY CONSTITUENCY	SCHOOL	DETAILS OF PROJECT	ESTIMATED COMPLETION DATE
Belfast West	La Salle Boys’ S.S. Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	Apr-09
Belfast West	St Dominic’s H.S. Belfast	Extension & Refurbishment	Jan-10
East Derry	Burnfoot/Dungiven/Largy P.S.	New replacement school on existing site	Aug-08
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	Mount Lourdes G.S. Enniskillen	Extension & Refurbishment	Jun-08
Lagan Valley	Ballymacrickett P.S.	New replacement school on extended site	Nov-08
Lagan Valley	Brookefield Special School, Moira	New replacement school on existing site	Feb-09
Lagan Valley	Ballinderry P.S.	New replacement school on existing site	Feb-09
Lagan Valley	Pond Park P.S. Lisburn	New replacement school on extended site	Apr-09
Newry & Armagh	St Colman’s College, Newry	Extension & Refurbishment	Feb-09
Newry & Armagh	St Peter’s P.S. Cloughreagh	New replacement school on existing site	Sep-09
Newry & Armagh	Abbey G.S. Newry	New replacement school on new site	Nov-09
North Antrim	Moorfields P.S. Ballymena	New replacement school on existing site	Aug-08
North Down	Bangor Academy	New replacement school on existing site	Jun-08
North Down	Towerview P.S. Bangor	New replacement school on existing site	Jul-09
South Down	St Patrick’s P.S. Saul	New replacement school on new site	Jul-08
South Down	Assumption G.S. Ballynahinch	Extension & Refurbishment	Dec-09
Strangford	Victoria P.S. Ballyhalbert	New replacement school on extended site	Sep-08
Upper Bann	Waringstown P.S.	Extension & Refurbishment	Sep-08
West Tyrone	Holy Cross College, Strabane	New replacement school on existing site	Jul-08
West Tyrone	Drumragh Integrated College. Omagh	New replacement school on new site	Apr-09

There are also major capital schemes that have been approved which are currently at various stages of the planning process prior to the construction stage. The details of these projects are listed in Table B. These projects are being progressed with the relevant education authorities and the estimated timescales for doing so will be subject to all statutory approvals being achieved, the necessary planning and building processes being completed satisfactorily, and the availability of resources in any particular year.

TABLE B

PARLIAMENTARY CONSTITUENCY	SCHOOL	DETAILS OF PROJECT	ESTIMATED COMPLETION DATE
Belfast East	Glendhu NS, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2008/09
Belfast East	Ravenscroft NS, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2008/09
Belfast East	Strathearn GS, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Belfast East	Knockbreda HS, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Belfast East	Strand / Sydenham P.S.	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Belfast East	Strandtown PS, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Belfast East	Mitchell House Special School	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
Belfast East	Greenwood Assessment Centre	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
Belfast East	Ashfield Girls H.S. Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Belfast East	Grosvenor G.S. Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Belfast East	Orangefield P.S. Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Belfast East	Lagan College, Belfast	Extension & refurbishment	2010/11
Belfast East	Our Lady & St Patrick’s College, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Belfast North	Whitehouse PS, N'Abbey	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Belfast North	Little Flower Girls S.S, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Belfast North	Belfast Boys Model School	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Belfast North	Belfast Model School for Girls	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Belfast South	Victoria College, Belfast	Extension & refurbishment	2012/13
Belfast South	Methodist College, Belfast	Extension & refurbishment	2013/14
Belfast South	Taughmonagh P.S. Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Belfast West	Scoil Na Fuiseoige P.S, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Belfast West	Colaiste Feirste, Belfast	Extension & refurbishment	2010/11
Belfast West	Springhill P.S. Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Belfast West	Glenwood P.S./Edenderry NS, Belfast	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
East Derry	BallyKelly PS, Limavady	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
East Derry	Limegrove / Glasvey Special School	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	Lisbellaw P.S.	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	Coranny & Cornagague P.S.	New replacement school on new site	2009/10
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	St Pat's Boys/Girls Acad, Dgnon	New replacement school on existing site	2012/13
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	Enniskillen Model PS	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	St Paul's P.S. Irvinestown	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
Fermanagh & South Tyrone	Devenish College	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
Foyle	Lisnagelvin P.S.	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Foyle	New Buildings PS, Derry	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Foyle	Eglinton PS, Derry	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Foyle	Ebrington PS, L'Derry	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
Foyle	Foyle & Londonderry College	New replacement school on new site	2012/13
Foyle	Belmont Special School	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Foyle	St Cecilia’s College, Derry (PPP)	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Foyle	St Mary’s College, Derry (PPP)	New replacement school on new site	2009/10
Lagan Valley	St Colman's P.S. Lambeg	New replacement school on extended site	2009/10
Lagan Valley	Dromore Central P.S.	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
Mid Ulster	St Columba's P.S, Straw, Draperstown	New replacement school on new site	2009/10
Mid Ulster	Magherafelt HS	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Mid Ulster	Magherafelt P.S.	New replacement school on new site	2009/10
Mid Ulster	Edendork P.S	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
Mid Ulster	Holy Family PS, Magherafelt	New replacement school on extended site	2011/12
Mid Ulster	Rainey Endowed School, Magherafelt	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Mid Ulster	Holy Trinity College, Cookstown	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
Newry & Armagh	St Joseph's P.S Madden, Armagh	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Newry & Armagh	St Catherine's College, Armagh	Extension to Irish medium unit	2008/09
Newry & Armagh	St Clare’s Abbey PS Newry	New replacement school on extended site	2010/11
Newry & Armagh	St Oliver Plunkett P.S. Forkhill	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
Newry & Armagh	Dromintee P.S.	New replacement school on extended site	2009/10
Newry & Armagh	St Joseph's Convent PS, Newry	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Newry & Armagh	St Patrick's G.S. Armagh	Extension & refurbishment	2012/13
North Antrim	St Patrick’s & St Brigid's P.S. B'castle	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
North Antrim	Ballymoney H.S.	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
North Antrim	St Mary’s P.S. Portglenone (PPP)	New replacement school on extended site	2009/10
North Down	Bangor Grammar	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
North Down	St Columbanus College, Bangor	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
North Down	Priory College, Holywood	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
North Down	Holywood PS	New replacement school on new site	2012/13
South Antrim	Templepatrick PS	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
South Antrim	Parkhall College, Antrim	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
South Down	Carrick P.S. Warrenpoint	New replacement school on extended site	2009/10
South Down	St Mary's P.S, Newcastle	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
South Down	St Louis Grammar, Kilkeel	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
South Down	Knockevin Spec School, Downpatrick	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
South Down	St Bronagh's P.S (Conv of Mercy/St Mary's Boys P.S) Rostrevor	New replacement school on extended site	2010/11
South Down	The High School, Ballynahinch	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
South Down	St Patrick’s G.S. Downpatrick (PPP)	New replacement school on existing site	2009/10
Strangford	Glastry College, Ballyhalbert	New replacement school on extended site	2011/12
Strangford	S Joseph’s P.S. Carryduff (PPP)	New replacement school on extended site	2009/10
Strangford	Tor Bank Special School, Dundonald (PPP)	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
Upper Bann	Banbridge Academy	Extension & refurbishment	2011/12
Upper Bann	St Teresa's PS, Lurgan	New replacement school on extended site	2009/10
Upper Bann	Tannaghmore P.S, Lurgan	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Upper Bann	St Patrick's College, Banbridge	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Upper Bann	St Mary's P.S, Banbridge	New replacement school on existing site	2010/11
Upper Bann	Lurgan College	New replacement school on existing site	2012/13
Upper Bann	Portadown College	New replacement school on existing site	2012/13
West Tyrone	St Columbkille's P.S. Carrickmore	New replacement school on extended site	2010/11
West Tyrone	Artigarvan PS, Strabane	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
West Tyrone	St Conor's P.S, Omagh	New replacement school on extended site	2010/11
West Tyrone	Omagh IPS	New replacement school on new site	2010/11
West Tyrone	Dean Maguirc College, Carrickmore	New replacement school on new site	2011/12
West Tyrone	Cranny Special School, Omagh	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
West Tyrone	Arvalee Spec School, Omagh	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12
West Tyrone	Loreto College, Omagh	New replacement school on existing site	2011/12

Funding Initiatives

Mr Attwood asked the Minister of Education what level of funding has been earmarked for major initiatives such as (i) children and young people's funding; (ii) Extended Schools; and (iii) Renewing Communities, in 2008-09; and how this compares with the level of funding in 2007-08.

(AQW 8155/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

Projects

2007/08 Allocation

£k

2008/09 Allocation

£k

Projects / activities formerly funded under the Children and Young People Funding Package

24,252

18,824

Renewing Communities

1,840

310

In addition to the above, for 2008-09, mainstream funding of £16.1 million has been provided within schools delegated budgets in line with the funding which was allocated direct to schools from the Children and Young People Funding Package in 2007/08.

In relation to the extended schools programme funded under the Children and Young People Funding Package, I wanted to continue funding at previous levels but with the resources available was unable to do so. I have only been able to continue funding at 60% of the level available to schools over the last two years meaning a massive cut from £10m to £5.8m.

Leanfaidh mé, gach deis atá ar fáil le linn na bliana, de bheith ag iarraidh tuilleadh acmhainní, ó thacaigh an Tionól le linn rún 20 Bealtaine, le hathbhunú an chláir thábhachtaigh seo.

I will continue to press at every available opportunity during the year for additional resources, given the endorsement by the Assembly during the motion on 20 May, to restore funding levels for this important programme.

You may have seen Nigel Dodds’ statement to the Assembly on 24 June regarding June Monitoring and it looks hopeful that additional resources will be made available for the programme.

Educational Psychologists

Mr Attwood asked the Minister of Education how many children were waiting to see an educational psychologist on 1 December 2007, in each of the Education and Library Board areas.

(AQW 8156/08)

Ms C Ruane: Chuir Príomh-Fheidhmeannaigh na mBord Oideachais agus Leabharlainne in iúl dom go raibh an líon seo páistí a leanas ag feitheamh le síceolaí oideachasúil a fheiceáil ar 1 Nollaig 2007.

I have been advised by the Chief Executives of the Education and Library Boards that the following numbers of children were waiting to see an educational psychologist on 1 December 2007.

BELB	564
NEELB	499
SEELB	600
SELB	218
WELB	88

These figures are in regard to children with a variety of need, including Stage 3 (non-statutory assessments) and Stage 4 (statutory assessments) of the Code of Practice on the Identification and Assessment of Special Educational Needs, reviews at Stage 3 and Stage 5 of the Code of Practice, special testing at transfer stage between primary and post-primary, pre-school and examination arrangements.

Class Sizes

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of Education the current maximum permissable class sizes for (i) P1 - P3 classes; (ii) P4 - P7 classes; and (iii) composite classes; and what plans her Department has to reduce pupil-teacher ratios.

(AQW 8184/08)

Ms C Ruane: The current maximum permissible class size for P1 – P4 classes (including composite classes) is 30. The Department has not set a maximum permissible class size in relation to P5 – P7 classes (including composite classes).

Creidim go bhfuil sé thar a bheith tábhachtach líon na ndaltaí a bhíonn i ranganna a laghdú; bheadh infheistíocht shubstaintiúil ón Choiste Fheidhmiúcháin de dhíth leis an sprioc sin a bhaint amach. Ar an ábhar go bhfuil ardchostas i gceist, breithneoidh an Coiste Feidhmiúcháin an plean taobh lena chuid tosaíochtaí eile.

I believe it is very important to reduce class sizes and this would require substantial investment by the Executive. It will therefore have to be considered alongside its other priorities.

St. Colman's Primary School, Shinn

Mr P J Bradley asked the Minister of Education if she is aware of the Health and Safety risk associated with the overcrowding at St. Colman's Primary School, Shinn.

(AQW 8210/08)

Ms C Ruane: I am very aware of the accommodation issues at St Colman’s, having visited the school on 2 May 2008. I was very impressed by the commitment and dedication of the teachers and pupils.

Bhí measúnú á dhéanamh ag Roinn s'agamsa ar an chóiríocht ag an scoil agus rachaimid i dteagmháil leis an scoil arís roimh i bhfad maidir leis an dóigh a bhfuil cúrsaí.

My Department has been assessing the accommodation at the school and will be in contact with the school again shortly on the position.

Primary School Pupils Receiving School Transport

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how many pupils attending (i) State Controlled primary schools; (ii) Catholic Maintained primary schools; (iii) Integrated primary schools; and (iv) Irish Medium primary schools, used school transport during the 2007-08 academic year, broken down by (a) Education and Library Board; and (ii) school.

(AQW 8220/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá dearbhaithe ag na Boird Oideachais agus Leabharlainne go raibh an líon daltaí a leanas ag freastal ar na h-earnálacha bunscoile liostaithe agus ag fáil iompar scoile in 2007/08:

The Education and Library Boards have confirmed that the following number of pupils were attending the primary school sectors listed and receiving school transport in 2007/08:

	Controlled	Catholic Maintained	Integrated*	Irish Medium	TOTAL
BELB	79	0	157	3	239
NEELB	1,540	1,471	253	5	3,269
SEELB	1,178	491	127	5	1,801
SELB	1,985	2,780	159	16	4,940
WELB	2,408	3,215	352	125	6,100

* This category includes both Grant Maintained and Controlled Integrated schools.

Broken down by individual school as follows:

(i) Controlled Primary Schools:

Belfast Board:	Ballygolan Primary School	29
	Botanic Primary School	2
	Cregagh Primary School	2
	Down High School (Prep)	2
	Elmgrove Primary School	1
	Euston Street Primary School	1
	Glenwood Primary School	2
	Knockbreda Primary School	3
	Orangefield Primary School	1
	Taughmonagh Primary School	35
	Vere Foster Primary School	1
North-Eastern Board:	Antrim Primary School	2
	Armoy Primary School	3
	Ballyclare Primary School	5
	Ballykeel Primary School	1
	Ballymena Primary School	6
	Ballymoney Model Primary School	3
	Ballynure Primary School	22
	Ballysally Primary School	6
	Ballytober Primary School	6
	Balnamore Primary School	7
	Broughshane Primary School	44
	Buick Memorial Primary School	74
	Bushmills Primary School	4
	Bushvalley Primary School	68
	Cairncastle Primary School	15
	Carnaghts Primary School	28
	Carnalbanagh Primary School	27
	Carrickfergus Central Primary School	1
	Carrowreagh Primary School	22
	Castleroe Primary School	1
	Clough Primary School	83
	Cloughmills Primary School	5
	Creavery Primary School	5
	Cregagh Primary School	1
	Crumlin Primary School	111
	Cullycapple Primary School	2
	D H Christie Memorial Primary School	2
	D H Christie Memorial Primary School, Special Unit	62
	Dromara Primary School	1
	Drumachose Primary School	1
	Drumard Primary School	19
	Duneane Primary School	4
	Dunseverick Primary School	93
	Earlview Primary School	1
	Eden Primary School, Ballymoney	14
	Fairview Primary School	1
	Garvagh Primary School	37
	Gorran Primary School	51
	Gracehill Primary School	13
	Greenisland Primary School	1
	Groggan Primary School	61
	Harpur's Hill Primary School	2
	Hazelbank Primary School	29
	Hezlett Primary School	32
	Kells & Connor Primary School	17
	Kilbride Central Primary School	1
	Kilrea Primary School	38
	Kilross Primary School	6
	Knockahollet Primary School	34
	Knockloughrim Primary School	24
	Larne & Inver Primary School	6
	Leaney Primary School	4
	Limavady Central Primary School	1
	Longstone Primary School	31
	Macosquin Primary School	20
	Maghera Primary School	8
	Magherafelt Primary School	16
	Millburn Primary School	1
	Moneymore Primary School	8
	Moorfields Primary School	104
	Mossley Primary School	3
	Moyle Primary School	1
	Mullaghdubh Primary School	1
	Oakfield Primary School	1
	Pond Park Primary School	1
	Portglenone Primary School	24
	Portstewart Primary School	3
	Randalstown Central Primary School	19
	Rasharkin Primary School	37
	Straid Primary School	26
	Straidbilly Primary School	7
	Straidhavern Primary School	41
	Templepatrick Primary School	7
	The Diamond Primary School	9
	The Irish Society's Primary School	2
	The Thompson Primary School	2
	Tildarg Primary School	16
	Toreagh Primary School	4
	Upper Ballyboley Primary School	22
	Victoria Primary School	1
	Whitehouse Primary School	2
	Woodburn Primary School	2
	Woods Primary School	14


South-Eastern Board:	Abbey Primary School	2
	Academy Primary School	41
	Alexander Dickson Primary School	1
	Anahilt Primary School	34
	Andrews Memorial Primary School	6
	Ballinderry Primary School	53
	Ballycarrickmaddy Primary School	74
	Ballycloughan Primary School	1
	Ballygolan Primary School	1
	Ballyholme Primary School	3
	Ballykeigle Primary School	10
	Ballymacash Primary School	2
	Ballymagee Primary School	5
	Ballynahinch Primary School	1
	Ballywalter Primary School	3
	Belvoir Park Primary School	36
	Bloomfield Road Primary School	13
	Braniel Primary School	2
	Brooklands Primary School	6
	Brownlee Primary School	1
	Cairnshill Primary School	3
	Carrowdore Primary School	1
	Castle Gardens Primary School	2
	Castlewellan Primary School	28
	Clandeboye Primary School	9
	Comber Primary School	1
	Crawfordsburn Primary School	3
	Cregagh Primary School	5
	Crumlin Primary School	13
	Cumran Primary School	101
	Donaghadee Primary School	5
	Down High Preparatory	3
	Downpatrick Primary School	60
	Downshire Primary School	18
	Dromara Primary School	28
	Dromore Central Primary School	1
	Dundonald Primary School	4
	Dunmurry Primary School	1
	Gilnahirk Primary School	2
	Grange Park Primary School	1
	Harmony Hill Primary School	1
	Holywood Primary School	7
	Kilcooley Primary School	1
	Killinchy Primary School	114
	Killowen Primary School	4
	Kilmaine Primary School	2
	Kirkistown Primary School	26
	Knockbreda Primary School	17
	Knockmore Primary School	56
	Largymore Primary School	4
	Leadhill Primary School	2
	Lisburn Central Primary School	1
	Lisnasharragh Primary School	4
	Loughries Primary School	1
	Maghaberry Primary School	16
	McKinney Primary School	39
	Meadow Bridge Primary School	140
	Millisle Primary School	1
	Moira Primary School	5
	Moneyrea Primary School	2
	Newcastle Primary School	6
	Newtownards Model Primary School	5
	Newtownbreda Primary School	1
	Old Warren Primary School	2
	Pond Park Primary School	5
	Portavogie Primary School	1
	Rathmore Primary School	3
	Redburn Primary School	1
	Riverdale Primary School	26
	Seymour Hill Primary School	18
	Spa Primary School	33
	Strandtown Primary School	1
	Taughmonagh Primary School	2
	Towerview Primary School	14
	Victoria Primary School (Ballyhalbert)	18
	Victoria Primary School (Newtownards)	4
	West Winds Primary School	11

Southern Board:	Abercorn Primary School	1
	Augher Central Primary School	18
	Aughnacloy Primary School	58
	Ballinderry Primary School	2
	Ballydown Primary School	46
	Ballytrea Primary School	61
	Benburb Primary School	14
	Birches Primary School	54
	Brackenagh West Primary School	162
	Bronte Primary School	9
	Bush Primary School	35
	Carntall Primary School	79
	Carrick Primary School, Lurgan	36
	Churchill Primary School	37
	Clare Primary School	38
	Clogher Regional Primary School	1
	Cookstown Primary School	6
	Cortamlet Primary School	55
	Donaghey Primary School	28
	Donaghmore Primary School	23
	Dromore Central Primary School	37
	Drumadonnell Primary School	35
	Drumhillery Primary School	47
	Dungannon Primary School	2
	Edenderry Primary School, Banbridge	2
	Fair Hill Primary School	28
	Fivemiletown Primary School	9
	Hamiltonsbawn Primary School	20
	Hardy Memorial Primary School	52
	Howard Primary School	1
	Iveagh Primary School	37
	Kilkeel Primary School	37
	Killylea Primary School	6
	Killyman Primary School	1
	Kingsmills Primary School	17
	Lisfearty Primary School	25
	Lisnadill Primary School	1
	Markethill Primary School	112
	Minterburn Primary School	6
	Mountnorris Primary School	48
	Moy Regional Primary School	4
	Newmills Primary School	15
	Newtownhamilton Primary School	36
	Omagh County Primary School	1
	Orchard County Primary School	60
	Orritor Primary School	90
	Poyntzpass Primary School	36
	Queen Elizabeth II Primary School	22
	Richmond Primary School	70
	Richmount Primary School	184
	Scarva Primary School	18
	Stewartstown Primary School	6
	Tamnamore Primary School	6
	Tandragee Primary School	2
	The Armstrong Primary School	1
	The Cope Primary School	112
	Walker Memorial Primary School	36

Western Board:	Aghadrumsee Primary School	45
	Ardstraw Primary School	22
	Artigarvan Primary School	71
	Ashlea Primary School	3
	Ballinamallard Primary School	5
	Ballykelly Primary School	65
	Bellarena Primary School	28
	Belleek No 2 Primary School	33
	Bready Jubilee Primary School	70
	Bridgehill Primary School	36
	Brookeborough Primary School	24
	Burnfoot Primary School	19
	Cooley Primary School	98
	Cumber Claudy Primary School	82
	Denamona Primary School	51
	Derrygonnelly Primary School	34
	Donemana Primary School	75
	Dromore Primary School	34
	Drumachose Primary School	27
	Drumahoe Primary School	20
	Drumlegagh Primary School	25
	Dunmullan Primary School	33
	Ebrington Primary School	1
	Edwards Primary School	57
	Eglinton Primary School	24
	Enniskillen Model Primary School	106
	Erganagh Primary School	21
	Fivemiletown Primary School	45
	Florencecourt Primary School	82
	Gibson Primary School	93
	Gillygooley Primary School	38
	Gortin Primary School	35
	Hezlett Primary School	2
	Irvinestown Primary School	70
	Jones Memorial Primary School	88
	Kesh Primary School	96
	Killen Primary School	11
	Lack Primary School	37
	Langfield Primary School	22
	Largy Primary School	12
	Limavady Central Primary School	48
	Lisbellaw Primary School	125
	Lisnagelvin Primary School	2
	Londonderry Model Primary School	2
	Maguiresbridge Primary School	33
	McClintock Primary School	55
	Moat Primary School	50
	Newbuildings Primary School	2
	Newtownbutler Primary School	29
	Newtownstewart Model Primary School	19
	Omagh County Primary School	60
	Queen Elizabeth II Primary School, Kilskeery	23
	Shanmullagh Primary School	7
	Sion Mills Primary School	26
	Strabane Primary School	99
	Tempo No 1 Primary School	76
	Trillick Primary School	12

(ii) Maintained Primary Schools:

North-Eastern Board:	Altayeskey Primary School	6
	Anahorish Primary School	4
	Ballyhackett Primary School	27
	Barnish Primary School	27
	Braid Primary School	10
	Creggan Primary School	3
	Crossroads Primary School	68
	Glenravel Primary School	43
	Holy Family Primary School	1
	Holy Trinity Primary School	1
	Knocknagin Primary School	1
	Millquarter Primary School	26
	Moneynick Primary School	7
	Mount St Michael's Primary School	29
	New Row Primary School	1
	Sacred Heart Boys Primary School	1
	Seaview Primary School	52
	St Anne's Primary School	36
	St Anthony's Primary School	3
	St Bernard's Primary School	6
	St Brigid's Primary School, Ballymoney	12
	St Brigid's Primary School, Cloughmills	24
	St Brigid's Primary School, Magherafelt	53
	St Brigid's Primary School, Mountjoy	1
	St Brigid's Primary School, Tirkane	69
	St Ciaran's Primary School	1
	St Colmcille's Primary School	6
	St Colmcilles Primary School, Ballymena	12
	St Columba's Primary School, Draperstown	14
	St Columba's Primary School, Garvagh	68
	St Columba's Primary School, Kilrea	9
	St Columb's Primary School, Desertmartin	17
	St Eoghan's Primary School	8
	St Francis' Primary School, Lurgan	1
	St James' Primary School, Newtownabbey	1
	St John Bosco Primary School, Ballynease	2
	St John's Primary School, Carnlough	4
	St John's Primary School, Coleraine	2
	St John's Primary School, Swatragh	29
	St Joseph's Primary School, Ahoghill	2
	St Joseph's Primary School, Crumlin	63
	St Joseph's Primary School, Dunloy	64
	St MacNissi's Primary School, Newtownabbey	3
	St MacNissius' Primary School	4
	St Malachy's Primary School	1
	St Mary's Primary School, Ballymena	13
	St Mary's Primary School, Belfast	16
	St Mary's Primary School, Cushendall	4
	St Mary's Primary School, Draperstown	16
	St Mary's Primary School, Glenview	4
	St Mary's Primary School, Greenlough	18
	St Mary's Primary School, Portglenone	69
	St Mary's PS Special Unit, Glenview	25
	St Mary's Star of the Sea Primary School	1
	St Nicholas' Primary School	20
	St Olcan's Primary School	8
	St Oliver Plunkett's Primary School	6
	St Patrick's & St Brigid's Primary School	21
	St Patrick's & St Joseph's Primary School	104
	St Patrick's Primary School, Ahoghill	2
	St Patrick's Primary School, Glenariff	12
	St Patrick's Primary School, Loughgiel	96
	St Patrick's Primary School, Loup	3
	St Patrick's Primary School, Maghera	99
	St Patrick's Primary School, Portrush	2
	St Patrick's Primary School, Rasharkin	109
	St Trea's Primary School	1

South-Eastern Board:	Ballymacrickett Primary School	61
	Ballymacward Primary School	32
	Christ the King Primary School, Drumaness	2
	Convent of Mercy Primary School	1
	Holy Family Primary School	18
	Holy Trinity Primary School	9
	Our Lady Queen of Peace Primary School	1
	St Aloysius Primary School	8
	St Anne's Primary School	1
	St Bernard's Primary School	3
	St Colman's Primary School, Lambeg	24
	St Colman's Primary School, Moira	12
	St Colmcille's Primary School	11
	St Comgall's Primary School	5
	St Finian's Primary School	2
	St Francis' Primary School, Drumaroad	5
	St Ita's Primary School	1
	St Joseph's Primary School, Carryduff	2
	St Joseph's Primary School, Crumlin	1
	St Joseph's Primary School, Holland Dr	2
	St Joseph's Primary School, Lisburn	2
	St Joseph's Primary School, Strangford	14
	St Joseph's Primary School, Tyrella	5
	St Kieran's Primary School	6
	St Luke's Primary School	1
	St Macartan's Primary School	39
	St Malachy's Primary School, Bangor	23
	St Malachy's Primary School, Castlewellan	20
	St Malachy's Primary School, Kilclief	2
	St Malachy's Primary School, Kilcoo	22
	St Mark's Primary School	2
	St Mary's Primary School, Derrymore	1
	St Mary's Primary School, Killyleagh	1
	St Mary's Primary School, Kircubbin	63
	St Mary's Primary School, Newcastle	2
	St Mary's Primary School, Portaferry	8
	St Michael's Primary School, Finnis	22
	St Nicholas' Primary School	4
	St Patrick's Primary School, Ballygalget	20
	St Patrick's Primary School, Ballynahinch	1
	St Patrick's Primary School, Derrynaseer	4
	St Patrick's Primary School, Downpatrick	5
	St Patrick's Primary School, Holywood	1
	St Patrick's Primary School, Legamaddy	20
	St Patrick's Primary School, Saul	2

Southern Board:	Aughamullan Primary School	50
	Ballyholland Primary School	123
	Ballymacrickett Primary School	1
	Blessed Patrick O'Loughran Primary School	34
	Clintyclay Primary School	5
	Clonalig Primary School	73
	Crievagh Primary School	18
	Derrylatinee St Francis Primary School	75
	Edendork Primary School	48
	Holy Trinity Primary School	5
	Laghey Primary School	15
	Moneydarragh Primary School	12
	Our Lady's & St Mochua's Primary School	61
	Primate Dixon Primary School	17
	Roan St Patrick's Primary School	30
	Sacred Heart Primary School	113
	St Brendan's Primary School	1
	St Brigid's Primary School, Augher	1
	St Brigid's Primary School, Drumilly	39
	St Brigid's Primary School, Glassdrummond	123
	St Brigid's Primary School, Mountjoy	64
	St Clare's Convent Primary School	5
	St Colman's Abbey Primary School	1
	St Colman's Primary School, Annaclone	59
	St Colman's Primary School, Bann	2
	St Colman's Primary School, Dromore	17
	St Colman's Primary School, Saval	96
	St Francis' Primary School, Aghaderg	22
	St James' Primary School, Drumatee	16
	St Jarlath's Primary School, Blackwatertown	33
	St John's Primary School, Eglish	45
	St John's Primary School, Kingsisland	13
	St John's Primary School, Middletown	53
	St John's Primary School, Moy	25
	St Joseph's and St James's Primary School	73
	St Joseph's Convent Primary School	40
	St Joseph's Primary School, Caledon	14
	St Joseph's Primary School, Crumlin	1
	St Joseph's Primary School, Galbally	93
	St Joseph's Primary School, Killeenan	58
	St Laurence O'Toole Primary School	15
	St MacCartan's Convent Primary School	28
	St Malachy's Primary School, Ballymoyer	72
	St Malachy's Primary School, Drummullan	8
	St Malachy's Primary School, Glencull	13
	St Mary's Primary School, Aughnacloy	22
	St Mary's Primary School, Ballygawley	25
	St Mary's Primary School, Cabra	120
	St Mary's Primary School, Derrymore	17
	St Mary's Primary School, Dunamore	114
	St Mary's Primary School, Glassdrumman	34
	St Mary's Primary School, Maghery	74
	St Mary's Primary School, Mullaghbawn	135
	St Mary's Primary School, Pomeroy	80
	St Mary's Primary School, Stewartstown	20
	St Michael's Primary School, Finnis	22
	St Oliver Plunkett Primary School, Ballyhegan	32
	St Patrick's Primary School, Aghacommon	30
	St Patrick's Primary School, Annaghmore	49
	St Patrick's Primary School, Crossmaglen	55
	St Patrick's Primary School, Donaghmore	28
	St Patrick's Primary School, Dungannon	6
	St Patrick's Primary School, Loup	33
	St Patrick's Primary School, Mayobridge	43
	St Patrick's Primary School, Mullinahoe	92
	St Ronan's Primary School, Newry	1
	St Teresa's Primary School Tullyherron	38

Western Board:	All Saint's Primary School, Tattysallagh	11
	Altishane Primary School	12
	Barrack Street Boys' Primary School	8
	Broadbridge Primary School	33
	Chapel Road Primary School	1
	Christ the King Primary School	2
	Cornagague Primary School	45
	Corranny Primary School	58
	Craigbrack Primary School	6
	Drumduff Primary School	31
	Drumnabey Primary School	5
	Envagh Primary School	22
	Evish Primary School	21
	Faughanvale Primary School	22
	Glendermott Primary School	7
	Good Shepherd Primary School	2
	Gortnagarn Primary School	13
	Hollybush Primary School	1
	Holy Child Primary School	1
	Holy Family Primary School	3
	Holy Trinity Primary School	94
	Killyhommon Primary School	44
	Knocknagor Primary School	25
	Listress Primary School	15
	Longtower Primary School	1
	Loughash Primary School	29
	Magheralough Primary School	23
	Mullabuoy Primary School	8
	Our Lady of Lourdes Primary School, Greencastle	92
	Recarson Primary School	1
	Roscavey Primary School	12
	St Aidan's Primary School, Magilligan	10
	St Anne's Primary School, Derry	11
	St Anne's Primary School, Strabane	12
	St Anthony's Primary School, Limavady	20
	St Brigid's Primary School, Altamuskin	52
	St Brigid's Primary School, Carnhill	1
	St Brigid's Primary School, Cranagh	23
	St Brigid's Primary School, Mountfield	5
	St Caireall's Primary School	82
	St Canice Primary School, Dungiven	45
	St Canice's Primary School, Feeny	10
	St Colmcille's Primary School, Claudy	88
	St Colmcille's Primary School, Omagh	3
	St Columban's Primary School, Belcoo	75
	St Columba's Primary School, Clady	16
	St Columba's Primary School, Dromore	3
	St Columba's Primary School, Newbuildings	1
	St Columbkille's Primary School, Carrickmore	130
	St Conor's Primary School, Omagh	13
	St Davog's Primary School, Belleek	30
	St Davog's Primary School, Scraghey	11
	St Dympna's Primary School, Dromore	12
	St Eithne's Primary School, Derry	1
	St Eugene's Primary School, Knocks	9
	St Eugene's Primary School, Tircur	23
	St Eugene's Primary School, Victoria Bridge	20
	St John the Baptist Primary School, Roscor	59
	St John's Primary School, Bligh's Lane	1
	St Joseph's Primary School, Donagh	36
	St Joseph's Primary School, Drumquin	63
	St Joseph's Primary School, Ederney	61
	St Joseph's Primary School, Glenmornan	8
	St Lawrence's Primary School, Fintona	92
	St Macartan's Primary School	6
	St Martin's Primary School, Garrison	62
	St Mary's Boys' Primary School, Strabane	3
	St Mary's Primary School, Fivemiletown	10
	St Mary's Primary School, Altinure	96
	St Mary's Primary School, Brookeborough	49
	St Mary's Primary School, Cloughcor	60
	St Mary's Primary School, Killesher	39
	St Mary's Primary School, Killyclogher	6
	St Mary's Primary School, Maguiresbridge	41
	St Mary's Primary School, Mullymesker	61
	St Mary's Primary School, Newtownbutler	63
	St Mary's Primary School, Teemore	33
	St Mary's Primary School, Tempo No 2	56
	St Matthew's Primary School, Drumsurn	18
	St Matthew's Primary School, Garvaghey	21
	St Naile's Primary School	72
	St Ninnidh's Primary School	48
	St Oliver Plunkett Primary School, Beragh	32
	St Oliver Plunkett Primary School, Strathfoyle	1
	St Patrick's Primary School, Castlederg	42
	St Patrick's Primary School, Creggan	25
	St Patrick's Primary School, Derrygonnelly	58
	St Patrick's Primary School, Dunamanagh	19
	St Patrick's Primary School, Eskra	23
	St Patrick's Primary School, Gortin	41
	St Patrick's Primary School, Mullanaskea	65
	St Patrick's Primary School, Newtownstewart	31
	St Patrick's Primary School, Pennyburn	6
	St Patrick's Primary School, Seskinore	7
	St Paul's Primary School, Irvinestown	42
	St Peter's & St Paul's Primary School	14
	St Peter's Primary School, Plumbridge	61
	St Ronan's Primary School, Lisnaskea	60
	St Scire's Primary School	45
	St Teresa's Primary School, Loughmacrory	76
	St Theresa's Primary School, Glebe	5
	St Therese Primary School, Lenamore	1
	St Tierney's Primary School, Roslea	38
	Tattygar Primary School	25
	Termoncanice Primary School	53
	Trench Road Primary School	3
	Tummery Primary School	24

(iii) Integrated Primary Schools

Belfast Board:	Cranmore Integrated Primary School	47
	Forge Integrated Primary School	9
	Hazelwood Primary School	94
	Loughview Integrated Primary School	7

North-Eastern Board:	Acorn Integrated Primary School	23
	Ballycastle Controlled Integrated Primary School	8
	Braidside Integrated Primary School	89
	Carhill Integrated Primary School	34
	Carnlough Integrated Primary School	2
	Corran Integrated Primary School	12
	Glengormley Integrated Primary School	5
	Hazelwood Primary School	40
	Mill Strand Integrated Primary School	22
	Rathenraw Integrated Primary School, Special Unit	9
	Roundtower Integrated Primary School	8
	Spires Integrated Primary School	1

South-Eastern Board:	All Children's Integrated Primary School	31
	Annsborough Integrated Primary School	15
	Bangor Central Integrated Primary School	4
	Cranmore Integrated Primary School	2
	Kircubbin Integrated Primary School	37
	Lough View Integrated Primary School	29
	Millennium Integrated Primary School	2
	Oakwood Integrated Primary School	4
	Portadown Integrated Primary School	1
	Portaferry Integrated Primary School	2
Southern Board:	All Children's Integrated Primary School	2
	Bridge Primary School	36
	Portadown Integrated Primary School	59
	Saints and Scholars Primary School	62

Western Board:	Enniskillen Integrated Primary School	78
	Groarty Integrated Primary School	2
	Oakgrove Integrated Primary School	156
	Omagh Integrated Primary School	114
	Roe Valley Integrated Primary School	2

(iv) Irish-Medium Primary Schools

Belfast Board:	Bunscoil Phobal Feirste	3

North-Eastern Board:	Bunscoil Mhic Reachtain	2
	Bunscoil Phobal Feirste	2
	Gaelscoil Na Speiriní	1

South-Eastern Board:	Bunscoil Phobal Feirste	5

Southern Board:	Gaelscoil Ui Neill	16

Western Board:	Bunscoil Cholmcille, Carrickmore	53
	Bunscoil Cholmcille, Derry	37
	Gaelscoil Eadain Mhoir, Derry	33
	Gaelscoil Uí Dhochartaigh, Strabane	2

Post-Primary Pupils Receiving School Transport

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how many pupils attending (i) State Controlled post-primary schools; (ii) Catholic Maintained post-primary schools; (iii) Integrated post-primary schools; and (iv) Irish Medium post-primary schools, used school transport during the 2007-08 academic year, broken down by (a) Education and Library Board; and (ii) school.

(AQW 8221/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá dearbhaithe ag na Boird Oideachais agus Leabharlainne go raibh an líon daltaí a leanas ag freastal ar na h-earnálacha iar-bhunscoile liostaithe agus ag fáil iompar scoile in 2007/08:

The Education and Library Boards have confirmed that the following number of pupils were attending the post-primary school sectors listed and receiving school transport in 2007/08:

	Controlled	Catholic Maintained	Integrated*	Irish Medium	TOTAL
BELB	124	24	942	69	1,159
NEELB	5,025	2,937	1,301	12	9,275
SEELB	4,195	1,872	1,658	102	7,827
SELB	5,159	5,697	962	27	11,845
WELB	3,977	4,179	1,472	18	9,646

* This category includes both Grant Maintained and Controlled Integrated schools.

Broken down by individual school as follows:

(i) Controlled Post-Primary Schools:

Belfast Board:	Antrim Grammar School	2
	Ashfield Boys' High School	3
	Ashfield Girls' High School	2
	Ballyclare High School	2
	Ballynahinch High School	1
	Balmoral High School	4
	Bangor Academy	3
	Belfast Boys’ Model School	11
	Belfast Model School for Girls	3
	Castle High School	2
	Downshire School	1
	Dundonald High School	3
	Dunmurry High School	34
	Glengormley High School	3
	Grosvenor Grammar School	9
	Knockbreda High School	4
	Lisnagarvey High School	1
	Lisnasharragh High School	1
	Monkstown Community School	3
	Nendrum College	2
	Newtownbreda High School	9
	Orangefield High School	7
	Wellington College	14

North-Eastern Board:	Antrim Grammar School	305
	Ashfield Girls' High School	1
	Ballee Community High School	97
	Ballycastle High School	254
	Ballyclare High School	632
	Ballyclare Secondary School	320
	Ballymoney High School	274
	Ballymoney HS Special Unit	12
	Balmoral High School	1
	Bangor Academy & Sixth Form College	1
	Belfast Model School for Girls	2
	Cambridge House Grammar School	672
	Carrickfergus College	109
	Carrickfergus Grammar School	80
	Coleraine College	89
	Coleraine College Special Unit	13
	Coleraine High School	389
	Cullybackey High School	394
	Downshire School	193
	Dunclug College	277
	Dunluce School	247
	Garvagh High School	90
	Glengormley High School	41
	Knockbreda High School	1
	Larne High School	56
	Larne High School Special Unit	7
	Limavady Grammar School	15
	Limavady High School	23
	Maghera High School	78
	Maghera High School Special Unit	20
	Magherafelt High School	203
	Monkstown Community High School	11
	Monkstown Community HS Special Unit	5
	Newtownabbey Community High School	10
	Parkhall College	101
	Wellington College	2

South-Eastern Board:	Antrim Grammar School	12
	Ashfield Boys' High School	3
	Ashfield Girls' High School	20
	Ballynahinch High School	198
	Banbridge Academy	26
	Banbridge High School	3
	Bangor Academy & Sixth Form College	95
	Belfast Boys' Model School	1
	Carrickfergus College	1
	Carrickfergus Grammar School	1
	Castle High School	1
	Craigavon Senior High School, Lurgan	24
	Donaghadee High School	81
	Down High School	851
	Dromore High School	249
	Dundonald High School	28
	Dunmurry High School	6
	Glastry College	418
	Glenlola Collegiate	148
	Grosvenor Grammar School	393
	Kilkeel High School	44
	Knockbreda High School	13
	Laurelhill Community College	172
	Lisnagarvey High School	24
	Lisnasharragh High School	5
	Lurgan College	65
	Lurgan Junior High School	123
	Movilla High School	12
	Nendrum College	47
	Newtownbreda High School	42
	Orangefield High School	10
	Parkhall College	4
	Rathfriland High School	12
	Regent House	588
	Saintfield High School	191
	Wellington College	284

Southern Board:	Aughnacloy College	120
	Ballynahinch High School	12
	Banbridge Academy	740
	Banbridge High School	197
	City of Armagh High School	188
	Clounagh Junior High School	179
	Collegiate Grammar School	14
	Cookstown High School	505
	Craigavon Senior High School, Lurgan	54
	Craigavon Senior High School, Portadown	195
	Devenish College, Enniskillen	1
	Down High School	5
	Dromore High School	217
	Drumglass High School	290
	Fivemiletown College	190
	Kilkeel High School	308
	Killicomaine Junior High School	42
	Laurelhill Community College	3
	Lisnagarvey High School	3
	Lurgan College	188
	Lurgan Junior High School	108
	Magherafelt High School	25
	Markethill High School	514
	Newry High School	227
	Newtownhamilton High School	252
	Omagh Academy Grammar School	28
	Omagh High School	2
	Portadown College	341
	Rathfriland High School	122
	Tandragee Junior High	86
	Wellington College	3

Western Board:	Castlederg High School	330
	Coleraine College	4
	Coleraine High School	9
	Collegiate Grammar School	399
	Devenish College, Enniskillen	545
	Fivemiletown HS & Community College	180
	Limavady Grammar School	469
	Limavady High School	314
	Lisnaskea High School	146
	Lisneal College	331
	Omagh Academy Grammar School	429
	Omagh High School	256
	Strabane Grammar School	337
	Strabane High School	228

(ii) Maintained Post-Primary Schools:

Belfast Board:	Christian Brothers' School	1
	Edmund Rice College	3
	Little Flower Girls’ School	1
	Our Lady of Mercy Girls' School	1
	St Colman's High School, Ballynahinch	4
	St Columbanus' College, Bangor	2
	St Gabriel's College, Belfast	1
	St Joseph's College, Belfast	6
	St Louise's Comprehensive College, Belfast	2
	St Patrick's College	3

North-Eastern Board:	Christian Brothers Secondary School	2
	Cross & Passion College	289
	De La Salle Boys' School	18
	Edmund Rice College	22
	Holy Trinity College	4
	La Salle Boys' Junior School	1
	Little Flower Girls' School	209
	Our Lady of Lourdes High School	139
	Our Lady of Lourdes HS Special Unit	18
	Our Lady of Mercy Girls’ School	36
	St Aloysius' High School	46
	St Benedict's College	334
	St Brigid's College	1
	St Colm's High School, Draperstown	135
	St Colm's High School, Twinbrook	1
	St Comgall's College	38
	St Gemma's High School	2
	St Genevieve’s High School	16
	St Joseph's College, Belfast	1
	St Joseph's College, Coleraine	135
	St Louise's Comprehensive College	69
	St Mary's College	154
	St Mary's High School, Limavady	2
	St Mary's High School, Lurgan	1
	St Patrick's College, Ballymena	165
	St Patrick's College, Bearnageeha	15
	St Patrick's College, Maghera	592
	St Patrick's College Special Unit, Maghera	15
	St Patrick's High School, Lisburn	28
	St Paul's College	197
	St Paul's High School, Lurgan	2
	St Pius X College	244
	St Rose's High School	6

South-Eastern Board:	Christian Brothers’ Secondary School	10
	Corpus Christi College	2
	De La Salle High School	143
	La Salle Boys' School	28
	Lismore Comprehensive School	8
	St Colman's High School	127
	St Colmcille's High School	295
	St Colm's High School	1
	St Columban's College	1
	St Columbanus' College	194
	St Columba's College	114
	St Genevieve's High School	11
	St Joseph's College	38
	St Louise's Comprehensive College	46
	St Malachy's High School	486
	St Mary's High School, Downpatrick	237
	St Mary's High School, Lurgan	21
	St Patrick's College, Banbridge	2
	St Patrick's High School, Lisburn	94
	St Paul's Junior High School	9
	St Rose's High School	5

Southern Board:	Dean Maguirc College	3
	Drumcree College	41
	Holy Trinity College	475
	Lismore Comprehensive School	227
	Sacred Heart College	1
	St Brigid's High School, Armagh	83
	St Catherine's College	448
	St Ciaran's High School	550
	St Colman's High School	7
	St Colm's High School, Draperstown	4
	St Columban's College	108
	St Genevieve's High School	1
	St Joseph's Boys' High School, Newry	106
	St Joseph's College, Coalisland	149
	St Joseph's High School, Crossmaglen	473
	St Louise's Comprehensive College	1
	St Malachy's High School, Castlewellan	344
	St Mark's High School, Warrenpoint	470
	St Mary's High School, Downpatrick	1
	St Mary's High School, Lurgan	137
	St Mary's High School, Newry	152
	St Patrick's College, Maghera	4
	St Patrick's College, Banbridge	192
	St Patrick's College, Dungannon	310
	St Patrick's High School, Keady	482
	St Patrick's High School, Lisburn	1
	St Paul's High School, Bessbrook	559
	St Paul's High School, Lurgan	95
	St Pius X College	273

Western Board:	Dean Maguirc College	387
	Holy Cross College	393
	Immaculate Conception College	36
	Sacred Heart College	428
	St Aidan's High School, Derrylin	146
	St Brigid's College	30
	St Cecilia's College	370
	St Ciaran's High School	184
	St Colms HS, Draperstown	16
	St Comhghall's College	159
	St Eugene's College, Roslea	177
	St Eugene's High School, Castlederg	87
	St Fanchea's College	190
	St John's Business and Enterprise College	116
	St Joseph's Boys' High School, Creggan	26
	St Joseph's College, Enniskillen	160
	St Mary's College, Irvinestown	101
	St Mary's College, Londonderry	35
	St Mary's High School, Brollagh	137
	St Mary's Secondary School, Limavady	441
	St Patrick's & St Brigid's College	219
	St Patrick's College, Dungiven	120
	St Patrick's College, Maghera	208
	St Peter's High School	13

(iii) Integrated Post-Primary Schools:

Belfast Board:	Fort Hill Integrated College	39
	Hazelwood Integrated College	299
	Lagan College	291
	Malone College	257
	Priory College	55
	Ulidia Integrated College	1

North-Eastern Board:	Crumlin Integrated College	111
	Fort Hill Integrated College	2
	Hazelwood Integrated College	115
	Lagan College	6
	Malone College	17
	North Coast Integrated College	169
	Priory College	1
	Slemish Integrated College	476
	Sperrin Integrated College	171
	Ulidia Integrated College	223

South-Eastern Board:	Crumlin Integrated College	68
	Down Academy	191
	Fort Hill Integrated College	136
	Hazelwood Integrated College	5
	Lagan College	369
	Malone College	45
	New-Bridge Integrated College	2
	Priory College	191
	Shimna College	192
	Strangford College	459


Southern Board:	Armagh Integrated College	52
	Brownlow College	97
	Crumlin Integrated College	2
	Drumragh Integrated College	6
	Fort Hill Integrated College	11
	Integrated College, Dungannon	246
	Lagan College	2
	Malone College	4
	New-Bridge Integrated College	367
	Shimna Integrated College	100
	Sperrin Integrated College	75

Western Board:	Drumragh Integrated College	355
	Erne Integrated College	241
	North Coast Integrated College	2
	Oakgrove Integrated College	874

(iv) Irish-Medium Post-Primary Schools:

Belfast Board:	Coláiste Feirste	69

North-Eastern Board:	Coláiste Feirste	12

South-Eastern Board:	Coláiste Feirste	102

Southern Board:	Coláiste Feirste	1
	St Catherine’s College, Irish Medium Unit	26

Western Board:	Coláiste Bhride (St Brigid's College)	18

Premature Retirement Compensation Scheme

Mr Attwood asked the Minister of Education for an update on the working group on Premature Retirement Compensation Scheme, particularly in relation to the issue of 'hard charging' schools for teachers' added years; and what plans she has to respond to the issue.

(AQW 8249/08)

Ms C Ruane: The Premature Retirement Compensation Scheme (PRCS) Review Group was established for consultation with key stakeholders on the arrangements for compensating teachers retiring prematurely from April 2009 onwards. The Review Group comprises representatives of the Department, employers and teacher unions in both the schools and FE sectors. Its remit is to bring forward options for managing the costs of the PRCS in future.

The group met on 26 February 2008, 7 April 2008 and 25 June 2008. At the meeting on 25 June it was agreed that my Department would amend existing legislation to bring provisions for compensating teachers for premature retirement broadly into line with arrangements under the corresponding schemes in Scotland and in England and Wales. The Review Group will in the meantime continue to consider how such provisions may be applied consistently for the benefit of teachers and employers, and in the interests of economy and efficiency.

Tá beart déanta cheana lena chinntiú, ón bhliain airgeadais seo amach, go mbeidh na daoine sin atá freagrach as a shocrú go mbronnfar cúiteamh méadaithe as scor roimh am ("blianta breise"), freagrach fosta as na costais.

Action has already been taken to ensure that, from the current financial year, those who are responsible for decisions to award enhanced compensation for premature retirement ("added years") are also accountable for the costs. In the corresponding scheme in England and Wales, responsibility for the cost of added years was transferred to teachers’ employers in 1991. In 1997 employers became liable for all the costs associated with the scheme, including the additional cost of early payment of unreduced pension benefits.

Sports Facilities at Schools

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education to give her assessment of sports facilities in (i) Primary Schools; and (ii) Post Primary Schools.

(AQW 8250/08)

Ms C Ruane: There are no plans to carry out an audit of sports facilities in all schools.

Cuirtear áiseanna spóirt ar fáil ag scoileanna chun tacú le soláthar an churaclaim agus ar chomhairle na Cigireachta Oideachais agus Oiliúna.

Sports facilities are provided at schools to support the delivery of the curriculum and on the advice of the Education and Training Inspectorate.

Sports Facilities at Schools

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education if she will carry out an audit of sports facilities in all schools.

(AQW 8251/08)

Ms C Ruane: There are no plans to carry out an audit of sports facilities in all schools.

Cuirtear áiseanna spóirt ar fáil ag scoileanna chun tacú le soláthar an churaclaim agus ar chomhairle na Cigireachta Oideachais agus Oiliúna.

Sports facilities are provided at schools to support the delivery of the curriculum and on the advice of the Education and Training Inspectorate.

School Buses Provided by Translink

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how many buses are provided by Translink on a daily basis for the purpose of transporting pupils attending (i) State Controlled primary schools; (ii) Catholic Maintained primary schools; (iii) Integrated primary schools; and (iv) Irish Medium primary schools, broken down by (a) Education and Library Board; and (b) school.

(AQW 8268/08)

Ms C Ruane: I have been informed by Translink that it does not hold the information in the format requested. Translink does not have a dedicated schools fleet but rather incorporates school transport provision into its stage carriage network.

Iompraíonn Translink tuairim is ar 65,000 dalta go dtí an scoil agus ar ais ar bhonn laethúil, agus cuirtear ar fáil 2,600 turas breise ar bharr ghnáthsheirbhísí amchláir le seo a chomhlíonadh.

Translink carries some 65,000 pupils to and from school on a daily basis, and 2,600 extra journeys are provided in addition to normal timetabled services to fulfil this.

School Buses Provided by Translink

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how many buses are provided by Translink on a daily basis for the purpose of transporting pupils attending (i) State Controlled post-primary schools; (ii) Catholic Maintained post-primary schools; (iii) Integrated post-primary schools; and (iv) Irish Medium post-primary schools, broken down by (a) Education and Library Board; and (b) school.

(AQW 8269/08)

Translink carries some 65,000 pupils to and from school on a daily basis, and 2,600 extra journeys are provided in addition to normal timetabled services to fulfil this.

School Closures

Mr Gallagher asked the Minister of Education how many school closures have been announced since devolution; and in how many cases at primary and post-primary level, has the school cited difficulties in delivering the revised curriculum among the reasons for closure.

(AQW 8286/08)

Ms C Ruane: Ón chineachadh, fógraíodh druidim ocht scoil agus aon aonad bunscoile. Níor luaigh ceann ar bit de na scoileanna deacrachtaí i soláthar an churaclaim athbhreithnithe ar an cúiseanna le druidim.

Closures of eight schools and one unit of a primary school have been announced since devolution. None of the schools cited difficulties in delivering the revised curriculum among the reasons for closure.

Movilla High School

Miss McIlveen asked the Minister of Education what plans she has for maintaining and improving facilities at Movilla High School.

(AQW 8294/08)

Ms C Ruane:

Tá Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlann an Oirdheiscirt freagrach as cothabháil agus soláthar na n-oibreacha caipitiúla ag Ardscoil Mhaigh Bhile. Thug an Bord le fios dom gur cuireadh coire úr isteach le gairid; chosain an coire tuairim is £29,000 agus soláthróidh sé teas don halla spóirt. Tá sé de rún ag an Bhord na háiseanna a fheabhsú trí uasghrádú a dhéanamh ar na seomraí a úsáidtear le haghaidh eacnamaíocht bhaile; samhradh 2009 an sprioc-am atá i gceist.

The South Eastern Education and Library Board has responsibility for maintenance and the provision of capital works at Movilla High School. The Board has advised that a new boiler to serve the sports hall has just been installed at a cost of approximately £29,000. The Board plans to improve the facilities with an upgrade of the home economics accommodation, with a target date of summer 2009.

Statements of Special Educational Needs

Mrs D Kelly asked the Minister of Education how many pupils are currently awaiting a statement of special educational need.

(AQO 4020/08)

Ms C Ruane: Thug Príomhfheidhmeannaigh na mbord oideachais agus leabharlainne eolas dom faoin líon daltaí a ndearnadh measúnú reachtúil ar a riachtanais speisialta oideachais, faoin líon a measann na Boird ráiteas riachtanas speisialta oideachais a bheith de dhíth orthu, agus faoin líon atá ag fanacht lena ráiteas a bheith réidh. Seo leanas an líon:

I have been advised by the Chief Executives of the education and library boards that the number of pupils who have undergone a statutory assessment of their special educational needs, are considered by the Boards to require a statement of special educational needs, and who are currently awaiting completion of their statement is as follows:-

1. Belfast Education and Library Board - 21

2. North-Eastern Education and Library Board - 45

3. South-Eastern Education and Library Board - 42

4. Southern Education and Library Board - 124

5. Western Education and Library Board - 34

These figures represent those pupils on whom a statutory assessment of their special educational needs has been completed and who are currently awaiting either a proposed or final statement of special education needs.

Education and Library Board Underspend

Mr O'Dowd asked the Minister of Education to detail the underspend of each of the Education and Library Boards in the last three financial years.

(AQW 8312/08)

Ms C Ruane: The amount of resources which remained unspent for each of the Education and Library Boards in the last three financial years, are detailed in the table below. These include unspent resources in the Education & Library Boards themselves, schools and youth services.

£000s

	2005-06		2006-07		2007-08
Education & Library Board	Resource	Capital	Resource	Capital	Resource	Capital
BELB	2,251	757	7,858	2,245	6,785	1,902
NEELB	5,725	3	14,900	61	5,887	209
SEELB	2,071	21	6,963	95	7,349	97
SELB	7,878	1,191	17,852	2,425	7,572	1,030
WELB	9,432	378	20,680	870	6,857	479
TOTAL

D’aontaigh an Coiste Feidhmiúcháin socruithe Solúbthachta Dheireadh na Bliana in Aibreán 2008; cinntíonn na socruithe sin nach n-úsáidfear na hacmhainní seo ach i gcomhair oideachais sna blianta amach romhainn.

It should be noted that under the End Year Flexibility arrangements, agreed by the Executive in April 2008, these resources remain committed to education for use in subsequent years.

Teachers’ Added Years Scheme

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education what are the effects of the changes in resourcing of the teachers’ added years scheme on the implementation of Sustainable Schools’ Policy.

(AQW 8338/08)

Ms C Ruane: Ní bhaineann na hathruithe a rinneadh le gairid ar an Scéim Chúitimh le haghaidh Múinteoirí a Scoireann Roimh Am (PRCS) leis an Pholasaí um Scoileanna Inmharthana

Recent changes to the administration of the Teachers’ Premature Retirement Compensation Scheme (PRCS) are unconnected to Sustainable Schools Policy. Action has been taken to ensure that, from the current financial year, those who are responsible for decisions to award teachers enhanced compensation for premature retirement ("added years") are also accountable for the costs. In taking this action my Department is seeking to ensure that in future the level of discretionary compensation awarded to teachers is both affordable and appropriate in light of criticism by the House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts of the generous nature of the PRCS. While it is a matter for employing authorities to determine what compensation they are prepared to offer, the guiding principle should be the maximum economy consistent with effectiveness.

Permanent Teaching Posts

Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Education how many qualified teachers who completed their training last year have yet to obtain a permanent teaching post in Northern Ireland.

(AQW 8339/08)

	(1) 2007/08
Graduate Records	801
Currently Registered	683
Currently Employed (see note 2)	187

Notes:

1. The year stated refers to the GTC Registration Year, i.e. 1 April 2007 to 31 March 2008.

2. "Currently Employed" includes teachers who are employed on a permanent or significant temporary basis (i.e. excludes substitute/supply teachers).

Tá iarrtha agam ar mo Roinn tuilleadh oibre a dhéanamh ar phatrúin fostaíochta mhac léinn ag baint céime amach as oideachas tosaigh múinteoireachta.

I have asked my Department to undertake further work on the employment patterns of students graduating from initial teacher education.

Permanent Teaching Posts

Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Education how many qualified teachers who completed their training in each of the last five years have yet to obtain a permanent teaching post in Northern Ireland six months after qualification.

(AQW 8340/08)

	(1) 2003/04	(1) 2004/05	(1) 2005/06	(1) 2006/07	(1) 2007/08
Graduate Records	705	792	816	807	801
Currently Registered	635	672	671	708	683
Currently Employed (see note 2)	535	490	413	337	187

Notes:

1. The years stated refer to the GTC Registration Year, i.e. 1 April to

31 March.

2. "Currently Employed" includes teachers who are employed on a permanent or significant temporary basis (i.e. excludes substitute/supply teachers).

Tá iarrtha agam ar mo Roinn tuilleadh oibre a dhéanamh ar phatrúin fostaíochta mhac léinn ag baint céime amach as oideachas tosaigh múinteoireachta.

I have asked my Department to undertake further work on the employment patterns of students graduating from initial teacher education.

Capital Scheme for Ballymacash Primary School

Mr Poots asked the Minister of Education what plans her Department has to provide a new teaching block at Ballymacash Primary School, Lisburn, and to remove the mobiles currently on site.

(AQW 8355/08)

Ms C Ruane: Baineann pleanáil eastát rialaithe na scoileanna le Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlainne an Oirdheiscirt ar an chéad dul síos. Níl aon phlean ann faoi láthair chun scéim chaipitil a bheith ann do Bhunscoil Ballymacash.

The planning of the controlled schools’ estate is a matter for the South Eastern Education and Library Board in the first instance. There are currently no plans for a capital scheme for Ballymacash Primary School.

Educational Provision and Facilities in Dromore, Co Down

Mr Poots asked the Minister of Education what plans her Department has to enhance the educational provision and facilities in Dromore, Co Down, to meet the needs of (i) pre-school; (ii) primary school; and (iii) post-primary school, education for children and young people aged between 3 and 18.

(AQW 8357/08)

Ms C Ruane: Pre-School

The Southern Education and Library Board are currently reviewing pre-school provision across the Board area, but has no specific plans relating to the Dromore area at this time.

(ii) Primary and (iii) Post Primary

There are no current major works proposals from the maintained or voluntary grammar sectors for the Dromore area.

Maidir leis an earnáil rialaithe, tá dhá scéim chaipitil á bpleanáil faoi láthair i gcomhair áitribh úra a thógáil do Lár-Bhunscoil an Droma Mhóir agus Ardscoil an Droma Mhóir.

In regard to the controlled sector, there are two capital schemes currently in planning for new school builds for Dromore Central Primary School and Dromore High School. A new school on a new site was approved for Dromore Central Primary School. The SELB has advised that the scheme is now progressing in planning, after some delay in acquiring the site. A capital scheme for Dromore High School is at Economic Appraisal stage. An appraisal was submitted to the Department in January 2008 and comments on the appraisal were provided to the SELB at the end of June.

Primary School Pupil Funding

Mr Elliott asked the Minister of Education the average amount spent per primary school pupil in each year since 2001-02.

(AQW 8375/08)

Ms C Ruane: The table below sets out the average funding per-pupil delegated to schools under Local Management of Schools arrangements in each of the last seven years. Further funding is allocated directly to Funding Authorities for a wide range of services, some which benefit all pupils while others are more specifically targeted.

Dá réir sin ní thig an maoiniú sin a chur i láthair ar bhonn dalta aonair.

Accordingly it is not possible to present that funding accurately on a per-pupil basis.

Primary School Sector	2001/02	2002/03	2003/04	2004/05	2005/06	2006/07	2007/08
Average amount Per Capita £	£1,890	£1,964	£2,126	£2,228	£2,442	£2,620	£2,741

Complaints Against Teachers

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education what mechanisms are in place to address complaints against teachers making inappropriate remarks related to prejudice.

(AQW 8428/08)

Ms C Ruane: Príomhoide agus Bord Gobharnóirí na scoile atá i gceist a bíos freagrach as fiosrú gearán in éadan múinteoirí.

Complaints against teachers are a matter for investigation by the Principal and Board of Governors of the school concerned. Following a preliminary investigation, if the complaint cannot be resolved informally, the Disciplinary Procedure for Teachers may be invoked. The Procedure was agreed by the employing authorities and the teacher unions through the Teacher Negotiating Committee to provide a fair, consistent process for dealing with alleged misconduct.

Post-Primary School Places

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education further to her answers to AQO 3975/08 and AQW 7582/08, to clarify and reconcile the differing figures in relation to the number of children from the North Down constituency who are without a suitable place in a post-primary school for the forthcoming academic year.

(AQW 8429/08)

Ms C Ruane: The reason for the difference between the figures given in response to these two questions is essentially because the questions have been understood as asking about two different definitions of the area concerned: the "North Down" and the smaller "North Down Constituency". In AQO 3975/08 Peter Weir MLA asked me what action my Department was taking to ensure adequate provision for the intake of new pupils at secondary level "in North Down" in September 2008. In my answer I stated that there were, at that time, 45 unplaced children resident "in the area". These 45 unplaced children did not all reside in the North Down constituency: for example, included in their number were unplaced children residing in Newtownards and Dundonald (Strangford constituency) who were seeking admission to schools in North Down. This reflects a long tradition of children from the Strangford constituency attending schools in North Down and vice versa.

In Question AQW 7582/08 you asked me (i) how many; and (ii) what percentage of, P7 children attending schools specifically in the North Down constituency have not been allocated a place at a post-primary school for the 2008-09 academic year. In my answer I quoted a figure of 30 children (which equates to 3%). This figure is lower than the 45 figure previously given because it excludes those children resident outside the North Down constituency but who were included in the figure of 45 given for the number of unplaced children resident "in North Down".

Tá áit glactha ag cuid de na 45 pháiste i scoileanna malartacha anois; seo na páistí a bhfuil cónaí orthu i limistéar Thuaisceart an Dúin agus a liostáladh ar 10 Meitheamh 2008 mar dhaoine gan áit scoile.

Some of the 45 children resident in the North Down area who, on June 10, 2008, were counted as unplaced have now accepted places at alternative schools. The South Eastern Education and Library Board have advised the Department that the number of children resident in North Down who, on July 3, 2008, were unplaced was 11 with a further eight unplaced children resident outside the North Down constituency.

Pre-school Places in East Antrim

Mr Ross asked the Minister of Education how many pre-school places are available in nursery schools in the East Antrim constituency.

(AQW 8446/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá 390 áiteanna páirtaimseartha agus 234 áiteanna lánaimseartha ar fáil i naíscoileanna agus i mbunscoileanna a bhfuil aonaid naíolainne acu i dtoghcheantar Aontroma Thoir.

There are 390 part-time places and 234 full-time places available in nursery schools and primary schools with nursery units in the East Antrim constituency.

Increasing Fuel Costs

Mrs Long asked the Minister of Education what assessment she has made of the impact of the increase in (i) fuel costs; and (ii) fuel duty, on the departmental budget and the realisation of efficiency targets; and what action she has taken to mitigate against these increased costs.

(AQW 8451/08)

Ms C Ruane: In recognition of the impact of increasing fuel costs and fuel duty on the budget for education, a bid was submitted in the June Monitoring round for £7.5 million to cover the increased energy costs in schools. This bid was unsuccessful but the pressure on school budgets will be kept under review and a further bid will be made in subsequent Monitoring rounds, if necessary. In relation to the fuel costs for the running of the Department of Education, these are paid for by the Department of Finance and Personnel and therefore any increase in costs is a matter for them to address.

Níltear ag dúil go n-oibreoidh an méadú ar chostas agus ar dhleacht breosla tionchar ar chumas na Roinne na spriocanna éifeachtúlachta a leagadh amach i bpróiseas buiséid 2007 a shroicheadh.

It is not anticipated that the increase in fuel costs and fuel duty will have an impact on the Department’s ability to achieve the efficiency targets set in the 2007 Budget process.

Primary Languages Group

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to her answer to AQW 7500/08, if she will give details of the Primary Languages Group set up to manage and monitor the Primary Languages Programme, including the members' names and the education partners they represent, as well as their background in the two primary languages.

(AQW 8456/08)

Ms C Ruane: The regional Primary Modern Languages group consists of curricular advisors from the North-Eastern, South-Eastern, Southern and Belfast Education and Library Boards, a Field Officer from the Western Education and Library Board, an Assistant Advisor from the South-Eastern Education and Library Board and an Assistant Principal Officer from the Council for the Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment. The group is chaired by an Assistant Senior Education Officer from the South Eastern Education and Library Board, and representation has been sought from the Higher Education Institutions.

In terms of background, group members bring educational expertise as well as a range of linguistic experience, including in Spanish and Irish. Specific language expertise in Spanish and Irish is drawn by the group from organisations such as the Spanish Embassy, Foras na Gaelige, the Centre for Information on Language Teaching and Research and Gael Linn.

Tuairiscíonn an grúpa ar bhonn rialta don Bhord Bainistíochta Páirtíochta (BBP) agus do mo Roinn. Tá an Chigireacht Oideachais agus Oiliúna fosta ag déanamh meastóireachta neamhspleáiche ar an chlár le linn na scoilbhliana 2008-09.

The group reports regularly to the Partnership Management Board (PMB) and my Department. The Education and Training Inspectorate is also carrying out an independent evaluation of the programme during the 2008-09 school year.

Pattern of Attendance

Mr Newton asked the Minister of Education how many nursery schools in the East Belfast constituency applied for additional places for the (i) 2008-09; and (ii) 2009-10, academic years; and to detail (a) the nursery schools that were refused additional places, and (b) the reasons for refusal.

(AQW 8463/08)

Ms C Ruane: Níor iarr aon naíscoil athrú sa phatrún freastail don bhliain acadúil 2008/09.

No nursery schools have requested a change in the pattern of attendance for the 2008/09 academic year.

One school, Braniel Primary School, has requested a change in pattern of attendance in their nursery unit from 1 full-time and 2 part-time classes to 2 full-time classes from 1 September 2009. This request is currently under consideration.

Independent Admissions Criteria

Mr Storey asked the Minister of Education when she became aware that it is legally permissible for schools to set their own independent admissions criteria in the absence of an agreed alternative.

(AQW 8487/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá faisnéis tugtha ag oifigigh domh ar impleachtaí gach gné den reachtaíocht a bhaineann le hiontráil go scoileanna ó thús mo thréimhse oifige.

I have been briefed by officials on the implications of all aspects of legislation governing school admissions from the beginning of my term of office.

Lisnadill Primary School

Mr Kennedy asked the Minister of Education for an update on the proposed extension works to Lisnadill Primary School for the provision of a new assembly hall and enhanced sports facilities and the timescale for this project.

(AQW 8505/08)

Ms C Ruane: Is mionscéim oibreacha atá ann agus dá bharr sin titeann sí faoi fhreagracht tharmligthe Bhord Oideachais agus Leabharlann an Deiscirt (BOLOD).

This is a minor works scheme and as such falls within the delegated responsibility of the Southern Education and Library Board (SELB).

I understand from the Chief Executive of the SELB that preliminary design drawings for the extension, comprising a multi-purpose hall and other ancillary accommodation, have been agreed with the school principal and that an outline planning application has been made.

Biometric Systems

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education how many schools in each Education and Library Board area use biometric systems in the administration of (a) school meals (b) school libraries.

(AQW 8515/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

SCHOOL MEALS SCHOOL LIBRARIES

BELB 0 1

NEELB 0 0

SEELB 0 4

SELB 2 Not Available

WELB 3 Not Available¹

Schools must comply with the Data Protection Act 1998 in using biometric systems. Biometric data must be treated just like any other personal data under the terms of the Act. Guidance for schools on the introduction of biometric systems is available on the Department’s website www.deni.gov.uk .

All systems are password protected and only permitted staff will have access. The majority of schools use fingerprint data, where a user has their fingerprint scanned, converted into digital data and recorded. The image of the fingerprint is not held on the system and cannot be regenerated from the digital data.

At the end of each school year, a complete upgrade is carried out when all school leavers will have all their biometric details deleted from the system and new intakes added.

Administration of School Meals

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education how many schools in each Education and Library Board area still use paper lunch tickets/passes in the administration of school meals.

(AQW 8516/08)

Ms C Ruane: Ní choinníonn an Roinn eolas ar líon na scoileanna i ngach Bord Oideachais agus Leabharlann atá ag úsáid ticéid/pasanna lóin go fóill de bharr nach mbaineann an t-ábhar sin ach leis na scoileanna iad féin.

The Department does not hold information on the number of schools in each Education and Library Board who are still operating lunch tickets/passes as this is a matter for individual schools.

The Belfast Board has confirmed that paper tickets have been withdrawn from their primary schools. The North-Eastern Board no longer issue paper tickets to schools as they operate a register system, but some of their schools may be operating a pass system. The Southern Board has confirmed that there are 9 primary schools and 25 post-primary schools who still use paper lunch tickets/passes. The South-Eastern and Western Boards do not hold figures on the number of schools who are still operating paper ticketing systems.

Biometric Systems

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education how the Department ensures the security of biometric information on pupils stored in schools.

(AQW 8517/08)

Ms C Ruane:

Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

SCHOOL MEALS SCHOOL LIBRARIES

BELB 0 1

NEELB 0 0

SEELB 0 4

SELB 2 Not Available

WELB 3 Not Available¹

At the end of each school year, a complete upgrade is carried out when all school leavers will have all their biometric details deleted from the system and new intakes added.

Biometric Systems

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education how and when schools dispose of biometric information on pupils.

(AQW 8518/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

SCHOOL MEALS SCHOOL LIBRARIES

BELB 0 1

NEELB 0 0

SEELB 0 4

SELB 2 Not Available

WELB 3 Not Available¹

At the end of each school year, a complete upgrade is carried out when all school leavers will have all their biometric details deleted from the system and new intakes added.

Free School Meals

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education for her assessment of whether the cafeteria system in schools leads pupils on free school meals to overspend on the daily allowance.

(AQW 8519/08)

Ms C Ruane: Níl aon fhianaise ag an Roinn go dtugann córas caifé ar bhonn airgead tirim ar dhaltaí atá i dteideal béilte scoile saor in aisce chun róchaithimh.

The Department has no evidence that a cash cafeteria system leads pupils entitled to free school meals to overspend. All free school meals pupils can obtain a nutritionally balanced 2 course meal in a cash cafeteria for the current free school meal allowance. It is only when they choose additional items that a charge is made.

Extended Schools Programme

Mr Beggs asked the Minister of Education how much money has been offered to each school under Extended Schools Funding for 2008-09, broken down by parliamentary constituency; and how this compares to funding allocated to each school for 2007-08.

(AQW 8559/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

DENI REF	SCHOOL NAME	PARLIAMENTARY CONSTITUENCY	2007/08	2008/09
	NURSERY SCHOOLS
1110002	MCARTHUR NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	8,200	1,270
1116074	GLENDHU NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	5,600	1,010
1116158	RAVENSCROFT NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	8,200	1,270
1116160	SANDBROOK NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	9,545	1,461
4116216	KING'S ROAD NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	9,430	1,461
4116240	CASTLEREAGH NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	8,200	1,270
1110003	EDENDERRY NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	9,430	7,112
1110007	GLENBANK NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	6,440	1,162
1110025	TUDOR LODGE NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	9,430	7,112
1110028	BREFNE NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	0	5,656
1110036	NEW LODGE NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	9,430	7,112
1116011	VICTORIA NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	6,440	5,656
1116157	STANHOPE STREET NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	8,200	1,270
1116159	OLDPARK NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	8,200	7,112
1136229	ST MARY'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	8,300	1,280
1136230	HOLY FAMILY NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	8,200	1,270
1136251	OUR LADY'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	9,430	1,461
1136360	HOLY CROSS NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	9,430	7,112
1110001	ARELLIAN NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST SOUTH	8,200	7,112
1130027	BETHLEHEM NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST SOUTH	4,100	0
1110038	SHAFTESBURY NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	1,461
1116155	HOPE NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
1136106	ST MARTIN'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,545	7,112
1136228	ST BERNADETTE'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
1136302	ST PAUL'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,056
1136314	ST TERESA'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	1,472
1136315	ST MICHAEL'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	1,461
1136316	HOLY CHILD NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	1,461
1136340	ST PETER'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
1136349	MATT TALBOT NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,545	7,112
1136353	ST MARIA GORETTI NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
1136383	ST OLIVER PLUNKETT NURSERY SCH	BELFAST WEST	8,100	7,112
1136603	THE CATHEDRAL NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
4136368	ST LUKE'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,168
4136481	ST KIERAN'S NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
4136606	ST THERESE NURSERY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	9,430	7,112
3136332	ST ANTHONY'S NURSERY SCHOOL	EAST ANTRIM	9,430	1,461
2116628	LIMAVADY NURSERY SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	9,430	1,449
3116215	KYLEMORE NURSERY SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	9,373	1,438
3116263	BALLYSALLY NURSERY SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	8,510	7,112
5116198	FIVEMILETOWN NURSERY SCHOOL	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	6,670	1,173
2116023	THE ACADEMY NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,603	1,484
2116232	STRATHFOYLE NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,545	1,461
2116266	BLIGH'S LANE NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,660	7,280
2116267	CARNHILL NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,430	1,461
2116336	GALLIAGH NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,430	7,224
2116345	BELMONT NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,545	1,484
2116348	TRENCH ROAD NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	9,430	1,461
4116018	BARBOUR NURSERY SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	8,200	1,270
4136286	GOOD SHEPHERD NURSERY SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	9,545	7,168
4136317	HOLY TRINITY NURSERY SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	9,660	1,461
3116177	MAGHERAFELT NURSERY SCHOOL	MID ULSTER	12,420	1,760
5110017	RAILWAY STREET NURSERY SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	6,555	2,828
5136342	ST MALACHY'S NURSERY SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	8,200	7,112
3110037	BALLYMENA NURSERY SCHOOL	NORTH ANTRIM	7,400	1,205
3116165	DUNCLUG NURSERY SCHOOL	NORTH ANTRIM	8,400	1,275
3116162	MOSSLEY NURSERY SCHOOL	SOUTH ANTRIM	8,200	1,270
3116220	BALLYCLARE NURSERY SCHOOL	SOUTH ANTRIM	12,363	1,765
3136183	ST JOSEPH'S NURSERY SCHOOL	SOUTH ANTRIM	9,430	1,461
4116176	DOWNPATRICK NURSERY SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	6,440	1,162
4136211	ST COLMCILLE'S NURSERY SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	9,430	1,461
4136212	ST PATRICK'S CONVENT NURSERY	SOUTH DOWN	9,430	1,461
5116197	KILKEEL NURSERY SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	9,430	1,461
4110035	NEWTOWNARDS NURSERY SCHOOL	STRANGFORD	8,200	1,270
4116307	GLENBROOK NURSERY SCHOOL	STRANGFORD	9,430	1,461
5116189	MILLINGTON NURSERY SCHOOL	UPPER BANN	9,545	1,472
5136217	ST JOHN THE BAPTIST NURSERY	UPPER BANN	9,430	1,461
5136631	DRUMNAMOE NURSERY SCHOOL	UPPER BANN	8,300	1,270
2116333	BALLYCOLMAN NURSERY SCHOOL	WEST TYRONE	9,430	1,438
	PRIMARY SCHOOLS
1010146	EUSTON STREET PS	BELFAST EAST	26,680	16,030
1010231	STRAND PRIMARY SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	24,150	13,160
1010255	ELMGROVE PS	BELFAST EAST	33,891	20,888
1010269	AVONIEL PS	BELFAST EAST	22,540	13,706
1010271	BEECHFIELD PS	BELFAST EAST	15,813	9,800
1010289	SYDENHAM INFANTS PS	BELFAST EAST	16,503	10,892
1013018	KNOCKNAGONEY PS	BELFAST EAST	15,100	11,102
1016242	DUNDELA INFANTS SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	0	16,205
1036505	ST MATTHEW'S PS	BELFAST EAST	29,411	17,395
4011632	CREGAGH PS	BELFAST EAST	21,419	13,034
4011657	LISNASHARRAGH PS	BELFAST EAST	21,850	2,513
4013038	TULLYCARNET PS	BELFAST EAST	15,554	9,128
1010063	CURRIE PS	BELFAST NORTH	16,589	10,766
1010266	SEAVIEW PS	BELFAST NORTH	29,153	8,418
1010282	CARR'S GLEN PS	BELFAST NORTH	29,871	17,794
1010283	GROVE PS	BELFAST NORTH	15,295	9,464
1010296	BALLYGOLAN PS	BELFAST NORTH	14,800	10,850
1010323	EDENBROOKE PS	BELFAST NORTH	22,195	13,160
1010325	LIGONIEL PS	BELFAST NORTH	15,295	10,304
1010831	CAVEHILL PS	BELFAST NORTH	0	18,529
1016076	BALLYSILLAN PS	BELFAST NORTH	17,796	11,270
1016483	CLIFTONVILLE PS	BELFAST NORTH	21,074	12,782
1016485	GLENWOOD PS	BELFAST NORTH	33,753	20,587
1016532	WHEATFIELD PS	BELFAST NORTH	20,729	13,118
1016537	LOWWOOD PS	BELFAST NORTH	24,840	14,945
1016647	BUNSCOIL MHIC REACHTAIN	BELFAST NORTH	9,500	8,176
1030194	HOLY CROSS BOYS' PS	BELFAST NORTH	30,705	18,424
1030326	OUR LADY'S GIRLS' PS	BELFAST NORTH	30,360	17,731
1030329	EDMUND RICE (CB) PS	BELFAST NORTH	30,274	17,857
1030331	HOLY CROSS GIRLS' PS	BELFAST NORTH	19,435	11,858
1036041	MERCY PS	BELFAST NORTH	25,588	14,875
1036042	ST VINCENT DE PAUL PS	BELFAST NORTH	23,690	14,420
1036048	ST MARY'S STAR OF THE SEA PS	BELFAST NORTH	18,100	12,446
1036464	STAR OF THE SEA GIRLS' PS	BELFAST NORTH	29,814	17,430
1036471	SACRED HEART PS	BELFAST NORTH	26,645	14,840
1036566	HOLY FAMILY PS	BELFAST NORTH	27,375	19,264
1046596	BUNSCOIL BHEANN MHADAGAIN	BELFAST NORTH	15,550	10,598
1066531	HAZELWOOD PS	BELFAST NORTH	14,685	20,720
3010827	WHITEHOUSE PS	BELFAST NORTH	30,964	19,075
3010862	ABBOTS CROSS PS	BELFAST NORTH	28,290	17,045
3010895	RATHCOOLE PS	BELFAST NORTH	22,799	13,286
1010267	NETTLEFIELD PS	BELFAST SOUTH	27,715	16,485
1010301	TAUGHMONAGH PS	BELFAST SOUTH	19,450	13,622
1010806	FINAGHY PS	BELFAST SOUTH	13,838	0
1016060	DONEGALL ROAD PS	BELFAST SOUTH	17,800	12,362
1016205	FANE STREET PS	BELFAST SOUTH	17,425	12,866
1016207	BLYTHEFIELD PS	BELFAST SOUTH	15,400	10,724
1016499	BOTANIC PS	BELFAST SOUTH	19,375	13,622
1036466	ST MALACHY'S PS	BELFAST SOUTH	23,550	16,205
1046641	SCOIL AN DROICHID	BELFAST SOUTH	11,900	9,926
4013013	BELVOIR PARK PS	BELFAST SOUTH	24,950	17,150
1010205	FORTH RIVER PS	BELFAST WEST	23,403	14,000
1010221	SPRINGFIELD PS	BELFAST WEST	11,845	7,952
1010307	SPRINGHILL PS	BELFAST WEST	28,348	16,380
1010321	VERE FOSTER PS	BELFAST WEST	15,123	8,736
1010863	SUFFOLK PS	BELFAST WEST	0	9,352
1016059	BLACKMOUNTAIN PS	BELFAST WEST	16,158	10,262
1016498	MALVERN PS	BELFAST WEST	16,158	10,472
1016604	HARMONY PS	BELFAST WEST	23,863	14,245
1030316	ST AIDAN'S CHRISTIAN BROTHERS PS	BELFAST WEST	23,805	12,992
1030317	ST BERNADETTE'S PS	BELFAST WEST	24,265	13,412
1036091	ST JOHN THE BAPTIST GIRLS' PS	BELFAST WEST	25,725	17,045
1036092	ST JOHN THE BAPTIST BOYS' PS	BELFAST WEST	26,525	17,941
1036388	ST MARY'S PS	BELFAST WEST	17,365	10,472
1036565	ST KEVIN'S PS	BELFAST WEST	33,321	20,664
1036576	HOLY CHILD PS	BELFAST WEST	31,260	21,672
1036589	ST TERESA'S PS	BELFAST WEST	28,750	19,432
1036602	ST OLIVER PLUNKETT PS	BELFAST WEST	31,720	22,652
1036620	ST PETER'S PS	BELFAST WEST	30,073	17,465
1036621	ST JOSEPH'S PS	BELFAST WEST	26,450	15,365
1036623	HOLY TRINITY PS	BELFAST WEST	36,754	23,030
1036624	ST PAUL'S PS	BELFAST WEST	27,140	15,820
1036630	ST CLARE'S PRIMARY SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	34,144	20,734
1046501	BUNSCOIL PHOBAL FEIRSTE	BELFAST WEST	24,775	16,573
1046571	GAELSCOIL NA BHFAL	BELFAST WEST	24,323	7,193
1046593	BUNSCOIL AN TSLEIBHE DHUIBH	BELFAST WEST	21,505	12,656
1046654	GAELSCOIL AN DAMBA	BELFAST WEST	6,555	5,824
1046671	GAELSCOIL NA MONA	BELFAST WEST	11,040	8,232
1046672	GAELSCOIL AN LONNAIN	BELFAST WEST	8,510	6,664
4036081	ST LUKE'S PS	BELFAST WEST	25,070	14,770
4036134	ST MARK'S PS	BELFAST WEST	35,294	21,070
4036285	THE GOOD SHEPHERD PS	BELFAST WEST	31,223	18,508
4036480	ST KIERAN'S PS	BELFAST WEST	33,264	19,327
4036591	OUR LADY QUEEN OF PEACE PS	BELFAST WEST	30,159	18,697
4046600	SCOIL NA FUISEOIGE	BELFAST WEST	17,883	11,186
3010553	CARRICKFERGUS MODEL PS	EAST ANTRIM	28,175	3,553
3010841	CARRICKFERGUS CENTRAL PS	EAST ANTRIM	19,750	2,200
3010860	SUNNYLANDS PS	EAST ANTRIM	17,950	11,984
3010870	MOYLE PS	EAST ANTRIM	27,658	3,464
3010880	KING'S PARK PS	EAST ANTRIM	30,590	3,835
3016005	SILVERSTREAM PS	EAST ANTRIM	16,300	10,976
3016038	HOLLYBANK PS	EAST ANTRIM	22,109	12,908
3016225	WOODLAWN PS	EAST ANTRIM	0	0
3030900	ST ANTHONY'S PS	EAST ANTRIM	15,726	2,056
3033317	ST JOHN'S PS	EAST ANTRIM	18,813	2,737
3036100	ST JAMES' PS	EAST ANTRIM	25,760	3,242
3036563	ST NICHOLAS' PS	EAST ANTRIM	13,450	1,803
3050519	CARNLOUGH CONTROLLED IPS	EAST ANTRIM	7,100	6,832
3066561	CORRAN INTEGRATED PS	EAST ANTRIM	22,540	2,875
2012058	LARGY PS	EAST DERRY	7,130	6,048
2012276	BURNFOOT PS	EAST DERRY	8,855	7,448
2012298	BALLYKELLY PS	EAST DERRY	0	0
2016426	LIMAVADY CENTRAL PS	EAST DERRY	35,800	4,491
2032263	ST CANICE'S PS	EAST DERRY	16,244	10,430
2032287	TERMONCANICE PS	EAST DERRY	36,214	4,584
2033706	FAUGHANVALE PS	EAST DERRY	17,193	10,934
2036085	ST PETER'S & ST PAUL'S PS	EAST DERRY	9,200	6,888
2036149	ST FINLOUGH'S PS	EAST DERRY	9,085	1,403
2036187	ST JOHN'S PS, DERNAFLAW	EAST DERRY	19,090	11,648
2036458	GORTNAGHEY PS	EAST DERRY	7,475	5,992
2066665	ROEVALLEY INTEGRATED PS	EAST DERRY	11,845	4,942
3012237	KILLOWEN PS	EAST DERRY	20,901	13,202
3012264	MILLBURN PS	EAST DERRY	32,804	19,936
3016052	HARPURS HILL PS	EAST DERRY	22,626	13,538
3016252	BALLYSALLY PS	EAST DERRY	23,403	14,175
3033709	ST JOHN'S PS	EAST DERRY	22,281	2,737
2011789	MOAT PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	16,158	2,142
2011873	AGHADRUMSEE PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	6,776
2011879	NEWTOWNBUTLER(2) PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	6,776
2016151	IRVINESTOWN PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	17,193	2,211
2031868	ST TIERNEY'S PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	9,016
2031869	ST MARY'S PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	19,004	11,774
2031886	CORRANNY PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	8,512
2031887	ST JOHN THE BAPTIST PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	8,512
2031892	CORNAGAGUE PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	7,280
2031898	ST PAUL'S PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	24,783	14,700
2031901	ST RONAN'S PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	26,680	16,240
2036258	ST DAVOG'S PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	7,784
2036632	HOLY TRINITY PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	37,053	4,824
2046669	BUNSCOIL AN TRAONAIGH	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	5,890	2,856
5012720	DUNGANNON PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	11,675	0
5016088	FIVEMILETOWN PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	20,729	2,530
5032736	ST MARY'S PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	7,590	1,277
5036363	ST MARY'S PS, AUGHNACLOY	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	11,200	1,630
5036504	ST PATRICK'S PS DUNGANNON	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	23,786
5066554	WINDMILL INTEGRATED PS	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	24,581	3,030
2010380	LONDONDERRY MODEL PS	FOYLE	30,274	18,403
2010382	EBRINGTON CONTROLLED PS	FOYLE	32,833	20,041
2012095	BALLOUGRY PS	FOYLE	11,385	8,176
2012227	DRUMAHOE PS	FOYLE	27,255	3,198
2012261	NEWBUILDINGS PS	FOYLE	25,099	14,350
2016071	GREENHAW PS	FOYLE	27,888	17,080
2016124	ASHLEA PS	FOYLE	13,915	9,240
2016203	LISNAGELVIN PS	FOYLE	35,972	4,476
2016564	FOUNTAIN PS	FOYLE	15,985	9,352
2030364	ROSEMOUNT PS	FOYLE	28,405	16,485
2030373	NAZARETH HOUSE PS	FOYLE	30,216	17,689
2030381	HOLY CHILD PS	FOYLE	28,578	16,975
2032212	GLENDERMOTT PS	FOYLE	0	12,698
2032277	CRAIGBRACK PS	FOYLE	0	0
2033707	MULLABUOY PS	FOYLE	12,200	9,352
2036032	ST JOHN'S PS	FOYLE	36,375	22,638
2036069	ST ANNE'S PS	FOYLE	35,547	21,560
2036084	STEELSTOWN VOL MAINTAINED PS	FOYLE	35,041	21,028
2036142	ST BRIGID'S PS	FOYLE	30,561	18,319
2036143	ST OLIVER PLUNKETT PS	FOYLE	20,729	12,446
2036227	ST PAULS PS, SLIEVEMORE	FOYLE	22,109	13,076
2036247	ST COLUMBA'S PS	FOYLE	11,155	1,530
2036259	TRENCH ROAD PS	FOYLE	30,504	17,962
2036288	GOOD SHEPHERD PS AND NURSERY SCHOOL	FOYLE	33,661	20,545
2036461	ST THERESA'S PS, LENAMORE	FOYLE	32,948	19,726
2036465	CHAPEL ROAD PS	FOYLE	19,349	12,572
2036472	HOLY FAMILY PS	FOYLE	33,580	20,293
2036473	ST EITHNE'S PS	FOYLE	35,156	21,364
2036475	LONGTOWER PS	FOYLE	29,641	17,360
2036555	ST EUGENE'S PS	FOYLE	24,380	14,175
2036574	BUNSCOIL CHOLMCILLE	FOYLE	20,384	12,278
2036581	ST PATRICKS PS	FOYLE	39,733	26,404
2046646	GAELSCOIL EADAIN MHOIR	FOYLE	14,200	11,270
2052035	GROARTY INTEGRATED PS	FOYLE	0	6,104
2066558	OAKGROVE INTEGRATED PS	FOYLE	39,365	20,125
4010743	LARGYMORE PS	LAGAN VALLEY	16,450	5,719
4010762	BROWNLEE PS	LAGAN VALLEY	17,050	2,200
4010807	LISBURN CENTRAL PS	LAGAN VALLEY	20,900	2,525
4010882	SEYMOUR HILL PS	LAGAN VALLEY	10,025	0
4010885	TONAGH PS	LAGAN VALLEY	17,125	11,984
4013308	FORT HILL PS	LAGAN VALLEY	22,200	2,744
4013309	DERRIAGHY PS	LAGAN VALLEY	8,300	6,608
4013334	KNOCKMORE PS	LAGAN VALLEY	17,725	6,223
4016144	OLD WARREN PS	LAGAN VALLEY	15,025	10,514
4030897	ST JOSEPH'S PS	LAGAN VALLEY	24,200	3,050
4033306	ST ALOYSIUS PS	LAGAN VALLEY	23,700	8,243
4036618	CHRIST THE REDEEMER PS	LAGAN VALLEY	35,972	22,386
4050618	HILDEN INTEGRATED PS	LAGAN VALLEY	9,315	1,277
4066611	OAKWOOD INTEGRATED PS	LAGAN VALLEY	10,425	0
3012267	MAGHERAFELT CONTROLLED PS	MID ULSTER	30,245	3,702
3036039	ST MARY'S PS (GLENVIEW)	MID ULSTER	0	17,584
3036562	HOLY FAMILY PS	MID ULSTER	35,018	4,451
5012615	BALLYTREA PS	MID ULSTER	14,720	9,884
5012632	DONAGHMORE PS	MID ULSTER	0	7,112
5012643	STEWARTSTOWN PS	MID ULSTER	7,360	6,160
5012649	COAGH PS	MID ULSTER	10,695	1,449
5016200	QUEEN ELIZABETH II (POMEROY) PS	MID ULSTER	5,900	5,936
5032692	ST MARY'S PS	MID ULSTER	16,158	10,304
5032699	ST MARY'S PS	MID ULSTER	20,384	12,614
5032703	ST PETER'S PS	MID ULSTER	22,195	13,328
5032713	DERRYCHRIN PS	MID ULSTER	15,381	10,094
5032717	ST PATRICK'S PS	MID ULSTER	0	12,824
5036033	ST JOSEPH'S PS	MID ULSTER	0	13,118
5036047	ST PATRICK'S PS	MID ULSTER	24,610	2,990
5036057	ST MALACHY'S PS	MID ULSTER	7,935	1,254
5036108	ST JOSEPH'S PS	MID ULSTER	11,730	8,736
5036118	ST MARY'S PS	MID ULSTER	21,505	12,824
5036590	PRIMATE DIXON PS	MID ULSTER	34,397	20,944
5046637	GAELSCOIL UI NEILL	MID ULSTER	13,300	5,173
5011137	NEWTOWNHAMILTON PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	11,040	7,840
5011175	CORTAMLET PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	9,800	7,896
5011179	BESSBROOK PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	15,295	9,842
5016028	KEADY PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	5,900	1,020
5030972	ST OLIVER PLUNKETT PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	10,724
5030975	ST MALACHY'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	13,570	9,072
5031070	ST MICHAEL'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	10,580	7,056
5031086	CLONALIG PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	17,451	11,018
5031088	DROMINTEE PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	12,614
5031110	CHRISTIAN BROTHERS' PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	25,050	17,710
5031126	MOUNT ST CATHERINE'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	19,225	14,280
5031133	ST MALACHY'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	13,916
5031135	ST OLIVER'S PS (CARRICKROVADDY)	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	9,085	1,380
5031146	ANAMAR PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	7,935	6,104
5031148	ST PATRICK'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	28,405	17,815
5031158	ST PATRICK'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	31,108	18,655
5031163	ST BRIGID'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	12,530
5031166	ST MICHAEL'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	9,660	1,461
5031169	ST BRIGID'S (DRUMILLY) PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	8,176
5031176	ST PETER'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	25,775	17,731
5031183	ST PATRICK'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	33707	10,199
5031188	ST JOSEPH'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	13,244
5031213	ST CLARE'S CONVENT PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	24,668	14,805
5031340	ST JOSEPH'S CONVENT PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	35,363	21,602
5031576	ST COLMAN'S ABBEY PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	15,855
5036064	ST MALACHY'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	16,625
5036087	ST MARY'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	17,185
5036099	ST PATRICK'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	23,978	14,035
5036110	ST JOSEPH'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	29,699	17,962
5036122	JONESBOROUGH PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	8,904
5036130	ST LAURENCE O'TOOLE'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	7,392
5036433	ST MALACHY'S PS	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	30,015	17,689
5036610	St Francis of Assisi Primary School	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	25,990	3,091
5046241	THE DRELINCOURT INFANTS SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	5,544
5046597	BUNSCOIL AN IUIR	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	9,884
3010726	DUNSEVERICK PS	NORTH ANTRIM	0	11,480
3010781	HARRYVILLE PS	NORTH ANTRIM	17,969	10,472
3010835	KELLS & CONNOR PS	NORTH ANTRIM	0	0
3010842	THE WM PINKERTON MEMORIAL PS	NORTH ANTRIM	10,300	8,288
3010873	BUSHMILLS PS	NORTH ANTRIM	16,675	10,094
3013315	BALLYKEEL PS	NORTH ANTRIM	29,958	17,899
3013322	CAMPHILL PS	NORTH ANTRIM	29,958	3,818
3013325	LEANEY PS	NORTH ANTRIM	25,650	3,204
3016040	ARMOY PS	NORTH ANTRIM	10,005	7,000
3016063	DUNCLUG PS	NORTH ANTRIM	16,244	10,640
3016171	BALLEE PS	NORTH ANTRIM	11,615	8,288
3016594	BUSHVALLEY PS	NORTH ANTRIM	19,004	2,496
3030719	ST OLCAN'S PS	NORTH ANTRIM	9,775	7,168
3030889	ST PATRICK'S PS AUGHTERCLONEY	NORTH ANTRIM	0	0
3030898	ST ANNE'S PS	NORTH ANTRIM	11,845	1,725
3036154	ST PATRICK'S PS	NORTH ANTRIM	23,058	2,823
3036559	ST PATRICK'S & ST BRIGID'S PS	NORTH ANTRIM	0	19,285
3053333	BALLYCASTLE PS	NORTH ANTRIM	14,950	10,850
4011681	MILLISLE PS	NORTH DOWN	17,538	2,297
4013023	BLOOMFIELD ROAD PS	NORTH DOWN	0	16,870
4016002	KILCOOLEY PS	NORTH DOWN	15,850	10,934
4033008	ST ANNE'S PS	NORTH DOWN	6,400	1,090
4036148	ST MALACHY'S PS	NORTH DOWN	26,400	3,094
3010558	DUNEANE PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	6,500	1,110
3010631	BALLYCLARE PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	34,811	4,338
3013301	CARNMONEY PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	26,475	3,286
3013331	BALLYCRAIGY PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	16,244	9,688
3016015	MOSSLEY PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	31,780	4,085
3016037	GREYSTONE PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	0	0
3016058	PARKHALL PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	26,105	7,928
3016249	EARLVIEW PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	16,075	11,522
3030713	CARLANE PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	7,475	1,219
3030815	MONEYNICK PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	0	0
3033303	ST OLIVER PLUNKETT'S PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	19,866	2,461
3033304	TIR-NA-NOG PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	6,900	1,219
3036026	ST JOSEPH'S PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	16,770	0
3036046	ST MARY'S ON THE HILL PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	24,350	3,038
3036050	ST JOSEPH'S PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	25,070	2,997
3056231	RATHENRAW INTEGRATED PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	14,490	8,960
3056248	ROUNDTOWER INTEGRATED PS	SOUTH ANTRIM	20,556	13,790
4016235	DOWNPATRICK PS	SOUTH DOWN	23,633	2,968
4031328	CHRIST THE KING PS	SOUTH DOWN	0	0
4031384	CONVENT OF MERCY PS	SOUTH DOWN	24,725	7,018
4031644	ST PATRICK'S BOYS' PS	SOUTH DOWN	29,469	17,626
4031671	ST PATRICK'S PS	SOUTH DOWN	7,700	1,210
4036036	ST MALACHY'S PS	SOUTH DOWN	14,350	1,915
4036182	ST COLMCILLE'S PS	SOUTH DOWN	24,208	14,560
5011649	KILKEEL PS	SOUTH DOWN	34,098	4,275
5011684	ANNALONG PS	SOUTH DOWN	17,200	12,614
5036545	ST COLMAN'S PS	SOUTH DOWN	19,300	12,740
4011345	NEWTOWNARDS MODEL PS	STRANGFORD	0	0
4011373	KIRKISTOWN PS	STRANGFORD	15,036	2,082
4011462	CASTLE GARDENS PS	STRANGFORD	26,600	3,223
4011488	VICTORIA PS (BALLYHALBERT)	STRANGFORD	18,055	2,340
4011507	PORTAVOGIE PS	STRANGFORD	21,074	2,711
4011587	DUNDONALD PS	STRANGFORD	36,053	4,591
4011588	COMBER PS	STRANGFORD	26,575	3,238
4011634	KILLYLEAGH PS	STRANGFORD	14,835	1,932
4011646	VICTORIA PS	STRANGFORD	31,310	3,995
4016004	LONDONDERRY PS	STRANGFORD	29,699	3,658
4016083	WEST WINDS PS	STRANGFORD	17,200	11,606
4016503	BROOKLANDS PS	STRANGFORD	36,490	4,525
4033017	ST FINIAN'S PS	STRANGFORD	17,193	2,211
4033036	ST MARY'S PS	STRANGFORD	17,193	2,211
4036530	ST MARY'S PS	STRANGFORD	24,898	2,983
4051601	PORTAFERRY INTEGRATED PS	STRANGFORD	12,995	1,794
5010992	LURGAN MODEL PS	UPPER BANN	22,971	13,664
5011127	CARRICK PS	UPPER BANN	31,079	3,822
5011129	HART MEMORIAL PS	UPPER BANN	28,520	16,853
5011190	TULLYGALLY PS	UPPER BANN	20,729	12,110
5011596	CRAIGAVON PS	UPPER BANN	16,503	2,099
5016007	MILLINGTON PS	UPPER BANN	35,984	4,548
5016065	DICKSON PS	UPPER BANN	18,918	2,392
5016080	DRUMGOR PS	UPPER BANN	26,450	15,575
5016117	BALLYORAN PS	UPPER BANN	27,313	16,415
5016543	MOYALLON PS	UPPER BANN	20,729	2,565
5031103	TANNAGHMORE PS	UPPER BANN	37,812	4,934
5031184	ST ANTHONY'S PS	UPPER BANN	35,317	21,826
5031669	ST JOHN'S PS	UPPER BANN	17,624	2,254
5036043	ST MARY'S PS	UPPER BANN	31,798	3,991
5036101	ST BRENDAN'S PS	UPPER BANN	31,510	19,411
5036173	ST JOHN THE BAPTIST PS	UPPER BANN	31,050	19,075
5036586	PRESENTATION PS	UPPER BANN	0	11,984
5036633	ST FRANCIS PS	UPPER BANN	38,238	25,018
2012392	DRUMLEGAGH PS	WEST TYRONE	8,740	6,664
2012617	ERGANAGH PS	WEST TYRONE	10,695	7,504
2012638	EDWARDS PS	WEST TYRONE	22,281	13,622
2012641	KILLEN PS	WEST TYRONE	14,720	9,884
2012660	DENAMONA PS	WEST TYRONE	12,420	4,564
2012671	LANGFIELD PS	WEST TYRONE	8,050	6,608
2012674	BRIDGEHILL PS	WEST TYRONE	9,660	6,944
2012691	OMAGH COUNTY PS	WEST TYRONE	30,446	3,715
2012707	DROMORE PS	WEST TYRONE	0	6,664
2012708	STRABANE CONTROLLED PS	WEST TYRONE	0	15,575
2012711	DONEMANA PS	WEST TYRONE	13,300	10,052
2016068	ARTIGARVAN PS	WEST TYRONE	21,246	12,278
2016262	NEWTOWNSTEWART MODEL PS	WEST TYRONE	12,535	8,736
2016376	ARDSTRAW PS	WEST TYRONE	11,270	7,784
2016395	GORTIN PS	WEST TYRONE	0	6,888
2016442	SION MILLS PS	WEST TYRONE	28,290	16,853
2016645	BREADY JUBILEE PRIMARY SCHOOL	WEST TYRONE	14,030	9,016
2032510	BARRACK STREET BOYS' PS	WEST TYRONE	22,195	13,538
2032573	ST BRIGID'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	8,008
2032600	DRUMNABEY PS	WEST TYRONE	10,120	6,888
2032603	TUMMERY PS	WEST TYRONE	0	8,232
2032612	ST MATTHEW'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	5,992
2032628	KNOCKNAGOR PS	WEST TYRONE	0	7,448
2032631	ENVAGH PS	WEST TYRONE	5,980	1,139
2032639	DRUMDUFF PS	WEST TYRONE	0	7,056
2032662	ST BRIGID'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	6,440
2032664	ST DAVOG'S SCRAGHEY PS	WEST TYRONE	5,865	5,264
2032681	ST PATRICK'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	5,936
2032682	ST EUGENE'S PS	WEST TYRONE	9,315	7,224
2032683	ST JOSEPH'S PS	WEST TYRONE	7,360	6,048
2032684	ST LAWRENCE'S PS	WEST TYRONE	26,623	15,190
2032685	ST BRIGID'S PS	WEST TYRONE	7,130	5,936
2032687	ST MACARTAN'S PS	WEST TYRONE	7,590	5,936
2032689	ST MARY'S BOYS' PS	WEST TYRONE	32,746	19,663
2032694	ST CAIREALL'S PS	WEST TYRONE	13,800	9,016
2032700	ST JOSEPH'S PS	WEST TYRONE	13,800	9,352
2032702	EVISH PS	WEST TYRONE	10,580	7,728
2032716	ST PATRICK'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	5,152
2032722	ALTISHANE PS	WEST TYRONE	8,050	6,496
2032724	LOUGHASH PS	WEST TYRONE	7,130	6,216
2032730	ST COLUMBA'S PS	WEST TYRONE	16,071	9,968
2032731	ST TERESA'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	11,186
2032737	ST COLUMBKILLE'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	16,905
2036008	ST PATRICK'S PS	WEST TYRONE	18,573	12,320
2036094	ST PATRICK'S PS	WEST TYRONE	25,128	14,998
2036095	ST MARY'S PS	WEST TYRONE	22,540	13,748
2036096	ST MARY'S GIRLS' PS	WEST TYRONE	30,878	18,508
2036097	ST PETER'S PS	WEST TYRONE	14,260	9,632
2036186	ST DYMPNA'S PS	WEST TYRONE	0	9,128
2036387	ST PATRICK'S PS	WEST TYRONE	9,775	7,000
2036389	ST ANNE'S PS	WEST TYRONE	27,658	16,310
2036415	OUR LADY OF LOURDES PS	WEST TYRONE	0	10,136
2036449	CHRIST THE KING PS	WEST TYRONE	18,831	11,900
2036459	ST THERESA'S PS	WEST TYRONE	18,573	11,606
2036557	ALL SAINTS PS	WEST TYRONE	7,475	1,231
2046638	GAELSCOIL UI DHOCARTAIGH	WEST TYRONE	16,416	11,060
	POST PRIMARY SCHOOLS
1210014	ASHFIELD GIRLS' HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	32,120	23,576
1210015	ASHFIELD BOYS' HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	36,754	23,240
1210266	ORANGEFIELD HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	25,550	17,465
4210030	LISNASHARRAGH HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	19,975	2,016
1210021	BELFAST MODEL SCHOOL FOR GIRLS	BELFAST NORTH	41,711	28,392
1210022	BELFAST BOYS' MODEL SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	40,641	27,636
1210258	CASTLE HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	17,451	11,144
1230026	ST PATRICK'S COLLEGE	BELFAST NORTH	33,080	24,290
1230032	ST GABRIEL'S BOYS SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	16,416	2,352
1230089	LITTLE FLOWER GIRLS' SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	32,340	23,828
1230104	OUR LADY OF MERCY GIRLS' SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	33,293	20,209
1230173	ST GEMMA'S HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	27,140	15,435
1260269	HAZELWOOD COLLEGE	BELFAST NORTH	38,790	25,578
3210279	NEWTOWNABBEY COMMUNITY HS	BELFAST NORTH	29,383	15,015
1230275	ST JOSEPH'S COLLEGE	BELFAST SOUTH	37,237	23,464
1260294	MALONE INTEGRATED COLLEGE	BELFAST SOUTH	33,630	25,508
1230053	ST LOUISE'S COLLEGE	BELFAST WEST	49,082	36,442
1230130	ST ROSE'S HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	35,915	21,770
1230146	CHRISTIAN BROTHERS SEC SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	31,530	21,896
1230155	ST GENEVIEVE'S HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	35,870	28,686
1230182	LA SALLE BOYS' SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	37,360	30,366
1230262	CORPUS CHRISTI COLLEGE	BELFAST WEST	36,513	22,596
1240291	COLAISTE FEIRSTE	BELFAST WEST	30,030	21,434
1420021	ST MARY'S CHRISTIAN BROTHERS' GS	BELFAST WEST	36,970	29,750
1420029	ST DOMINIC'S HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	35,610	28,308
4230223	ST COLM'S HIGH SCHOOL	BELFAST WEST	37,674	24,038
3210200	MONKSTOWN COMMUNITY SCHOOL	EAST ANTRIM	37,881	24,038
3230066	ST COMGALL'S HIGH SCHOOL	EAST ANTRIM	0	0
2210302	LIMAVADY HIGH SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	16,785	0
2230077	ST MARY'S LIMAVADY	EAST DERRY	38,985	5,161
2230109	ST MARY'S COLLEGE	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	12,908
2230180	ST EUGENE'S COLLEGE	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	14,525
2230190	ST COMHGHALL'S HIGH	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	17,115
5230293	ST PATRICK'S COLLEGE	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	35,409	4,520
2210306	LISNEAL COLLEGE	FOYLE	0	0
2230081	ST MARY'S COLLEGE	FOYLE	39,940	26,446
2230131	ST JOSEPH'S SECONDARY	FOYLE	39,986	26,726
2230181	ST PETER'S HIGH SCHOOL	FOYLE	30,590	17,255
2230188	ST CECILIA'S COLLEGE	FOYLE	40,170	26,964
2230225	ST BRIGID'S COLLEGE	FOYLE	39,273	25,536
2230254	IMMACULATE CONCEPTION COLLEGE	FOYLE	25,818	15,505
2260276	OAKGROVE INTEGRATED COLLEGE	FOYLE	39,365	26,152
2420052	THORNHILL COLLEGE	FOYLE	45,828	33,978
2420054	ST COLUMB'S COLLEGE	FOYLE	46,794	35,028
2420229	FOYLE & LONDONDERRY COLLEGE	FOYLE	0	0
2420287	LUMEN CHRISTI COLLEGE	FOYLE	0	26,250
1210288	BALMORAL HIGH SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	17,050	0
4210051	LISNAGARVEY HIGH SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	29,958	16,800
4210194	DUNMURRY HIGH SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	30,073	17,710
4230165	ST PATRICK'S HIGH SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	29,383	3,680
3210090	MAGHERA HIGH SCHOOL	MID ULSTER	17,950	12,068
5230192	ST JOSEPH'S HIGH SCHOOL	MID ULSTER	33,730	20,706
5230278	HOLY TRINITY COLLEGE	MID ULSTER	38,215	12,383
5230056	ST JOSEPH'S BOYS' HIGH SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	33,408	20,587
5230108	ST MARY'S HIGH SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	35,455	21,938
5230157	ST PAUL'S HIGH SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	33,978
5230160	ST BRIGID'S HIGH SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	0	15,155
5230167	ST JOSEPH'S HIGH SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	35,869	22,008
5420062	ST COLMAN'S COLLEGE	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	17,185	0
3210124	BALLYCASTLE HIGH SCHOOL	NORTH ANTRIM	30,360	18,277
3210233	BALLEE COMMUNITY HIGH SCHOOL	NORTH ANTRIM	30,331	18,109
4210031	DONAGHADEE HIGH SCHOOL	NORTH DOWN	0	0
3210207	PARKHALL HIGH SCHOOL	SOUTH ANTRIM	0	0
3230203	EDMUND RICE COLLEGE	SOUTH ANTRIM	35,501	21,966
4230224	DE LA SALLE SECONDARY SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	31,510	3,771
5210016	KILKEEL HIGH SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	38,387	5,046
4210045	COMBER HIGH SCHOOL	STRANGFORD	0	0
4210262	DUNDONALD HIGH SCHOOL	STRANGFORD	31,481	18,172
5230088	ST PAUL'S JUNIOR HIGH SCHOOL	UPPER BANN	34,328	10,556
5230213	LISMORE COMPREHENSIVE SCHOOL	UPPER BANN	41,860	29,372
5230256	DRUMCREE COLLEGE	UPPER BANN	30,648	16,660
5250216	BROWNLOW INT COLLEGE	UPPER BANN	33,293	20,377
2210065	CASTLEDERG HIGH SCHOOL	WEST TYRONE	32,718	20,314
2210164	STRABANE HIGH SCHOOL	WEST TYRONE	26,968	16,485
2230111	ST EUGENE'S HIGH SCHOOL	WEST TYRONE	18,573	11,774
2230138	DEAN BRIAN MAGUIRC COLLEGE	WEST TYRONE	0	20,762
2230148	ST JOHN'S HIGH SCHOOL	WEST TYRONE	0	12,194
2230301	HOLY CROSS COLLEGE	WEST TYRONE	45,713	33,516
2410096	STRABANE GS	WEST TYRONE	32,028	19,558
2420065	LORETO GS	WEST TYRONE	0	27,188
	SPECIAL SCHOOLS
1310017	GREENWOOD HSE ASSESSMENT CENTRE	BELFAST EAST	0	7,336
1316584	CLARAWOOD SPECIAL SCHOOL	BELFAST EAST	0	4,816
1310003	CEDAR LODGE SPECIAL SCHOOL	BELFAST NORTH	17,969	11,690
1310014	HARBERTON SPECIAL SCHOOL	BELFAST SOUTH	0	14,490
1316500	PARK EDUC RESOURCE CENTRE	BELFAST SOUTH	0	9,884
1316569	GLENVEAGH SPECIAL	BELFAST SOUTH	10,063	14,000
1316582	OAKWOOD SPECIAL SCHOOL	BELFAST SOUTH		9,352
1336012	ST FRANCIS DE SALES	BELFAST WEST	5,800	1,456
1336548	ST GERARD'S RESOURCE EDUCATION CENTRE	BELFAST WEST	20,750	14,385
3310018	ROSSTULLA SPECIAL SCHOOL	EAST ANTRIM	0	12,404
3316514	RODDENS VALE SPECIAL SCHOOL	EAST ANTRIM	12,420	1,783
3340002	JORDANSTOWN SPECIAL SCHOOL	EAST ANTRIM	9,600	7,504
2310007	LIMEGROVE SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	11,500	8,120
2316526	GLASVEY SPECIAL SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	6,555	5,040
3316512	SANDELFORD SPECIAL SCHOOL	EAST DERRY	16,225	11,690
2316234	ERNE SPECIAL SCHOOL	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	15,381	9,968
2316601	ELMBROOK SPECIAL SCHOOL	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	10,005	7,392
5316523	SPERRINVIEW SPECIAL SCHOOL	FERMANAGH & SOUTH TYRONE	0	8,848
2310015	BELMONT HOUSE SPECIAL SCHOOL	FOYLE	22,109	12,992
2316525	FOYLEVIEW SPECIAL SCHOOL	FOYLE	16,071	10,850
4310008	BEECHLAWN SPECIAL SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	25,530	15,190
4316022	BROOKFIELD SPECIAL SCHOOL	LAGAN VALLEY	15,468	10,514
3316570	KILRONAN SPECIAL SCHOOL	MID ULSTER	10,200	1,430
5316519	RATHORE SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	12,400	5,026
5316577	LISANALLY SPECIAL SCHOOL	NEWRY AND ARMAGH	14,260	1,944
3316676	CASTLETOWER SCHOOL	NORTH ANTRIM	19,608	16,380
3316510	HILL CROFT SPECIAL SCHOOL	SOUTH ANTRIM	11,400	1,590
4310019	ARDMORE HOUSE SPECIAL SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	4,000	4,872
4316516	KNOCKEVIN SPECIAL SCHOOL	SOUTH DOWN	11,960	1,748
4310013	KILLARD HOUSE SPECIAL SCHOOL	STRANGFORD	20,470	2,625
4316273	LONGSTONE SPECIAL SCHOOL	STRANGFORD	18,325	6,517
5316521	CEARA SPECIAL SCHOOL	UPPER BANN	13,915	1,921
2316528	KNOCKAVOE SCHOOL AND RESOURCE CENTRE	WEST TYRONE	10,465	7,952
2316661	ARVALEE SCHOOL AND RESOURCE CENTRE	WEST TYRONE	17,796	10,892

Breakdown of funding by Parliamentary Constituency

2007/08 2008/09

Belfast East £406,485 £240,044

Belfast North £923,110 £678,916

Belfast South £284,633 £226,772

Belfast West £1,265,961 £873,121

East Antrim £335,252 £115,655

East Derry £417,509 £178,406

Fermanagh & South

Tyrone £290,001 £218,105

Foyle £1,317,010 £813,827

Lagan Valley £421,279 £157,266

Mid Ulster £404,048 £228,828

Newry & Armagh £606,631 £531,432

North Antrim £343,105 £190,776

North Down £66,188 £34,285

South Antrim £370,361 £103,693

South Down £315,270 £95,908

Strangford £433,112 £83,145

Upper Bann £653,864 £281,625

West Tyrone £825,836 £700,958

Education Targets

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to her answer to AQW 6298/08, what specific action she will take to address the figures which show that young male protestants are not meeting educational achievement targets and are well below the average in both rural and urban areas.

(AQW 8563/08)

Ms C Ruane: Under-achievement is found among Protestant boys in urban and rural settings but can also be found in other groups within our community.

As stated in my previous response, I am determined to establish an education system which ensures that each and every child reaches her of his potential.

I plan to do this through: -

the removal of academic selection;

having an effective policy in place to promote and support school improvement (Every School a Good School); and

revising the literacy and numeracy strategy so that all schools ensure that no child leaves school with under-developed literacy and numeracy skills.

Tacófar leis na bearta seo trí chur chuige níos éifeachtaí i gcomhair Riachtanais Speisialta Oideachais agus foilseoidh mé moltaí s’agamsa i dtaca leis an ábhar seo le linn na scoilbhliana úire.

These actions will be supported by a more effective approach to Special Educational Need and I shall be publishing my proposals for this in the new school year.

Use of the Irish Language

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to her answer to AQW 6256/08, to detail the number of occasions and percentage of time spent in using the Irish language during meetings and visits since devolution; and whether the proposed post of Staff Officer - Irish language is justified by the amount of work involved.

(AQW 8564/08)

Ms C Ruane: Elements of business have been in conducted in Irish by me since devolution, but existing staff cannot provide adequate support in this aspect. It is not possible to provide the breakdown requested.

There is a pressing need for additional capacity at Staff Officer level to cope with a wide range of pressures in my Department’s Top Management Support Unit. The work will not be exclusively on Irish Language support services. There will also be responsibilities in relation to the preparation of papers and arranging meetings where North South co-operation on education matters is considered.

Tá an post-tuairisc iomlán cuimsithe i Leabhrán Eolais Iarratasóra Oifigeach Foirne (Teanga Ghaeilge) a cuireadh i Leabharlann an Tionóil.

The full job description is included in the Staff Officer (Irish Language) Candidate Information Booklet which has been placed in the Assembly Library.

Special Education Funding

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education what action she is taking (i) to address the number of special education needs children; and (ii) to ensure that they are given the assistance needed to access mainstream education.

(AQW 8580/08)

Ms C Ruane: Provision for special educational needs (SEN) is matched to individual needs. It may be made in a range of settings including special schools, in special units attached to mainstream schools; or in mainstream classes themselves.

Cinntíonn na Boird Oideachais agus Leabharlann (BOL) leibhéal an mhaoinithe i gcomhair oideachas speisialta mar pháirt dá gcinntí bliantúla ar dháileadh a mblocdheontas. I dtaca le RSO, bheifí ag súil go gclúdódh buiséad an BOL na nithe seo a leanas:

The level of funding for special education is determined by the Education and Library Boards (ELBs) as part of their annual decisions about the allocation of their block grant. In terms of SEN, the ELB’s budget would be expected to cover:

ELB support for the provision for statemented and non-statemented (stage 3) children with SEN in mainstream schools, including those in special units;
special schools, including external placements; and
central costs e.g. educational psychology services, SEN peripatetic teachers, special education administration.

In addition, mainstream schools are funded by means of the Local Management of Schools (LMS) arrangements via the Common Funding Scheme. The Targeting Social Need component, also within the Scheme, includes an educational element for SEN-related factors.

Special schools are not included in LMS arrangements. ELBs retain the major element of special school expenditure (staff salaries) as a centre cost although each school is allocated a delegated budget to cover non-staff items, eg electricity, heating.

2006/07 is the last year for which full Board outturn figures are available;

In 2006/07 around £171m was expended in the North of Ireland for provision for children with special educational needs;

This includes some £141m expended by the Education and Library Boards for special schools (£92m) and to meet the additional costs of statemented pupils in mainstream schools and units (£49m);

Also included is some £24m to address educational underachievement for pupils who do not have a statement of SEN, which was distributed directly to schools through the Targeting Social Need element of the LMS formula;

As well as funding provided through the voluntary grammar school (VGS) and grant maintained integrated (GMI) funding formulae, further amounts of £2.0m and £3.8m were provided to schools in the VGS and GMI sectors respectively in the 2006/07 financial year, to meet the costs of pupils with statements.

Arising out of the Education Order 1996 the Department issued a Code of Practice on the Identification and Assessment of Special Education Needs. This provides practical guidance to parents, schools and Boards on the statementing process. The Department, in collaboration with the ELBs and the Education and Training Inspectorate, has also published guidance on various SEN including ASD, Dyslexia, Speech and Language, ADHD, Acquired Brain Injury, Deaf Friendly Schools and is currently preparing guidance on Vision Friendly Schools.

The introduction, in September 2005, of the Special Educational Needs and Disability Order (SENDO) has further strengthened the rights of children with SEN to be educated in mainstream education.

If no statement is maintained for a child he or she shall be educated in an ordinary (ie mainstream) school. If a statement is maintained for the child he or she shall be educated in an ordinary school unless that is incompatible with –

(a) the wishes of the parent, or

(b) the provision of efficient education for other children.

A Supplement to the Code of Practice has been issued by the Department as a result of SENDO. In 2004, the percentage of Statemented pupils in mainstream schools was 46.78% but this has now risen, post SENDO, to 67.6%.

It is accepted that there is a range of problems associated with the current SEN framework and in order to address these issues the Department commenced a review of SEN and Inclusion in April 2006. The review’s draft policy proposals have been approved by me and were presented to the Education Committee on 23rd May 2008. Central to the emerging recommendations are the key principles of equality of access and continuity, quality and consistency of assessment and intervention. The draft proposals have been circulated to members of the Health Committee and the Executive. Following progress through the Assembly structures, public consultation is planned for autumn 2008.

Donaghadee High School

Mr Easton asked the Minister of Education when she will make an announcement on the future of Donaghadee High School.

(AQW 8589/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an tréimhse comhairliúcháin reachtúil 2 mhí díreach i ndiaidh críochnú ar 30 Meitheamh; cuireadh tús leis an tréimhse comhairliúcháin de bharr gur foilsíodh an Togra Forbartha le hArdscoil Dhomhnach Daoi a dhúnadh ó Lúnasa 2009. Déanfaidh mé cinneadh ar an togra chomh luath agus is féidir.

The 2-month statutory consultation period initiated by the publication of the Development Proposal to allow for the closure of Donaghadee High School from August 2009 has just ended on 30 June. I will make a decision on the proposal as soon as possible.

Increasing Fuel Costs

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education what additional funding has been provided to the Education and Library Boards to cover the additional costs resulting from rising fuel prices.

(AQW 8606/08)

Ms C Ruane: Education and Library Boards receive budgets to meet the cost of pupil to school transport under the Assessment of Relative Needs arrangements. I have recognised that there has been a significant increase in fuel costs in recent months. The Education and Library Boards have put forward details of pressures they are encountering with these increased costs and I will endeavour to consider how we can meet them.

Is féidir go dteastódh tairiscint ar bhreis acmhainní ag an chéad bhabhta foirmiúil faireacháin eile.

A bid for additional resources at the next formal monitoring round may be required.

Children of Army Personnel

Mr Storey asked the Minister of Education what changes have been made to the funding formula in relation to children of Army Personnel, and when did the changes come into effect.

(AQW 8641/08)

Ms C Ruane: From 1st April 2005, all grant-aided schools have been funded under the Common Funding Formula arrangements set out in a Common Funding Scheme, which replaced the seven separate LMS Schemes previously used to distribute funding.

Ag an am sin, cuireadh fachtóir isteach san fhoirmle úr le tacaíocht bhreise a sholáthar do scoileanna a bhíonn ag teagasc páistí phearsanra na seirbhísí slándála mar gur aithníodh go mbíonn dúshláin agus costais bhreise i gceist do na scoileanna sin, nithe nach dtugtar aghaidh orthu trí fhachtóirí maoiniúcháin eile laistigh den fhoirmle.

At that time, a factor was included within the new formula to provide additional support for schools educating children of service personnel as it was recognised that these pupils provide extra challenges and costs for schools which are not addressed via other funding factors within the formula.

This funding is intended to support schools in inducting these children during their transition to a new school and curricular environment and in designing learning programmes to bring them to the same stage as other pupils already in the school.

The current arrangements provide for schools to receive an additional 0.2 of the basic Age Weighted Pupil Unit (AWPU) cash value (equivalent to £393 in 2008/09) for each of those pupils who are children of service personnel.

As the funding support for these pupils is directly linked to the AWPU cash value, the additional support funding for these pupils changes year on year with the changes to the AWPU cash value.

Children Diagnosed with Autism

Mr Storey asked the Minister of Education how many children are diagnosed with Autism, broken down by Education and Library Board.

(AQW 8642/08)

Ms C Ruane: A diagnosis of Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is provided under the auspices of the Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety and not by the Department of Education. Provision for special educational need (SEN) does not depend upon such a diagnosis but is centred on the need of the individual child.

Chuir an Roinn ar fáil treoir do scoileanna agus do an Boird Oideachais agus Leabharlainne, "Taifeadadh Páistí le Sainriachtanais Oideachasúla/Recording Children with Special Educational Needs", ar mhaithe le comhordú eolais don Daonáireamh Bliantúil Scoileanna.

The Department has provided guidance to schools and the Education and Library Boards, "Recording Children with Special Educational Needs", in order to collate information for the completion of the Annual School Census. The following table, from the 2007/08 School Census, details the number of children, at Stages 1 to 5 of the Code of Practice on the Identification and Assessment of SEN, in pre-primary, primary and secondary education, whose primary SEN is ASD.

	ELB
School type	BELB	WELB	NEELB	SEELB	SELB	TOTAL
Preschool centres	*	0	*	15	*	22
Nursery schools	#	5	#	14	#	45
Primary	80	98	146	294	247	865
Post primary	10	37	45	40	98	230
Special	105	129	177	259	140	810
Total	210	269	379	622	492	1,972

Source: school census
Note:
1. Primary includes nursery, reception and year 1 - 7 classes.
2. Figures relate to pupils at Stage 1 - 5 of the Code fo Practice with autism recorded.
Some pupils at stages 1 and 2 of the code of Practice may have their needs recorded at a more general level.
* denotes fewer than 5 pupils.
# denotes figure suppressed due to possible identification of individual pupils.

Autism Services

Mr Storey asked the Minister of Education what services, other than those provided by the Autism Centre in Middletown, are currently provided for children with Autism in each Education and Library Board area.

(AQW 8643/08)

Ms C Ruane: Thug Príomhfheidhmeannaigh na mBord Oideachais agus Leabharlann le fios dom gur bunaíodh na seirbhísí seo a leanas i gcomhair uathachais i ngach ceann dá gcuid limistéa.:

I am advised by the Chief Executive Officers of the Education and Library Boards that the following services for Autism have been established in each of their areas.

Belfast Education and Library Board (BELB)

Children with ASD are educated in a range of settings both mainstream and special school across the education sector. The Board also supports a number of pupils currently in receipt of Applied Behavioural Analysis (ABA) provision.

Provision available within schools in the BELB for children with ASD can include:-

The annual Transition support programme for parents, teachers and children at transfer from nursery to year 1 and from year 7 to year 8 provided by the BELB;
Assessment by an educational psychologist in liaison with Health and Social Care professionals;
Schools visits/assessments by the BELB ASD Service and provision of written recommendations which are then incorporated into the child’s education plan and implemented by the class teacher/school staff;
Reviews of these recommendations by the BELB ASD Service on request by school;
In more complex cases the BELB ASD Service can provide an ASD trained adult assistant for the child;
In the most complex cases a statutory assessment may ultimately lead to a statement of special educational needs.

South Eastern Education and Library Board

The Board provides a range of services to pupils with autism including:

Pre-school advice and support to children with autism and their parents.
Social Communication Units at Cumran PS, Belvoir Park PS, Knockmore PS and Killard House Special School.
Speech and Language Units at Belvoir Park PS, Knockevin PS and Killard House Special School (many children with speech, language and communication difficulties have a diagnosis of autism).
Specialist teaching and non-teaching support at The High School, Ballynahinch and Fort Hill Integrated College.
Additional adult assistance (teaching and non-teaching) for pupils with autism attending mainstream schools.
An advisory and support service to pupils with autism, teachers, parents and other professionals.
A specialist Senior Educational Psychologist.

North Eastern Education and Library Board

The North Eastern Board has established an ASD Support Service:

The Service team is comprised of: 3 Assistant Advisory Officers, 1 Field Officer, 2 Autism Intervention Officers, one Senior Educational Psychologist and one specialist educational psychologist trained as a Board Certified Analyst on a part time basis.

Core work involves providing support to pupils with ASD and their schools through: training, giving advice to teachers and offering individual input to pupils.

Training is organised annually, on a rolling programme and covers general to very specific topics relating to ASD. Information is sent to schools in regard to this training and they select from this, as required. Longitudinal training for Teachers and Classroom Assistants and training on ABA Intervention is a recent addition to the training menu.

One Assistant Advisory Officer from the Autism Support Service also leads within the TEACCH regional training programme.

Within mainstream schools individual pupil support is provided at Stages 3-5 of the Code of Practice. Individual pupils also have access to individual levels of support classroom assistance, supervisory assistance or teaching time.

Within Special Schools, advice and training can be accessed, on request.

In addition is it sometimes more appropriate for a pupil to access support from other Board Services e.g. Behaviour Support, literacy teaching or Pre-school Home Teaching Service.

ASD Provision in Schools

The majority of the SLD schools in the NEELB (four in total) have specialised classes for children with Autism and this provision is also available within the MLD schools. Staff in these classes have received additional training in ASD interventions to enable them to provide for the needs of pupils with a severe learning difficulty and ASD.

Multi-disciplinary Work

The Senior Educational Psychologist (Sp ASD) is a member of the core multi-disciplinary Autism Assessment and Diagnosis Service for the former Homefirst Trust area. This work involves the diagnostic assessment of young people through a range of options (such as school, clinic and group assessment). Parent training runs alongside group assessment of the young people (usually for six sessions) and feedback is offered from two professionals. Individual Educational Psychologists provide psychological input within the former Causeway Trust area.

Throughout the year there is a rolling programme of six evening parent training for parents of children already diagnosed and those awaiting diagnostic assessment (within the former Homefirst Trust). This group has also organised social skills training for adolescent pupils with ASD.

Practical assistance and training is being provided to the Paediatric Dental Service within the former Homefirst Trust area, to develop a programme towards enabling children with ASDs to visit the dentist, without undue stress.

Voluntary Agencies

Close links have been established with PAPA (Autism NI) and contact with the National Autism Society has recently been established. Collaborative training is regularly provided by the ASD Support Service (with Autism NI) and the members of the Support Service make themselves available to speak to parents in the evenings at the local branches.

Western Education and Library Board

As with other Boards the Western Board has established a Support Service, the Autism Spectrum Advisory Service (ASAS) based in Robin House, Omagh. The Service is managed by an Advisor and has a team of ten officers who work on a Board wide basis to provide support from Early Years to 19 yrs. The Support Service works closely with other statutory and voluntary agencies to co-ordinate training and intervention in specific cases and has also established effective links with the Western Health and Social Care Trust to enable therapy services to be provided in ASD provision. The key elements of the service are:

Advice and information – Telephone advice and information on general matters relating to ASD;
INSET – Centre based courses for school professionals aimed at promoting the development of a range of relevant skills;
School based training – Whole/part staff on-site tailored training for school;
Parent training – Centre based courses for families aimed at promoting a range of skills;
Teacher/classroom assistant support – Advisory visits to provide general advice and support and specific advice regarding classroom strategies for individual pupils and input into Individualised education plans;
Parent support – Advisory visits/telephones advice to provide general advice and support to families;
Pupil support – Support for individual pupils based on the level of need including assessment and intervention programmes.

The ASAS provides statutory advice in relation to pupils for whom a Statement of Special Educational Need is being undertaken. The service also provides input into the Annual Review Process of pupils with Statements of Special Educational Need.

The Board also has ASD specific classes as detailed below:

(i) Special Schools

Arvalee, Elmbrook, Knockavoe, Belmont and Foyleview Schools provide KS1 autism specific classes. Each class is staffed with 1 teacher and up to 2 classroom assistants and caters for up to 8 pupils. Elmbrook and Arvalee have begun to develop autism specific classes for post-primary pupils on the basis of identified need.

(ii) Mainstream Schools

The Board has recently received DE approval to open 4 autism specific classes attached to mainstream schools at St Brigid’s PS, Carnhill, Londonderry Model PS, Omagh County PS and Holy Trinity PS, Enniskillen. Each school will provide KSI autism specific classes with effect from September 2008. Each class will be staffed with 1 teacher and up to 2 classroom assistants and will cater for up to 8 pupils.

The Board is also progressing the establishment of a pilot programme for Autism in the Post-Primary sector on the basis of identified need.

Southern Education and Library Board

The Board established an Autism Advice and Intervention Service (AAIS) which is based in Silverwood, Lurgan. This service is managed by an Adviser and has a team of 10 officers who work on a Board wide basis. This support is provided by the AAIS Service for pupils from Early Years to 19 years. In addition to working with Board services, the AAIS works closely with other statutory and voluntary agencies to co-ordinate training and interventions in specific cases. Indeed, the SELB has established effective links with the Southern Health & Social Care Trust in particular so that Therapy Services can be provided in Autism Specific Provision.

The key elements of the work of the AAIS can be summarised as follows:-

Advice and information – Telephone advice and information on general matters relating to ASD;
INSET – Centre based courses for school professionals aimed at promoting the development of a range of relevant skills;
School based training – Whole/part staff on-site tailored training for school;
Parent training – Centre based courses for families aimed at promoting a range of skills;
Teacher/classroom assistant support – Advisory visits to provide general advice and support and specific advice regarding classroom strategies for individual pupils and input into Individualised education plans;
Parent support – Advisory visits/telephones advice to provide general advice and support to families;
Pupil support – Support for individual pupils based on the level of need including assessment and intervention programmes.

The AAIS provides statutory advice in relation to pupils for whom a Statement of Special Educational Need is being undertaken. The service also provides input into the Annual Review Process of pupils with Statements of Special Educational Need.

The SELB also has Autism Specific Classes as detailed below:-

(i) Special Schools:

Ceara, Donard, Rathore and Sperrinview provide Autism Specific Classes. Each class is staffed with one teacher and up to 2 Classroom Assistants and caters for up to 8 pupils.

(ii) Mainstream Schools:

The Southern Board has 9 Autism Specific Classes which are attached to mainstream schools. These are located at:-

Edenderry Primary School, Portadown;

St Mary’s Primary School, Banbridge;

St Joseph’s Convent Primary School, Newry;

Kilkeel Primary School;

Dungannon Primary School;

Primate Dixon Primary School, Coalisland;

Christian Brothers Primary School, Armagh;

Cookstown Primary School; and

The Armstrong Primary School, Armagh.

Each class is staffed with one teacher and up to 2 Classroom Assistants and caters for up to 8 pupils.

The Board is also progressing the establishment of a pilot programme for Autism in the Post-Primary sector on the basis of identified need.

The Inter-Board ASD Group

This group is chaired by a Principal Educational Psychologist and an ASEO. Five Senior Educational Psychologists and Five Assistant Advisory Officers/Field Officers (all ASD specialists) meet monthly to promote consistency and commonality of practice – in meeting the needs of children with ASD across the North of Ireland.

Present work includes the compiling of a core training menu of courses which can be made available to school staff and the completion of an early years programme for use with children with Autism.

The Group is the identified link with the Middletown Centre for Excellence.

Utilisation of the Post Office

Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Education what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by her Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.

(AQW 8692/08)

Ms C Ruane: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ Report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of Postal Services and the Post Office network. Junior Minister Donaldson and Junior Minister Kelly wrote to Executive Ministers on 21 April asking them to consider whether any further public services could be delivered through post offices.

Leanfaidh Roinn s’agamsa le deiseanna a mheas de réir mar a thagann siad aníos le hoibriú amach cé acu an féidir aon seirbhís phoiblí úr a sholáthar trí Oifig an Phoist cé go mbeadh na seirbhísí sin faoi réir an pholasaí chuí soláthair.

My Department will continue to look at opportunities as they arise to consider whether any new public service could be delivered through the Post Office although these would be subject to the appropriate procurement policy.

Re-build of Ballywalter Primary School

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Education to provide an estimated start date for the re-build of Ballywalter Primary School, now that the Department has accepted the option for a new school on an alternative site.

(AQW 8698/08)

Ms C Ruane: Ar an ábhar nach ndearnadh aon chinneadh ar thráthúlacht an chéad fhógra maoiniúcháin eile, ní féidir dáta tosaigh mheasta a thabhairt ag an phointe seo i dtaca le hatógáil Bhunscoil Bhaile Bháltair.

As no decision has been made on the timing of the next capital funding announcement an estimated start date for a re-build of Ballywalter Primary School cannot be provided at this time.

New Build at Braidside Integrated School, Ballymena

Mr McKay asked the Minister of Education when the Braidside Integrated School in Ballymena will be provided with a new building to replace the current mobile classrooms.

(AQW 8703/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá scéim le haghaidh foirgneamh úr scoile d’Abhainn na Brád ag dul tríd na luathchéimeanna pleanála i láthair na huaire. Caithfear breithmheas eacnamaíochta bheith comhlánaithe ag an scoil agus aontaithe ag an Roinn sula mbeidh sí i dteideal an chláir chaipitil.

A scheme for a new school building for Braidside is currently in the early stages of planning. The school will need to have an economic appraisal completed and agreed by the Department before it is eligible for consideration for the capital programme.

Post-Primary School Places

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how many Year 7 pupils have obtained places in post-primary education for the year 2008-2009, for each post-primary school in the South Eastern Education and Library Board area, broken down by feeder primary school.

(AQW 8714/08)

Ms C Ruane: Cuireadh an t-eolas a iarradh i leabharlann an Tionóil.

The information requested has been placed in the Assembly library.

Selection of Post-Primary School Places

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education to detail the first choice of post-primary school for 2008-2009, of year 7 pupils attending primary schools in the South Eastern Education and Library Board area, broken down by primary school.

(AQW 8715/08)

Ms C Ruane: Cuireadh an t-eolas a iarradh i leabharlann an Tionóil.

The information requested has been placed in the Assembly library.

Statements of Special Educational Needs

Mrs D Kelly asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to her answer to AQO 4020/08, to explain why the figures for the Southern Education and Library Board are much higher compared to other education and library boards.

(AQW 8761/08)

Ms C Ruane: I have been advised by the Chief Executive of the Southern Education and Library Board (SELB) that the SELB is the largest Board in terms of pupil enrolment. This may be one factor which could explain the higher number of Statements of Special Educational Needs.

The Chief Executive also reports that further to a review of the figure of 193 which was previously submitted the revised figure of 124 is now considered to be accurate. This figure decreased from 193 to 124 when officers updated the Capita System to take account of cases which had already been finalised, or where Notes in Lieu had been issued.

Maidir leis na 124 cás atá le críochnú go fóill, tá an briseadh síos seo a leanas i gceist:-

In relation to the 124 cases which have yet to be finalised the following break-down applies:-

18% (22 cases) are waiting to be drafted by Special Education Officers;

82% (102 cases) have been issued as Proposed Statements to parents and schools but a final response confirming acceptance of the Proposed Statement has not been obtained. In some cases there has been no response from the parent or school and in other cases details relating to the placement have to be finalised.

Waiting Lists

Mrs D Kelly asked the Minister of Education what action she is taking to (i) reduce the waiting list in the Southern Education and Library Board area; and (ii) further reduce the waiting lists in the other education and library board areas, before the school term begins in September 2008.

(AQW 8764/08)

Ms C Ruane: Bhain na figiúirí a tugadh mar fhreagra ar AQO 4020/08 leis na páistí úd, a ndearnadh measúnú reachtúil RSO orthu faoin dáta sin, agus a bhí ag fanacht lena ráitis deiridh RSO bheith críochnaithe .i. céim 4 den Chód Chleachtais maidir le Riachtanais Speisialta Oideachais a Shainaithint agus a Mheas.

The figures provided in response to AQO 4020/08 were in respect of those children on whom a statutory assessment of SEN had been completed, at that date, and who were awaiting completion of their final statement of SEN i.e. stage 4 of the Code of Practice on the Identification and Assessment of Special Educational Needs. I would refer to my answer to AQW 8761/08 which provides a breakdown of the figures relevant to the South Eastern Education and Library Board.

By way of further explanation I should explain that on completion of an assessment a Board has 2 weeks in which to issue a Proposed Statement or to inform the parent that they do not intend to make a Statement. If the Board issues a Proposed Statement it has a further 8 weeks in which to issue a completed Statement.

The Board will serve a Proposed Statement on the parent, who then has 15 days to make representations to the Board and to arrange a meeting to discuss any concerns they may have about the content of the Statement. After this meeting the parent then has a further 15 days to make further representations to the board. Therefore, within the statutory timeframe, there will always be a number of children whose assessment has been completed but whose final Statement has not yet been issued. Should the parent not reach agreement with the Board they may appeal to the Special Educational Needs and Disability Tribunal.

Initial Teacher Intake

Mr McClarty asked the Minister of Education, in light of the importance of the Shared Futures Agenda, to give an assurance that teacher training places at the University of Ulster will not be reduced.

(AQW 8796/08)

Ms C Ruane: I have reviewed, in consultation with the Minister for Employment and Learning the overall initial teacher education intake (ITE) numbers for the 2008/09 academic year.

I have made my decision on the revised intake figures for the 2008/09 academic year in the context of: i) the overall places made available for ITE across all of the institutions here in the north; ii) the wider education reform agenda; iii) the Programme for Government key goal of increasing the number of students studying Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics; iv) the Department for Employment and Learning’s review of funding for the two University Colleges; and, v) the "Stakeholder Review" of teacher training announced by the Assembly’s Committee for Employment and Learning.

The numbers notified to the University of Ulster in February 2008 remain unchanged and, therefore, have not been reduced.

Teacher Training Places

Mr McClarty asked the Minister of Education how many teacher training places are allocated to (i) St Mary's University College; (ii) Stranmillis University College; and (iii) the University of Ulster.

(AQW 8797/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá iontrálacha ar oiliúint thosaigh do mhúinteoirí (ITE) don bhliain acadúil 2008/09 do Choláiste Ollscoile Naomh Muire, do Choláiste Ollscoile an tStutháin Mhilis; agus d’Ollscoil Uladh leagtha amach sa tábla thíos:

The 2008/09 academic year initial teacher education (ITE) intakes for St Mary’s University College, Stranmillis University College; and for the University of Ulster are set out in the table below:

ITE INSTITUTION	ITE INTAKES (June 2008)
St Mary’s University College	152
Stranmillis University College	145
University of Ulster	145

Initial Teacher Intake

Mr McClarty asked the Minister of Education, in light of the increase in teacher training places at St Mary's and Stranmillis University Colleges, if there are plans to increase teacher training places at the University of Ulster; and if not to detail the reasons why.

(AQW 8798/08)

Ms C Ruane: I have reviewed, in consultation with the Minister for Employment and Learning the overall initial teacher education intake (ITE) numbers for the 2008/09 academic year.

The numbers notified to the University of Ulster in February 2008 remain unchanged and, therefore, have not been reduced.

Academic Selection

Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to her answer to AQW 7869/08, to confirm that under devolution she has no power to unilaterally abolish (i) academic selection; and (ii) the Dickson Plan for education.

(AQW 8811/08)

Ms C Ruane: My powers are defined by the current legislative position, something which I have explained on a number of occasions. The legislation makes the commencement of Article 28(2) of the Education Order 2006 subject to an Assembly vote and it makes the introduction of new admissions criteria regulations contingent on resolution of the future of academic selection. Without this resolution and without these regulations there will simply be an absence of law and an unregulated system.

Chuir mé tograí faoi bhráid an Choiste Fheidhmiúcháin le plé a dhéanamh orthu agus tá mé ag iarraidh a ghabháil chun tosaigh ar bhealach a bheas comhthoilíoch agus bunaithe ar na tograí sin.

I have brought forward proposals to the Executive for discussion and I am seeking a consensual way forward based around those proposals. My proposals do not threaten the Dickson Plan structures, which are entirely compatible with my focus on age 14 as a key decision point, but I do not accept the need for academic selection as a component part of those structures.

Pattern of Attendance

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education how many nursery schools in the North Down constituency applied for additional places for the (i) 2008-09; and (ii) 2009-10, academic years; and to detail (a) the nursery schools that were refused additional places, and (b) the reasons for refusal.

(AQW 8825/08)

Ms C Ruane: Nursery schools and primary schools with nursery units have set numbers of places available and these numbers cannot be increased by applying for additional places. Instead, the Department considers applications for changes in pattern of attendance.

One school, Millisle Primary School, has requested a change in pattern of attendance in their nursery unit from 1 part-time class to either 2 part-time classes or 1 full-time class for 2008/09. The South-Eastern Education & Library Board’s Pre-School Education Advisory Group (PEAG) has considered this request but does not support, as statistics indicate that there is adequate provision in the Millisle and neighbouring wards. This request is currently under consideration with the Department.

Tá an t-athrú ar phatrún tinrimh don bhliain 2009/10, dá dtagraítear thuas, iarrtha ag Bunscoil Millisle fosta. Tá an t-iarratas sin á bhreithniú ag an Roinn agus ag PEAG.

Millisle Primary School has also requested the above change in pattern of attendance for 2009/10. This request is under consideration with both the Department and PEAG.

Surplus School Places

Mr Storey asked the Minister of Education how many surplus school places there are (i) in total; and (ii) as a percentage of the total number of places, in each sector.

(AQW 8826/08)

Ms C Ruane: Meastar go raibh farasbarr de 55,000 áit ann sa bhliain 2006/07.

Seo a leanas céatadán na n-áiteanna measta uile i ngach earnáil:

There were an estimated 55,000 surplus places in 2006/07. The percentage of the total estimated places in each sector was as follows:

Primary

Sector	2006/07 enrolment (A)	Estimated Surplus places (B)	Surplus as a % of total (A) + (B)
Controlled	76,802	17,931	18.9
Maintained	73,661	18,193	19.8
Irish-medium	1,752	378	17.7
Grant Maintained Integrated	4,805	156	3.1
Totals	157,020	36,658	18.9

Post-primary

Sector	2006/07 enrolment	Estimated Surplus places	Surplus as a % of total
Controlled	51,475	7,933	13.4
Maintained	41,582	9,269	18.1
Irish-medium	489	0	0
Grant Maintained Integrated	8,725	213	2.4
Voluntary Grammar	47,494	1,049	2.2
Totals	149,765	18,464	11.00

Temporary Classrooms in SEELB Schools

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education what schools in the South Eastern Education and Library Board area have mobile classrooms; and how many there are in each school.

(AQW 8832/08)

Ms C Ruane: Sa tábla seo a leanas tá liosta de na scoileanna i gceantar Bhord Oideachais agus Leabharlainne an Oirdheiscirt a bhfuil seomraí ranga sealadacha acu:

The following table shows the schools in the South Eastern Education and Library Board area which have temporary classrooms:

School	Number of Temporary Classrooms

Abbey Primary	5
Andrews Memorial Primary	4
Ballykeigle Primary	1
Ballymacash Primary	1
Ballymagee Primary	1
Ballynahinch Primary	1
Ballyvester Primary	2
Ballywalter Primary	1
Brownlee Primary	1
Cairnshill Primary	4
Comber Primary	1
Conlig Primary	1
Crawfordsburn Primary	4
Glasswater Primary School	1
Derriaghy Primary	1
Donaghadee Primary School	2
Downpatrick Primary	2
Dromara Primary	1
Fort Hill Primary	1
Holywood Primary	1
Killinchy Primary	4
Killowen Primary	2
Knockmore Primary	3
Leadhill Primary	2
Londonderry Primary	1
Maghaberry Primary	1
Moira Primary	1
Portavogie Primary	2
Seymour Hill Primary	2
Tonagh Primary	1
Kindle Integrated Primary	3
Victoria Primary - Ballyhalbert	2
Riverdale Primary	1
Convent Of Mercy Primary	1
Christ The King P/S Drumaness	2
St Francis Primary (Drumaroad)	1
Good Shepherd Primary	12
Holy Family Primary	3
St Patrick's P/S Legamaddy	4
Sacred Heart Primary	1
Saint Colmans P.S. (Lisburn)	9
Saint Colmans P.S. (Moira)	2
Saint Colmcilles Primary	1
Saint Comgalls Primary	3
Saint Josephs P.S. (Ballycruttle)	1
Saint Josephs Primary Carnacaville	5
Saint Josephs Primary Carryduff	16
Saint Josephs P.S. (Crossgar)	1
Saint Josephs P.S. (Killough)	1
Saint Josephs P.S. (Lisburn)	1
Saint Josephs P.S. (Strangford)	2
Saint Kierans Primary	13
Saint Macartans Primary Loughlisland	1
Saint Malachys Primary Kilcoo	1
Saint Marks Primary	4
Saint Nicholas P.S. (Ardglass)	1
Saint Patricks P.S. (Downpatrick)	6
Saint Patricks Primary Burrenreagh	1
Hilden Integrated Primary	2
Portaferry Integrated Primary	2
Bangor Central Primary	2
Kircubbin Primary	2
Donaghadee High School	1
Laurelhill Community College	6
Newtownbreda High	5
Ballynahinch High School	3
Saint Colmans High	4
Saint Colmcilles High	5
Saint Columbanus' College	4
Saint Marys High	4
Saint Patricks High School	2
Down Academy	7
Fort Hill College	3
Down High School	21
Wallace High	4
Cedar Integrated PS	6
Oakwood Integrated Primary	1
Millennium Integrated PS	7
Scoil na Fuiseoige	8
St Patrick’s PS Saul	5
St Malachy’s Castlewellan	2
St Patrick’s PS Ballygalget	3
	263

Replacement of Mobile Classrooms

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education what action she is taking to replace mobile classrooms in schools.

(AQW 8833/08)

Ms C Ruane: Déantar athsholáthar seomraí ranga soghluaiste a mheas ar bhonn measúnaithe ar riocht agus oiriúnacht na lóistíne ag gach scoil.

The replacement of mobile classrooms is considered on the basis of an assessment of the condition and suitability of the accommodation at each school.

Newly Qualified Teachers

Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Education when she intends to put in place a scheme which guarantees newly qualified teachers a probationary year in teaching.

(AQW 8852/08)

Ms C Ruane: Faoi láthair níl na hacmhainní ag an Roinn seo le bliain phromhaidh faoi ráthaíocht a thabhairt isteach do mhúinteoirí nua-cháilithe. Meastar go gcosnódh ráthaíocht do mhic léinn a bheadh ag cáiliú tar éis 2008 breis agus £12 milliún sa chéad bhliain agus breis agus £20 milliún sna blianta ina dhiaidh sin.

The Department does not currently have the resources to introduce a guaranteed probationary year for newly qualified teachers. It is estimated that a guarantee to students graduating after 2008 would cost over £12 million in the first year and over £20 million in subsequent years.

Post-Primary School Places

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education how many (i) places have been allocated to; and (ii) applications have been received for, each post-primary school in the South Eastern and Education Library Board area, for the 2008-09 academic year.

(AQW 8862/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tugtar mionsonraithe maidir le (i) líon na n-áiteanna a tugadh do; agus (ii) líon na n-iarratas a fuarthas do gach iarbhunscoil i gceantar Bhord Oideachais agus Leabharlann an Oirdheiscirt don bhliain acadúil 2008/9 sa tábla atá ceangailte leis seo.

The number of (i) places allocated to; and (ii) applications received for, each post-primary school in the South Eastern and Education Library Board area, for the 2008/09 academic year are detailed in the attached table.

School Reference Number	School Name	(i) Approved Year 8 Places 2008/2009 School Year	(ii) Total Applications Received 2008/09 School Year
421-0012	Movilla High School	180	88
421-0029	The High School, Ballynahinch	76	64
421-0031	Donaghadee High School	76	11
421-0045	Nendrum College	80	116
421-0046	Glastry College	110	123
421-0051	Lisnagarvey High School	100	60
421-0063	Saintfield High School	68	112
421-0086	Knockbreda High School	120	124
421-0183	Newtownbreda High School	170	168
421-0194	Dunmurry High School	80	51
421-0201	Laurelhill Community College	175	152
421-0262	Dundonald High School	120	40
421-0296	Bangor Academy and Sixth Form College	242	296
423-0023	St Mary's High School	125	66
423-0067	St Columba's High School, Portaferry	104	51
423-0102	St Colmcille's High School, Crossgar	90	87
423-0107	St Columbanus' College, Bangor	90	128
423-0161	St Colman's High School, Ballynahinch	95	52
423-0165	St Patrick's High School, Lisburn	106	63
423-0211	St Malachy's High School	164	166
423-0223	St Colm's High School	132	130
423-0224	De La Salle Secondary School, Downpatrick	86	59
425-0024	Priory College	85	102
425-0072	Fort Hill College	160	139
425-0272	Blackwater Integrated College	80	50
426-0255	Lagan College	200	476
426-0281	Shimna Integrated College	80	112
426-0295	Strangford Integrated College	80	158
441-0063	Regent House School	210	258
441-0085	Down High School	128	197
441-0097	Glenlola Collegiate School	157	244
442-0015	Bangor Grammar School	125	173
442-0044	Sullivan Upper School	150	187
442-0050	Friends' School	140	214
442-0051	Wallace High School	170	237
442-0086	Assumption Grammar School, Ballynahinch	120	176
442-0088	St Patrick's Grammar School, Downpatrick	96	130
442-0259	Our Lady and St Patrick's College	180	266

School Enrolments

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education what proportion of pupils enrolled in Controlled schools are from (i) a Catholic background; and (ii) a mixed religious or other religious background.

(AQW 8864/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

Controlled and Integrated primary and post primary pupils’ religious background – 2007/08

Religion	Primary¹				Post primary
Religion	Controlled		Integrated²		Controlled		Integrated²
Catholic	4,009	5%	2,912	38%	1,481	3%	4,491	40%
Protestant	58,645	75%	2,882	38%	39,461	82%	4,946	44%
Other³	15,454	20%	1,826	24%	7,054	15%	1,810	16%
Total	78,108	100%	7,620	100%	47,996	100%	11,247	100%

Source: school census

Note:

Primary includes nursery, reception and year 1 – 7 classes.
Integrated schools includes controlled integrated and grant maintained integrated schools.
The ‘Other’ category includes ‘other Christian’, ‘non-Christian’ and ‘no religion/religion unknown’.

Religious Background of Pupils

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education what proportion of pupils enrolled at integrated schools are from (i) a Protestant background; (ii) a Catholic background; and (iii) a mixed religious or other religious background.

(AQW 8865/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

Controlled and Integrated primary and post primary pupils’ religious background – 2007/08

Religion	Primary¹				Post primary
Religion	Controlled		Integrated²		Controlled		Integrated²
Catholic	4,009	5%	2,912	38%	1,481	3%	4,491	40%
Protestant	58,645	75%	2,882	38%	39,461	82%	4,946	44%
Other³	15,454	20%	1,826	24%	7,054	15%	1,810	16%
Total	78,108	100%	7,620	100%	47,996	100%	11,247	100%

Source: school census

Note:

Primary includes nursery, reception and year 1 – 7 classes.
Integrated schools includes controlled integrated and grant maintained integrated schools.
The ‘Other’ category includes ‘other Christian’, ‘non-Christian’ and ‘no religion/religion unknown’.

Information Requested from the South Eastern Education and Library Board

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Education, pursuant to her answer to AQW 8048/08, what further information has been requested from the South Eastern Education and Library Board; and on what date it was requested.

(AQW 8867/08)

Ms C Ruane: Iarradh eolas faoi bhail agus faoi oiriúnacht reatha na bhfoirgneamh ag Bunscoil an Acadaimh ar Bhord Oideachais agus Leabharlainne an Oirdheiscirt ar 16 Meitheamh 2008.

Information on the current condition and suitability of the buildings at Academy Primary School was requested from the South Eastern Education and Library Board on 16 June 2008.

Reinstatment of the South Eastern Education and Library Board

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education when the South Eastern Education and Library Board is due to be re-instated.

(AQW 8882/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá súil agam fógra a dhéanamh ar an ábhar seo gan mhoill.

I hope to make an announcement on this matter in the near future.

Primary Languages Programme

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education what finance, staff training, learning and teaching resources will be provided to support teaching Irish in those primary schools participating in the Primary Languages Programme who have opted for Irish.

(AQW 8904/08)

Ms C Ruane: Regardless of the language chosen by schools, all participating teachers and tutors receive the same high standard of training and support.

To date I have allocated £455, 000 to the primary languages programme, covering the period up to March 2009. This supports the provision of tutors, teaching resources, and training, which has so far included awareness-raising events, at which teaching resources were disseminated in both Spanish and Irish, and three in-service days for teachers. These received positive feedback and further opportunities for professional development will be provided as the programme develops.

De bharr thoradh Bhuiséad 2007, tá maoiniú breise aimsithe agam fosta i gcomhair theagasc na dteangacha i mbunscoileanna suas go dtí Márta 2011, mí an Mhárta san áireamh, agus leithdháilfear na hacmhainní chun tacú le forbairt an chláir sin sa bhliain 2008-09.

As a result of the Budget 2007 outcome, I have also secured additional funding for primary languages up to and including March 2011, and allocations will be made to support an expansion of the programme in 2008-09. When work to develop a wider strategy for the promotion of language learning in schools has been completed, I will, in the context of this strategy, be announcing how I intend to build on the initial stages of the programme in future years.

Primary Languages Programme

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education what finance, staff training, learning and teaching resources will be provided to support teaching Spanish in those primary schools participating in the Primary Languages Programme who have opted for Spanish.

(AQW 8905/08)

Ms C Ruane: Regardless of the language chosen by schools, all participating teachers and tutors receive the same high standard of training and support.

Revised GCSE Irish

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education what progress has been made with commissioning two textbooks for the revised GCSE Irish, which will be taught from September 2009.

(AQW 8910/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas seo a leanas curtha ar fáil ag Príomhfheidhmeannach na Comhairle Churaclaim, Scrúdúcháin agus Mheasúnaithe Thuaisceart Éireann.

The Chief Executive of the Council for the Curriculum, Examinations and Assessment (CCEA) has provided the following information.

CCEA has negotiated with a local publisher with a view to producing a textbook to support the revised GCSE specification for first teaching in September 2009. The result of those discussions is that CCEA’s role will be to provide advice and guidance as appropriate to the publishers and author on the content and structures of the revised specification and to quality assure drafts accordingly. CCEA will endorse the final version of the textbook for distribution, aimed to coincide with first teaching in September 2009, but will have no role in the distribution and costs involved. An author has been appointed by the publishers who have now been briefed on the draft version of the specification. Progress on the writing of the textbook is at an ‘early ideas’ stage and cannot progress in earnest until the specification has been accredited in August 2008.

Education and Skills Authority

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education how much it would cost to establish an Education and Skills Authority.

(AQW 8912/08)

Ms C Ruane: Is é an phríomhaidhm a bheas ag an Údarás um Oideachas agus Scileanna (ESA) torthaí oideachasúla a fheabhsú do gach páiste, agus trí riarachán an oideachais a nuachóiriú, táthar ag súil go scaoilfidh sé £20m in aghaidh na bliana ó chostais riaracháin le hinfheistíocht a dhéanamh i seirbhísí bunúsacha.

The principal focus of the Education and Skills Authority (ESA) will be to improve educational outcomes for all children, and in modernising the administration of education it is anticipated that it will release £20m per annum from administration costs for investment in front line services. Upfront costs of £50million have been provided by the Executive over the Budget 2007 period to facilitate the establishment of the new ESA. Further significant savings will be achievable in the medium and longer term through innovation in service delivery, the rationalisation of the schools’ estate and the introduction of area based planning.

Review of Public Administration

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education what specific responsibilities the advisory body for Maintained schools will have, as proposed in the Review of Public Administration.

(AQW 8913/08)

Ms C Ruane: The Trustees of Catholic schools have submitted a Business Case for funding under the Department’s new Sectoral Support policy. This funding will be used by a new voluntary organisation to be established by the Trustees to support their work post-RPA. The organisation will have no statutory basis; therefore, it will not have any formal responsibilities in law.

The organisation may use the funding allocated to it by the Department to carry out a number of roles under the Sectoral Support policy. These are:

Representation and advocacy;
Development and maintenance of the collective ethos of the sector;
Identifying/nominating foundation governors and encouraging others to put themselves forward as community governors;
Participating in the planning of the schools estate;
Building co-operation and engaging with other sectors
Supporting the role of the ESA in raising educational standards in the sector.

Déanfaidh an Roinn monatóireacht ar chaiteachas an mhaoinithe seo le cinntiú go mbaintear an úsáid chuí as. Fáiltíodh roimh Chásanna Gnó den chineál céanna ó gach earnáil eile agus cuirfear isteach iad.

The Department will monitor the use of this funding to ensure it is used appropriately. Similar Business Cases have been invited from, and will be submitted by, each of the other sectors.

Education and Skills Authority

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education if she will ask for the Education and Skills Authority to become a Centre for Procurement Expertise.

(AQW 8914/08)

Ms C Ruane: Nuair a bhunófar an tÚdarás um Oideachas agus Scileanna, féachfaidh sé le bheith ina Ionad um Shaineolas Soláthair lena chinntiú go mbainfear ardchaighdeáin amach i gcúrsaí soláthair agus go gcoinneofar na caighdeáin sin ag an leibhéal chuí, faoi réir na Rialachán um Chonarthaí Poiblí 2006.

The Education and Skills Authority, when established, will seek to become a Centre for Procurement Expertise to ensure high standards in procurement are achieved and maintained, in line with the Public Contracts Regulations 2006.

Mixed Education

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education for her assessment of the desire for mixed education, based on the Northern Ireland Life and Times Surveys.

(AQW 8915/08)

Ms C Ruane:

Sample surveys, such as the Life and Times Survey (NILT Survey), can be useful in the absence of other forms of evidence on which to base considerations.

However, my Department bases its assessment of the desire for particular forms of education upon the expression of parental choice for individual children.

Mar Aire Oideachais tá sé de dhualgas orm a chinntiú go dtugtar an rogha oideachais dá bpáistí nuair is féidir é.

As Minister of Education it is my duty to ensure that parents are provided with the choice of education for their children wherever possible.

Mixed Education

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education for her assessment of the public's view on the performance of her Department in the delivery of mixed education, based upon the Northern Ireland Life and Times Surveys.

(AQW 8917/08)

Ms C Ruane: Sample surveys, such as the Life and Times Survey (NILT Survey), can be useful in the absence of other forms of evidence on which to base considerations. However, my Department delivers particular forms of education based on the expression of parental choice for individual children.

Maidir le soláthar oibríonn mo Roinn leis an earnáil chomhtháite ar gach mholadh ar leith a bhaineann le soláthar nua. Ón bhliain 1997, faomhadh 12 scoil nua chun stádais comhtháite faoi chothabháil stáit agus faomhadh 13 scoil chun aistriú go stádas comhtháite rialaithe.

In terms of delivery my Department works with the integrated sector on each individual proposal for new provision. Since 1997, 12 new schools have been approved for grant maintained integrated status, and 13 existing schools have received approval to transform to controlled integrated status.

Surplus School Places

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education what steps are being taken to ensure that there is adequate provision of school places for children from mixed religious or other religious backgrounds.

(AQW 8918/08)

Ms C Ruane: There is a currently an overall surplus of places available due to a declining pupil population, and this surplus applies to all children regardless of religious background, due to the fact that places cannot be allocated on the basis of religious background.

San earnáil imeasctha tá eisceacht leis seo, áit a mbíonn cead ag scoileanna critéir iontrála a oibriú ar bhealach a bhaineann amach iontógáil chothromaithe a léiríonn an dá phríomh-thraidisiún, agus iad siúd a thagann ó thradisiúin nach Protastúnaigh nó Caitlicigh iad.

The exception to this is within the integrated sector where schools are permitted to operate admissions criteria in such a way as to achieve a balanced intake which is representative of the two main traditions, and those from traditions other than Protestant or Catholic. The figures here indicate adequate levels of provision. For instance, in the post-primary integrated sector for 2008/09 there were 2010 places available at the outset of the transfer process and there were 1954 first preference applications. As the transfer process ran its course some first preference applicants were displaced by second or lower preference applicants who were unsuccessful in gaining admission to their first preference school (a natural part of the open enrolment process) resulting in a final position whereby 1510 (77%) of these 1954 first preference applications were successful.

Applications to Post-Primary Integrated Schools

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education to detail the proportion of first preference applications to post-primary integrated schools that did not result in admissions for the 2008-09 academic year to these schools.

(AQW 8920/08)

Ms C Ruane: Fuair iar-bhunscoileanna imeasctha 1954 iarratas príomhrogha san iomlán don bhliain acadúil 2008-09; ní bhfuair 444 acu sin (22.72%) isteach sna scoileanna sin.

A total of 1954 first-preference applications were received by integrated post-primary schools for the 2008-09 academic year, 444 of which (22.72%), did not gain admission to these schools.

Pupils Currently Enrolled in Catholic Maintained Schools

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Education to detail the proportion of pupils currently enrolled in Catholic Maintained schools who are from (i) a Protestant background; and (ii) a mixed/other religious background.

(AQW 8921/08)

Ms C Ruane: Tá an t-eolas a iarradh mionsonraithe sa tábla faoi iamh.

The information requested is detailed in the attached table.

Religious background of pupils attending Catholic Maintained primary and post-primary schools – 2007/08

Religion	Primary¹		Post-primary
Catholic	75,110	98%	40,272	99%
Protestant	486	1%	240	<1%
Other²	884	1%	251	<1%
Total	76,480	100%	40,763	100%

Source: school census

Note:

Primary includes nursery, reception and year 1 – 7 classes.
The ‘Other’ category includes ‘other Christian’, ‘non-Christian’ and ‘no religion/religion unknown’.

Transformation Fund

Mr Gallagher asked the Minister of Education for an update on the Department's plans for the Transformation Fund.

(AQW 8923/08)

Ms C Ruane: A paper on a proposed pilot Transformation Fund has been developed by the Early Years Organisation and submitted to OFMDFM which was then forwarded to my officials.

Eisíodh freagra ar 10 Meitheamh 2008 a léirigh na réimsí ina mbeadh gá le tuilleadh oibre le freastal ar na riachtanais bhreithmheasa sula mbeifí in ann breithniú a dhéanamh ar scéim phíolótach a cheadú.

A response was issued on 10^th June 2008 highlighting the areas in which further work would be required in order to meet appraisal requirements before approval for a pilot could be considered.

Recruitment on Teachers

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education how many teachers on the substitute teachers' roll have not yet been in full time permanent employment in teaching.

(AQW 8938/08)

Ms C Ruane: The recruitment of teachers is the responsibility of teachers’ employers. The register contains the names of qualified teachers who are registered with the General Teaching Council and who indicate they are available for employment as teachers in grant-aided schools. It includes not only those newly qualified but also those who have retired or who have previously been employed in the profession. In terms of advice, the Department has issued guidance to employers advising them that preference should be given to newly qualified teachers and experienced non-retired teachers seeking employment. Schools have also been advised that they should recruit to vacancies on a permanent rather than a temporary basis unless the vacancy is clearly of a temporary nature. Moreover, the capping of the levels of the central reimbursement of the costs of substitute cover works in favour of and provides an incentive for schools to employ newly qualified teachers.

Déanann an Roinn monatóireacht agus athbhreithniú ar bhonn leanúnach ar na fachtóirí a bhaineann le soláthar agus éileamh sa ghairm bheatha.

The Department continues to monitor and review the supply and demand factors in the profession.

Teachers on the Substitute Teachers' Roll

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education what action she is taking to provide permanent employment in teaching for teachers on the substitute teachers' roll who have not yet been in full time employment in teaching.

(AQW 8939/08)

Déanann an Roinn monatóireacht agus athbhreithniú ar bhonn leanúnach ar na fachtóirí a bhaineann le soláthar agus éileamh sa ghairm bheatha.

The Department continues to monitor and review the supply and demand factors in the profession.

Teachers on the Substitute Teachers' Roll

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education what advice in relation to employment her Department gives to teachers on the substitute teachers' roll who have not yet been in full time permanent employment in teaching.

(AQW 8940/08)

Ms C Ruane: The recruitment of teachers is the responsibility of teachers’ employers. However, the Department has issued guidance to employers advising them that preference should be given to the appointment of newly qualified teachers and experienced non-retired teachers when they are filling vacancies. Schools have also been advised that they should recruit to vacancies on a permanent rather than a temporary basis unless the vacancy is clearly of a temporary nature. Furthermore, the capping of the levels of the central reimbursement of the costs of substitute cover also provides an incentive to employ newly qualified teachers.

Thug Ciorclán na Roinne 2006/07, a eisíodh i Márta 2006, le fios do scoileanna nár chóir múinteoirí a fhostú mar mhúinteoirí ionaid ó 1 Meán Fómhair 2006 mura bhfuil siad cláraithe ar chlár na múinteoirí ionaid.

The Department’s Circular 2006/07, which issued in March 2006, advised schools that only teachers registered on the substitute teacher register should be employed as substitute teachers from 1 September 2006. It is significant to note that the substitute teacher register includes not only young teachers but teachers of all ages who wish to be employed on a substitute teacher basis, together with teachers who no longer wish to be full-time members of the teaching profession.

Primary Languages Programme

Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Education how many teachers on the substitute teachers' roll, who have not yet been in full time employment in teaching, will be employed in the primary languages programme.

(AQW 8941/08)

Ms C Ruane: De réir mo chuid freagraí ar AQW8042/08 agus AQW8254/08, caithfidh gach oide atá fostaithe sa Chlár do Theangacha Bunscoile critéir chlár na bunscoile a bheith acu, is é sin cumas d’ardchaighdeán bheith acu i labhairt na Gaeilge nó na Spáinnise.

Further to my responses to AQW 8042/08 and AQW 8254/08, any tutors employed in the Primary Languages Programme must meet the primary programme criteria of having excellent oral language competence in Irish or Spanish. The tutor positions are subject to public advertisement procedures, and any person meeting the criteria is welcome to apply for positions, including unemployed newly-qualified teachers and teachers on the Substitute Teacher Register; it is a matter for the employing authority to determine who is employed. I am pleased that the programme may offer teachers who have not been in full-time employment in teaching the opportunity to gain experience of working in schools.

Review of Public Administration

Mr Weir asked the Minister of Education what legislative restrictions there are preventing a continuing role for transferor representatives on the boards of governors of schools after the Review of Public Administration reforms have been implemented.

(AQW 8967/08)

Ms C Ruane: Faoi na tograí reatha le haghaidh an Athbhreithnithe ar Riarachán Poiblí, thiocfadh le hionadaithe Aistreora iarratas a dhéanamh le bheith ceaptha mar ghobharnóirí scoile, faoi shocruithe arna n-oibriú ag an Údarás um Oideachas agus Scileanna.

Under the current proposals for the Review of Public Administration, Transferor representatives could apply to be appointed as school governors, under arrangements operated by the Education and Skills Authority. However, it would not be possible to legislate to permit the Transferors to nominate governors as of right. Such provisions would constitute discrimination on the grounds of religious belief and, as such, would be contrary to section 6 of the NI Act 1998.

Employment and Learning

European Social Funding

Ms S Ramsey asked the Minister for Employment and Learning what mechanisms are in place for mainstream funding of supported employment services currently in receipt of European Social Funding or short-term funding.

(AQW 8425/08)

The Minister for Employment and Learning (Sir Reg Empey):

The Disablement Advisory Service (DAS), on behalf of the Department, provides public match funding to a number of organisations that receive ESF funding to deliver training, supported employment and other services to people with disabilities. DAS also provides public match funding to an EQUAL research project – Supported Employment for All (the SEA Project). The SEA Project has membership from DHSS & PS, DSD and DEL as there are elements relating to all three departments that are required for the delivery of supported employment. DEL does not provide mainstream funding for the delivery of supported employment.

Renewing Communities Project

Mr Ross asked the Minister for Employment and Learning for his assessment of the Renewing Communities project.

(AQW 8695/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The Renewing Communities Initiative, which was developed to tackle disadvantage across communities, was led by the Department for Social Development.

My Department had responsibility for 8 of the Initiative’s 62 Actions. All 8 Actions have had a positive impact on disadvantaged communities, offering over 24,000 educational opportunities.

An evaluation, to be carried out later this year, will provide more detailed information on its wider impact.

Renewing Communities Project

Mr Ross asked the Minister for Employment and Learning how much money has been given to the Renewing Communities Scheme in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 8696/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The Renewing Communities Initiative, which was developed to tackle disadvantage across communities, was a two year programme launched in April 2006 and led by the Department for Social Development. My Department had responsibility for 8 of the initiative’s 62 published Actions.

To date, since its launch, £16.744m has been expended on the Initiative, as follows:

Renewing Communities Action	Year 1	Year 2	Expended
1.15 Step Up	£0.267m	£0.267m	£0.534m
1.16 Fast Track	£0.192m	£0.077m	£0.269m
1.17 Workforce & Economic Development Centre	£0.475m	£0.389m	£0.864m
1.18 WEDC Outreach Programme N&W Belfast	£0.140m	£0.155m	£0.295m
1.19 WEDC Outreach Programme E&S Belfast	£0.140m	£0.156m	£0.296m
1.20 Pre-Apprentice and Pre-Vocational Enhancement Training Programmes	£7.100m	£7.100m	£14.200m
1.22 Regeneration Through Skills	£0.132m	£0.140m	£0.272m
3.5 Community Service by FE and HE Students	£0.014m	£0.000m	£0.014m
Total	£8.460m	£8.284m	£16.744m

Renewing Communities Project

Mr Ross asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to detail the areas in which the Renewing Communities Scheme is operating.

(AQW 8697/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The Renewing Communities Initiative, which was developed to tackle disadvantage across communities, was a two year programme launched in April 2006 and led by the Department for Social Development.

My Department had responsibility for 8 of the initiative’s 62 published Actions.

The Table below identifies these Actions and the areas in which they took place:

Renewing Communities (DEL) Actions	Areas Delivered
1.15 Step Up	Belfast
1.16 Fast Track	Belfast
1.17 Workforce & Economic Development Centre	North and West Belfast
1.18 WEDC Outreach Programme N&W Belfast	North and West Belfast
1.19 WEDC Outreach Programme E&S Belfast	East and South Belfast
1.20 Pre-Apprentice and Pre-Vocational Enhancement Training Programmes	All areas of Northern Ireland
1.22 Regeneration Through Skills	Belfast
3.5 Community Service by HE and FE Students	North Belfast, Shankill

Departmental Underspend

Mr Ross asked the Minister for Employment and Learning what impact the £35.8 million budget underspend by his Department will have on the Renewing Communities Scheme.

(AQW 8705/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The Renewing Communities Initiative, which was developed to tackle disadvantage across communities, was led by the Department for Social Development.

My Department had responsibility for 8 of the Initiative’s 62 Actions. Through my Department’s Renewing Communities Actions, over 24,000 participants benefited from a range of educational and training opportunities.

Regrettably, demand for some of the Actions, which sought to engage particular client groups, did not fulfil expectations, and this resulted in an under-spend of £1.4m of the Department’s Renewing Communities budget. Overall, there was no adverse impact in terms of the programme’s capacity to include all those in the chosen client groups, who wished to participate.

Impact of Sectarian Divisions on Workforce Mobility

Dr Farry asked the Minister for Employment and Learning for his assessment of the impact of sectarian divisions and segregation on labour market mobility.

(AQW 8744/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The available data suggest that there is a possible negative impact on labour mobility of sectarian divisions and segregation. My Department continues to assist individuals to access jobs wherever they are located and to assist employers to fill job vacancies. Research commissioned by the Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister and published in 2005 shows that religion has declined substantially as an explanatory factor for labour market outcomes over the previous decade.

Departmental Funding in East Antrim

Mr Ross asked the Minister for Employment and Learning what projects his Department has funded in the East Antrim constituency in the last 12 months.

(AQW 8748/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

In addition to ongoing funding provided to the educational and training organisations based in the East Antrim constituency, such as the University of Ulster and the Northern Regional College, the Department for Employment and Learning has funded five projects in the last 12 months.

Four projects were funded under the EU Building Sustainable Prosperity Programme at the Jordanstown Campus of the University of Ulster. These included a Post-graduate Diploma/MSc course in Engineering, a Post-graduate Diploma/MSc course in Web Information Systems, and projects on ‘Women in Enterprise’ and ‘Pathways to Education and Employment for Women’.

Also, a project from Carrickfergus Women’s Forum was funded under the PEACE II Programme.

Cost of Teacher Training

Mr McClarty asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to give the costs of training teachers at (i) St. Mary's University College; (ii) Stranmillis University College; and (iii) the University of Ulster.

(AQW 8793/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The cost of Initial Teacher Education (ITE) is met in the main through two sources. The Northern Ireland ITE providers receive grant funding from my Department. In addition to this, the providers also retain the majority of the tuition fee income from students.

The per-student units of grant for ITE for academic year 2008/09 are as follows;

St Mary’s

University College

(note 1 & 2)

£

Stranmillis

University College

(note 1 & 2)

£

University of Ulster

£

Academic year 2008/09- Grant per ITE Student

6,648

£4,974

Source: Department for Employment and Learning

Note 1. Grant allocations for the 2008/09 academic year are not yet finalised and so the amounts shown are provisional. The amounts are derived from the new university college funding methodology which replaces the previous block grant funding mechanism.

Note 2 Base unit of grant £4,732. Premiums are applied to the base unit of grant plus non – retained fee income of £1,255 i.e. £5,987. Small Premium 10% Specialist Premium 20%. Historical Buildings Premium 2%.

As you will be aware, my officials have developed a new unit based funding methodology for the university colleges to replace the old block grant arrangement which was not fit for purpose. The new methodology, which will be implemented for academic year 2008/09 funding allocations, is based on best practice approaches developed by the Training and Development Agency for Schools (TDA), the national body which funds teacher education in England, and also the Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE). The units of funding for the university colleges include a base per-student unit of grant which is then augmented by premiums which recognise their small and specialist nature and the expected higher level of fixed costs resulting from this. A further premium in recognition of the historical nature of the university colleges’ estates has also been applied. These premiums account for 32% of the amount included above.

The universities are funded in the main through the use of a formula developed by HEFCE. When responsibility for ITE transferred from HEFCE to the TDA, the ITE element of the Northern Ireland universities funding was separated out. Since then, the funding has been uplifted annually and pro-rated to reflect changes in student numbers. As large institutions with a diverse range of provision, the universities do not attract small or specialist premiums.

The ITE providers are free to allocate these resources as they see fit in order to deliver the outcomes expected of them, and in accordance with a Financial Memorandum which sets out the conditions which apply to the funding. The cost of teacher training at each provider therefore reflects the management decisions taken by each Governing Body as well as the individual characteristics of the institution. Amongst a range of accountability information, my department receives and reviews the providers’ annual financial statements.

On an annual basis, higher education institutions also provide financial information to the Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA). This is used to generate unit expenditure statistics which are then published. Although these statistics are often referred to when the cost of ITE is discussed, it is important to note that HESA themselves stress that comparisons based solely on these unit expenditure statistics are liable to be seriously misleading.

Further and Higher Education in Coleraine

Mr Dallat asked the Minister for Employment and Learning what plans he has for the development of a new campus for Further and Higher Education to serve the Coleraine area.

(AQW 8851/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The former Causeway Institute submitted a business case to the Department, in March 2004, which confirmed serious accommodation deficiencies in its campuses, at Coleraine and Ballymoney. The business case proposed a single new build solution in Coleraine, to replace both campuses. Funding for the project was not available at that time. However, the subsequent merger of Causeway Institute with East Antrim, and North East Institutes required the newly appointed Northern Regional College’s Senior Management Team and Governing Body to review the proposals. That review, across all campuses, is continuing and is expected to be submitted for the Department’s consideration in the near future.

Concessionary Fees at Further Education Colleges

Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to detail the categories of individuals who qualify for concessionary fees at further education colleges, for courses commencing in the next academic year.

(AQW 8925/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

All further education colleges in Northern Ireland have agreed that, as from the start of the 2008/09 academic year, they will adopt a consistent approach to the implementation of concessionary fees, and they are already using agreed criteria for the September 2008 intake to their courses.

Therefore, students enrolling on courses at a further education college in the next academic year who are in receipt of Income Support, Jobseekers Allowance (Income based), Guaranteed Pension Credit and Rates Relief, and learners holding an income based NHS Exemption Certificate, will be entitled to concessionary fees.

Funding for Essential Skills

Mrs Long asked the Minister for Employment and Learning how many places will be funded by his Department for Essential Skills at foundation level and level one for the 2008-2009 academic year, and how this compares with provision for 2006-2007 and 2007-2008.

(AQW 8949/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

The number of Essential Skills enrolments at Entry Levels 1, 2 and 3 and at Level 1 funded by my Department in 2006/07 and 2007/08 are as follows:

2006/07: 15,343

2007/08: 14,444

Source: Essential Skills enrolment return.

Note: Figures are correct as at 29^th February 2008, but are provisional and, therefore, subject to change.

Information for 2008/09 is not available in the format requested, because Further Education Colleges’ enrolment targets for Essential Skills are not broken down by the different Levels of Essential Skills. Also, Essential Skills provision is available within other DEL programmes, such as Training for Success, Jobskills and New Deal, but is demand led according to the identified needs of participants on these programmes. Therefore, information on places and enrolments by different levels is only available retrospectively.

However, the Department has increased the budget for Essential Skills provision in FE colleges from £5m in 2007/08 to £6.6m in 2008/09, to help to meet challenging PSA targets in this area. This should lead to increased Essential Skills enrolments in 2008/09.

Funding for Essential Skills

Mrs Long asked the Minister for Employment and Learning to outline the plan for delivery of Essential Skills, with particular regard to foundation level and level one, in the context of a more difficult funding climate for community-based training organisations.

(AQW 8950/08)

Sir Reg Empey:

My Department has set a challenging PSA target in respect of Essential Skills. This target is that, by March 2011, 42,000 adult learners will have achieved a recognised qualification in Essential Skills, including 4,000 in respect of ICT.

In future, Further Education Colleges will be the main providers of Essential skills for adults, and in 2008/09 college budgets in respect of Essential Skills have been increased to £6.6m, from £5m in 2007/08. Colleges’ extensive network of outreach centres will ensure that Essential Skills provision is fully accessible to all. The Learner Access and Engagement pilot programme will help colleges to increase uptake on their Essential Skills provision, particularly at Entry Level and Level 1.

In addition, Training Organisations, including FE colleges, will continue to provide Essential Skills, where appropriate, as part of their delivery of DEL programmes such as Training for Success, Jobskills and New Deal.

Enterprise, Trade and Investment

Northern Ireland Tourist Board

Mr Storey asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment what work her Department has done with its counterparts in (i) Great Britain; and (ii) the Isle of Man; with a view to attracting more tourists.

(AQW 8488/08)

The Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment (Mrs A Foster): Northern Ireland benefits from considerable ongoing contact with Great Britain and the Isle of Man on a range of tourism issues. Examples include:

The Northern Ireland Tourist Board’s (NITB) strong working relationship with VisitBritain. The benefits to Northern Ireland of this link include access to valuable tourism market intelligence; presence on the VisitBritain website (www.visitbritain.com), access to PR platforms such as inclusion in press releases and media updates; and the distribution of Northern Ireland guides through the Britain and London Visitor Centre and overseas offices;

NITB’s representation on a range of UK National Tourist Board Groups which deal with issues of mutual interest such as marketing, planning and performance, PR and quality standards;

Tourism Ireland Ltd’s (TIL) engagement in co-operative marketing with VisitBritain and other GB tourism bodies regarding long-haul markets, for example Canada or Australia, where a visit to Northern Ireland is planned as part of a longer trip to Great Britain or to Europe;

TIL’s work with VisitBritain on a Northern Ireland specific eCampaign to target those actively planning a vacation to the UK in 2008. Northern Ireland will feature in three Visit Britain eZines (each sent to approximately 150,000 opt-in contacts);

TIL’s co-operation in 2007 with the Isle of Man’s Manx 2 radio station on a campaign promoting Belfast in the Isle of Man. Manx 2 estimated a 24 % growth in traffic from the Isle of Man to Northern Ireland in 2007 and considered the campaign a successful contributor to this growth; and

NITB’s and TIL’s work with VisitBritain to develop plans to help ensure that Northern Ireland maximises the tourism opportunities presented by the 2012 Olympic Games.

In addition, DETI has worked with tourism counterparts in the other administrations within the British Isles under the auspices of the Tourism Sub Group of the British Irish Council. This Group considered a range of areas of mutual interest such as tourism statistics, sustainable tourism, and emerging tourism markets.

Applications for Alternative Eco-Friendly Energy in the Strangford Constituency

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how many applications there have been for alternative eco-friendly energy for the Strangford constituency.

(AQW 8609/08)

Mrs A Foster: The most recent support scheme for alternative eco-friendly energy was Reconnect which closed to applications on 31 March 2008. There were 769 applications from private householders in the Strangford constituency.

Annual Twelfth Celebrations

Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment to quantify the value to the economy of the annual Twelfth celebrations.

(AQW 8652/08)

Mrs A Foster: No assessment has been made of the value to the economy of the Twelfth of July celebrations. However, the celebrations are unique to Northern Ireland and have the potential to be of interest to visitors from across the globe who want to see and learn more about local traditions.

The Northern Ireland Tourist Board and Tourism Ireland Ltd have been in contact with the Loyal Orders to explore the extent to which the celebrations might feature as part of Northern Ireland's tourism product.

Annual Twelfth Celebrations

Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how the Northern Ireland Tourist Board and Tourism Ireland intend to market the annual Twelfth celebrations as a visitor attraction.

(AQW 8653/08)

Mrs A Foster: Over the last three years, the Northern Ireland Tourist Board (NITB) and Tourism Ireland Ltd (TIL) have established good working relationships with the Grand Orange Lodge and have attended Orange Order parades.

NITB has been working with the Orange Order to help them broaden the appeal of this year’s Twelfth of July demonstrations. NITB has identified four ‘flagship’ parades, Belfast, Tandragee, Dromara and Coleraine, as having the most potential to appeal to visitors.

NITB supports the development of world class standards of service and has organised Welcome Host Training for representatives from these parades to help maximise their tourism potential. The parades will also feature on NITB’s consumer website discovernorthernireland.com.

Tourism Ireland has discussed the portrayal of the Twelfth of July demonstrations with the Orange Order, Orangefest and other relevant parties. In addition, TIL recently presented to representatives of ten District Lodges regarding this year’s demonstrations.

Varney 2 Report

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment which recommendations within the Varney 2 Report have been prioritised for action.

(AQW 8660/08)

Mrs A Foster: The information requested is not available at present.

I will write to the Member when the information is available, and ensure that a copy of the letter is placed in the Assembly Library.

Invest NI

Dr Farry asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment what plans he has to review the workings and role of Invest NI.

(AQW 8710/08)

Mrs A Foster: The information requested is not available at present.

I will write to the Member when the information is available, and ensure that a copy of the letter is placed in the Assembly Library.

Local Postal Services

Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by her Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.

(AQW 8737/08)

Mrs A Foster: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ Report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of Postal Services and the Post Office network.

Junior Minister Donaldson and Junior Minister Kelly wrote to Executive Ministers on 21 April 2008 asking them to consider whether any further public services could be delivered through post offices.

I can confirm that there are no DETI services currently provided, or any that could potentially be delivered through the Post Office network in Northern Ireland.

Invest NI Office Space

Ms Ní Chuilín asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment (i) what the is length of each contract/lease for InvestNI office space in the North Belfast constituency; (ii) for how long have each of these contracts/leases been in place; and (iii) how much has been paid to date on the contracts/leases for vacant office space.

(AQW 8753/08)

Mrs A Foster: Invest NI does not lease any office space in the North Belfast parliamentary constituency.

In the interests of clarity, information on all the property Invest NI pays or makes contribution to rental on can be found in AQW 7988-08.

Invest NI Office Space

Ms Ní Chuilín asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment (i) what office space Invest NI currently leases in North Belfast constituency; and (ii) which of these locations is currently occupied by InvestNI client companies.

(AQW 8755/08)

Mrs A Foster: Invest NI does not lease any office space in the North Belfast parliamentary constituency.

In the interests of clarity, information on all the property Invest NI pays or makes contribution to rental on can be found in AQW 7988-08.

Energy From Renewable Sources

Mr B Wilson asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment, in the light of her Department’s commitment to increase the amount of energy obtained from renewable sources, would she examine the possibility of generating electricity through a pump storage generation project, similar to that proposed in Camlough in the early 1970s.

(AQW 8790/08)

Mrs A Foster: Pump storage facilities can be a cost effective, although not necessarily entirely renewable, means of generating electricity.

I am aware that the concept of a pump storage proposal at Camlough has recently been investigated again and that it could be developed if shown to be commercially feasible. However, it is important to note that the output of such a project will only be truly renewable if the electricity used to pump the water in the first instance is generated from renewable sources.

While Government encourages the development of renewable energy in Northern Ireland through the Northern Ireland Renewables Obligation (NIRO), it is left to private sector developers to make the investment based on the commercial feasibility of individual projects. This ensures that renewable electricity is produced in a cost-effective way that provides best value for consumers.

Cross Border Illegal Trade

Mr Savage asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment if cross border illegal trade and smuggling will be addressed in the next meeting of the North South Ministerial Council, given the potential of such activities to undercut the work that has been achieved with InterTrade Ireland.

(AQW 8794/08)

Mrs A Foster: The issue of cross border illegal trade and smuggling does not fall within the remit of InterTradeIreland nor of the North South Ministerial Council and will not, therefore, form part of the business of any North South Ministerial Council meeting.

Nevertheless I wholly share concerns at the potential of such activity to undermine the work of InterTradeIreland and indeed, all legitimate efforts to promote economic and business co-operation between the two jurisdictions.

The Organised Crime Task Force (OCTF) is a forum where partner agencies such as the Police Service of Northern Ireland and HM Customs & Excise meet to agree priorities and share information in relation to tackling organised crime in Northern Ireland.

I understand that recently published statistics by the OCTF provide strong evidence that this approach is having a significant impact in the fight against illegal trade and smuggling.

Clearly this is something that I welcome.

Inward Investors in Limavady

Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how many potential inward investors have visited the Limavady area since Seagate and HUCO announced their plans to close their production plants.

(AQW 8850/08)

Mrs A Foster: Three potential investors have visited the North West Travel to Work Area between 29^th October 2007 and 4^th July 2008.

The North West Travel to Work Area is defined as the areas in the North West Action Plan and comprises Derry, Strabane, Limavady, Coleraine and Magherafelt District Council Areas.

Economic Research Agenda

Ms J McCann asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment in light of the launch of the Economic Research Agenda, if she will give a commitment to include an audit of the Social Economy Sector and its contribution to the local economy.

(AQW 8856/08)

Mrs A Foster: DETI’s Economic Research Agenda, published on 27^th June 2008, made an open call for research proposals in DETI’s priority areas of: productivity growth, increasing employment and tourism. The Agenda sets out a number of themes to guide the research community in preparing proposals. One such theme is to develop our understanding of the Northern Ireland economy, including areas such as the Social Economy sector. The Department will assess all research proposals received before the closing date of 15^th August 2008, with a view to identifying projects that can best inform policy development.

I recognise the importance of the Social Economy sector in Northern Ireland, and DETI has already undertaken work to better understand the contribution of the sector to the local economy. In September 2006, DETI undertook a ‘first steps’ survey which provided baseline data for nearly 400 enterprises with a total of 6,700 paid employees, 5,000 volunteers and turnover of just over £355million. The survey database has been transferred to the Social Economy Network (SEN) for future development. DETI will continue to work with SEN and other stakeholders to develop the importance of the social economy sector to the NI economy.

Farm Accidents

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how many people have been killed and injured in accidents on farms in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 8887/08)

Mrs A Foster: As the regulations regarding the statutory reporting of non fatal work related injuries do not apply to self employed persons, such as farmers, HSENI has very incomplete figures for the numbers injured on farms. On the other hand all fatal farm incidents are brought to HSENI’s attention by the PSNI who respond to these on behalf of the Coroner.

23 people have been killed as a result of work related incidents on farms since April 2005. The breakdown is as follows:-

Year	Number of Fatalities
2007-08	7
2006-07	6
2005-06	10

Deaths Involving Cattle

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how many people have been killed by bulls or cows on farms in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 8888/08)

Mrs A Foster: 9 people have been killed as a result of incidents involving bulls or cows on farms since April 2005. The break down is as follows;

Year	Fatalities
2007-08	4
2006-07	2
2005-06	3

Injuries Involving Cattle

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how many people have been injured by bulls or cows on farms in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 8889/08)

Mrs A Foster: Since the regulations governing the reporting of work related injuries do not apply to self employed persons such as farmers, HSENI has a very incomplete picture of the true scale of such incidents.

HSENI’s limited records show that 3 people were injured as a result of incidents involving bulls or cows during the past 3 years.

Year	Number of injuries
2007-08	1
2006-07	2
2005-06	0

Contract Awarded to the Citizen's Advice Bureau

Mr Craig asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment for his assessment of the benefits of the new contract awarded to the Citizen's Advice Bureau.

(AQW 8946/08)

Mrs A Foster: The new contract awarded to Citizens Advice in April 2008 secures funding for the continuation of a free face to face debt advice across Northern Ireland for the period 2008-2011. This longer term contract provides ongoing face to face support to clients who typically require such assistance in order to regain control of their finances. The new contract enables the advisers to develop their skills through training and thus enhance the quality of the debt advice service. I made an announcement on 3 July 2008 of additional funding of £600,000 per annum for 2009/10 and 2010/11 for debt advice which will significantly enhance the provision already in place through the new contract.

Wind Farms

Mr Buchanan asked the Minister of Enterprise, Trade and Investment how many wind farms are in operation, broken down by district council area.

(AQW 8960/08)

Mrs A Foster: There are currently 16 wind farms in operation in Northern Ireland. This covers all developments of one or more turbines with a total capacity of at least one megawatt.

An analysis of these wind farms by District Council is shown in the table below.

DISTRICT COUNCIL

WINDFARMS (No.)

Ballymena

2

Ballymoney

2

Dungannon

1

Fermanagh

3

Limavady

3

Omagh

2

Strabane

3

NORTHERN IRELAND

16

Environment

Waiting Times for MOT

Mr Bresland asked the Minister of the Environment what is the average waiting time for an MOT test in each of the test centres.

(AQW 7927/08)

The Minister of the Environment (Mr S Wilson): Detail of the weekly and year to date average waiting time for a vehicle test in the 15 test centres is included in the following table.

Average waiting time for a vehicle test in days
	Weekly	Year to Date
Test Centre	01 June to 07 June 2008	01 April to 07 June 2008
Armagh	16	14
Ballymena	25	19
Belfast	17	18
Coleraine	19	18
Cookstown	26	23
Craigavon	16	14
Downpatrick	24	16
Enniskillen	16	17
Larne	20	16
Lisburn	18	17
Londonderry	29	23
Mallusk	14	16
Newry	24	21
Newtownards	24	20
Omagh	17	15

Expired MOTs

Mr Bresland asked the Minister of the Environment how many vehicles' MOT certificate had expired by 1 June 2008.

(AQW 7928/08)

Mr S Wilson: The Agency’s data shows that there are currently 8,388 vehicles (private cars and motorcycles) with an MOT certificate that had expired by 1 June 2008 and who currently have a vehicle test appointment. Many of these customers may not have applied for the vehicle test until after the expiry date of the previous certificate.

Vehicle Tests

Mr Bresland asked the Minister of the Environment how many vehicle (i) tests; and (ii) re-tests, were carried out at each MOT test centre, in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 7930/08)

Mr S Wilson: Detail of the number of vehicle test full tests and re-tests carried out in each of 15 test centres in the years 2005/06, 2006/07 and 2007/08 is included in the following table.

	2005/06		2006/07		2007/08
Centres	Full Tests	Re-tests	Full Tests	Re-tests	Full Tests	Re-tests
Armagh	20322	5911	22571	6451	24589	6759
Ballymena	41114	8981	48594	10928	52888	11793
Belfast	59859	15730	66581	15158	64401	14719
Coleraine	43189	10140	45079	9213	47612	9550
Cookstown	38834	12430	40991	12162	40538	11312
Craigavon	28763	8143	33242	8621	38103	9658
Downpatrick	26257	5644	27568	5727	31381	6014
Enniskillen	27530	6348	29661	6453	32299	7199
Larne	25163	4324	27368	4322	29892	4835
Lisburn	33235	8732	36974	7124	40344	7256
Londonderry	35757	9370	42517	10383	45890	10838
Mallusk	47933	13247	53562	12934	47930	11230
Newry	41830	10316	46824	9448	48386	9343
Newtownards	62464	15457	73520	17495	72670	18033
Omagh	24757	7242	26161	6096	27843	6630
Totals	557007	142015	621213	142515	644766	145169

Unauthorised Developments

Mr Simpson asked the Minister of the Environment how many files relating to possible unauthorised developments his Department has (i) opened; and (ii) concluded, in each of the last three years; and the total number of possible cases still outstanding.

(AQW 8341/08)

Mr S Wilson: The number of files relating to possible unauthorised developments that have been opened and concluded (closed) in each of the last 3 years is as follows:

Year	Number of cases opened	Number of cases concluded (closed)
2005	4330	3199
2006	4378	3838
2007	3553	3068
TOTAL	12261	10105

The number of summons and prosecutions are indicated in the table below:

Year	Summons	Prosecutions
2005	20	12
2006	28	33
2007	15	13
TOTAL	63	58

I must stress that a relatively small number of cases require the Department to take formal enforcement action. Many cases are successfully resolved without the need for full action or in some instance do no warrant a breach/further investigation.

(iii) The total number of outstanding enforcement cases is 5877. These figures have been extracted from a live dataset which is continuously updated and validated. They should therefore be regarded as indicative only at this point in time and should not be compared with any previous figures published by the Agency.

Wind Farms

Mr Ross asked the Minister of the Environment for his assessment of wind farms; and what action he will take to assist planning applications in this area.

(AQW 8443/08)

Mr S Wilson: Windfarm developments have played a significant role in the drive towards securing renewable sources of energy generation.

Northern Ireland set itself a target of deriving 12% of energy consumption from renewable sources (equivalent to 400MW) by 2012 (of which 15% should be non wind sources). As of 26 June 2008 Planning Service has consented 480MW of power from windfarms alone.

To date 33 planning applications for windfarms have been approved. Currently there are 48 applications for windfarms in the planning system.

My Department has recently consulted on draft Planning Policy Statement 18 (PPS 18) which sets out updated planning policy for proposals to develop renewable sources of energy generation, including energy from wind. The primary aim of draft PPS 18 is to encourage and facilitate the provision and siting of renewable energy generating facilities in appropriate locations within the built and natural environment while assisting the diversification of energy supply and a more competitive energy market, and to encourage economic growth and rural diversification associated with the development of an indigenous renewable energy industry.

Areas of Special Scientific Interest and Special Areas of Conservation

Mr Ford asked the Minister of the Environment what areas of Special Scientific Interest and Special Areas of Conservation are affected by the A4, A5 and A6 roads.

(AQW 8561/08)

Mr S Wilson: No Areas of Special Scientific Interest or Special Areas of Conservation are currently affected by the A4, A5 or A6.

However, as you will no doubt appreciate there are a number of improvement schemes on the A4, A5 and A6 routes and that the various schemes are at different stages of planning and delivery. It is perhaps worth considering the schemes, and in particular how they affect Areas of Special Scientific Interest (ASSI) and Special Areas of Conservation (SAC), on an individual basis.

A4 – The A4 dual carriageway between Dungannon and Ballygawley, the realignment of the A4 Annaghilla and the realignment of the A5 Tullyvar schemes do not affect any ASSI or SAC, nor does it pose a risk to them.

A5 – The upgrading of the A5 to dual carriageway status is by far the largest scheme ever undertaken in Northern Ireland and, because of its scale, there will no doubt be issues associated with ASSIs and SACs. However, I would point out that the scheme is at a very early stage and that it is envisaged that the preferred route will be published in mid-2009. While it is not possible to be more specific at this stage, I can confirm that Roads Service will liaise with interested parties including the Northern Ireland Environment Agency before deciding on the preferred route.

A6 – The upgrading of the A6 to dual carriageway standard will have a direct effect on the candidate SAC at the River Faughan and its Tributaries and at the River Roe. It will also have indirect effects on the ASSI at Ervey Wood and in the Lough Beg Area.

Ballymartin River Pollution Incident

Mr Burnside asked the Minister of the Environment what preventive measures his Department has in place to forestall any repeats of the Ballymartin River pollution incident.

(AQW 8591/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department’s Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA), formerly the Environment and Heritage Service, is already working on a number of initiatives to improve what is being done to prevent pollution occurring and to protect the aquatic environment.

NIEA undertakes Pollution Prevention Risk Assessments at any site that is causing, or has the potential to cause pollution, e.g. construction sites and various industrial and commercial sites. This includes an investigation of the catchments and water bodies that are at risk, or potentially at risk, from pollution or have historically had poor water quality. Through direct interaction with site managers and owners NIEA can, through education or enforcement, reduce the risk of these sites causing pollution or downgrading the water quality in the catchment.

NIEA has also established nine Catchment Stakeholder Groups to enable a wide range of individuals to participate in identifying and resolving issues related to pollution and water quality.

In addition three Catchment Officers were appointed last year with a specific role to liaise with site managers and owners in an attempt to advise and reduce the risk of pollution.

Development of National Parks

Mr Burnside asked the Minister of the Environment to outline his Department’s ten year strategy for the development of national parks, outlining all areas under consideration, and detailing the formal links between his Department and the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment in relation to tourism.

(AQW 8593/08)

Mr S Wilson: I will consider the range of issues in relation to National Parks and make my views known in due course.

It is my intention to explore with my colleague Arlene Foster the potential for developing the relationship between national parks and tourism. I am aware that the Mournes is one of the NI Tourist Board’s signature projects and that the Tourist Board is a strong advocate of national park designation in order to maximise the tourism potential of the area.

10 Year Development of Lough Neagh

Mr Burnside asked the Minister of the Environment what are his plans and strategies for the 10 year development of Lough Neagh.

(AQW 8594/08)

Mr S Wilson: No single Department has the sole responsibility of producing a development plan or strategy for Lough Neagh. The Department of the Environment is responsible for guiding and regulating development on and around the Lough and, jointly with DCAL, sponsors the Lough Neagh Advisory Committee.

Environmental Protection Agency

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment to (i) review the case for establishing an independent Environmental Protection Agency in the aftermath of the pollution incident on the Ballymartin/Sixmilewater; and (ii) ensure that, in the interim, the Environment and Heritage Service assumes an advisory and preventative stance to deter such incidents on watercourses.

(AQW 8636/08)

Mr S Wilson: Arlene Foster made the right decision in relation to an Environmental Protection Agency and there is no need to review it. The Northern Ireland Environment Agency already works proactively to prevent pollution incidents on watercourses. It assesses pollution risk at sites where there is the potential for such incidents and advises and educates site managers and owners so that they can reduce the risk. Where necessary the Agency resorts to enforcement action.

Consequences of Pollution

Mr K Robinson asked the Minister of the Environment what further preventative and protective measures he will take to ensure that residents, commercial and farming interests within river catchment areas are aware of the consequences of pollution incidents upon the eco-systems that are dependant upon the water quality of these waterways.

(AQW 8637/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department will always seek to improve on what is being done to both prevent pollution occuring and to protect water quality. The Environment and Heritage Service (EHS) is already working on a number of initiatives as follows:

- Nine, locally based Catchment Stakeholder Groups have been established to enable a wide range of individuals to participate in resolving issues related to pollution and water quality in their locality.

- Three Catchment Officers were appointed last year specifically to liaise with a wide range of stakeholders at a local level and to work with stakeholders to identify and help resolve problems.

- The regulation by EHS of farming activities, to prevent pollution problems arising, is linked to award of the Single Farm Payment by DARD, under the EU Common Agricultural Policy.

- A Pollution Prevention Risk Assessment Database has been established. This records details of all site inspection visits and the findings in terms of the risk which these, mainly, industrial sites pose to the aquatic environment. This enables more targeted advisory visits and any necessary enforcement action.

- EHS publishes an annual report detailing statistics and other information about water pollution incidents. A series of 28 practical pollution prevention guidelines are also available on request. These guidelines, and many other publications, can all be accessed on the EHS website.

- In 1998, EHS established the freephone pollution hotline (0800 80 70 60) to enable members of the public to report any sightings of pollution. This facility has been widely advertised and is highlighted at every opportunity, eg, at the EHS stand which is present every year at the Balmoral Agricultural Show.

Greenhouse Gas Emissions

Mr McCallister asked the Minister of the Environment for his assessment of the European Union targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 20% by 2020 as part of a range of measures to halt climate change.

(AQW 8676/08)

Mr S Wilson: The UK Government has taken the lead in discussions within the European Union on emission reduction targets and measures. This has resulted in targets to reduce emissions by 20% through measures such as the EU Emissions Trading Scheme and increased renewables.

I am personally not convinced that man is the cause of climate change and I believe that efforts to reduce greenhouse gases should not be to the detriment of the economy. However, it is clear that whilst any move to alternative energy supplies such as renewables will not be cheap, it becomes more feasible economically as fossil fuel prices rise. Using alternatives to coal, oil and gas will reduce our demand on these finite resources and improve the security of our energy supplies.

Other emission reduction measures require improved energy efficiency which will reduce energy costs for both individuals and businesses.

Nitrates Action Programme Regulations

Mr P J Bradley asked the Minister of the Environment what policy he will pursue in addressing situations where livestock owners are refused planning permission to build a collection tank in order to comply with the Nitrates Directive.

(AQW 8683/08)

Mr S Wilson: Under the terms of the Nitrates Action Programme Regulations farmers are required to have a minimum of 22 or 26 weeks storage depending on type of livestock.

While my Department has in place extended permitted development rights for farmers who are required to provide additional slurry storage arrangements under the Nitrates Directive there are some instances where they do not meet the necessary criteria for permitted development and a planning application is required.

In processing such applications Planning Service will take account of any adverse impacts on any occupied dwelling not on the farm holding. If an applicant was refused planning permission on this basis they have the right of appeal to the Planning Appeals Commission. Alternatively in view of the limited timescale for grant assistance Planning Service staff are available to advise on alternative locations to avoid detrimental impacts on other occupied dwellings. Any new application dependent on grant aid will be given priority by Planning Service.

A small number of applications have been refused where the proposal involved the construction of the slurry tank in close proximity to a dwelling because it would result in the creation of unacceptable living conditions for the residents by reason of severe odours and noise nuisance, based on advice from Environmental Health Officials. In such situations, Planning Service would try to work with the applicant and his agent to find an acceptable alternative site for the tank, if this is possible. Where an application is refused it will be necessary for a farmer to make alternative arrangements for storage in order to comply with the requirements of the Nitrates Directive.

Rural Development Programme

Mr Doherty asked the Minister of the Environment if the Planning Service has informed all its staff of the Department's intention to give priority to planning applications which are dependent on grant aid, such as the Rural Development Programme.

(AQW 8741/08)

Mr S Wilson: All Planning Service staff are aware of the need to give priority to individual planning applications on which grant-aid may depend. Guidance for prioritising planning applications was issued to all staff in July 2006 by way of a planning circular, PC 11/06.

Staff are reminded in the circular of the circumstances in which certain types of application, including those on which grant-aid depend, may be given priority. It is important, however, that the applicant or agent advises Planning Service that an application is dependent on grant-aid when the planning application is submitted.

Divided Societies and Carbon Footprints

Dr Farry asked the Minister of the Environment for his assessment of comments from the Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors that divided societies tend to have greater carbon footprints.

(AQW 8746/08)

Mr S Wilson: I have made no assessment of comments from the Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors that divided societies tend to have greater carbon footprints. Whilst my Department has sponsored the Community Eco-Challenge project aimed at helping community groups in the Southern region of councils to reduce their ecological footprint by focusing on use of food, waste, transport and energy, it did not address the issue of the impact of divided societies on the ecological footprint as this was not an outcome that was to be measured.

Planning Policy Statement 13

Dr Farry asked the Minister of the Environment what plans he has to review the Northern Ireland planning framework to ensure that it maximises the development of new housing around current and future public transport nodes.

(AQW 8749/08)

Mr S Wilson: Planning Policy Statement 13 ‘Transportation and Land Use’ provides strategic policy guidance and advice relating to the integration of land use and planning through the preparation of development plans. This also promotes higher density and mixed use developments in locations benefiting from high accessibility to public transport facilities.

This is complemented by policy and advice contained in PPS 3 ‘Access, Movement and Parking’, PPS 7 ‘Quality Residential Environments’ and PPS 12 ‘Housing in Settlements’.

I have no plans at present to review current planning policy on this issue.

Household Recycling Rates

Mr Ross asked the Minister of the Environment to detail the recycling rate of each District Council in each of the last 3 years.

(AQW 8754/08)

Mr S Wilson: The recycling rates for household, municipal and biodegradable municipal waste diverted from landfill for each of the 26 District Councils are set out in the tables below. Municipal waste represents all collections within the Councils’ possession and control.

The names in bold within the table refer to the 3 waste management groups into which the District Councils are grouped.

Household Recycling Rates

	2004/05	2005/06	2006/07
District Council	Household Recycling & Composting Rate	Household Recycling & Composting Rate	Household Recycling & Composting Rate
Antrim	38.39%	44.02%	47.11%
Ards	20.40%	24.02%	25.45%
Ballymena	23.39%	26.87%	28.15%
Belfast	8.86%	14.36%	18.95%
Carrickfergus	17.20%	17.41%	21.89%
Castlereagh	22.24%	32.53%	34.91%
Down	19.17%	33.69%	32.16%
Larne	16.49%	25.00%	31.63%
Lisburn	12.25%	19.83%	25.08%
Newtownabbey	19.90%	22.54%	24.79%
North Down	17.21%	24.63%	32.97%
ARC21	16.70%	22.90%	26.80%
Ballymoney	24.02%	24.44%	24.75%
Coleraine	18.60%	24.26%	25.67%
Derry	13.72%	28.07%	24.37%
Limavady	27.33%	35.88%	28.51%
Magherafelt	31.42%	35.66%	35.26%
Moyle	11.32%	25.51%	26.53%
Strabane	17.32%	21.30%	22.81%
NWRWMG	19.30%	27.60%	26.30%
Armagh City & District Council	23.30%	26.70%	32.83%
Banbridge District Council	39.21%	40.99%	45.13%
Cookstown District Council	20.06%	28.14%	31.57%
Craigavon Borough Council	23.35%	29.29%	29.96%
Dungannon & South Tyrone Borough Council	20.13%	19.54%	24.93%
Fermanagh District Council	21.04%	20.77%	27.83%
Newry & Mourne District Council	20.03%	24.86%	27.83%
Omagh District Council	19.62%	17.77%	27.95%
SWaMP	23.00%	25.90%	30.50%
Northern Ireland	18.90%	24.50%	27.70%

Municipal Recycling Rates

	2004/05	2005/06	2006/07
	Municipal Recycling Rate	Municipal Recycling Rate	Municipal Recycling Rate
Antrim	39.8%	45.8%	47.1%
Ards	19.4%	22.9%	24.5%
Ballymena	21.6%	25.7%	26.5%
Belfast	8.7%	13.0%	16.9%
Carrickfergus	14.6%	15.0%	19.5%
Castlereagh	22.7%	33.2%	35.6%
Down	16.8%	29.2%	27.8%
Larne	14.5%	23.1%	28.4%
Lisburn	13.7%	21.1%	24.8%
Newtownabbey	18.0%	20.9%	22.8%
North Down	19.8%	20.1%	26.8%
arc21	16.5%	21.5%	24.8%
Ballymoney	22.2%	21.4%	21.9%
Coleraine	17.8%	24.0%	22.4%
Derry	11.9%	28.3%	23.6%
Limavady	24.1%	33.2%	28.1%
Magherafelt	27.4%	32.1%	32.1%
Moyle	9.5%	18.0%	21.1%
Strabane	15.0%	18.7%	20.3%
NWRWMG	17.4%	26.0%	24.1%
Armagh	25.7%	29.1%	35.0%
Banbridge	40.0%	40.7%	44.1%
Cookstown	22.4%	26.8%	28.4%
Craigavon	21.6%	25.6%	26.2%
Dungannon and South Tyrone	19.1%	19.2%	23.8%
Fermanagh	18.9%	17.7%	24.3%
Newry and Mourne	18.2%	22.7%	25.8%
Omagh	17.9%	15.9%	23.6%
SWaMP	22.3%	24.2%	28.1%

Northern Ireland	18.2%	23.0%	25.5%

Biodegradable municipal waste diverted from landfill

District Council	BMW sent to landfill for scheme year 2005/06 (As reported)	% Utilisation of Allowances	BMW sent to landfill for scheme year 2006/07 (As reported)	% Utilisation of Allowances
Antrim	12,635	73.1%	12,402	65.49%
Ards	25,851	81.2%	25,046	86.78%
Ballymena	19,355	90.2%	18,439	80.75%
Belfast	106,509	91.1%	96,063	93.27%
Carrickfergus	14,935	87.3%	14,116	95.10%
Castlereagh	15,496	67.1%	14,450	56.92%
Down	17,262	67.1%	17,382	68.58%
Larne	11,345	83.9%	10,259	86.49%
Lisburn	37,242	76.4%	34,186	81.00%
Newtownabbey	27,599	88.5%	28,024	90.69%
North	28,503	84.9%	25,257	85.31%
Arc21 – Total	316,732	83.3%	295,622	83.56%
Ballymoney	8,119	62.6%	87,241	96.30%
Coleraine	22,604	78.5%	234,112	99.98%
Derry	27,909	76.9%	33,509	81.52%
Limavady	8,016	65.4%	9,200	70.37%
Magherafelt	10,445	73.4%	10,977	69.20%
Moyle	6,043	87.7%	5,739	90.61%
Strabane	12,345	70.9%	12,697	85.24%
NWRWMG – Total	95,481	74.1%	104,258	84.25%
Armagh	14,296	83.6%	13,715	64.11%
Banbridge	10,213	79.2%	9,110	54.15%
Cookstown	10,402	89.1%	9,977	77.22%
Craigavon	27,624	89.2%	24,191	76.16%
Dungannon & South Tyrone	16,694	90.9%	16,223	86.33%
Fermanagh	21,740	100.0%	21,117	93.62%
Newry & Mourne	28,105	97.9%	27,608	79.49%
Omagh	16,722	87.3%	13,894	72.94%
SWaMP – Total:	145,796	90.8%	135,835	76.30%
Northern Ireland – Total:	558,009	83.3%	535,715	81.72%

Raw Sewage in the Closet River

Mr Savage asked the Minister of the Environment what action is being taken to clean up the discharge of raw sewage in the Closet River before it enters Lough Neagh.

(AQW 8795/08)

Mr S Wilson: It is the role of the Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) to conserve, protect and, where possible, improve both the freshwater and marine aquatic environment in Northern Ireland.

In Northern Ireland, NIEA issues consents for discharges for Northern Ireland Water (NIW) assets. Since 1 April 2007, the standards for NIW discharges have been regulated under the Water (Northern Ireland) Order 1999.

All sewer systems that contain an element of storm water require an overflow to prevent flooding and consequent damage to property during times of heavy rainfall.

A combined sewer overflow (CSO) discharges to the Closet River and this is consented as part of the Craigavon sewerage system. Under the terms of its discharge consent, NIW is required to effect a clean-up of sewage related debris following a discharge from the CSO.

NIEA staff have requested NIW clean-ups on various occasions as a result of reports of pollution incidents. However, if a clean-up is not undertaken promptly and effectively, then NIEA may consider taking enforcement action.

Halloween Bonfire Complaints

Mr Moutray asked the Minister of the Environment how many complaints his Department has received in relation to the possible adverse environmental effect of Halloween bonfires in each of the last five years.

(AQW 8806/08)

Mr S Wilson: The Northern Ireland Environment Agency received four complaints about Hallowe'en bonfires in 2005 and two in 2008.

Planning Applications

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of the Environment when the green paper will be issued for planning application R/2006/0814 - the Finnebrogue Estate Farm Game Handling business; and to detail the reasons for the delay.

(AQW 8835/08)

Mr S Wilson: The decision will issue as soon as the remaining issues are resolved. Since the approval opinion was presented to Council in February 2008, the Department has been involved in discussions with the applicant to resolve outstanding matters relating to the conditions to be attached to the planning permission and other legal mechanisms available to secure the desired outcome.

Legal Fees for Area Plans

Mr I McCrea asked the Minister of the Environment what legal fees have been incurred for each area plan over the last five years.

(AQW 8836/08)

Mr S Wilson: In the last 5 financial years my Department has to date incurred an estimated total of almost £400,000 in legal costs for area plans. This figure includes an estimate of the costs incurred in the last financial year and will be subject to final adjustment.

These legal costs arise from legal advice and representation in regard to Public Inquiries and to court proceedings relating to judicial challenges to the Environmental Reports for a number of development plans.

The costs for each plan are as follows:

Dungannon & South Tyrone Area Plan = £32,500

Craigavon Area Plan = £38,351

Draft Ards & Down Area Plan = £116,205

Draft Belfast Metropolitan Plan = £85,200

Draft Northern Area Plan = £87,494

Draft Magherafelt Area Plan = £39,330

Legal proceedings in relation to the judicial challenge to the Draft Banbridge Newry & Mourne Area Plan have recently been resolved however an estimate of final costs is not yet available. Proceedings in relation to the Northern and Magherafelt cases are ongoing and it is therefore not possible to provide final costs at this point in time.

Delay in Adopting Ards and Down Area Plan

Mr T Clarke asked the Minister of the Environment to explain the delay in adopting the Ards and Down Area Plan 2015; and what steps his Department is taking to have the plan finalised and adopted.

(AQW 8859/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department has only received the report of the public inquiry into the draft Ards and Down Plan, which closed in January 2007, at the end of March this year. A dedicated team of officers was in place at that time and is currently considering the implications of the report.

The content of that report is confidential until the formal adoption of the Plan, however I can say that it has raised a number of complex policy and procedural issues. One possible consequence may be the need for a formal modification of the Plan, prior to adoption. An alternative, which my Department is also considering, may be to proceed to adoption without the need for such a modification process to be followed.

I can assure you that considerable progress has been made towards the adoption of the Plan, however, in the circumstances I am reluctant to commit to a final date until my officials have fully considered the implications of each approach, perhaps by the end of July. It is my intention to complete the adoption stage as quickly as possible and to establish the certainty that this new Plan will bring to both Ards and Down Districts in terms of its local planning framework.

Belfast City Airport

Mr Newton asked the Minister of the Environment what measures are in place as part of an ongoing programme to monitor the quality of air in proximity to the George Best Belfast City Airport.

(AQW 8870/08)

Mr S Wilson: Air quality is managed by district councils in Northern Ireland under a statutory framework laid down under the Environment (Northern Ireland) Order 2002. Belfast City Council regularly reviews and assesses air quality throughout its Council area including monitoring at Sydenham and Knocknagoney. This is undertaken at particular locations, usually near domestic properties, and results to date have shown no exceedences of the air quality objective for nitrogen dioxide at these locations.

Litigation of the Northern Area Plan

Mr Paisley Jnr asked the Minister of the Environment how much his Department has spent on the litigation of the Northern Area Plan; and what the estimated full legal cost will be to his Department.

(AQW 8877/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department has incurred to date legal costs at an estimated total of almost £87,500 in respect of the litigation of the draft Northern Area Plan (dNAP). This includes an estimate for the last financial year and further costs for this period can be expected.

My Department’s ongoing appeal of the judgment in this case has now been referred by the Court of Appeal to the European Court of Justice (ECJ). In the judgement, costs were awarded against the Department; however the final position on costs, in the dNAP case, must await the outcome of the appeal and it is therefore not possible to give an estimate of total costs at this point in time.

Litigation of the Magherafelt Area Plan

Mr Paisley Jnr asked the Minister of the Environment how much his Department has spent on the litigation of the Magherafelt Area Plan; and what the estimated full legal cost will be to his Department.

(AQW 8878/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department has incurred to date legal costs at an estimated total of just over £39,300 in respect of the litigation in relation to the draft Magherafelt Area Plan. This includes estimates for the last financial year and further costs for this period can be expected.

The legal proceedings in this matter have only recently been settled while the court awarded costs against the Department are as yet unknown. It is therefore not possible to give an estimate of total costs at this point in time.

Pollution in the Glenavy River

Mr Burns asked the Minister of the Environment to detail all pollution incidents which have occurred in the Glenavy river in each of the last 10 years, including (i) the severity of each incident; (ii) the source of the pollution; and (iii) the sanctions that were imposed on those responsible.

(AQW 8922/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department’s Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA), is responsible for investigating water pollution throughout Northern Ireland.

The data presented in table A indicate the number of pollution incidents which have occurred in the Glenavy River in each of the last 10 years.

The data presented in table B indicate the source of pollution incidents which have occurred in the Glenavy River in each of the last 10 years.

Table A

The Number of Incidents by Severity
	1997	1998	1999	2000	2001	2002	2003	2004	2005	2006	2007	Total
High	0	0	2	0	0	0	0	0	1	0	0	3
Medium	3	5	4	2	2	0	4	3	3	0	2	28
Low	2	4	6	5	7	6	5	1	4	3	2	45
Total	5	9	12	7	9	6	9	4	8	3	4	76

Table B

Number of Incidents by Source 1997-2007
Domestic	Farm	Industry	Other	Water Service/ Northern Ireland Water	TOTAL
12	21	26	2	15	76

Where pollution occurs it is the policy of NIEA, to take formal enforcement action, if this is warranted by the severity of the pollution and the circumstances which led to it occurring.

Between 1997 and 2007 NIEA issued 9 warning letters and has taken 11 cases for prosecution. Fines for the successful prosecutions ranged from £100 to £3,600.

Archaeological Finds in Strangford Lough

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of the Environment what archaeological finds have been discovered in operations carried out by the Environment and Heritage Service in Strangford Lough, in each of the last 4 years.

(AQW 8926/08)

Mr S Wilson: The then Environment and Heritage Service (EHS) undertook archaeological excavations in the vicinity of Strangford Lough using its contracted team, the Centre for Archaeological Fieldwork, Queen’s University Belfast, at the following sites:

In 2004 at Kilnatierney, excavation of a shell midden with a collection of late mesolithic flint flakes, scallop shells, a boar’s tusk and two pig incisors.
In 2005- 2007 there were no finds.
In 2008 at Castleward, EHS supported excavations to uncover the Queen Anne period house on the National Trust owned estate. The work is continuing with the Northern Ireland Environment Agency and the finds have yet to be reported.

Grey Squirrel Eradication

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of the Environment what action his Department is taking to eradicate the Grey Squirrel population from the grounds surrounding Parliament Buildings, in order to increase the Red Squirrel population.

(AQW 8928/08)

Mr S Wilson: My Department, in conjunction with the Republic’s National Parks and Wildlife Service, published an all-island species action plan for the red squirrel in May 2008. This addresses various factors relating to the decline in our red squirrel population, including the spread of the grey squirrel.

An action recommended in the plan is to provide funding for two posts of Squirrel Conservation Officer by 2009. Discussions between the Red Squirrel Forum and NGOs about these posts are ongoing. Their duties will include grey squirrel control in targeted areas as well as disseminating advice to landowners and the general public on red squirrel conservation.

The Department is not in a position to eradicate grey squirrels from lands at Parliament Buildings or on other publicly owned land. It will, however, offer advice on methods and best practice if required.

Blood Alcohol Limits for Drivers

Mr Craig asked the Minister of the Environment what plans he has to reduce the maximum allowable blood alcohol level while driving, from 80 mgs to the European standard of 50mgs, in line with the recommendations of the Association of Chief Police Officers.

(AQW 8943/08)

Mr S Wilson: I favour a reduction in the general drink driving limit to 50 mg/100ml. My officials are working towards consultation on this issue later this year and are liaising with colleagues in the Department for Transport in considering a range of measures to deter drink driving and reduce casualties and with counterparts in Ireland on their proposals.

There are other measures worth considering which might include even lower limits for some categories of driver, for example, inexperienced drivers or professional drivers, random breath testing and alcohol ignition interlocks.

Subject to general agreement and legislative arrangements, I would hope that we could have new limits in place during 2009/10.

Storage of Archaeological Finds

Mr Shannon asked the Minister of the Environment what the Environment and Heritage Service has done to store the significant archaeological finds in Strangford Lough.

(AQW 8958/08)

Mr S Wilson: The Northern Ireland Environment Agency (NIEA) has conserved a considerable proportion of the finds from the excavations it sponsored at Nendrum tide mills, particularly those made of timber. It now stores these, along with other artefacts which are not in need of conservation, both at its Belfast headquarters and on specially set aside premises at works depots in County Down. From time to time local museums accept items from the tidal mill excavation for display, but these are always returned to NIEA afterwards.

The then Environment and Heritage Service sponsored excavations in 2004 at Kilnatierney which revealed a shell midden with a collection of late Mesolithic flint flakes, scallop shells, a boar’s tusk and two pig incisors. The finds are stored at the Queen’s University of Belfast.

Effect of Wind Turbines on Birds

Mr Buchanan asked the Minister of the Environment what adverse effect the down draft from wind turbines has on grouse and other game birds.

(AQW 8959/08)

Mr S Wilson: There is no evidence available from studies of windfarms in Northern Ireland or from elsewhere that Red Grouse or other game birds are affected by the downdraft from wind turbines. Information from the windfarm industry indicates that there is no down draft specifically associated with the operation of wind turbines.

Number of Windfarm Applications

Mr Buchanan asked the Minister of the Environment how many proposals for new or extended wind farms are currently awaiting a decision, broken down by district council area.

(AQW 8961/08)

Mr S Wilson: There are currently 47 applications for wind farms in the planning system.

The breakdown by district council area is as follows:

District Council Area	No. of current windfarm applications
Omagh	9
Strabane	11
Londonderry	2
Limavady	5
Fermanagh	7
Dungannon	4
Cookstown	1
Newtownabbey	2
Ballymoney	1
Ballymena	2
Antrim	1
Coleraine	2
Total	47

Application Rejection, Buncrana Road Development

Mr McCartney asked the Minister of the Environment to outline the reasons for not supporting/approving the planning application for the proposed foodstore, car parking and servicing arrangements and associated works on the Buncrana Road, Templemore Road, Derry/Londonderry.

(AQW 8962/08)

Mr S Wilson: The application was refused on the grounds that the proposal is contrary to Planning Policy Statement 5 Retailing and Town Centres in that the development of this out of centre location would, if permitted, result in the vitality and viability of existing centres being adversely affected and undermine their convenience shopping function.

The proposal is also contrary to Planning Policy Statement 3 Access Movement and Parking Policy, Policies AMP3 (Transport Assessment) and AMP7 (Car Parking and Service Arrangements).

Advice in Planning Application Process

Mr O'Loan asked the Minister of the Environment what action he is taking to ensure that there is consistency of advice to applicants throughout the planning application process, to prevent the situation where an applicant is given a positive response from the case officer, but an eventual negative response as the application reaches its final stage.

(AQW 8974/08)

Mr S Wilson: During the processing of planning applications my Department will occasionally be asked by applicants to express an opinion on the acceptability of a proposal. My Department will always be as helpful as possible and attempt to answer questions from members of the public as accurately and fully as possible. However, any opinion given in advance of a formal decision notice, either written or verbal remains only an opinion. Final decisions on planning applications are taken corporately and opinions may be subject to change. I will remind my Department to make this clear when giving an opinion to applicants in these circumstances.

Finance and Personnel

Staff Sick Days

Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what comparison his Department has made between the number of days off work annually due to sick leave in the (i) public; and (ii) private, sectors; and the average number of days off work in one period of absence in each sector.

(AQW 8417/08)

The Minister of Finance and Personnel (Mr N Dodds): Central Personnel Group, a division within the Department of Finance and Personnel, routinely monitors sickness absence data from across the public and private sectors. This work would include comparisons with GB Departments and local Government and would also involve analysis of the annual absence surveys undertaken by the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) and the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD).

I can confirm that the number of days off work due to sick leave in the NICS was higher (13.7 days – 2006/07 figures) than in GB Departments (9.3 days). The table below provides some trend data reflecting the period 2002 – 2006/07.

Trends in absence

Working days lost per staff year	2002	2003	2004	2005		2005-06		2006-07
				Original	Adjusted	Original	Adjusted
GB	9.8	10.0	9.1	9.8	9.4	9.4	9.0	9.3
NICS¹	15.4	15.5	14.2	13.4				13.7

^{1 NICS fitted into calendar years for presentational purposes.

According to a Report published in January 2008, by the Chief Local Government Auditor, in 2006/ 07 the average absenteeism rate for NI Councils as a whole, was 13.82 days, slightly higher than the NICS figure for the same period (13.7 days).

The latest CBI / AXA Absence Survey showed that average absence levels across the public sector stood at 9 days, which is 55% higher than the 5.8 day average of the private sector. According to the CIPD annual survey on Absence Management, absence levels for public services organisations increased to 4.5% (10.3 days) from 4.3% for the previous 12 months. There was also an increase in the average absence levels recorded by private services sector employers, with the rate rising over the year to
3.2% (7.2 days) from 3%.

Some caution is needed when comparing information produced by organisations such as the CBI or Chartered Institute for Personnel and Development. Their methods for gathering data differ from the NICS, which makes it difficult to draw statistically valid comparisons. For example, the CIPD Absence Report was based on 819 replies to a survey questionnaire, comprising 437 paper questionnaires and 382 on-line questionnaires.

Cost of Recent Equal Pay Settlement for Departments
Mr O'Loan asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel (i) when the costs of the recent equal pay settlement for Departments were (a) anticipated; and (b) known; (ii) the manner in which the equal pay settlement was factored into the budget announcement for the current three year period; and (iii) what information was given during the budget discussions to the Finance and Personnel Committee and to the Assembly.
(AQW 8491/08)

Mr N Dodds: As yet, no equal pay settlement has been agreed. The potential equal pay pressure has arisen as a consequence of the handling of pay issues for the relevant staff since 1996 when the Treasury delegated responsibility for pay negotiations to individual departments both in Great Britain and in Northern Ireland.

In June 2007, when the Trade Unions lodged equal pay questionnaires, officials engaged with the Northern Ireland Statistical Research Agency (NISRA) to assess the potential liability. The work that was carried out by NISRA examined two aspects of any potential equal pay settlement - back pay and the options for future pay arrangements. In addition, the Department of Finance and Personnel began the collation of all information relevant to the questionnaires in order to assess the potential for any future equal pay liabilities.

It was not until the NISRA exercise was completed and the Department had completed its assessment of all of the available information that a clear indication of the potential liability and its possible timing was known. Discussions with the trade unions about how this issue might be resolved will be progressed over the coming months and any precise estimate of a settlement figure will not be available until this process has concluded.
The costs of the potential equal pay liabilities were not factored into the budget as it was not until after the Budget process had been concluded and the allocations for 2008-11 approved by the Assembly that it became clear that there was a possibility that a liability in respect of equal pay claims could arise in 2008. Furthermore, an exact figure will not be available until further work is completed.
No information was given to the Finance and Personnel Committee and the Assembly during the budget discussions regarding this issue as, at that time, the work was under way to gather the relevant information and carry out the assessments indicated above. However, a letter was issued to the Finance & Personnel Committee on the 29^th May which outlined the position and issues involved. The Minister, in his June monitoring statement to the Assembly on the 24^th June made reference to the equal pay issue.

Zero-Based Budgeting
Mr Burnside asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel if he has applied zero-based budgeting (i) to any sections of his Department; (ii) to any of the operations of his Department; (iii) to his Department overall; (iv) to any agencies under the supervision of his Department; and (v) to any of the other Departments in the Executive or to any Agencies under their supervision.
(AQW 8586/08)
Mr N Dodds: As part of the 2008-2011 Budget process a zero based approach was adopted with respect to decisions on the capital allocations to Northern Ireland Departments and their Agencies. This reflects the time bounded nature of most capital projects which means that they are more amenable to a zero based analysis.
Although all Government spending programmes should be regularly evaluated to ensure that the original rationale for intervention remains and services delivered efficiently, it was decided that it would not be appropriate to adopt a zero-based approach with respect to resource allocations in the 2008 Budget process. This was on the basis that a number of significant areas had already been subject to recent review and, importantly, it is simply inconceivable that the Executive would decide to not continue the provision of key services in terms of for example health, education or support to business. Therefore, it would be expected that the costs would outweigh the benefits from such an all encompassing approach.
However, in deciding upon how to deliver the 3% per annum efficiency savings target, it is expected that Northern Ireland Departments and their Agencies will have examined the whole suite of programmes they deliver in order to identify the required level of savings
In addition, the Performance and Efficiency Delivery Unit (PEDU) will examine the scope for departments to deliver high levels of cash releasing efficiencies, combined with parallel improvements in performance and delivery.

Gross Value Added in Belfast
Dr Farry asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel how the Gross Value Added of Belfast compares to other major UK cities.
(AQW 8632/08)

Mr N Dodds: Gross Value Added (GVA) is not produced specifically for the cities of the United Kingdom. The Office for National Statistics is responsible for producing estimates of GVA for the UK, its regions and sub-regions. GVA estimates are produced on the basis of the EU-wide geographies known as NUTS (Nomenclature of Units for Territorial Statistics) and are available for the UK at the levels of NUTS1, NUTS2 and NUTS3. A number, but not all, of the UK’s largest cities approximate to NUTS3 regions. The attached table provides NUTS3 based estimates of GVA for 2005, where available, for the ten largest (by population size) UK cities and for Belfast.

NUTS 3 name

Total GVA £million, 2005

GVA per head £, 2005 #

Population

London*

206,324

27,672

7,456,073

Birmingham

18,038

17,984

1,002,982

Leeds

15,268

20,613

740,689

Glasgow City

14,108

24,375

578,790

Sheffield

8,265

15,823

522,368

Bradford

6,623

13,572

487,975

Edinburgh, City of

13,017

28,432

457,830

Liverpool

7,133

16,321

437,052

Manchester

No appropriate NUTS3 region

Bristol, City of

9,506

23,434

405,641

Belfast

7,180

26,792

267,999

Source: Regional, sub-regional and local gross value added, First Release ONS December 2007

*Figures provided for London are for the entire NUTS1 region of London. London is broken down into two sub-regions at the NUTS2 level (Inner London and Outer London) and five local areas at the NUTS3 level (Inner London West, Inner London East, Outer London East and North East, Outer London South, Outer London West and North West).
# Comparisons of GVA per head estimates must be treated with caution at this geographical level as they do not take account of commuting effects. GVA is calculated on a workplace basis, for example all of the activity generated within Belfast is included in Belfast’s GVA. However, the GVA per head figures are calculated by dividing this workplace based activity by the number of people who reside in the area. GVA per head figures will therefore be artificially high in areas with high levels of net inward commuting and correspondingly low in areas with high levels of net outward commuting. For example, data from the 2001 Census show that over 173,000 people work in Belfast but only 77,000 of those also live in Belfast. Taking account of those people who live in Belfast but work outside of Belfast, there is a net inward commuting flow of around 73,000 workers to Belfast. These workers will contribute to the GVA that is allocated to Belfast but will not be included in the resident-based population denominator for calculating GVA per head.

Gross Value Added in Belfast
Dr Farry asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what the methodology is for calculating the Gross Value Added of Belfast relative to other major UK cities.
(AQW 8633/08)

Mr N Dodds: Gross Value Added (GVA) is not produced for the cities of the United Kingdom. The Office for National Statistics (ONS) is responsible for producing GVA for the UK and its regions. The methodology for producing Regional GVA involves the allocation of the UK National GVA totals (published as National Accounts in the Blue Book) to each of the UK regions whilst also ensuring that each UK industry GVA total is also allocated amongst industries in each of the UK regions. This involves a two-way balancing process between industry and region. Further details can be found in the ONS publication entitled Regional Accounts Methodological Guide which is available from the ONS website (http://www.statistics.gov.uk/downloads/theme_economy/RegionalAccountsMethodologyGuide.pdf)

Local Postal Services
Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by his Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.
(AQW 8694/08)

Mr N Dodds: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ Report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of Postal Services and the Post Office network.

Junior Minister Donaldson and Junior Minister Kelly wrote to Executive Ministers on 21 April asking them to consider whether any further public services could be delivered through post offices.

Within the Department, Land and Property Services (LPS) currently offer ratepayers the opportunity to pay their rates at the Post Office using a rate payment card or the Transcash facility. Last year over 342,000 rate payment transactions were completed through the Post Office. LPS continues to promote the payment of rates at the Post Office.

LPS recognises the potential opportunity to work with the Post Office as a channel to improve access to LPS services and information and officials will keep this under review.

The Department will continue to look at further opportunities as they arise to consider whether any new public service could be delivered through the Post Office although these would be subject to the appropriate NI procurement policy.

Rates Cap
Mr B Wilson asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what measures he will take to compensate councils for the loss of income resulting from the decision to cap rates at a maximum capital value of £500,000.
(AQW 8724/08)

Mr N Dodds: The decision to introduce a £500,000 maximum capital value was taken as part of the St Andrew’s agreement, by direct rule Ministers, in anticipation of the restoration of devolution. This affected just under 2500 properties. The revenue loss to district councils was just over £1m. While some were more adversely affected than others, the relative impact for the majority was minimal, with an average revenue loss of just under £40,000.

This measure consists of a modification to the tax base and is not, in itself, a rate relief which would be compensated through any of the existing derating provisions. I understand that the Rates (Amendment) (Northern Ireland) Order 2006, which provided for the introduction of the new capital value system, did not contain any enabling powers that would provide for compensating payments to be made. Indeed, so far as I am aware there is no other legislation in place that would allow such payments to be made.

If the loss of revenue from the £500,000 measure is causing severe hardship to councils, in terms of service cuts or unacceptably high district rate increase, the longer term financial impact may be considered as part of the wider Review of Public Administration financial arrangements and its associated legislation. However, I would need to discuss the matter with the Minister responsible for local government issues, Sammy Wilson.

Rates Relief for Married Couples
Mr Savage asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel when he will provide rates relief for married couples over the age of 65.
(AQW 8745/08)

Mr N Dodds: Within the Northern Ireland domestic rating system rate relief for married couples over the age of 65 can primarily be obtained through the housing benefit system and the low income rate relief scheme. Both provisions are means-tested, aimed at targeting rate rebates at those most in need.

While housing benefit is a long standing measure, the new low income rate relief scheme came into operation in April 2007, at the same time as the move to rating on the basis of individual capital values. It aims to provide assistance to those in receipt of partial housing benefit or just outside the housing benefit thresholds. The scheme was enhanced further for pensioners following the St Andrews negotiations, with a further £4.4 million of funding put into the scheme for those meeting the qualifying age for state pension credit.

An outcome of the Executive Review of domestic rating was, from April 2008, to increase the amount of savings pensioners are allowed under the scheme from £16,000 to £50,000. This formed part of an integrated package of measures aimed at pensioners which also included the lone pensioner allowance for those aged 70 or over living alone, a proposed rates deferment scheme for home owning pensioners and enhanced data-sharing powers aimed at increasing rate relief take up.

Flooding Compensation
Mr Savage asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel how much money is expected to be received from the E162.4M European Union Solidarity Fund to deal with the consequences of the flooding which took place in June 2007.
(AQW 8766/08)

Mr N Dodds: The Northern Ireland Executive will receive £180,158 as a result of the successful UK application to the European Union Solidarity Fund (EUSF) following the flooding which occurred last summer.

Civil Service Career Breaks
Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what steps he is taking to ensure that civil servants who request 1 to 2 year career breaks can find alternative job opportunities closer to their homes.
(AQW 8782/08)

Mr N Dodds: The objectives of the career break scheme are to provide new job opportunities in the NICS and to facilitate an officer who wishes to take a break away from work. A career break may be granted for most purposes including further education, domestic responsibilities, starting a business, maintaining a family business or to work outside Northern Ireland.

Staff returning from career breaks will not normally be posted to their prior post/location but to vacancies as and when they arise. Departments will endeavour to absorb their own staff however exceptionally were a department is unable to accommodate a return they will negotiate with other departments to find suitable posts.
In summary due to the length of career breaks, which under our policy can be anything from one to five years, we cannot provide guarantees of where a member of staff will be posted on their return, regardless of personal circumstances.

Number of People Living in Segregated Areas
Dr Farry asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel, based on figures from the 2001 census, to give the number of people living in segregated areas (i.e. areas in which more than 90% of people come from a particular community background), broken down by community background.
(AQW 8816/08)

Mr N Dodds: The 2001 Census showed that just over 484,000 people lived in Super Output Areas (SOAs)¹ where more than 90% of the population came from a single community background, where community background is defined as religion or religion brought up in.

The attached table details the number and community background of people living in segregated Super Output Areas.

Table - Community background of people living in segregated² SOAs.

Community Background

People living in SOAs which are:

Total

More than 90% Catholic

More than 90% Protestant

Catholic

255,612

8,223

263,835

Protestant and Other Christian (including Christian related)

8,747

202,294

211,041

Other religions and philosophies

401

660

1,061

No community background

1,345

6,976

8,321

Total number of people in areas

266,105

218,153

484,258

^{1 SOAs are geographical units, based on electoral wards, each with a population of around 2,000.

^{2 For the purposes of this analysis a SOA was defined as segregated if more than 90% of the people living there came from a single community background

Civil Service Career Breaks
Mr Shannon asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what action his Department is taking to re-locate single mothers within the civil service, who take a career break due to the birth of a child, to positions that are closer to their home.
(AQW 8829/08)

Mr N Dodds: The objectives of the career break scheme are to provide new job opportunities in the NICS and to facilitate an officer who wishes to take a break away from work. A career break may be granted for most purposes including further education, domestic responsibilities, starting a business, maintaining a family business or to work outside Northern Ireland.

Staff returning from career breaks will not normally be posted to their prior post/location but to vacancies as and when they arise. Departments will endeavour to absorb their own staff however exceptionally were a department is unable to accommodate a return they will negotiate with other departments to find suitable posts.

In summary due to the length of career breaks, which under our policy can be anything from one to five years, we cannot provide guarantees of where a member of staff will be posted on their return, regardless of personal circumstances.

New Civil Service Payroll System
Mr Durkan asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel, pursuant to the answer to AQW 3437/08, for an update on the implementation of the new civil service payroll system, which will make the salary sacrifice childcare voucher scheme available to civil service staff.
(AQW 8858/08)

Mr N Dodds: Work is ongoing for the Salary Sacrifice Scheme for Childcare Vouchers to be made available to staff following the introduction of the new NICS payroll system. It is currently planned that the new payroll system will be implemented by the end of September 2008 at the latest.

Rates Cap
Dr Farry asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what understandings were given to district councils on how the lost revenue, from the rates cap of £500,000 during the 2007-2008 financial year, would be funded.[R]
(AQW 8868/08)

Mr N Dodds: The £500,000 maximum capital value was introduced in the final days of direct rule, by direct rule Ministers, in anticipation of the restoration of devolution. While a legislative enabling power would have allowed local Ministers to subsequently take this decision, the measure was introduced at the request of the local political parties to ensure that it was in place for April 2007, when bills issued for the first time using capital values as the basis of assessment.

This measure was always considered by the Department to be a modification to the tax base and not a rate relief applied to particular uses made of property (Reliefs such as sport and recreation and industrial derating are compensated through the derating element of the general grant).
At that time there were discussions with officials in district councils, (through the Association of Local Government Finance Officers) on the impact of the various reforms. Indeed, in October 2006, finance officers from a number of councils were provided with figures showing the number and value of properties above the £500,000 threshold, including Ards, Castlereagh, Down and North Down.

In addition, a consultation paper issued to all political parties, showing the potential impact of a maximum capital value at £500,000. These did not include the option of compensation for councils and the issue was not raised during the consultation process or policy finalisation.

I understand that the legislation which allowed the cap to be introduced, the Rates (Amendment) (Northern Ireland) Order 2006, did not contain any enabling powers that would provide for the lost revenue to be borne by the regional rate in its entirety or for compensating payments to be made to councils. Indeed, so far as my department is aware there is no other legislation in place that would allow such payments to be made.

If the loss of revenue from the £500,000 measure is causing severe hardship to councils, in terms of service cuts or an unacceptably high district rate increase, there may be an opportunity to consider any longer term financial impact as part of the new financial arrangements under the Review of Public Administration. However, I would need to discuss the matter with the Minister responsible for local government issues, Sammy Wilson.

Lost Revenue from Rates Cap
Dr Farry asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel how the lost revenue from the rates cap of £500,000 during the 2007-2008 financial year is being funded.[R]
(AQW 8869/08)

Mr N Dodds: The introduction of a £500,000 maximum capital value was taken by direct rule Ministers shortly before, and in anticipation of, the restoration of devolved power. The measure was considered to be a modification to the tax base rather than a relief and the revenue loss associated with the maximum cap affected both the regional and district rate. In terms of the district rate, while some councils were more adversely affected than others, the relative impact for the majority was minimal, with an average revenue loss of just under £40,000 (just over £1m in total). In terms of the regional rate, the loss of revenue was in the region of £1.5m and represented a marginal adjustment to the overall forecast rate revenue. No compensating payments were made to district councils, with the revenue loss borne by both the regional and district rate.

Protestant Males in Lower Grades of the Civil Service
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what action his Department is taking to address the under representation of protestant males in lower grades of the Civil Service.
(AQW 8880/08)

Mr N Dodds: Since 2002, the NICS has included affirmative statements in all advertisements for AA and AO positions, to which applications from members of the Protestant community are particularly welcomed.
As well as being advertised in the 3 main local newspapers, the recent AA and AO competitions were also advertised on local radio stations, in public buildings and via the jobcentre network. The requirement for academic qualifications was also removed on a trial basis.

Initial analysis of these recent competitions has indicated that the number of applications from the Protestant community has increased by just over 10% but my officials plan to carry out further in-depth analysis, when all appointments have been made, and will consider what further action is required.

Females in Senior Grades of the Civil Service
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what action his Department is taking to address the under representation of females in senior grades of the Civil Service.
(AQW 8881/08)

Mr N Dodds: In order to attract as wide an applicant pool as possible, the NICS makes extensive use of open recruitment to fill senior posts. Recruitment advertisements for senior posts include a statement welcoming applications from under-represented groups, including females. Appointments are, however, based on merit.
Across the NICS, as a whole, the number of female staff at Grade 5 and above has steadily increased from 16.8% in 2003 to 27.4% in 2008.
My officials plan to carry out further in-depth analysis of gender across the Service and will consider what further action is required.

Compulsory Energy Performance Certificates
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what obligations are placed on estate agents arising from the introduction of compulsory energy performance certificates.
(AQW 8916/08)

Mr N Dodds: The Energy Performance of Buildings (Certificates and Inspections) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2008 do not place any obligations on estate agents. Rather they identify a "relevant person" who is obliged to give or make available an energy performance certificate when a building is constructed, sold, leased or rented. For sales or rentals, the relevant person is the seller or landlord.

Charges for Inspecting Insulation
Mr Lunn asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel what guidance has his Department given to local councils on the implementation of charges for inspecting the installation of loft insulation and cavity wall insulation.
(AQW 8919/08)

Mr N Dodds: The Building (Prescribed Fees) Regulations (Northern Ireland) 1997 (the "Fees Regulations") establish the types of building work that are subject to a fee and the amount of fee that may be levied.

The insertion of insulation material into a cavity wall of a building is exempt from fee. There is no such exemption for loft insulation, as the insertion of this material may impact consequentially upon other building matters such as roof space ventilation and which therefore normally requires inspection by a district council’s building control officers.

A district council may waive any fee if it feels it is appropriate to do so.

The Department will shortly be commencing a review of the Fees Regulations.

Rates Discounts
Mr Burns asked the Minister of Finance and Personnel why rates discounts are not available for single person households, in line with other regions of the United Kingdom.
(AQW 8968/08)

Mr N Dodds: The possibility of introducing a single person discount was considered as part of the Executive’s Review of the domestic rating system. However, it was felt that such a widespread discount would be difficult to justify in terms of cost, need and vulnerability to widespread fraud and therefore should not be introduced. This was supported by the Committee for Finance and Personnel.
A single person discount would cost in the region of £30m a year, which would have to be paid for either through other ratepayers paying more or revenue foregone. It is difficult to argue that single person households represent a vulnerable group requiring this level of support and no evidence of such was provided during the Executive Review.

Health, Social Services and Public Safety

Ministerial Visits
Mr Easton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many visits he made to North Down constituency in his first year in office.
(AQW 8430/08)

The Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (Mr M McGimpsey): I can advise that since the 8 May 2007 I have made 9 visits to the North Down Constituency area.

Review of Carers Support
Mr McNarry asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (i) what progress has been made on the review of carers support; and (ii) what is the Department's initial response to the National Strategy for Carers.
(AQW 8434/08)
Mr M McGimpsey: My officials are continuing to engage with their colleagues in the Department for Social Development to determine how best this joint review can be taken forward.

I welcome the launch of the National Strategy for Carers in England. Like our own strategy which was published in 2006, it recognises the vital role played by the many thousands of carers in our society and provides a framework for the development of services that carers need and deserve to enable them to continue in their caring role.

Departmental Restucturing
Mr McKay asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action he is taking to ensure that the restructuring of his Department is rural proofed.
(AQW 8466/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The Health and Social Care Reform Bill, which I introduced to the Assembly on 23 June, provides for the restructuring of the health and social care system, including the Department. Subject to the Assembly’s consideration of the Bill, the current guidance on rural screening and impact assessment will be taken fully into account in the implementation of the various provisions contained within the Bill, alongside any other impact assessments that are required, such as equality, environmental, health, regulatory, economic, human rights, social, victims, and community safety.

Cataract Operations
Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many cataract operations have been carried out in each of the last three years.
(AQW 8475/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The number of cataract operations carried out in Health and Social Care Hospitals in Northern Ireland in each of the past three years is detailed below:

Year

2004/2005

2005/2006

2006/2007

Cataract Operations

8,391

9,441

8,718

Source: Hospital Inpatient System

These figures do not relate to individuals, as a person may have more than one cataract procedure carried out in a year.

Cataract Operations.
Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many people have been waiting for (i) 3 to 6 months; (ii) 6 to 9 months; (iii) 9 to 12 months; and (iv) over 12 months, for a cataract operation (a) in total; and (b) broken down by Trust.
(AQW 8476/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Information on the number of people waiting over three months for a cataract operation in Northern Ireland, and in each of the five Health and Social Care Trusts, at 31^st March 2008, is detailed below.

Trust

Number of People Waiting (Monthly Timebands)

>3-6

>6-9

>9-12

12+

Belfast HSC Trust

554

0

0

0

South Eastern HSC Trust

24

0

0

0

Southern HSC Trust

29

0

0

0

Western HSC Trust

72

0

0

0

Northern Ireland Total

679

0

0

0

Source: DHSSPS Inpatient Waiting Times Dataset

Anorexia and Bulimia Nervosa
Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many new cases of (i) anorexia nervosa; and (ii) bulimia nervosa, were reported in each of the last three years.
(AQW 8477/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The information requested is not available.

Heroin Abuse
Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many people presented for treatment for heroin abuse for the first time in each of the last three years (i) in total; and (ii) broken down by Health and Social Care Trust.
(AQW 8478/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The table below shows how many people presented for treatment for heroin abuse for the first time in each of the last three years by Health and Social Care Trust.

Health and Social Care Trust

2004/05

2005/06

2006/07

Belfast

12

9

11

Northern

30

19

13

South Eastern

7

5

0

Southern

4

13

9

Western

4

3

6

Prison

6

1

2

Total

63

50

41

Sexually Transmitted Infections
Mr Simpson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many cases of (i) HIV; (ii) chlamydia; (iii) gonorrhoea; (iv) syphilis; (v) genital warts; (vi) genital herpes; and (vii) AIDS, have been diagnosed in each of the last three years.
(AQW 8479/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The number of cases of (i) HIV; (ii) chlamydia; (iii) gonorrhoea; (iv) syphilis; (v) genital warts; (vi) genital herpes; and (vii) AIDS which have been diagnosed in each of the last three years is given in the table below.

2004

2005

2006

HIV

62

62

56

Chlamydia

2,060

2,395

2,686

Gonorrhoea

159

277

292

Syphilis

67

87

82

Genital Herpes

328

366

418

Genital Warts

2,803

3,237

3,100

AIDS

<5

7

<5

Source: CDSC (NI)
Notes: The figures for Chlamydia, Gonorrhoea, Syphilis, Genital Warts and Genital Herpes are derived from statutory KC60 Returns made by NI Genito-Urinary Medicine (GUM) Clinics. These figures relate to episodes of diagnoses and/or treatment of infection or disease and not individual people. Thus one individual may contribute to more than one episode.

Renal Dialysis
Mr Storey asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many people will require renal dialysis in each of the next 3 years, broken down by Health and Social Care Trust.
(AQW 8482/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: We anticipate that around 40 additional patients will commence dialysis therapy throughout Northern Ireland in each of the next 3 years.

For planning purposes, this total is broken down by Health and Social Services Board based on the proportion of the population living in each board area as follows:

Eastern Health and Social Services Board - 16
Northern Health and Social Services Board - 10
Southern Health and Social Services Board - 8
Western Health and Social Services Board - 6

It is important to note however, that renal dialysis is a service required by relatively small numbers of patients and that actual numbers of patients may vary from year to year and may not be spread evenly across the Board areas.

Ambulance Service Pay Bands
Mr Storey asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to detail each pay band for Ambulance Service staff.
(AQW 8483/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Emergency ambulance service staff employed in the Northern Ireland Ambulance Service Trust are paid according to the job undertaken and are currently paid on the Agenda for Change pay bands as follows: Emergency Medical Technicians Band 4 (pay range £17,316 - £20,818) and Paramedics Band 5 (pay range £20,225 - £26,123). Staff in both these groups are set to have their jobs evaluated under the Agenda for Change job evaluation system. In the event that this evaluation process demonstrates that either of these jobs merits a higher pay band the Trust will adjust the salaries for the staff involved and make back payments to 1 October 2004. Rapid Response Paramedics will be moved to the Agenda for Change rates of pay when the job evaluation process is complete.

Midwives and Maternity Staff at Craigavon Area Hospital
Mr Moutray asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for an update on efforts to recruit midwives and maternity staff at Craigavon Area Hospital.
(AQW 8485/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Whilst specific recruitment and retention issues are a matter for the Health and Social Care trusts, the Southern Trust has assured me of a very positive response to recent advertisements in the press for Band 5/6 midwives. The Trust is confident that, following the interview process, the vacancies identified for staff midwives will be filled.

In addition, my Department is funding 10 Nursing Auxiliaries to train as Maternity Care Support Workers.

Ambulance Service Pay Increases
Mr Storey asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to detail the annual pay increase awards for each grade in the Ambulance Service, in each of the last 3 years; and how many staff were included in each award.
(AQW 8486/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: All staff in the Northern Ireland Ambulance Service, with the exception of senior executives, have received standard pay awards during the last 3 years in accordance with the terms and conditions introduced in the Health Service by the Agenda for Change initiative. Details for each year are shown in the table below:

YEAR

STAFF IN POST (WHOLE TIME EQUIVALENTS)

% PAY AWARD

2005/06

978

3.225

2006/07

1,039

2.5

2007/08

1,076

2.5

Adoption in Northern Ireland
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what plans he has to introduce legislation to take account of the recent House of Lords ruling on adoption in Northern Ireland.
(AQW 8535/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department is giving careful consideration to the recent House of Lords judgement to identify what implications it may have in taking forward our ongoing comprehensive reform of adoption legislation.

Home Help Staff
Mr Durkan asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety the number of Home Help staff in the WHSCT area (i) who are still to receive a back payment under the Agenda for Change HPSS pay system for work undertaken between (a) 1 October 2004 and April 2005; (b) April 2005 and March 2006; and (c) April 2006 and April 2007; and, (ii) who have received this payment already for the same three years?
(AQW 8542/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The information is not available in the format requested. However, I understand that all 1,278 Home Helps employed in the Western HSC Trust have received arrears due to them. 283 were paid arrears in November 2007, a further 614 were paid in May 2008 and the remaining 381 received arrears due to them at the end of June 2008.

Food Safety Promotion Board
Mr Easton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what plans he has to address the imbalances in, and the location of, jobs in the Food Safety Promotion Board.
(AQW 8552/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The review of North-South Implementation Bodies as provided for in the St Andrews Agreement is currently underway. The terms of reference for the review include an objective examination of the efficiency and value for money of existing Implementation Bodies.

It would not be appropriate for me to speculate about the outcome of the review.

Food Safety Promotion Board
Mr Easton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for his assessment of the efficiency savings that can be made in the Food Safety Promotion Board.
(AQW 8553/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The review of North-South Implementation Bodies as provided for in the St Andrews Agreement is currently underway. The terms of reference for the review include an objective examination of the efficiency and value for money of existing Implementation Bodies.

It would not be appropriate for me to speculate about the outcome of the review.

Genito-Urinary Medicine (GUM) Service at the Royal Victoria Hospital
Mrs Hanna asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many appointments are available each week at the Genito-urinary Medicine (GUM) drop-in service at the Royal Victoria Hospital; and the average number of people that are turned away each week.
(AQW 8571/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: There are 412 slots available on a weekly basis for both new and review GUM patients attending the Royal Victoria Hospital. The service operates Monday to Friday and, since April 2008, evening clinics on Tuesdays and Thursdays have been added to make the service more responsive to needs. Most clinics operate on a combination of booked appointments and a walk-in service.

The number of patients presenting on a walk-in basis who cannot be seen is not available.

Speech and Language Services
Mr McElduff asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (i) how many people who suffered a stroke have been left with the inability to speak or understand language in each of the last 3 years; and (ii) what services are available to these people, broken down by Health and Social Care Trust.
(AQW 8574/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: (i) The information requested is not available. (ii) All trusts have speech and language services; these are provided for patients with speech and language impairment on the basis of assessed need, including those needs arising from stroke. Following public consultation, the stroke strategy was launched on 9 June and it acknowledges that further work is required to provide specialist assessment, support and intervention in response to individual need. The recommendations will be implemented by 2010.

Agenda for Change
Mr Easton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if the implementation of Agenda for Change is now fully complete.
(AQW 8590/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The assimilation of staff to the new Agenda for Change rates of pay is complete and employers are continuing with the process of calculating arrears due to staff from 1 October 2004. There is a small number of staff where there are grading issues to be resolved and they are most likely to be subject to job evaluation; for those staff the process continues. There is also a number of staff that have requested that their employer carries out a review of their grading and for those staff this part of the implementation process also continues.

Cost of Maliciously Started Fires
Mr Hilditch asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many maliciously started fires the Fire and Rescue Service has attended in the Borough of Carrickfergus, in each of the last 3 years; and what costs were incurred.
(AQW 8611/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The table shows the number of ‘deliberate’/’malicious’ incidents attended by the Northern Ireland Fire and Rescue Service in the Carrickfergus Station area together with the estimated cost for the last 3 years.

Year

No of ‘Deliberate’/ ‘Malicious’ Fires

Cost

2007/08

370

£808,000

2006/07

285

£634,000

2005/06

181

£374,000

Information on Drug and Alcohol Abuse in Schools
Mr Hilditch asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action he is taking to alert young people to the dangers of drug and alcohol abuse; and what information is being provided in schools.
(AQW 8618/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The New Strategic Direction for Alcohol and Drugs (NSD), which was launched in 2006, identified providing education and information for young people as a priority. Regionally, a range of public information campaigns have been undertaken to provide more information to children and young people on the dangers of alcohol and drug misuse – along with the publication of a range of targeted leaflets and websites.

At the local level, in support of the New Strategic Direction for Alcohol and Drugs, the four Health Board-based Drug and Alcohol Co-ordination Teams commission and fund a range of services, initiatives and programmes in support of their own local action plans. These provide support to children and young people's groups that are working directly and/or indirectly towards improving young people’s awareness of the dangers of alcohol and/or drug misuse.

Examples include:

Targeted education and prevention programmes aimed at vulnerable and at risk young people and adults across the localities;
Community & Family Support Services;
Cross-sectoral Training Programmes;
Alternative Criminal Justice Options; and
Drug and alcohol outreach services.

In respect of schools, the Department of Education has policies in place to educate and support young people and has issued guidance to all schools on drugs education, including alcohol. Schools are required to have a drugs policy, including education on alcohol and drugs misuse. Education boards provide support to schools and youth clubs with dedicated drug and alcohol education officers.

In addition, the revised curriculum gives every young person the chance to learn about the dangers of drinking and illicit drug use. It allows them to develop the skills they need to deal with peer pressure and the problems that may drive them to drugs and alcohol in the first place. This is supported through schools’ pastoral care arrangements, including the new school counselling service.

Clostridium Difficile
Mr Spratt asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many (i) cases of clostridium difficile; and (ii) deaths resulting from clostridium difficile, have occurred in the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust in each of the last 3 years, broken down by hospital.
(AQW 8635/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The number of cases of clostridium difficile and the number of deaths resulting from clostridium difficile in the Belfast HSC Trusts for the previous three calendar years are as follows;

Cases of Clostridum difficile which have occurred in the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust broken down by hospital.

2005

2006

2007

Royal Victoria Hospital

109

108

89

Belfast City Hospital

165

167

107

Green Park

12

22

11

Mater Infirmorum Hospital

32

88

45

Cancer Centre

0

0

13

(ii) Number of deaths with Clostridium difficile mentioned on the death certificate by hospital within the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust and registration year, 2005-2007.

Place of Death

Registration Year

2005

2006

2007^P

Royal Group of Hospitals

2

1

5

Belfast City Hospital

3

8

8

Forester Green Hospital

-

-

-

Mater Infirmorum Hospital

-

2

1

Musgrave Park Hospital

1

1

-

All other Hospital

29

51

63

All Clostridium Difficile Related Deaths Registered in all places

35

63

77

^{P Data for 2007 remains provisional until the publication of the 2007 Annual Report of the Registrar General due to be released in November 2008

Support for Stroke Sufferers
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action his Department is taking to improve the support available to people with communication difficulties as a result of suffering a stroke.
(AQW 8662/08)
Mr M McGimpsey: Following public consultation, the stroke strategy was launched on 9 June and it acknowledges that further work is required to provide specialist assessment, support and intervention in community settings in response to individual need. The recommendations include enhanced availability of speech and language therapy will be implemented by 2010.

Health Centre Phonecall Targets
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if Health Centres have targets for responding to phone calls.
(AQW 8664/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Health centres do not have targets for responding to phone calls. The Department has directed that Health and Social Services Boards offer an access enhanced service to all GP practices. The specification of this service includes a requirement that telephone systems should be able to cope with the normal volume of calls from patients and where there is a delay in answering calls, patients should be informed within a reasonable time about the situation.
>
Health Centre Call Charges
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action he is taking to ensure that Health Centres do not charge callers a premium rate.
(AQW 8665/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: In August 2005 the Department, in line with the rest of the UK, introduced legislative amendments to the General Medical Services Contract. These amendments prevent GPs, who provide primary medical services to the public under contract to the Health and Social Services Boards, from being party to any contract or other arrangement under which the number for telephone services to be used by patients starts with the digits 087, 090, or 091 or consists of a personal number (personal number means a telephone number which starts with the number 070 followed by a further 8 digits), unless the service is provided free to the caller.

Health Centre Call Charges
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety which Health Centres use call waiting phone systems that charge callers premium rates for their calls.
(AQW 8667/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: No health centres managed by Health and Social Care Trusts use telephone systems, which charge callers premium rates for their calls.

Free Car Parking
Mr B Wilson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if Health Trusts have fully implemented his proposals that patients suffering from cancer and other serious illnesses and their next-of-kin would receive free car parking, as outlined in his press statement of 21 May 2008.
(AQW 8669/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Trusts are currently working to put in place the necessary operational arrangements to fully implement these proposals by September 2008.

Community Carers
Ms Anderson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to make a statement on the future role of community carers; and whether those currently providing this service have been told not to reapply for their positions if they do not have a valid driving licence.
(AQW 8704/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Domiciliary care workers are vital to the current and future provision of services as we strive to provide support where the vulnerable members of our society want it most, and that is in their own homes. We are currently supporting more people in their own homes than in any other setting and I want to see that trend increase further. It is essential therefore that we have domiciliary care workforce which is regulated and trained to ensure the highest possible quality of care, and that domiciliary care workers are given the recognition they deserve for the important work that they do. My Department is currently taking steps to address these issues.

I have been advised by the HSC that no current HSC-employed domiciliary care workers have been told that they must secure a valid driving licence to continue their employment. It will be for each independent provider of domiciliary care to determine their own terms and conditions of employment within the context of their legal responsibilities.

People Receiving Physiotherapy from the SEHSCT Unit at Market Street in Downpatrick
Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many people are presently in receipt of physiotherapy from the SEHSCT unit located at Market Street in Downpatrick.
(AQW 8716/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The SEHSCT reported that the total physiotherapy caseload in their unit located at Market Street in Downpatrick was 134 (122 children and 12 adults) at 1^st July 2008.

Pay Changes for Medical Staff
Mr Durkan asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for an update on the progress made under Agenda for Change in changing pay for paramedics and emergency medical technicians; and when this process will be concluded.
(AQW 8729/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: I refer the member to the response I gave to AQW 7925/08 answered on 24 June 2008.

Sports Clubs and Defibrillators
Mr Ross asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what is the training offered to sports clubs that purchase their own defibrillators.
(AQW 8736/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The Department of Health and Social Services and Public Safety has no statutory responsibility to offer training to sports clubs that purchase their own defibrillators.

Post Offices Delivering Services
Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by his Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.
(AQW 8738/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of postal services and the Post Office network. In the area of health and social care, the Post Office can play an important role in the provision of information and advice to the public. One example is the application for a European Health Insurance Card, which can be obtained at Post Offices. People can also use a Post Office service called "check and send" for this, in which Post Office staff will assist with the completion of the form. The utilisation of the Post office network for the provision of such information and assistance is kept under review by my Department.

Gynaecologist Employed by Belfast Health and Social Care Trust
Ms Ní Chuilín asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to confirm that the gynaecologist who has been the subject of recent reporting in the local press no longer works in any capacity for the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust.
(AQW 8756/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: This gynaecologist is employed within the Belfast Health and Social Care Trust, but is working in a different capacity and in a carefully supervised role.

Procedures in Ulster hospital
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action is being taken to review procedures in the Ulster Hospital, in particular the handling of laundry, to ensure the avoidance of contamination and infection.
(AQW 8759/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Procedures for the handling of laundry in the Ulster Hospital are kept under continual review to ensure everything possible is being done to ensure the safety of patients, visitors and staff. These procedures are based on the NHS Guidance document, HSG (95)18; Hospital Laundry Arrangements for Used and Infected linen, which is applied in Northern Ireland. The Ulster Hospital Linen Services Department has been ISO 9000/2000 accredited with the British Standards Institute since 1998 and as part of this accreditation, all procedures are reviewed at least annually.

Procedures and Infections in Hospitals
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action is being taken to reduce contamination and infection in hospitals, particularly in the handling of laundry.
(AQW 8760/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: On 28 January 2008 I announced a £9 million investment in a range of measures including MRSA screening for high risk patients; a regional hand hygiene campaign; and unannounced hygiene inspections; with the aim of further reducing contamination and infection in hospitals. There are already rigorous policies and procedures in place to ensure that laundry is handled in a manner which seeks to ensure that infection risks to staff, patients and visitors are minimised.

Hospital Workers and Protective Clothing
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what protective clothing is provided to van drivers dealing with hospital laundry.
(AQW 8762/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: All hospital laundry is bagged and infectious linen is double bagged. The risk of transport staff being in contact with dirty linen is therefore small and protective clothing should not be necessary. Nevertheless gloves are normally offered to van drivers dealing with hospital laundry.

Homehelp Care Worker Absences
Mr Gallagher asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (i) how many people were employed by the Western Health and Social Care Trust as home-help/domiciliary care workers; (ii) how many of these workers have been on sick leave for periods of more than 1 week; and (iii) how many of these workers were absent for periods of more than 1 month, in 2007-08.
(AQW 8768/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Information been supplied directly from the Western Health and Social Care Trust.

Year

Number of staff employed as homehelp/domiciliary care workers

2007/08

1527

Year

Number of staff with days lost more than 5

Number of staff with days lost more than 20

2007/08

112

91

I have asked the Western Health and Social Care Trust to look into the levels of sick leave reported.

Gardasil Vaccination
Mr McCarthy asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if his Department is aware of a vaccination called Gardasil, which is available for the human papillomavirus vaccination programme due to commence in September 2008.
(AQW 8770/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department is aware of the vaccination ‘Gardasil’ which protects against human papillomavirus (HPV).

Review of Department of Health Decision
Mr McCarthy asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if he will review the decision made by the GB Department of Health to offer young women a bivalent human papillomavirus vaccine.
(AQW 8771/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: It is not my intention to review the decision made by the Department of Health (London). A robust adjudication process was carried out by the Department of Health, on behalf of the four UK nations. This process carefully examined the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines offered, against a wide range of criteria such as their scientific qualities, technical attributes and cost effectiveness. The criteria used for the adjudication process had been shared in advance with both companies that tendered. Based on the national procurement process Cervarix was chosen.

The purpose of the HPV immunisation programme is cancer prevention. Cervarix protects against HPV types 16 and 18, which cause 70% of cervical cancer cases.

Review of Public Administration
Mr McCarthy asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how regional health bodies will function after the Review of Public Administration, including the division between the Director of Public Health and Chief Medical Officer.
(AQW 8773/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The Health and Social Care (Reform) Bill, which passed its Second Stage in the Assembly on 1 July 2008, sets out the new overarching structures for Health and Social Care.

The Bill requires the Department to produce a Framework Document, which will cover all health and socials care bodies. To produce this document further work is being undertaken by my Department to define system wide functions, roles and responsibilities.

Councillors on Regional Health Bodies
Mr McCarthy asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what plans he has to involve councillors on the new regional health bodies; and what consideration has been given to the potential clashes of interest, given the accountability role of District Councils.
(AQW 8774/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: I can confirm my intention to ensure local government representation in the Regional Agency for Public Health and Social Well-being and the Patient and Client Council. There will also be 4 locally elected representatives on each of the 5 Local Commissioning Groups of the Regional Health and Social Care Board.

A number of responses to the February 2008 consultation document, "Proposals for Health and Social Care Reform" raised the issue of how local councillors would be appointed to the new organisations. Similar considerations are underway in other Departments and I therefore wish to take account of these and engage with the NI Local Government Association before reaching final decisions.

Cervarix Vaccine
Mr McCarthy asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if he has noted the disappointment expressed by patients' groups on the recent decision by the GB Department of Health to choose Cervarix as the vaccine for the human papillomarvirus vaccination to commence in September 2008; and if he will outline how the vaccine was chosen.
(AQW 8775/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The purpose of the HPV (human papillomavirus) immunisation programme is cancer prevention. Cervarix protects against HPV types 16 and 18, which cause 70% of cervical cancer cases. There are approximately 80 new cases of cervical cancer diagnosed annually in Northern Ireland with 30 – 40 deaths each year. The announcement of a national vaccination programme to protect young women from their future risk of cervical cancer should be viewed positively by all groups.

The contract to provide the vaccine against HPV was awarded by the Department of Health to pharmaceutical company GlaxoSmithKline for their vaccine ‘Cervarix’, following an EU procurement exercise.

A robust adjudication process was carried out by the Department of Health (L), on behalf of the four nations. This process carefully examined the vaccines offered, against a wide range of criteria such as their scientific qualities, technical aspects and cost effectiveness. The criteria used for the adjudication had been shared in advance with the companies which tendered. Based on the national procurement process Cervarix was chosen.

Halloween Bonfire Damage
Mr Moutray asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many complaints his Department has received in relation to the possible damage to public health caused by Halloween bonfires in each of the last five years.
(AQW 8805/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department has received no complaints in this regard.

Health and Social Care Councils
Mr McCarthy asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety when a final decision must be made on the number of Health and Social Care councils.
(AQW 8813/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: In my announcement to the Assembly on the 1 July 2008, I confirmed that I am replacing the four existing Health and Social Services Councils with a single, independent regional body – the Patient and Client Council. This new body will have five area committees operating within the same geographical areas as the five integrated trusts, to provide a strong regional and local voice on behalf of patients, clients, carers and communities.

Out-of-Hours Provision in Strabane
Mrs McGill asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what the outcome was of the benchmarking exercise undertaken by the Primary Care Foundation into out-of-hours provision; and to give an assurance that out-of-hours provision in Strabane will be retained.
(AQW 8819/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Currently all Out of Hours (OOH) services in Northern Ireland are subject to a review looking at their efficiency and effectiveness. The benchmarking exercise is part of the review process. During the exercise the Primary Care Foundation collected data across a broad range of indicators from both Northern Ireland and benchmark partners in other parts of the UK. This will provide a basis of evidence supporting the options for discussion in order to determine the most appropriate way forward for OOHs. Officials will be meeting with the Board sponsors of the project over the next few weeks to discuss the results of the benchmarking exercise and the proposed way forward. It is expected that the final review will be published later this year. This being the case, no decisions have been made, although no commitment can be given at this time that there will be no change to the Strabane OOH service in the future.

Agenda for Change Rates of Pay
Mr I McCrea asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if his target date of 30 June for Health and Social Care Employers to have all staff on ‘Agenda for Change’ rates of pay has been met.
(AQW 8837/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Yes, the target date of 30 June 2008 for the assimilation of staff to the new Agenda for Change rates of pay has been met. Health and Social Care employers are continuing with the process of calculating arrears due to staff from 1 October 2004. There is a small number of staff where there are grading issues to be resolved and they are most likely to be subject to job evaluation; for those staff the process continues. There is also a number of staff that have requested that their employer carries out a review of their grading and for those staff this part of the implementation process also continues.

Health Trust Solicitors
Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to list the solicitors appointed by each Health Board and Health and Social Care Trust to deal with compensation claims; and to confirm if their appointment was made using public procurement processes.
(AQW 8839/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The information you requested is provided in the attached table:

HSS Organisation

Legal Firms appointed to handle compensation claims

Appointment made using pubic procurement processes

Eastern Health and Social Services Board

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Yes

Northern Health and Social Services Board

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

No

Southern Health and Social Services Board

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Yes

Western Health and Social Services Board

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Yes

Belfast Health and Social Care Trust

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

MSC Daly, Solicitors

Carson McDowell, Solicitors

Fisher & Fisher, Solicitors

Yes

No

Yes

Yes

South Eastern Health and Social Care Trust

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Carson McDowell, Solicitors

Yes

Yes

Northern Health and Social Care Trust

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Yes

Southern Health and Social Care Trust

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Carson McDowell, Solicitors

Yes

Yes

Western Health and Social Care Trust

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Yes

Northern Ireland Ambulance Service

Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency

Yes

With the exception of the Northern Board and Belfast Trust, legal firms used are those appointed under the Framework. The appointment of the Directorate of Legal Services by the Northern Board and MSC Daly by the Belfast Trust to handle compensation claims was not made under a public procurement process as in both cases claims were transferring from Brangam Bagnall & Co, following its closure by the Law Society and pressing time constraints did not permit this to be undertaken.

Dental Services in Randalstown
Mr Burns asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to detail all dental services available in Randalstown; and to state which dentists provide Health Service treatment.
(AQW 8842/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Currently there are 2 dental practices employing 8 dentists in Randalstown who are all registered on the dental list of the Central Services Agency (CSA) to facilitate the undertaking of health service dentistry. An analysis of health service claims shows that all 8 dentists have been actively providing health service dentistry over the past 12 months. However, under current contractual arrangements, there is no obligation on dentists to accept patients for health service treatment, or to continue to offer health service treatment to existing patients, and the situation can change at any time. Dental practices in Randalstown (as elsewhere) are under no obligation to inform their local Health and Social Services Board of those patients whom they are treating under the health service or under a private contract.

The Community Dental Service provides health service dental care to three private nursing homes in Randalstown, which includes care for patients with a learning disability.

The Northern Board have advised that there are Health Service dentists in both Ballymena and Antrim who are still accepting Health Service patients.

Treatment for Parkinson's Sufferers
Mr Burns asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for his assessment of the availability of treatment for patients with Parkinson’s Disease and to provide a comparison of available resources, including beds and nurse to patient ratios, between Northern Ireland and other regions of the UK.
(AQW 8844/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: People with Parkinson’s disease may be referred to consultants in the neurology or care of the elderly specialties for diagnosis, treatment and monitoring. Care may also be managed by their GP. Most people with Parkinson’s disease are treated with medication; however, when drug treatment is not suitable for a patient, surgery may be considered. Patients may access a wide spectrum of health and social care based on their individual assessed needs and the severity of their illness, including primary and community care, acute hospital care, physiotherapy, speech and language therapy and occupational therapy.

It is not possible to quantify the resources available to people with Parkinson’s disease. Health and social care resources are normally allocated on a service or Programme of Care basis rather than by specific medical condition. My Department does not hold information on the levels of resources available to patients with Parkinson’s disease in other parts of the UK.

Resources for Parkinson's Disease
Mr Burns asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what plans he has to direct additional resources towards treating Parkinson’s disease.
(AQW 8845/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: It is the responsibility of the Health and Social Services Boards to plan and allocate resources to meet the needs of their local population, including those with Parkinson’s disease. In determining their priorities for funding, Boards will take into account local circumstances, the strategic objectives established for the HSC, and competing demands and pressures for a wide range of health and social care services generally.

In June 2007 my Department issued a circular endorsing a National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence clinical guideline on the management of Parkinson’s disease in primary and secondary care. I would expect the HSC to take account of the guideline in the future planning and delivery of services to those diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease.

Tarceva Drug
Mr Dallat asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety when he intends to make the drug Tarceva available on the Health Service.
(AQW 8849/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) is currently appraising Tarceva (erlotinib) for the treatment of non-small-cell lung cancer, and issued its Final Appraisal Determination on the 24 April 2008. Subject to appeals against this determination, NICE expect to publish final guidance in November 2008.

My Department has established a link with NICE whereby all guidance published by the Institute from 1 July 2006 is reviewed locally for its applicability to Northern Ireland and, where appropriate, is endorsed by the Department for implementation in Northern Ireland. The guidance on Tarceva will be considered under local arrangements when NICE publishes its final guidance in November 2008.

Funding for People with Learning Disabilities
Mr Bresland asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what funding has been provided by his Department for people with learning disabilities, broken down by Health and Social Services Board, in each of the last four financial years.
(AQW 8855/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The spending, by Health and Social Service Board, on learning disabilities in the last four available years was as follows:

Year

2003-04

2004-05

2005-06

2006-07

£000s

£000s

£000s

£000s

Eastern Board

60,946

63,052

66,220

69,022

Northern Board

27,731

34,560

35,081

36,782

Southern Board

28,841

31,457

33,896

34,832

Western Board

19,455

20,676

23,249

24,424

136,973

149,744

158,445

165,060

Air Quality in Sydenham
Mr Newton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (i) what action he is taking in relation to perceived health problems due to air quality within Sydenham district; and (ii) what are the causes of the air quality problems.
(AQW 8871/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department is not aware of any health problems associated with air quality in the Sydenham area.

Stroke Patients' Survey
Mr McGlone asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if he is aware of the results of the survey carried out by the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapists into communication needs of stroke patients, published on 5 March 2008; and what measures are being put in place as a result of the survey's findings.
(AQW 8885/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: I am aware of the Royal College of Speech and Language Therapy’s survey. After a period of consultation, the DHSSPS Stroke Strategy was published on 9 June. The Regional Implementation Group, which I have asked to be established, will be expected to take account of the recommendations contained within the 'Lost Without Words' report and Royal College of Speech and Language Therapy’s survey. The Strategy sets a target that by 31 March 2010 every stroke patient should have access to appropriate community rehabilitation including specialist assessment, advice, support and intervention. This includes communication needs.

Hospital Admissions for Stab Wounds
Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many hospital admissions there have been for stab wounds, in each of the last 5 years.
(AQW 8886/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Hospital admissions with a diagnosis of stab wound are shown in the table below.

Year

Admissions

2002/03

194

2003/04

164

2004/05

183

2005/06

157

2006/07

171

Source: Hospital Inpatient System

Deaths and discharges are used as an approximation of admissions. These figures should not be used to denote individuals as a person may be admitted to hospital more than once in a year, or across a number of years.

Home Start in Newry & Armagh
Mr Irwin asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what areas are covered by the Home Start organisations in the Newry and Armagh constituency.
(AQW 8891/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department currently provides core funding for central administration costs to Home Start NI in its capacity as a regional voluntary organisation that provides training, information, guidance and support to 25 local schemes across Northern Ireland. In 2008/09 this funding will amount to £49,190.

DHSSPS is currently supporting four locally-based Home Start schemes which were previously funded through the Children’s Fund – Home Start Ards, Comber and Peninsula, Home Start Down District, Home Start Newry and Mourne and Home Start Armagh and Dungannon. We will continue to fund these until March 2009. We do not support any Home Start activity in the Poyntzpass area, and have no plans to do so.

Individual Home Start schemes provide local service delivery and as such fall within the responsibility of the Health and Social Services Boards and Trusts. Therefore, it is a matter for them to consider the provision of support for local schemes.

Home Start in Poyntzpass
Mr Irwin asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what plans he has to include the Poyntzpass area in the Home Start remit.
(AQW 8892/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department currently provides core funding for central administration costs to Home Start NI in its capacity as a regional voluntary organisation that provides training, information, guidance and support to 25 local schemes across Northern Ireland. In 2008/09 this funding will amount to £49,190.

DHSSPS is currently supporting four locally-based Home Start schemes which were previously funded through the Children’s Fund – Home Start Ards, Comber and Peninsula, Home Start Down District, Home Start Newry and Mourne and Home Start Armagh and Dungannon. We will continue to fund these until March 2009. We do not support any Home Start activity in the Poyntzpass area, and have no plans to do so.

Individual Home Start schemes provide local service delivery and as such fall within the responsibility of the Health and Social Services Boards and Trusts. Therefore, it is a matter for them to consider the provision of support for local schemes.

Capital Investment
Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to detail the strategic capital investment for projects in excess of £5m, in each Health and Social Care Trust area, over the past five years.
(AQW 8893/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Capital investment over the past 5 years for projects in excess of £5m is detailed by Trust area in the table below. There were no capital projects in excess of £5m in the Northern Trust or Northern Ireland Ambulance Service Trust. I have recently commissioned a review of capital investment priorities over the next ten years, which is expected to be completed by September.

TRUST

PROJECT DETAILS

CAPITAL EXPENDITURE IN LAST 5 YEARS
(2003-2008)
(£m)

Belfast

Muckamore Abbey Redevelopment

15.4

Belfast

Health & Wellbeing Centres in North & West Belfast (Grove, Carlisle, Shankill, Beechhall)

19.5

Belfast

Community Treatment & Care Centres (Holywood Arches, Bradbury Place, Castlereagh)

18.7

Belfast

Regional Secure Unit, Knockbracken

8.3

Belfast

Regional Acquired Brain Injury Unit, Musgrave Park

9.5

Belfast

Regional Cancer Centre, Belfast City Hospital (inc car park)

52.4

Belfast

RVH Redevelopment - including Imaging Centre, Receipt & Distribution Centre, Critical Care building)

53.1

Belfast

RVH Central Decontamination Unit

11.6

Belfast

Victoria Pharmaceuticals

0.7

TOTAL BELFAST TRUST

189.2

TRUST

PROJECT DETAILS

CAPITAL EXPENDITURE IN LAST 5 YEARS
(2003-2008)
(£m)

South Eastern

Downe Hospital

32.1

South Eastern

Ulster Hospital Redevelopment Phase A

71.6

South Eastern

Lakewood Adolescent Secure Unit

8.8

South Eastern

Bayview - replacement day care facilities for the elderly

5.3

TOTAL SOUTH EASTERN TRUST

117.8

Southern

Mental Health Inpatient Unit at CAH (Bluestone Unit)

13.3

Southern

Trauma & Orthopaedics Unit at CAH

5.7

Southern

Portadown Health & Care Centre

3.5

TOTAL SOUTHERN TRUST

22.5

Western

Stradreagh - replacement hospital based facilities for people with learning disabilities

5.1

Western

South West Hospital (inc land purchase, enabling works, project mgt costs)

24.2

Western

Omagh Local Hospital (inc land purchase, enabling works, project mgt costs)

16.5

Western

Altnagelvin Hospital

43.9

Western

Altnagelvin - Laboratories & Pharmacy Unit

18

TOTAL WESTERN TRUST

107.7

Increasing Costs of Fuel
Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what proposals his Department has to meet the increasing fuel costs incurred by Health and Social Care Trusts.
(AQW 8894/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: I recognise that it is important that all practicable steps are taken to ensure that the recent increases in fuel costs have minimal impact on the provision of health and social care services. It is an integral part of the financial management of health and social care facilities and services that all cost increases, whether or not they are foreseeable, are managed within available resources

My Department has considered the impact of the recent increases on the Health and Social Care Trusts and I can confirm that I have made available a further £8m to help Trusts cope with the rising costs of fuel.

Nursing Vacancies
Mr Easton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for a breakdown of current nursing vacancies, by (i) Grade Band; (ii) Health Trust; and (iii) specialty.
(AQW 8898/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: (i) Information in the form requested is not readily available and could only be provided at disproportionate cost.

(ii) Information on the number of Nursing Vacancies by Health and Social Care Trust as at 30^th September 2007 is given in the table below.

Table 1: Number of Nursing Vacancies by Health & Social Care Trust as at 30^th September 2007.

Health & Social Care Trust

Qualified Nursing Staff

Nurse Support Staff

All Nursing Staff

Headcount

WTE

Headcount

WTE

Headcount

WTE

Belfast

121

109.0

98

89.0

219

198.0

Northern

73

68.7

26

18.7

99

87.5

South Eastern

23

17.4

3

1.5

26

18.9

Southern

61

53.6

17

14.1

78

67.7

Western

21

19.5

1

1.0

22

20.5

Other Organisations

4

4.0

0

0.0

4

4.0

Total

303

272.2

145

124.4

448

396.5

Source: NI Health and Social Care Organisations.
Notes:

A current vacancy is an unoccupied post, which at 30^th September 2007 was vacant and which the organisation was actively trying to fill.
WTE = Whole-Time Equivalent
Survey figures are now finalised following completion of validation exercise.

(ii) Information in the form requested is not readily available and could only be provided at disproportionate cost.

Newry Day Care Centre
Mr D Bradley asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what progress has been made in the provision of a Social Education Centre for Newry.
(AQW 8903/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The new Day Care Centre in Newry remains a high priority for my Department. The Southern Trust has advised that planning consent for the scheme is expected on 11^th July, subject to final sign off by Newry & Mourne Council. The construction of the new Centre is expected to commence in early 2009.

Cardiovascular Health and Wellbeing Service Framework
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety for an update on which service development frameworks are currently being pursued.
(AQW 8911/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The Cardiovascular Health and Wellbeing Service Framework is the first service framework to be developed for Northern Ireland, and it has recently been launched for public consultation. This consultation is due to finish on 30^th September 2008. The Framework will then be finalised and it is anticipated to be launched for implementation before the end of this year.

There are currently four more Service Frameworks in preparation at various stages of development. These are;
Respiratory Health and Wellbeing,
Cancer Prevention, Treatment and Care,
Mental Health and Wellbeing, and
Learning Disability.

It is anticipated that additional areas for Service Framework development will be taken forward in 2009/10.

Maternity Units
Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety to outline the revised training for midwives in the use of electronic foetal monitoring following the deaths of two babies at Antrim Area Hospital.
(AQW 8933/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The Department has asked all maternity units across the province to address a number of areas in training, including the use of electronic foetal monitoring equipment. All five Trusts are complying with these requests.

Midwives are trained in the use of Electronic Foetal Monitoring during their undergraduate studies. In addition to undergraduate training, annual training in Electronic Foetal Monitoring is mandatory.

Recently my Department issued a letter to the five Trusts on "The Use and Interpretation of Cardiotocography in Intrapartum Foetal Surveillance - Advice to Midwives". This letter outlined a number of issues to be addressed including Electronic Foetal Monitoring. All Trusts are currently in the process of complying with the measures set out in the letter.

Medical Records
Mr Hamilton asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what procedures are in place to deal with lost records or where breaches in the Data Protection Act have occurred in relation to medical records; and how many lost or breached medical record incidents have been recorded in each of the last 5 years.
(AQW 8934/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Organisations holding medical records have records management procedures in place that are based on guidance issued by the Department. The organisations all have incident recording systems in place and where medical records have been lost or a DPA breach has been reported the incident is investigated and appropriate action is taken.

The number of recorded lost medical records incidents and the number of recorded Data Protection Act breaches relating to medical records in each of the last five years is shown in the table below. Not all organisations could supply information for 2003/04 and 2004/05 so figures for those years are incomplete.

2003/04

2004/05

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Number of Incidents relating to lost Medical Records

3

0

25

32

39

Number of Incidents of DPA breaches relating to Medical Records

1

2

2

1

2

Infant Deaths
Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what procedures have been put in place to safeguard the health of maternity patients and prevent a repeat of the circumstances that led to the deaths of two babies at Antrim Area Hospital.
(AQW 8935/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Subsequent to the deaths of two infants at Antrim Area Hospital, the Northern Trust has commissioned an independent review of maternity services in their area, the outcome of which will help identify any action which can be taken to prevent such incidents in future.

The Northern Trust has also advised that they continuously review factors surrounding any adverse outcome to make sure that appropriate action is taken to reduce the risks to other mothers and babies. Furthermore, the Trust has implemented the Physiological Early Warning System (PEWS) in maternity services which will alert staff to the need for immediate action with patients who display signs of requiring urgent medical intervention.

In addition, the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) published a clinical guideline on Intrapartum Care in September 2007.

My Department has established a link with NICE whereby all guidance published by the Institute from 1 July 2006 is reviewed locally for its applicability to Northern Ireland and, where appropriate, is endorsed by the Department for implementation in Northern Ireland.

The clinical guideline on intrapartum care has been considered under these arrangements, and my Department will advise local health and social care organisations of the outcome of this shortly.

I also draw the Member’s attention to the answer to Assembly Question AQW/8933/2008.

Support for Bereaved Parents
Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what support the Health Service provideS to bereaved parents following the death of a baby close to the time of birth.
(AQW 8936/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The care and support provided to bereaved parents will depend on their individual needs and circumstances. As part of the implementation of the Human Organ Enquiry recommendations, the Department issued a care pathway entitled "Care Plan for Women who experience a Miscarriage, Stillbirth or Neonatal Death". Trusts offer a wide range of support consistent with the recommendations of this care plan.

Each of the Trusts has in place an appropriate staff contact / contacts for families who experience the loss of a baby. These staff can guide the parents through arrangements and procedures and are a point of contact if the parents have any concerns they wish to discuss. Full support is provided and parents are given advice on how to avail of counselling if they choose to do so.

Infant Deaths
Mrs I Robinson asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many infant deaths have there have been in midwifery-led services over the last five years.
(AQW 8937/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The number of infant deaths in midwifery-led services over the last five years is not available.

Ambulance Funding
Mr Craig asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what cutbacks are planned for the Northern Ireland Ambulance Service to meet the 3% savings figures; how these cutbacks will effect frontline services; and which services will be affected.
(AQW 8944/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: My Department is currently finalising challenging efficiencies amounting to £118m/£233m/£344m by 2010/11, as part of the Executive Committee’s agreed approach to the Comprehensive Spending Review.

There are no plans to cut ambulance funding. I have yet to see and consider the Trust’s proposals in respect of 2009/10 and 2010/11.

Dial an Angel Scheme
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what consideration his Department has given to the introduction of a scheme similar to the 'Dial an Angel' scheme in Australia.
(AQW 8963/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The ‘Dial an Angel’ scheme is a privately run enterprise which provides a wide range of domestic services, the core of which, insofar as they represent what we would regard as social care services, are broadly equivalent to those already provided by Health and Social Care Trusts. I have not therefore given consideration to the introduction of such a scheme. I do, however, expect the HSC to be innovative in service delivery, wherever possible, and to learn from best practice elsewhere.

Needs Assessment
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action his Department is taking to ensure flexibility in the Home Care provision for the elderly, so that the help given meets the needs of those that require assistance with independent living.
(AQW 8964/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The need to respond to the wishes of individuals to lead independent lives in the community, with appropriate support from Health and Social Care Trusts, is at the heart of my Department’s community care policy. I have sent a very clear signal to the HSC that services must be flexible and respond sensitively and appropriately to the assessed needs of service users and carers. Service users and carers have these assessed needs reviewed at least annually or more often if necessary to ensure the services they receive continue to meet their needs.

Care Workers
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what action his Department is taking to ensure that those in receipt of Home Care have the same care worker on a regular basis.
(AQW 8965/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: I expect Health and Social Care Trusts to ensure, wherever possible, that care is delivered by the same care workers. I recognise, however, that factors such as availability, reliability, changing needs of service users and competence of care workers may mean that this is not always possible. Where it is not, I expect the HSC to ensure that high quality alternative service provision is available.

CSR Funding
Mr Weir asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what provision is being made for changes to respite care to ensure that more people can achieve independent living.
(AQW 8966/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The additional funding I secured under the Comprehensive Spending Review will be used to provide a range of additional services including: 200 new or enhanced learning disability respite packages by 2011, which will provide 800 people with respite care; 200 new or enhanced physical and sensory disability respite packages by 2011; 2,000 additional dementia respite places by 2011; and the development of a range of flexible and responsive community care services to support an additional 1,500 older people in the community.

Role of GPs
Mr Spratt asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety what steps he is taking to stop attempts by some GPs who seek to charge patients for signing SmartPass applications.
(AQW 8969/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: In 2002, as part of the UK Government’s commitment to reduce unnecessary approaches to GPs for non-clinical purposes, and therefore increase their availability for the delivery of clinical appointments, and treatment and care to patients, the Cabinet Office Regulatory Impact Unit, in their Report "Making a Difference – GP Report 2", recommended that GPs be removed from the list of authorised counter-signatories for a range of social and welfare-related administrative processes such as passport and driving licence applications.

There is no list of specific counter-signatories required for the completion of SmartPass applications: those fulfilling this task simply need to know the applicant and not be a relative. The signature of a GP is not required for any category of SmartPass within the Northern Ireland Concessionary Fares Scheme and the provision of such services by GPs is not covered in the General Medical Services contract between GPs and Health and Social Care in Northern Ireland.

GPs, as independent contractors to Health and Social Care, retain the choice to provide services outside the scope of primary care medical services, such as counter-signatures, and can charge a fee for this should they wish to do so. However, this is a private matter between the GP and the individual.

Dentists in South Belfast
Mr Spratt asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many dentists there are in the South Belfast constituency who offer Health Service treatment, broken down by electoral ward.
(AQW 8970/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: The information requested is shown in table 1 below:

Table 1 Number of dentists¹ offering Health Service dental treatment² in the South Belfast constituency, by electoral ward.

Electoral Ward

June 2008

Ballynafeigh

2

Beechill

2

Blackstaff

1

Botanic

4

Malone

17

Musgrave

9

Newtownbreda

5

Ravenhill

8

Rosetta

6

Shaftesbury

6

Stranmillis

11

Source: Central Services Agency

Notes:
1. Figures include Principal dentists only - excludes assistants and Vocational Dental Practitioners.
2. A dentist offering Health Service treatment is defined as a dentist who is currently registered on the Central Services Agency’s dental list, however, as independent contractors there is no obligation on these dentists to accept a patient for health service treatment.

MRSA Patients
Mr P Ramsey asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many cases of hospital-acquired Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) have been diagnosed in hospitals in each of the past five years.
(AQW 8971/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Number of MRSA patient episodes by Health & Social Care Trust 2003 - 2007

The format for recording the information has altered due to reconfiguration of the new Trusts therefore the data has been provided in two different formats.

Health Social & Services Trusts

2003

2004

2005

2006

Altnagelvin Hospital

17

22

21

11

Belfast City Hospital

55

47

39

32

Causeway

9

9

10

9

Craigavon Area Hospital

25

24

20

19

Down Lisburn

12

17

7

5

Green park health centre

5

2

3

5

Mater Infirmorum

25

9

23

29

Newry & Mourne

10

5

3

3

Royal Group of hospitals

42

44

49

49

Sperrin Lakeland

15

16

6

9

Ulster Community & Hospitals

23

34

25

37

United Hospitals

46

41

37

37

Totals

284

270

243

245

Health & Social care Trusts

2007

BELFAST

Belfast City Hospital

33

NICCO (Formerly at Belvior park)

3

Foster Green Hospital/Green Park

0

Musgrave Park Hospital

2

Mater Infirmorum

21

Royal Victoria Hospital

45

RJMH

0

RBHSC

4

Total

108

NORTHERN

Antrim Area Hospital

20

Mid Ulster Hospital

2

Moyle Hospital

0

Braid Valley Hospital

2

Whiteabbey Hospital

13

Causeway Hospital

8

Dalriada Hospital

0

Robinson Memorial Hospital

0

Total

45

SOUTH EASTERN

Ulster Hospital

32

Ards Hospital

0

Bangor hospital

0

Downe Hospital

3

Lagan Valley Hospital

4

Total

39

SOUTHERN

Daisy Hill

4

Craigavon Area Hospital

7

Lurgan

3

South Tyrone Hospital

0

Mullinure

0

Total

14

WESTERN

Altnagelvin Area hospital

11

Waterside

0

Earne Hospital

7

Tyrone County hospital

5

Total

23

Overall Total 2007

229

MRSA Cases
Mr P Ramsey asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many cases of hospital-acquired Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) have been diagnosed, broken down by each hospital department, for each year over the past five years.
(AQW 8972/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: This information is not available in the format requested. To gather this information would be very time consuming and would be at a disproportionate cost.

Equality Issues
Mr Durkan asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety pursuant to his answer to AQW 4503/08, for his assessment of existing consistency criteria in fulfilling the principle of equal pay for equal work across the Health Service.
(AQW 8973/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: Equal pay for work of equal value is one of the key aims of the Agenda for Change agreement and equality issues are paramount when Health and Social Care employers and staff representatives, both locally and regionally, assign a grading to a job. The equality features of the implementation procedures include; a detailed matching procedure to ensure that all jobs have been compared to the national benchmark profiles on an analytical basis, training in equality issues and the avoidance of bias for all matching panel members, job analysts and evaluators and a detailed Job Analysis Questionnaire to ensure that all relevant information is available for local evaluations. I am confident that this implementation process fulfils the principle of equal pay and provides for a fair system.

Ketogenic Diet
Miss McIlveen asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many patients require a kinogenetic diet as part of the management of their illness.
(AQW 8975/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: It is assumed this question refers to the ketogenic diet for epilepsy. There are currently two patients on a ketogenic diet.

Ketogenic Diet
Miss McIlveen asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how many people are qualified to prepare, administer and supervise a kinogenetic diet.
(AQW 8980/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: It is assumed this question refers to the ketogenic diet for epilepsy. Adherence to the diet normally requires the support of a doctor and a dietician, working in partnership with the patient and his or her parents/carers. In Northern Ireland, one paediatric dietician is trained to advise on ketogenic diet.

Ketogenic Diet
Miss McIlveen asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety how much has been spent on kinogenetic dietary specialists in each of the last five years.
(AQW 8981/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: It is assumed this question refers to the ketogenic diet for epilepsy. The information requested is not available.

Ketogenic Diet
Miss McIlveen asked the Minister of Health, Social Services and Public Safety if there are any plans to commence or increase funding in the area of kinogenetic diets.
(AQW 8983/08)

Mr M McGimpsey: It is assumed this question refers to the ketogenic diet for epilepsy. It is the responsibility of Health and Social Services Boards to plan and allocate resources to meet the needs of their local population, including those with epilepsy. It would be for Belfast Health and Social Care Trust to bring forward proposals for any expansion of the current ketogenic diet service and submit these to the commissioners for consideration.

Regional Development

Breaks in Water Supply
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development how many breaks in the water supply have occurred in the Ards Borough Council area in each of the last 3 years.
(AQW 8270/08)

The Minister for Regional Development (Mr C Murphy): You will be aware of my previous answer to your similar question AQW 6416/08 in May 2008 that there were 92 planned and 92 unplanned interruptions to the water supply in the Ards Borough Council area in the 12 months to March 2008. These figures were derived from comprehensive interruption records, against office and depots compiled for regulatory purposes since 1 April 2007. However, comprehensive interruption records prior to 1 April 2007 are not available. In April and May 2008 there were 12 planned and 12 unplanned interruptions of greater duration than 3 hours in the Ards Borough Council area.

In addition to the above, there were also planned interruptions to the water supply in the Ards Borough Council area associated with Northern Ireland Water’s Capital Works programme. These are recorded on a Northern Ireland wide basis split across North, South East and West areas and detailed records can not be provided for the Ards Borough Council area.

Broken Fencing at Scrabo School
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development what action is being taken to address the breaks in the fence at the pumping station adjacent to the former Scrabo School site in Newtownards.
(AQW 8287/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water that the broken fence at the former Scrabo School, adjacent to Scrabo Wastewater Pumping Station, is not its property or responsibility. The perimeter fence at the Pumping Station has been inspected and is secure.

Traffic Calming Measures
Mr Ross asked the Minister for Regional Development to list the (i) streets; (ii) villages; and (iii) estates, that Roads Service have assessed, scored and prioritised within the (a) Larne; (b) Carrickfergus; and (c) Newtownabbey, Borough Council areas; and for the score and priority given in each case.
(AQW 8304/08)

Mr C Murphy: Details of traffic calming schemes for the Larne, Carrickfergus and Newtownabbey Borough Council areas assessed by my Department’s Roads Service, that will be considered for inclusion in a future programme of works, are provided in the tables below.

Assessments for Traffic Calming Measures in Larne Borough Council Area

Current Priority Ranking

Location

Score

1

Linn Road

140

2

Upper Cairncastle Road

125

3

Ballygalley Village

100

Work is also ongoing to implement a traffic calming scheme included in the 2008/2009 programme of works within the Larne Borough Council area at Seacliff Estate (off Old Glenarm Road).

Assessments for Traffic Calming Measures in Carrickfergus Borough Council Area

Current Priority Ranking

Location

Score

1

Windmill Avenue

60

2

Broadlands

45

3

Drumhoy Drive and Salia Avenue

40

4

Farm lodge

40

5

Minorca Drive

35

6

Marine Parade

30

7

Fergus Avenue

30

8

Kingsland

15

In addition, subject to the successful conclusion of the public consultation and legislative processes, Roads Service plans to carry out traffic calming schemes within the Carrickfergus Borough Council area at Alexander Road, Barn Road/Elizabeth Avenue, Prospect Heights and Station Road. These schemes have been included in the 2008/2009 programme of works.

Assessments for Traffic Calming Measures in Newtownabbey Borough Council Area

Current Priority Ranking

Location

Score

1

Rashee Park

85

2

Glebe Road

50

3

Ballycraigy Road

50

4

Rosstulla Park /Glenbroome Park

45

5

Bridge End

45

6

Hazelwood Park

45

7

Beverly Road

40

8

Collinward Avenue

40

9

Glencairn Park / Drive

40

10

Beverly Gardens

35

11

Burnet Avenue

35

12

Huntingdale

35

13

Kimberley Road

35

14

Armoy Gardens

30

15

Swanston Road Crescent

30

16

Whitehouse Park

30

17

Henryville Manor

30

18

Ravelston Avenue

30

19

Glebecoole Park

25

20

Churchill Park /Crescent

25

21

Dorchester Avenue

20

22

Meadowbank Park

15

23

Wesleydale

15

24

Hillcrest Crescent

5

Further to the successful conclusion of the public consultation and legislative processes, Roads Service plans to carry out traffic calming schemes within Newtownabbey Borough Council area at Straid Village, Bracken Drive, Hazelburn Road, and Carnmoney Road North/The Glade. Again, these schemes have been included in the 2008/2009 programme of works.

In all instances the priority ranking indicated within the above tables does not take into account the ranking order of other existing/ongoing traffic calming schemes, within the respective Roads Service Division, or new schemes yet to be assessed and scored.

Religious and Gender Breakdown of Ulsterbus Personnel
Mr McKay asked the Minister for Regional Development to detail (i) the management structure and areas of responsibility within Ulsterbus; and (ii) the religious and gender breakdown of Ulsterbus personnel at each regional office.
(AQW 8467/08)

Mr C Murphy:
Ulsterbus is an operating company of the Northern Ireland Transport Holding Company and is managed by a General Manager of Bus Services. The General Manager has responsibility for bus operations, engineering and fleet maintenance. Operations are organised into three geographic areas: Central Area, with an Area Manager based in Belfast; Northern Area, with an Area Manager based in Derry; and Southern Area, with an Area Manager based in Craigavon. Each of these managers has responsibility for Ulsterbus operations and engineering at a number of locations within his area of responsibility.

Set out below is a table showing gender and perceived religious affiliation in each area.

Area

Central

Northern

Southern

Gender

Female

200

106

104

Male

575

754

791

Total

775

860

895

Perceived religious affiliation

Protestant

523

415

472

Catholic

235

424

393

Other

17

21

30

Total

775

860

895

B52 Largy Road Route Study
Mr McKay asked the Minister for Regional Development for an update on the implementation of the B52 Largy Road Route Study.
(AQW 8468/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service has advised that since my last response to the Member’s Assembly Question, AQW 3835/08, it has fully completed the minor works scheme at Casheltown Crossroads. The purpose of this scheme was to improve the sight distance at the Kilcurry Road/Casheltown Road junction and to introduce a short length of one-way system on the Casheltown Road to prevent vehicles joining the Largy Road, where visibility to the right is limited.

As I advised in my previous response, an assessment of the remaining scheme proposals along this route is ongoing. Prioritisation of schemes will take account of technical merit, availability of funding, Council consultations and Roads Service priorities.

Troubles-Related Illegal Roadside Memorials
Mr Moutray asked the Minister for Regional Development pursuant to his answer to AQW 864/08, which statutory obligations arising under Section 75(2) of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 influence his Department's attitude towards troubles-related illegal roadside memorials.
(AQW 8484/08)

Mr C Murphy: Section 75(2) of the Northern Ireland Act 1998 requires my Department’s Roads Service, in carrying out its functions, to have due regard to the desirability of promoting good relations between persons of different religious belief, political opinion or racial group.

Roads Service is acutely aware that taking action to remove illegally erected monuments, without the support of the wider local community, could have a negative impact on relations between such groups. Roads Service’s experience in dealing with similarly contentious issues such as flag flying, kerb painting, etc. has shown that community agreement is key to successfully resolving such sensitive issues.

Roadway at Shore Road in Ballyronan
Mr McGlone asked the Minister for Regional Development if and when the roadway at Shore Road, Ballyronan, from and including the village of Ballyronan to Ballylifford, will be resurfaced.
(AQW 8510/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service has no plans to carry out resurfacing along the Shore Road, between Ballyronan and Ballylifford.

Some sections of the Shore Road are in a provisional programme for edge strengthening in 2009/10, and similar works are expected to be required in later years. However, the majority of the carriageway surface is in reasonable condition.

In Ballyronan village, the road has been affected by utility work associated with new developments and Roads Service is monitoring its re-instatement. Roads Service is also aware of additional developments and other utility works planned within the village. Resurfacing will be considered when these works have been completed.

Contracts for Surface Dressing
Mr Beggs asked the Minister for Regional Development to detail the value of contracts that have been issued for surface dressing of roads during the summer months, broken down by divisional roads area.
(AQW 8558/08)

Mr C Murphy: The table below illustrates the value of work to date issued to external contractors, under the term contracts for surface dressing 2008.

SURFACE DRESSING FOR THE 2008 SUMMER SEASON

Division

Amount
(Issued as at 30 June 2008)

Northern Division

£800,000

Southern Division

£440,000,

Eastern Division

Nil

Western Division

£570,000

Total

£1,810,000

I should, however, explain that the surface dressing season will run until August 2008, and it is expected that the total value of surfacing dressing completed in 2008, will be around £3.7 million.

In addition, a sizeable proportion of the surface dressing activity is carried out by the agency’s internal contractor, Roads Service Direct. There is no associated contractual value for this in-house work.

Residents Parking Schemes in Belfast
Mr Spratt asked the Minister for Regional Development for an update on the proposed residents parking scheme for areas of Belfast.
(AQW 8578/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service extended the informal consultation period, in the first five areas under consideration for Residents’ Parking Schemes, to 30 June 2008 and an assessment of the responses received is ongoing.

It is likely that the proposals will not be supported by the residents in any of the five areas under consideration. If that proves to be the case, Roads Service will then move on to consider schemes proposed for other areas.

However, Roads Service will continue to work with the five areas under consideration to find the best way forward in tackling the problems that all-day parking causes for the residents.

Flooding Risks
Mr K Robinson asked the Minister for Regional Development what measures he plans to reduce flooding risks in all areas which have proved susceptible to flooding over the past ten years, and to detail his plans for each area.
(AQW 8601/08)

Mr C Murphy: Responsibility for the drainage infrastructure is shared between my Department’s Roads Service, Northern Ireland Water (NIW), and DARD’s Rivers Agency.

The Rivers Agency has taken the lead in the formulation of procedures, which has resulted in the development of Best Practice Guidelines and the Flooding Hotspot list, and for the liaison and co-ordination of the emergency response for localised flooding events.

The Flooding Hotspots register includes a list of key flooding locations across the North, identified by NIW, Rivers Agency and Roads Service. It also notes the nominated lead agency for dealing with the problem at each location. The criteria for inclusion on the Hotspot list require more than one agency to be involved and a history of flooding at a particular location. As you might expect, the problems at these locations are not always easy to resolve, i.e. are prohibitively expensive, relatively serious, or the solution may not be immediately obvious and requires liaison between agencies. The flooding hotspot list is continually updated, as new locations are added and problem locations are dealt with.

With regard to my Department, Roads Service has emergency plans to deal with flooding related incidents, including details of where the risk of flooding is greatest, to ensure that a 24 hours, 7 days a week response service is in place. Roads Service also makes preparations in response to early warning of heavy rain, issued by the Met Office, to ensure, as far as is practicable, that it is ready to deal with the impact of adverse weather.

These preparations include putting operational staff on standby, checking that drainage outlets/culverts at identified hotspots are clear from debris, and checking the readiness of emergency equipment and stocks of sandbags.

Regarding preventative maintenance, Roads Service aims to inspect and clean, where necessary, all gullies in urban areas twice each year. Gullies in rural areas are inspected and cleaned, if necessary, once each year. This policy ensures that a reasonable level of maintenance is carried out to drainage systems, taking account of the Department’s finite funding and staff resource levels.

NIW is continuing with its infrastructure improvement projects which will contribute to the long-term solution to local flood prevention. NIW is currently constructing the £126 million Belfast Sewer Project, which will substantially reduce the risk of flooding in the Greater Belfast area when it is completed in 2009. It is also undertaking a programme of 108 Drainage Area Studies across the North to identify improvements required to sewerage networks to reduce the risk of flooding and to meet environmental requirements. The sewer improvement recommendations resulting from these studies will be included in a construction programme requiring a total capital investment in excess of £300 million. However, given other funding priorities, the bulk of the construction expenditure is expected to be in the period beyond 2010.

Following the widespread flooding in June 2007 it was recognised that in more severe emergencies where a multi-agency response is required (i.e. more than the 3 main drainage organisations), wider co-ordination is necessary. This co-ordination can best be achieved by councils through the local resilience fora to ensure integration with the regional structures and coordination of a local response. The Belfast Resilience Forum is already established, the others, including the Northern Resilience Forum, are currently being developed.

Street Lighting Scheme for the Coast Road Area in Larne
Mr Hilditch asked the Minister for Regional Development, pursuant to his answer to AQW 2594/08, for an update on the street lighting scheme for the Coast Road area of Larne.
(AQW 8610/08)

Mr C Murphy: Roads Service is arranging a meeting with a number of Councillors and the Chief Executive from Larne Borough Council. This meeting will be arranged for a suitable time that best demonstrates an innovative low level LED bollard lighting solution to illuminate the footway at Drain’s Bay, Larne, without detracting from the Black Arch.

If this solution is acceptable, every effort will be made to have the lighting installed before winter 2008.

Traffic Calming Measures in the Alexander Road Area of Carrickfergus
Mr Hilditch asked the Minister for Regional Development for an update on the progress made in relation to traffic calming measures in the Alexander Road area of Carrickfergus; and when this work is due to commence.
(AQW 8612/08)

Mr C Murphy:

My Department’s Roads Service has advised that there are proposals for traffic calming measures at Alexander Road, Downshire Gardens, Carrickburn Road, Castleburn Road and Trailcock Road, Carrickfergus. The implementation of any such scheme is subject to the successful completion of residents’ consultation and the legislative process. I understand that a number of residents of Downshire Gardens have indicated their opposition to traffic calming in their area.

Roads Service will now write to all households on Downshire Gardens to ascertain the level of local support. I have asked that the Divisional Roads Manager to write to you when the outcome of this consultation is known.

Departmental Response to Increasing Fuel Costs
Mrs Long asked the Minister for Regional Development what assessment he has made of the impact of the increase in (i) fuel costs; and (ii) fuel duty on the departmental budget and the realisation of efficiency targets; and what action he has taken to mitigate against these increased costs.
(AQW 8628/08)

Mr C Murphy: My department anticipated increased fuel costs and fuel duty when preparing spending proposals for Budget 2008-2011. An element of these increased costs has already been reflected in the departmental budget.

DRD is currently assessing the impact of the latest fuel costs and fuel duty on the departmental budget and the need to submit bids in the September 2008 Monitoring Round.

At this stage it is not expected that the increase in fuel costs will affect my department’s ability to meet its efficiency targets.

Fencing Around the Kilcooley Estate in Bangor
Mr Easton asked the Minister for Regional Development what plans he has in relation to fencing around the Kilcooley Estate, Bangor.
(AQW 8644/08)

Mr C Murphy: I understand that the fencing around the Kilcooley Estate, Bangor, was erected by the roads authority at the time of the construction of the Belfast Road/West Circular Road, Bangor. This was prior to the creation of my Department’s Roads Service, in 1973. It is believed that the fence was erected to provide accommodation works, delineation of the road boundary and to afford protection to footway users, where there is a difference in level between the footway and the adjoining property.

Responsibility for the maintenance of fences provided as accommodation works, normally reverts to the landowner abutting the road. While the Housing Executive is the current owner of this land, neither they nor the Department for Social Development have any records of responsibility for the fencing being transferred to them and they have not carried out any maintenance to the fencing, since its erection.

While Roads Services does not believe it is the owner of the fence, it has agreed, in the interests of road safety and on a without prejudice basis, that it will maintain the fence, where there is a perceived risk to road users.

Also, while Roads Service does not accept responsibility for the fencing at other parts, and has no plans to replace it, discussions with the Housing Executive will continue, in an effort to establish longer term maintenance or removal options. I have asked Roads Service to liaise with you directly on these options, before discussing them with the Housing Executive.

Proposed Roundabout at Maryland Crossroads Between Moneyreagh and Belfast
Mr Hamilton asked the Minister for Regional Development if the Roads Service has any plans to construct a roundabout at the Maryland crossroads between Moneyreagh and Belfast.
(AQW 8645/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service has advised me that it has recently completed a route study on the A23, Moneyreagh/Ballygowan Road. A number of potential schemes were identified to improve the safety and efficiency of the route, with Merrylands crossroads identified as one of the locations which may benefit from an improvement scheme.

Further development of proposals is now required to determine the most appropriate measures for the Merrylands crossroads. Due to the close proximity of properties, including Marylands Industrial Estate, to this junction, it is unlikely that a roundabout would be considered feasible.

It should be noted that route studies are for feasibility purposes only, with no guarantee that proposals will be implemented.

Caravan Park in Ballyhalbert
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development how many developers have to provide for a footpath within their planning application from the caravan park towards the mini-roundabout in Ballyhalbert.
(AQW 8661/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service has advised that it is now a requirement that any significant planning application for properties along the frontage of Shore Road, between the disused caravan park and the mini roundabout at High Street, must provide footways along their frontage.

Roads Service records show that at least 20 individual planning applications have been submitted over the past 12 years in the vicinity. A number of these would be in respect of single dwellings. Taking account of the limitations of the historic information available, the best estimate is that three of these applications have been required to make footway provision.

Drainage System on Killynether Road
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development further to correspondence with his Department, why has the Department delayed their response to the Rivers Agency request for information of the drainage system of Killynether Road which had been requested 3 months ago.
(AQW 8663/08)

Mr C Murphy: Officials in my Department’s Roads Service have advised that they did not receive a request from Rivers Agency, for information on the drainage system at Killynether Road.

However, I can confirm that following a site meeting at Killynether Road to investigate the flooding problem, Rivers Agency advised Roads Service on the size of pipe required for a new road crossing to accommodate the run-off water.

This improvement scheme has been included on Roads Service’s list of proposed schemes and it is hoped that it will be implemented before the onset of Autumn/Winter 2008, taking account of the availability of funding at that time.

Northern Ireland Water
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development further to AQW 6416, how many breaks in the water supply have occurred in each parliamentary constituency in the last 12 months.
(AQW 8666/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water (NIW) that the information held in relation to this matter is inclusive of the geographical areas of the north of Ireland. NIW holds comprehensive interruption records, of duration greater than three hours, against office and depots for regulatory purposes. The number of interruptions to the water supply during the 12 month period to May 2008 is shown in the table below:

Local Area Office

All Interruptions >3hrs (1 Jun 07 to 31 May 08)

Antrim

47

Ards/Bangor

108

Armagh

82

Ballykeel

54

Clogher/Ballygawley

61

Coleraine

78

Downpatrick

80

Enniskillen

29

Londonderry

67

Lisburn

43

Magherafelt

52

Newry/Seagoe

151

Omagh/Strabane

97

Belfast/Carrickfergus

149

TOTAL

1,098

In addition to this, NIW’s contractors carry out other planned interruptions to supplies, associated with its Capital Works Programme. However, these cannot be broken down into parliamentary constituencies. The number of planned interruptions to water supplies during the 12 month period to May 2008 is shown in the table below based on water mains rehabilitations contracts across North, South East and West areas.

All Interruptions >3hrs (1 Jun 07 to 31 May 08)

NORTH

77

SOUTH EAST

730

WEST

2

TOTAL

809

GRAND TOTAL

1,907

Offences Against Traffic Wardens
Mr Gallagher asked the Minister for Regional Development the number of occasions that traffic wardens have instigated court proceedings against members of the public for alleged offences against them in the course of carrying out their duties on behalf of the Department; and the number of cases that have been (a) successfully prosecuted; and (b) otherwise determined by the courts.
(AQW 8680/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service does not maintain details of Traffic Attendants who have instigated court proceedings against members of the public for alleged offences. However, NCP Services Ltd, who employ the Traffic Attendants, have advised Roads Service, that there have been two offences against Traffic Attendants that have led to court proceedings, both resulting in successful prosecutions.

Culvert at Movilla Road in Newtownards
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development to explain the delay in the Roads Service contacting the Rivers Agency with the information, requested on Good Friday this year, in relation to the pipe that crosses the Movilla Road in Newtownards.
(AQW 8699/08)

Mr C Murphy: Officials from my Department’s Roads Service have advised that negotiations have taken place with officials from the Rivers Agency, regarding the culvert that crosses the Movilla Road in Newtownards. The outcome of these negotiations is that Roads Service will replace the existing stone culvert with a new pipe, set to levels agreed with Rivers Agency. This will enable the adjacent landowner to carry out the remedial work that is required on his drain, under the instruction of Rivers Agency.

This should result in a resolution of flooding problems, which have occurred at this location during spells of very heavy rainfall.

Roads Service plans to carry out their work within the next two months.

Weed Growth in Rural Areas
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development what steps he is taking to eradicate weeds along road edges to prevent Hogweed affecting nearby residents.
(AQW 8700/08)

Mr C Murphy: Officials from my Department’s Roads Service have advised that they normally control weed growth in rural areas, by mowing roadside verges, prior to the weed flowering/seeding season, between May and June. A second cut is normally undertaken at the end of the summer.

Chemical control of weeds is undertaken for kerbed and paved areas. It is normally carried out on an annual basis in spring, with any significant re-growth being dealt with as necessary.

Spraying of highway surfaces or edges is carried out by trained personnel, in accordance with advice from the manufacturers of the products used and the Department of Agriculture and Rural Development, using the minimum treatment necessary, compatible with required results.

Water Loss at the Clay Lakes at Shrigley and Killyleagh
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development what steps he has taken to address acute water loss at the Clay lakes at Shrigley and Killyleagh, where water levels are already two feet below the minimum level.
(AQW 8701/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have not taken any steps to address acute water loss at the lakes at Shrigley and Killyleagh, as Northern Ireland Water are not responsible for extracting water from the lakes.

Responsibility for water level management in the lakes currently rests with the private land owners. I have been advised by DARD Rivers Agency that they have received written confirmation that the current controller of the water levels of the lakes, is content to relinquish control. Subsequently work is ongoing to finalise the formal legal transfer to Rivers Agency.

Once formal transfer has been completed, and subject to Drainage Council approval, control of water levels by Rivers Agency should provide for more consistent water management for drainage purposes.

Meeting at Innishmore and Benown, Killyleagh
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development to outline the outcome of the meeting with NI Water and departmental officials that took place at Innishmore and Benown in Killyleagh earlier this year.
(AQW 8702/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water (NIW) that following the site meeting earlier this year it was agreed that a CCTV inspection of the public sewer would be carried out. As a result of the inspection, it was confirmed that desilting of the local sewer system was necessary. This has been completed and it is understood the problem of sewage flooding has been alleviated.

NIW also advised that a Drainage Area Study for the overall Killyleagh sewer system is planned and that this study will further assess flooding problems, such as this specific complaint at Innishmore and Benown, to ensure that any recommendation for major capital spending fully resolves hydraulic capacity in the system.

Northern Ireland's Carbon Footprint
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Regional Development what is the expected impact of the transport aspects of the current Investment Strategy on Northern Ireland's carbon footprint.
(AQW 8706/08)

Mr C Murphy: The transport aspects of the current Investment Strategy will be influenced by the commitment to undertake a review of the Regional Transportation Strategy. That review will consider a range of issues including the impact of sustainable development and environmental issues such as carbon and other emissions from transport.

Investment Strategy for Northern Ireland
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Regional Development what fuel price assumptions lie behind the transport aspects of the current Investment Strategy for Northern Ireland.
(AQW 8707/08)

Mr C Murphy:
The Investment Strategy is a high level framework to support the planning and delivery of the infrastructure programme. The transport aspects of the Strategy will all be subject to their own economic appraisals prior to delivery or implementation. The price of fuel will be an element that will feature at that time to inform the decision making process.

Investment Strategy for Northern Ireland
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Regional Development what plans there are to revise the current Investment Strategy for Northern Ireland in light of the rise in fuel prices.
(AQW 8708/08)

Mr C Murphy:
The Investment Strategy will be reviewed in each three year budget cycle with the next review planned before April 2011. This will provide an opportunity to reflect on the over arching direction, progress to date and modify strategic plans if necessary to reflect the impact of a sustained rise in fuel costs.

Repairing Vandalism to Bus Shelters
Mr Hamilton asked the Minister for Regional Development how much has been spent on repairing vandalism to bus shelters in each of the last five years.
(AQW 8717/08)

Mr C Murphy:

In January 2001 Roads Service and the majority of district councils entered into a 15-year contract with Adshel (the bus shelter provider) for the provision of approximately 1500 bus shelters throughout the council areas involved. The provision and maintenance of these shelters are funded by Adshel through advertising revenue and at no cost to the Department. The contract covers the vast majority of the North bus shelters and the Department has no knowledge of the costs incurred by Adshel in carrying out their contractual commitments.
In addition to the above contract, Adshel installed a small number of bus shelters for Translink. This was funded through the Rural Transport Fund and under the terms of the contract Translink paid for any related vandalism costs. The associated vandalism costs are as follows.

2003/04

£1,815

2004/05

£600

2005/06

£2,103

2006/07

£165

2007/08

£2,200

Illegal Signage
Mr B Wilson asked the Minister for Regional Development on how many occasions the Roads Service has used Article 87 of the Roads Order to prosecute bodies for illegally erecting signs within the curtilage of the road in each district council area.
(AQW 8723/08)

Mr C Murphy: Officials from my Department’s Roads Service have advised that they have been successful in securing four prosecutions in 2007/8, for the erection of unlawful advertising signs. Although all of these were located within the Belfast area, the overall beneficial affect of these prosecutions is expected to impact on other areas across the North.

Northern Ireland Water
Mr Durkan asked the Minister for Regional Development for an update on the proposal to centralise Telemetry Services in Northern Ireland Water to a single location; and to outline the criteria being used to select a specific site.
(AQW 8725/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water (NIW) that it has completed the initial phase of the rationalisation of its Telemetry Services at a central location by amalgamating the duties previously performed at Altnagelvin, Derry and Ballymena at the Altnagelvin Telemetry Centre site, and the amalgamation of the Belfast and Craigavon duties at the Belfast, Westland House, Telemetry Centre site.

NIW is currently working on the vision for its future structure and completing its strategic planning in respect of its office and depot accommodation needs. This is a substantial amount of work and the elements contributing to the decision on the location of the centralised site for the Telemetry function will be included in this decision.

The centralisation of telemetry services will provide benefits for NIW and its customers, including standardised telemetry practice, improved monitoring services and savings on manpower costs. Therefore, in order to select the most appropriate location, the main criteria being considered are value for money and the location of functions and key decision makers. Other criteria also being considered include: the current telemetry coverage of physical assets and monitoring points; minimising the impact on telemetry staff; the ownership of Telemetry Centre premises and facilities; and the location of the Telemetry Development and Configuration Centre.

Northern Ireland Water
Mr Durkan asked the Minister for Regional Development when staff working in Telemetry Services in Northern Ireland Water had a pay review; and to outline the other companies against which their pay was compared.
(AQW 8727/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water (NIW) that there are 2 groups of staff who work within Telemetry Services in NIW who are subject to separate pay agreements.

The industrial employees are subject to the terms of a collective pay bargaining process which is subject to an annual review with effect from 1 July each year. Agreement has been reached with the industrial trade unions to apply a 3.2% uplift to all current pay and allowances covered by the collective pay agreement with effect from 1 July 2007. NIW expects the 2008 pay negotiations to commence in the coming weeks.

The non-industrial employees are subject to the terms of a collective pay bargaining process which is subject to an annual review with effect from 1 August each year. However the current pay agreement is tied into a 3-year pay agreement which runs from 1 August 2006 to 31 July 2009 and will not be subject for an annual review until 2009.

However negotiations between the company and the Water Group of Trade Unions on the terms of a new grading and pay structure are ongoing at present.

Local Postal Services
Mr Dallat asked the Minister for Regional Development what consideration has been given and what progress has been made by his Department to utilise the Post Office as a source, agency or outlet for the delivery of its services as outlined in the May 2008 report of the Assembly's Ad Hoc Committee, 'Report of the Committee’s Consideration of, and Proposals for, Partnership that could Enhance the Economic Case for Viable Local Postal Services'.
(AQW 8740/08)

Mr C Murphy: The Ad Hoc Committee on Local Postal Services’ Report made a number of recommendations to the Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (DBERR) concerning the future of Postal Services and the Post Office network. Junior Minister Donaldson and Junior Minister Kelly wrote to Executive Ministers on 21 April asking them to consider whether any further public services could be delivered through post offices.

The Department for Regional Development has been unable to identify any services that could be delivered through Post Offices. We will continue to look at opportunities as they arise to consider whether any new public service could be delivered through the Post Office although these would be subject to the appropriate procurement policy.

Planning Framework and Shared Space
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Regional Development what plans he has to review the Northern Ireland planning framework to ensure that it maximises the potential to create shared space.
(AQW 8747/08)

Mr C Murphy: AQW 8747/08

I [Conor Murphy, DRD] am answering this question as I have responsibility for the Regional Development Strategy.

The Regional Development Strategy (RDS) includes guidance in relation to shared space. It highlights the need to support the development of shared places which are accessible to all members of the community. The RDS is presently the subject of a major review which is planned for completion by the Spring of 2010.

Northern Ireland Water
Mr McKay asked the Minister for Regional Development what work is currently being carried out by Northern Ireland Water in Rasharkin; and when is this work due to be completed.
(AQW 8751/08)

Mr C Murphy: I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water (NIW) that preparatory work was initiated for the Rasharkin flood alleviation scheme, week beginning 23 June 2008, with a view to construction beginning in earnest following the July holidays on 4 August 2008. It had been hoped to commence before this date following successful resolution of the pipe route with local land-owners. However several did not avail of a clause to permit NIW early entry prior to the statutory 90-day notification period, so that period has had to run its course to mid July. In the absence of any objections, work will begin after that period. Most of the work is in fields, but any residents or businesses affected by work in roads will be notified in advance.

Rasharkin is also currently benefiting from a watermain improvement scheme that has a rolling programme to replace 37km of watermains in the area at a total cost of £4 million. This may affect some of Main Street but the majority of work is in the areas surrounding Rasharkin village.

Disabled Access to Public Transport
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Regional Development what provision is made in the Department's budget to provide increased access to, and usage of, public transport by people with disabilities.
(AQW 8763/08)

Mr C Murphy: To provide increased access to, and usage of, public transport by people with disabilities my Department has made the following provisions in its budget:

Programme

2007/08

2008/09

2009/10

Transport Programme for People with Disabilities

£4.63m

£4.63m

£4.63m

Upgrade of all railway stations and halts
to meet accessibility standards

£8.65m

£1.32m

nil

In addition, provision has been made for the following programmes which are designed to offer significant benefit to people with disabilities:

Programme

2007/08

2008/09

2009/10

Concessionary Fares Scheme

£22.05m

£28.95m

£30.02m

Rural Transport Fund

£3.75m

£3.75m

£3.75m

Also of benefit to people with disabilities are:

the purchase of trains which are fully accessible to people with disabilities at a cost of £95 million (over next five years); and,
the purchase of new buses which are fully accessible to people with disabilities at a cost of £45 million (over next three years)

Disabled Access to Public Transport
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Regional Development what action is he taking to provide increased access to, and usage of, public transport by people with disabilities.
(AQW 8765/08)

Mr C Murphy:
My Department published the Accessible Transport Strategy for Northern Ireland 2015 which sought to address a wide range of barriers that impede use of the transport system by older people and people with disabilities. These barriers include physical, attitudinal or psychological, the availability of information, the type of services and affordability. The Strategy is being implemented through action plans containing measures to overcome these barriers. The Action Plan for 2007/09 was recently endorsed by the Executive and will be published shortly.

Old A1 Newry to Dundalk Road
Mr Brady asked the Minister for Regional Development if he will review the protected route status of the of the old A1 Newry to Dundalk Road.
(AQW 8767/08)

Mr C Murphy: Officials from my Department’s Roads Service have advised that they will review the protected route status of the old A1 Newry to Dundalk road.

Parking Surveys in Belfast
Mr Spratt asked the Minister for Regional Development which streets in (i) Lisburn Road; (ii) Lower Malone Road; and (iii) Stranmillis, are initial parking surveys to take place.
(AQW 8777/08)

Mr C Murphy: In relation to AQW8777/08, my Department’s Roads Service have advised that initial parking surveys will be carried out as detailed in the following table:

LISBURN ROAD

LOWER MALONE ROAD

STRANMILLS

Adelaide Avenue
Ashley Avenue
Ashley Drive
Ashley Mews
Belgravia Avenue
Brookland Street
Chadwick Street
Donnybrook Street
Edinburgh Street
Ethel Street
Fane Street
Great Northern Street

Cussick Street
Eglantine Avenue
Eglantine Gardens
Eglantine Place
Malone Avenue
Malone Road
Wellesley Avenue
Wellington Lane
Wellington Park
Wellington Park Avenue
Wellington Park Mews
Wellington Park Terrace

Chlorine Gardens
Colenso Parade
Elaine Street
Landsleer Street
Lennoxvale
Mount Pleasant
Pretoria Street
Ridgeway Street
Riverview Street
Sanhurst Drive
Sandhurst Gardens
Sandymount Street

LISBURN ROAD

LOWER MALONE ROAD

STRANMILLS

Lisburn Avenue
Lorne Street
Lower Windsor Avenue
Meadowbank Place
Meadowbank Street
Melrose Street
Mount Prospect Park
Northbrook Gardens
Northbrook Street
Rathcool Street
Rathdrum Street
Rathgar Street
Sandringham Street
Sloan Crescent
Surrey Street
Tates Avenue
Ulsterville Avenue
Ulsterville Drive
Ulsterville Gardens
Ulsterville Place
Windsor Drive
Windsor Road

Windsor Avenue
Windsor Avenue North

St Albans Gardens
St Ives Gardens
Strandview Street
Stranmillis Court
Stranmillis Gardens
Stranmillis Mews
Stranmillis Park
Stranmillis Road
Stranmillis Street

In regard to AQW 8778/08, I understand that initial surveys to establish the extent of the parking problems in these areas are programmed to be undertaken during September / October 2008. These surveys will establish any parking problems and whether they can be addressed by the introduction of residents' parking schemes. If residents parking schemes are proposed, it will be early 2009 before consultation with residents would commence.

It should be noted that residents' parking schemes are unlikely to be proposed for an area where the parking demand by non-residents is not high, or residents have adequate opportunities to park.

In relation to AQW 8780/08, initial surveys to assess the level of residential and non-residential parking in these areas were carried out during February 2006. An additional validation survey was also undertaken during March 2007 following the introduction of Decriminalised Parking Enforcement (DPE) in late 2006.

Consultants are currently working with Roads Service to produce indicative designs for the introduction of residents' parking schemes in these areas. This will enable informal consultation to commence, on proposals for the introduction of these schemes.

Parking Surveys in Belfast
Mr Spratt asked the Minister for Regional Development when will consultations for residents parking schemes commence in (i) Lisburn Road; (ii) Lower Malone Road; and (iii) Stranmillis.
(AQW 8778/08)

Mr C Murphy: In relation to AQW8777/08, my Department’s Roads Service have advised that initial parking surveys will be carried out as detailed in the following table:

LISBURN ROAD

LOWER MALONE ROAD

STRANMILLS

Adelaide Avenue
Ashley Avenue
Ashley Drive
Ashley Mews
Belgravia Avenue
Brookland Street
Chadwick Street
Donnybrook Street
Edinburgh Street
Ethel Street
Fane Street
Great Northern Street

Cussick Street
Eglantine Avenue
Eglantine Gardens
Eglantine Place
Malone Avenue
Malone Road
Wellesley Avenue
Wellington Lane
Wellington Park
Wellington Park Avenue
Wellington Park Mews
Wellington Park Terrace

Chlorine Gardens
Colenso Parade
Elaine Street
Landsleer Street
Lennoxvale
Mount Pleasant
Pretoria Street
Ridgeway Street
Riverview Street
Sanhurst Drive
Sandhurst Gardens
Sandymount Street

LISBURN ROAD

LOWER MALONE ROAD

STRANMILLS

Lisburn Avenue
Lorne Street
Lower Windsor Avenue
Meadowbank Place
Meadowbank Street
Melrose Street
Mount Prospect Park
Northbrook Gardens
Northbrook Street
Rathcool Street
Rathdrum Street
Rathgar Street
Sandringham Street
Sloan Crescent
Surrey Street
Tates Avenue
Ulsterville Avenue
Ulsterville Drive
Ulsterville Gardens
Ulsterville Place
Windsor Drive
Windsor Road

Windsor Avenue
Windsor Avenue North

St Albans Gardens
St Ives Gardens
Strandview Street
Stranmillis Court
Stranmillis Gardens
Stranmillis Mews
Stranmillis Park
Stranmillis Road
Stranmillis Street

In regard to AQW 8778/08, I understand that initial surveys to establish the extent of the parking problems in these areas are programmed to be undertaken during September / October 2008. These surveys will establish any parking problems and whether they can be addressed by the introduction of residents' parking schemes. If residents parking schemes are proposed, it will be early 2009 before consultation with residents would commence.

It should be noted that residents' parking schemes are unlikely to be proposed for an area where the parking demand by non-residents is not high, or residents have adequate opportunities to park.

In relation to AQW 8780/08, initial surveys to assess the level of residential and non-residential parking in these areas were carried out during February 2006. An additional validation survey was also undertaken during March 2007 following the introduction of Decriminalised Parking Enforcement (DPE) in late 2006.

Consultants are currently working with Roads Service to produce indicative designs for the introduction of residents' parking schemes in these areas. This will enable informal consultation to commence, on proposals for the introduction of these schemes.

Parking Surveys in Belfast
Mr Spratt asked the Minister for Regional Development what initial parking surveys and design processes have taken place for residents' parking schemes in (i) the Markets (East); (ii) Lower Ormeau Road; (iii) Holylands/University; (iv) Lower Lisburn Road; and (v) Donegall Road.
(AQW 8780/08)

Mr C Murphy: In relation to AQW8777/08, my Department’s Roads Service have advised that initial parking surveys will be carried out as detailed in the following table:

LISBURN ROAD

LOWER MALONE ROAD

STRANMILLS

Adelaide Avenue
Ashley Avenue
Ashley Drive
Ashley Mews
Belgravia Avenue
Brookland Street
Chadwick Street
Donnybrook Street
Edinburgh Street
Ethel Street
Fane Street
Great Northern Street

Cussick Street
Eglantine Avenue
Eglantine Gardens
Eglantine Place
Malone Avenue
Malone Road
Wellesley Avenue
Wellington Lane
Wellington Park
Wellington Park Avenue
Wellington Park Mews
Wellington Park Terrace

Chlorine Gardens
Colenso Parade
Elaine Street
Landsleer Street
Lennoxvale
Mount Pleasant
Pretoria Street
Ridgeway Street
Riverview Street
Sanhurst Drive
Sandhurst Gardens
Sandymount Street

LISBURN ROAD

LOWER MALONE ROAD

STRANMILLS

Lisburn Avenue
Lorne Street
Lower Windsor Avenue
Meadowbank Place
Meadowbank Street
Melrose Street
Mount Prospect Park
Northbrook Gardens
Northbrook Street
Rathcool Street
Rathdrum Street
Rathgar Street
Sandringham Street
Sloan Crescent
Surrey Street
Tates Avenue
Ulsterville Avenue
Ulsterville Drive
Ulsterville Gardens
Ulsterville Place
Windsor Drive
Windsor Road

Windsor Avenue
Windsor Avenue North

St Albans Gardens
St Ives Gardens
Strandview Street
Stranmillis Court
Stranmillis Gardens
Stranmillis Mews
Stranmillis Park
Stranmillis Road
Stranmillis Street

In regard to AQW 8778/08, I understand that initial surveys to establish the extent of the parking problems in these areas are programmed to be undertaken during September / October 2008. These surveys will establish any parking problems and whether they can be addressed by the introduction of residents' parking schemes. If residents parking schemes are proposed, it will be early 2009 before consultation with residents would commence.

It should be noted that residents' parking schemes are unlikely to be proposed for an area where the parking demand by non-residents is not high, or residents have adequate opportunities to park.

In relation to AQW 8780/08, initial surveys to assess the level of residential and non-residential parking in these areas were carried out during February 2006. An additional validation survey was also undertaken during March 2007 following the introduction of Decriminalised Parking Enforcement (DPE) in late 2006.

Consultants are currently working with Roads Service to produce indicative designs for the introduction of residents' parking schemes in these areas. This will enable informal consultation to commence, on proposals for the introduction of these schemes.

Water Charges
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development how much the average water charge is on bills issued.
(AQW 8781/08)

Mr C Murphy:
I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water (NIW) that they calculate invoices for water charges either on the basis of the Net Annual Value (NAV) of the premises (unmeasured charges) or on the basis of water consumption recorded by a meter (measured charges). NIW also invoices its customers for sewerage charges, where the premises are connected to the public sewers.

The Net Annual Values of premises invoiced by NIW vary from less than £1,000 to over £100,000 and the calculated water charges vary depending on the NAV. NIW’s first unmeasured annual bill run contained 28,667 bills. The average water charge was £109.50, the average sewerage charge was £108.09 and the total annual charge was £218.95 (including an average VAT charge of £1.36).

Measured customers’ water charges depend on their water consumption. The largest water users use more than a million cubic meters per year and are billed on a monthly basis. Many customers use less than 100 cubic meters per year and are billed every six months so the disparity between invoice values and invoice timing means that an average measured water bill is not representative of the bills received by the vast majority of NIW’s customers. The tariff for 2008/09 for measured water is 95.53 pence per cubic meter. There is also a standing charge based on the supply pipe size diameter which varies between £63 and £1600 per year. Where applicable, measured sewerage charges are calculated on the assumption that 95% of water supplied is returned to sewer, unless the customer can demonstrate otherwise. The standing charge for sewerage varies between £31 and £800 for 2008/09 and the tariff for 2008/09 is 66.84 pence per cubic metre.

NIW is happy to work out the expected or average bills for individual accounts based on prior consumption history.

Discounts on Public Transport
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development why blind people are given full discount to use public transport, while partially sighted people are only given a 50% reduction.
(AQW 8786/08)

Mr C Murphy:
When the Concessionary Fares Scheme in the North was extended in 2004 to include half fare travel for people with disabilities, the Department used categories similar to those in the Transport Act 2000 which included that category of persons who were blind or partially sighted. However, in the North, the registered blind had been eligible for free travel since the introduction of the Scheme in 1978.

As part of the Comprehensive Spending Review I bid for the resources to provide free fares for the disabled. This would have included the partially sighted. Unfortunately, that bid was unsuccessful.

North West Gateway Initiative
Mr McElduff asked the Minister for Regional Development what engagement he has had with the North West Gateway Initiative; and what the focus of this initiative has been.
(AQW 8787/08)

Mr C Murphy: As part of the OFMDFM lead North West Gateway Initiative my officials have been working with counterparts from the south to provide a strategic spatial framework for the North West. I will bring the spatial framework to Executive Colleagues shortly.

Royal National Institute for Deaf People
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development what discussions he has had with the Royal National Institute for Deaf People in relation to improvements to shared surface footpaths and roads.
(AQW 8799/08)

Mr C Murphy: I can confirm that I have had no discussions to date, with the Royal National Institute for Deaf People.

However, my Department’s Roads Service takes the needs of those with disabilities very seriously and works closely with officials in the Department for Social Development in matters of urban regeneration, such as Public Realm Schemes. The Belfast Public Realm – 'Streets Ahead' project has been designed in accordance with specifications, which include addressing the needs of disabled people.

Roads Service also has an ongoing programme of installing tactile cones at pedestrian crossings. These can assist both deaf and the visually impaired pedestrians to identify when it is safe to use the crossing.

Free Travel for Over 60s
Mr McGlone asked the Minister for Regional Development what steps have been taken to ensure that the Smart Pass allowing free travel for pensioners is being recognised in both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.
(AQW 8800/08)

Mr C Murphy: Employees of transport operators on both sides of the border have been trained to recognise and differentiate between the Senior SmartPass, the 60 plus SmartPass and the South’s Senior SmartPass. In the North, all three SmartPasses can be read electronically by Translink ticketing equipment.

Road Use
Mr Irwin asked the Minister for Regional Development for the average number of vehicles using, on a daily basis, the (i) A28 Armagh Newry Road; (ii) A3 Armagh Portadown Road; (iii) A29 Armagh Moy Road; (iv) A26 Armagh Killylea Road; and (v) A3 Monaghan Road.
(AQW 8803/08)

Mr C Murphy: Officials from my Department’s Roads Service have advised that some 270 traffic census sites are strategically located throughout the North, on both the major and minor road network. The annual average figure is calculated from information that is recorded for 365 days per year or for at least one week in every quarter of the year. The information is then published in the Traffic and Travel Information Report, which presents the traffic volumes in a variety of formats for each site.

The most recent information on the daily average number of vehicles using the roads that you have specified was calculated in 2007 and is provided in the table below.

For your information, the road between Armagh and Killylea is the A28, and not the A26.

Road No.

Description

Annual Average (5 day) Daily Traffic Count

(i)

A28

Armagh – Newry

10830

(ii)

A3

Armagh - Portadown (counter at Stoneybridge)

14322

A3

Armagh – Portadown
(counter at Armagh Rd, Portadown)

19261

(iii)

A29

Armagh - Moy

11312

(iv)

A28

Armagh - Killylea

4398

(v)

A3

Armagh - Monaghan

7171

UK Government White Paper 'The Future of Air Transport' 2003
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Regional Development what representations his Department made in the consultation process leading to the UK Government White Paper 'The Future of Air Transport' 2003.
(AQW 8817/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department co-ordinated responses to the consultation from public and private bodies and individuals in the North and copied these to the Department for Transport but it did not make a separate representation. To inform the consultation process, my Department commissioned and published "The Northern Ireland Air Services Study", a copy of which I have placed in the Assembly library.

Northern Ireland Water
Mr Shannon asked the Minister for Regional Development when Northern Ireland Water will finish its co-ordination with Loch Cuan House in Newtownards, to enable it to fix the leaks in the water pipes in the Westwinds Estate, which have resulted in flooding in some parts of the estate.
(AQW 8831/08)

Mr C Murphy:
I have been advised by Northern Ireland Water that the leaking valve near Loch Cuan House was repaired on the evening of Thursday 3 July. There was a short interruption to the local supply as a result.

School Buses
Mr Dallat asked the Minister for Regional Development how many school buses operated by Translink were taken out of service over the last year, due to failures related to road safety.
(AQW 8838/08)

Mr C Murphy: Translink does not operate a dedicated school bus fleet. However, I can confirm that no buses delivering school services were taken out of service over the last year due to failures related to road safety.

Rail Stop at Downhill in Coleraine
Mr Dallat asked the Minister for Regional Development what plans he has to introduce a rail stop at Downhill, Coleraine, particularly during the summer season to accommodate holiday makers going to and from beaches.
(AQW 8840/08)

Mr C Murphy:
At this time Northern Ireland Railways have no plans to reintroduce a rail stop at Downhill. The halt at Downhill was discontinued over 30 years ago due to a lack of patronage and it is considered that reintroduction of a stop would extend journey times and be detrimental to passengers presently travelling between Coleraine and Derry.

Traffic Management Schemes in Crumlin
Mr Burns asked the Minister for Regional Development what work is scheduled to be undertaken in Crumlin, Glenavy, Toome, Randalstown and Mallusk by NI Water and the Roads Service in July and August.
(AQW 8846/08)

Mr C Murphy: The Department’s Roads Service has advised that there are a number of proposed Traffic Management schemes for the Crumlin area. Some elements of these schemes will commence during August, including the upgrading of lay-bys on Glenavy Road and Ballytromery Road, and the provision of footway links at Diamond Road. Northern Ireland Water (NIW) has advised that the reinstatement of pre-laid sewer pipe trenches will continue during July and August in the Crumlin area.

Roads Service has advised that there are no works scheduled to be undertaken in Glenavy in July and August. NIW has advised that the final reinstatement, of an existing pipe track, in Main Street is planned for the week commencing 21 July 2008.

Roads Service and NIW have advised that there are no works scheduled to be undertaken in Toome during July and August.
Roads Service has advised that Traffic Calming proposals for Randalstown are currently being advertised in the local newspapers. As the summer closure of schools results in reduced traffic flows, works on the Barnish Road, Craigstown Road and Station Road will be carried out during August. Following the completion of these works the remainder of the Traffic Calming proposals for Randalstown will be undertaken. NIW has advised they plan to lay 400 metres of trunk watermain on the Randalstown Road, between the Rugby Club and the Enkelon Industrial Estate following Moleseye approval.

Roads Service has advised that during July and August work will continue on the M2 Improvement Scheme between Sandyknowes and Greencastle junctions.
Reconstruction of the Hightown Bridge will continue in conjunction with other main elements of the M2 scheme, including the lowering of the city bound carriageway under Hightown and Collin Bridges, and the associated alteration to road drainage, street lighting and motorway communication equipment. NIW has advised that they plan to lay 450 metres of storm sewer and 175 metres of foul sewer on Park Road and Antrim Road, Mallusk.

Public Transport Services
Mr Dallat asked the Minister for Regional Development if the contractual arrangements between Translink and other operators that provide public transport services, provide equality to the (i) operators and (ii) public who use the services.
(AQW 8847/08)

Mr C Murphy:

I have been informed by Translink that the only contractual arrangement it has to provide public transport services is with Chambers Coach Hire Ltd. As such, the question of inequality as between operators does not arise. I can confirm that the service given to the public is the same as that on equivalent services provided directly by Translink.

New Road Linking Ballyhampton to the Antiville Road in Larne
Mr Hilditch asked the Minister for Regional Development when the new road linking Ballyhampton to the Antiville Road in Larne will be completed.
(AQW 8854/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service has advised that the new road to which you refer, is known as the Larne West Spine Road. This is a developer-led housing distributor road, and will run west of Larne, eventually linking Millbrook to Killyglen.

Approximately two thirds of the Larne West Spine Road is already constructed. However, I am unable to provide an exact completion date of the remaining stretch, as the construction of is the responsibility of individual developers.

Northern Ireland Railways' Employees
Mr G Robinson asked the Minister for Regional Development if Northern Ireland Railways' employees are covered by the European Union Working Time directive; and if this directive is adhered to as standard practice.
(AQW 8857/08)

Mr C Murphy: Translink advise me that Northern Ireland Railways’ employees are covered by the European Union Working Time directive which is adhered to as standard practice.

Northern Ireland Railways' Employees
Mr G Robinson asked the Minister for Regional Development for his assessment of (i) the adequacy of a four hour rest between shifts for Northern Ireland Railways' employees; (ii) the possibility of such a short break posing a danger to public safety; and (iii) whether a break of this length complies with the European Union Working Time directive.
(AQW 8863/08)

Mr C Murphy: Translink advise me that shift rostering arrangements within Northern Ireland Railways are designed to be fully compliant with the European Union Working Time directive resulting in a normal minimum rest period between shifts of 11 hours. Under specific abnormal circumstances e.g. weekly shift changeover or as a result of a major service disruption, this may be reduced to 8 hours.

Flooding in East Belfast
Mr Newton asked the Minister for Regional Development what steps he has taken to reduce the potential scale of flooding in East Belfast as experienced on 12 June 2007.
(AQW 8873/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service have advised that the flooding which occurred in June 2007 was described by the Met Office as ‘abnormal’ and, that the storm water road gullies, drainage systems and watercourses were simply overwhelmed by the deluge of water.

This view was supported by the conclusions of an extensive study commissioned by DARD’s Rivers Agency, following the flooding in June 2007. The recommendations of the study are currently being considered by all drainage providers with a view to implementing an integrated flood risk management strategy for East Belfast.

In addition to this study, prior to the flooding in June 2007, DARD’s Rivers Agency had already been progressing two feasibility studies into possible drainage schemes in East Belfast. The design phase of a Flood Alleviation Scheme for a section of the Loop River system is expected to commence shortly, and the results of the East Belfast Feasibility Study are expected in autumn 2008.

Roads Service aim to inspect and clean storm water gullies in urban areas twice per year, and the scheduled maintenance operation for 2008 is ongoing. This policy ensures that a reasonable level of maintenance is carried out to the drainage system, whilst taking account of my Department’s finite funding and staff resource levels.

Northern Ireland Water has advised that it is currently updating and reviewing a Drainage Area Study for the East Belfast Sewer Catchment. This study will assess the structural, hydraulic capacity and environmental needs for the catchment. The study will take account of out of sewer flooding locations and make recommendations for alleviation of this flooding. However, these recommendations will only identify upgrading works to cater for normal rainfall patterns. It will not be possible to provide enlargement of the pipework within the public sewer system to cater for excessive rainfall, events similar to those experienced in June 2007. It is expected that the review of the East Belfast Drainage Study will be completed by April 2009 and that the anticipated upgrading works will be implemented in the following years subject to the current expenditure review.

Traffic Congestion
Mr Burns asked the Minister for Regional Development for his assessment of the current level of traffic congestion at Sandyknowes roundabout and on the M2.
(AQW 8895/08)

Mr C Murphy: AQW 8895/08

In relation to AQW 8895/08, my Department’s Roads Service has advised that at present, on the Belfast-bound carriageway of the M2 approaching the Sandyknowes junction, there is only minor congestion for a short 15 minute period prior to 8.00am. Similarly on the country-bound carriageway of the M2 approaching the Greencastle junction and on the up hill section, there is only minor congestion during the evening peak period. This pattern is expected to continue throughout the summer months.

During the current closure of the Hightown Bridge, traffic is being diverted via a signed diversionary route. In addition to this, the measures that I announced on 7 January 2008 have helped to alleviate disruption in the Glengormley and Mallusk areas, and also reduced the level of traffic congestion on Sandyknowes Roundabout. At present, there is only minor congestion on Sandyknowes Roundabout and its approaches during the morning and evening peaks.

As with any section of road, there is always the potential for an unforeseen incident to occur, which could lead to serious congestion. Roads Service will continue to actively monitor traffic management measures connected with works on the M2 motorway, provide a free breakdown recovery service and co-ordinate work with contractors, to ensure that a minimum of two lanes are available for traffic in each direction.

In relation to AQW 8896/08, my Department’s Roads Service has advised the following progress on the work taking place to upgrade the M2

Longlands Bridge & Collin Bridge

The former Longlands and Collin Bridges have been demolished, and traffic is presently running on a newly constructed half of each of the replacement bridges, under traffic light control.

Hightown Bridge

Construction of the new Hightown Bridge is ongoing. The new bridge foundations, central pier and abutments have been constructed and steel bridge beams placed. The reinforced concrete bridge deck, which will accommodate a right turning lane at the Mallusk Road / Hightown Road junction, is currently being constructed.

Bellevue Bridge

Work is presently underway to upgrade the existing substandard parapets of Bellevue Bridge.

M2 country-bound at Greenisland

Work is underway to upgrade the existing bridge parapets on the country-bound carriageway of the M2 at Greenisland Interchange. This is to facilitate construction of an additional traffic lane on the country-bound carriageway through the junction.

M2 Belfast-bound road works

Work has recently begun to lower the Belfast-bound carriageway of the M2 under the Hightown and Collin Bridges.

The overall M2 improvements scheme is presently on target for completion in summer 2009.

M2 Upgrade
Mr Burns asked the Minister for Regional Development for an update on the work taking place to upgrade the M2, including an estimated completion date.
(AQW 8896/08)

Mr C Murphy:
In relation to AQW 8895/08, my Department’s Roads Service has advised that at present, on the Belfast-bound carriageway of the M2 approaching the Sandyknowes junction, there is only minor congestion for a short 15 minute period prior to 8.00am. Similarly on the country-bound carriageway of the M2 approaching the Greencastle junction and on the up hill section, there is only minor congestion during the evening peak period. This pattern is expected to continue throughout the summer months.

During the current closure of the Hightown Bridge, traffic is being diverted via a signed diversionary route. In addition to this, the measures that I announced on 7 January 2008 have helped to alleviate disruption in the Glengormley and Mallusk areas, and also reduced the level of traffic congestion on Sandyknowes Roundabout. At present, there is only minor congestion on Sandyknowes Roundabout and its approaches during the morning and evening peaks.

As with any section of road, there is always the potential for an unforeseen incident to occur, which could lead to serious congestion. Roads Service will continue to actively monitor traffic management measures connected with works on the M2 motorway, provide a free breakdown recovery service and co-ordinate work with contractors, to ensure that a minimum of two lanes are available for traffic in each direction.

In relation to AQW 8896/08, my Department’s Roads Service has advised the following progress on the work taking place to upgrade the M2

Longlands Bridge & Collin Bridge

The former Longlands and Collin Bridges have been demolished, and traffic is presently running on a newly constructed half of each of the replacement bridges, under traffic light control.

Hightown Bridge

Construction of the new Hightown Bridge is ongoing. The new bridge foundations, central pier and abutments have been constructed and steel bridge beams placed. The reinforced concrete bridge deck, which will accommodate a right turning lane at the Mallusk Road / Hightown Road junction, is currently being constructed.

Bellevue Bridge

Work is presently underway to upgrade the existing substandard parapets of Bellevue Bridge.

M2 country-bound at Greenisland

Work is underway to upgrade the existing bridge parapets on the country-bound carriageway of the M2 at Greenisland Interchange. This is to facilitate construction of an additional traffic lane on the country-bound carriageway through the junction.

M2 Belfast-bound road works

Work has recently begun to lower the Belfast-bound carriageway of the M2 under the Hightown and Collin Bridges.

The overall M2 improvements scheme is presently on target for completion in summer 2009.

Blasting on the A1 Road
Mr D Bradley asked the Minister for Regional Development for the full schedule of blasting on the A1 road.
(AQW 8902/08)

Mr C Murphy:
The contractor undertaking this work has provided Roads Service with the schedule below, detailing blasting operations at Cloghogue.

Roads Service Design Build Finance Operate Package 2 : Scheme 1 - Beech Hill to Cloghogue

Schedule of Planned Rock Blasting at Cloghogue, Chancellors Road and Derrybeg Lane

Week beginning

Date

Comment

Monday - 7 July 2008

Road expected to be closed on Wednesday and Friday for up to 20 minutes between 12.00am and 4.00pm - delays expected.

Monday - Derrybeg Lane
Wednesday - Cloghogue (south)
Friday - Derrybeg Lane and Cloghogue (south)

Monday - 14 July 2008

Although UIE will be closed this week, work will continue on blast drilling in all areas to make provision for future blasting operations.

No Blasts this week due to closure of Ulster Industrial Explosives (UIE) for holidays

Monday - 21 July 2008

Road expected to be closed up to 20 minutes between 12.00am and 4.00pm on the day that blasting takes place at Cloghogue (north) - delays expected.

Monday - Derrybeg Lane.
Wednesday – Derrybeg Lane
Friday - Derrybeg Lane

Note: - Blasting will also start at Cloghogue (north) this week, but the Construction Contractor cannot be more specific currently and advises that only 1 blast at that location is anticipated.

Monday - 28 July 2008

Road expected to be closed on Monday, Wednesday and Friday for up to 20 minutes between 12.00am and 4.00pm - delays expected.

Monday,
Wednesday, and
Friday; -

Cloghogue (north),
Chancellors Road and
Derrybeg Lane

Monday 4 August 2008 and following

The Construction Contractor' advise that it is its intention to continue blasting at Cloghogue, Chancellor’s Road and Derrybeg Lane at frequent intervals over the next 12 months or so.

Since the operations at both Cloghogue and Chancellors Road have the potential to impact significantly on the travelling public, the blasting operations at these locations will be restricted to Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays between 12:00 noon and 4:00 pm to enable the travelling public to better plan their journeys. On these occasions the road is expected to be closed for up to 20 minutes between 12.00am and 4.00pm - delays expected.

Rock blasting remote from traffic on the A1 Newry Bypass (i.e. in the Derrybeg Lane area) may also take place on any day from Monday-Friday inclusive.

The Construction Contractor advised that a detailed programme for blasting beyond the current 4-week period (ie after week beginning 28 July) has not yet been prepared and is subject to many factors out with its control, including the availability of explosives from UIE, availability of PSNI personnel and the railway timetable, and progress on processing and clearing previously blasted material.

Capital Works Projects
Mr Gallagher asked the Minister for Regional Development (i) what firms have been placed on the select list for tenders for Capital Works Projects in (a) 2005-2006, (b) 2006-2007 and (c) 2007-2008; and (ii) what firms have applied to be placed on the select list but have not been successful.
(AQW 8924/08)

Mr C Murphy:
My Department’s Roads Service does not have a select list for tenders for Capital Works projects.

The A6 Dualling Scheme from Derry/Londonderry to Dungiven
Ms Anderson asked the Minister for Regional Development for an update on the deliberations in relation to the preferred route for the A6 dualling scheme from Derry/Londonderry to Dungiven.
(AQW 8942/08)

Mr C Murphy: My Department’s Roads Service is currently examining possible alignments for the proposed A6 Derry to Dungiven dual carriageway. These potential routes were communicated to the public during May 2008, through a series of Community Information Events. The public feedback received from these events, in conjunction with the results of a wide range of other surveys and assessments, will allow Roads Service to comprehensively explore all possible routes. This examination should allow an announcement of the ‘preferred route’ to be made in spring 2009. Once the alignment of this route has been finalised, an in-depth assessment will allow the publication of draft statutory procedures and an Environmental Statement in autumn 2010.

Roads Service expects that the timing for the construction of the dual carriageway will be determined by a Public Inquiry into the scheme held during 2011, and that planning will be completed in early 2012. The scheme is proposed to be delivered within the period 2013 to 2018.

Cycle Lanes
Mrs Long asked the Minister for Regional Development (i) how many miles of cycle lanes there are (a) in total; and (b) by constituency; and (ii) how many additional miles of cycle lanes have been added in each of the last three financial years (a) in total; and (b) by constituency.
(AQW 8947/08)

Mr C Murphy: With regard to AQW 8947/08, my Department’s Roads Service does not maintain details of cycle lanes on a parliamentary constituency basis. However, the table below provides details, where available, of the total miles of cycle lanes in each Council area, where cycle lanes are in operation, and the additional miles of cycle lanes added in each of the last three financial years.

Council

Total Cycle Lanes (miles)

Miles of cycle lanes provided in

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Belfast

46.53

2.99

1.43

1.80

Carrickfergus

1.19

0.24

0

0

Castlereagh

12.67

2.32

0.25

3.86

Lisburn

21.64

0.31

1.73

2.21

Newtownabbey

12.00

0.62

0.88

0.24

North Down

11.71

1.09

0

0

Antrim

8.58

2.17

0

1.27

Ballymena

5.10

0

0

0.4

Coleraine

17.31

0.24

0.5

1.03

Limavady

6.90

0.44

0

0

Derry

18.00

1.93

1.20

2.20

Larne

1.24

0

0

0

Ballymoney

1.03

0

0

0.5

Craigavon

Not Available

0.63

0

0.07

Down

Not Available

0.18

0

0.31

Newry & Mourne

Not Available

5.46

1.49

0

Ards

Not Available

0

1.05

0.36

Banbridge

Not Available

0

0.42

0

Armagh

Not Available

0

0

0.12

TOTALS

163.90

18.62

8.95

14.37

In relation to AQW 8948/08, Roads Service does not maintain details of bus lanes on a parliamentary constituency basis. However, the table below provides details of the total miles of bus lanes in each Council area, where bus lanes are in operation, and the additional miles of bus lanes added in each of the last three financial years.

Council

Total Bus Lanes (Miles)

Miles of Bus lanes provided in

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Belfast

14.50

2.40

0

0.10

Carrickfergus

0

0

0

0

Castlereagh

1.40

0.30

0

0

Lisburn

4.10

0

2.10

0.20

Newtownabbey

2.70

0

0

1.40

Antrim

0.01

0

0

0

Ballymena

0.21

0

0

0

TOTALS

22.92

2.70

2.10

1.70

Bus Lanes
Mrs Long asked the Minister for Regional Development (i) how many miles of bus lanes there are (a) in total; and (b) by constituency; and (ii) how many additional miles of bus lanes have been added in each of the last three financial years (a) in total; and (b) by constituency.
(AQW 8948/08)

Mr C Murphy: With regard to AQW 8947/08, my Department’s Roads Service does not maintain details of cycle lanes on a parliamentary constituency basis. However, the table below provides details, where available, of the total miles of cycle lanes in each Council area, where cycle lanes are in operation, and the additional miles of cycle lanes added in each of the last three financial years.

Council

Total Cycle Lanes (miles)

Miles of cycle lanes provided in

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Belfast

46.53

2.99

1.43

1.80

Carrickfergus

1.19

0.24

0

0

Castlereagh

12.67

2.32

0.25

3.86

Lisburn

21.64

0.31

1.73

2.21

Newtownabbey

12.00

0.62

0.88

0.24

North Down

11.71

1.09

0

0

Antrim

8.58

2.17

0

1.27

Ballymena

5.10

0

0

0.4

Coleraine

17.31

0.24

0.5

1.03

Limavady

6.90

0.44

0

0

Derry

18.00

1.93

1.20

2.20

Larne

1.24

0

0

0

Ballymoney

1.03

0

0

0.5

Craigavon

Not Available

0.63

0

0.07

Down

Not Available

0.18

0

0.31

Newry & Mourne

Not Available

5.46

1.49

0

Ards

Not Available

0

1.05

0.36

Banbridge

Not Available

0

0.42

0

Armagh

Not Available

0

0

0.12

TOTALS

163.90

18.62

8.95

14.37

In relation to AQW 8948/08, Roads Service does not maintain details of bus lanes on a parliamentary constituency basis. However, the table below provides details of the total miles of bus lanes in each Council area, where bus lanes are in operation, and the additional miles of bus lanes added in each of the last three financial years.

Council

Total Bus Lanes (Miles)

Miles of Bus lanes provided in

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Belfast

14.50

2.40

0

0.10

Carrickfergus

0

0

0

0

Castlereagh

1.40

0.30

0

0

Lisburn

4.10

0

2.10

0.20

Newtownabbey

2.70

0

0

1.40

Antrim

0.01

0

0

0

Ballymena

0.21

0

0

0

TOTALS

22.92

2.70

2.10

1.70

Social Development

Multi-Element Improvement for Annadale Flats
Mr Spratt asked the Minister for Social Development, pursuant to her answer to AQW 7551/08, how many of the 145 flats identified for the multi-element improvement scheme are currently 3 bedroom properties.
(AQW 8302/08)

The Minister for Social Development (Ms M Ritchie): As these two questions are linked I shall answer them together. Of the 145 Housing Executive flats identified for multi-element improvement 45 are currently 3-bedroom. The waiting list for Annadale is predominately for singles, with only one family in housing stress requiring 3-bedroom accommodation. The proportion of three bedroom accommodation proposed is considered sufficient for current needs.

Waterloo Place/Guildhall Square Public Realm Scheme
Ms Anderson asked the Minister for Social Development how she intends to utilize the new Procurement guidelines during the implementation of the Waterloo Place/Guildhall Square Public Realm scheme, and whether she plans to work with local communities when devising her implementation plans.
(AQW 8408/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The Waterloo Place/Guildhall Square Public Realm scheme will revitalise an important part of Derry City Centre. The procurement guidelines will be used to support local inputs as far as possible and local communities will be involved.

Woodburn Housing Scheme in Carrickfergus
Mr Hilditch asked the Minister for Social Development what progress the Northern Ireland Housing Executive has made in relation to finding a new contractor to complete the Woodburn Housing Scheme in Carrickfergus.
(AQW 8493/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The contractor previously responsible for the scheme in question, Ashley Decorators, has been wound up by the court. The Housing Executive has secured the 5 dwellings in which the contractor had been working but had not completed the required works. The Housing Executive is currently going through the normal procurement process required to get a new contractor appointed and on site and will seek to expedite the necessary works as quickly as possible.

Hibernia Street in Holywood
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development what plans she has to complete the sale or transfer of public land in Hibernia Street, Holywood.
(AQW 8536/08)

Ms M Ritchie: DSD officials are working with colleagues in DRD to bring forward a regeneration scheme which uses existing DRD owned land in Hibernia Street.

Hibernia Street in Holywood
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development what action she is taking to tie down legal arrangements for the car park in Hibernia Street, Holywood.
(AQW 8537/08)

Ms M Ritchie: DSD and DRD are working with solicitors from DFP to resolve a number of difficulties in relation to this development. Officials have briefed me on these issues and progress on discussions with our legal team. I have stressed to officials the need for urgency in resolution and have agreed to meet the developer to discuss progress

Hibernia Street in Holywood
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development what progress the Department has made in the last year to resolving legal difficulties surrounding Hibernia Street in Holywood.
(AQW 8538/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Progress has been made in relation to the form and nature of the proposed development contract and in relation to resolving errors and inconsistencies in relation to title to the various portions of land involved.

Hibernia Street in Holywood
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development when the Department expects to have resolved all the difficulties surrounding the development at Hibernia Street, Holywood.
(AQW 8539/08)

Ms M Ritchie: DSD and DRD are working with solicitors from DFP to resolve a number of difficulties in relation to this development. Although I would hope that these could be resolved in coming weeks I am not able to give a definitive date at this stage.

Social Housing Units in Belfast City Centre
Ms Ní Chuilín asked the Minister for Social Development how many social housing units her Department expects to provide in or around Belfast city centre.
(AQW 8545/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The Social Housing Development Programme for the next 5 years will provide 672 new homes within Belfast city centre. This will be complemented by re-lets of existing stock.

Fuel Allowances for People with Disabilities
Mr Adams asked the Minister for Social Development what plans she has to introduce a fuel allowance for people with disabilities.
(AQW 8570/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Disabled people who satisfy the qualifying conditions are already included in the Winter Fuel Payment Scheme. Cold Weather Payments are also made to vulnerable groups, including those people who get a disability premium in their income support or income-based jobseeker’s allowance regardless of age, when there is severe weather in their area.

Disabled people can receive disability benefits, and the disability premium in income-related benefits, in recognition of their extra costs. The care and mobility components in Disability Living Allowance for a person under 65 years old are used as broad indicators of the extra costs a disabled person has which include heating, laundry or special diets.

There are other schemes available to help with fuel costs such as the Warm Homes Scheme. Among the eligible groups for this Scheme are householders who claim disability related benefits such as Disability Living Allowance. This Scheme provides assistance towards insulating their homes with a grant of up to £850.

As a direct response to the recent rise in fuel prices I have established a Task Force to identify ways to help the most vulnerable in society. The Task Force will report back to me with recommendations before the end of the summer. On the basis of those recommendations I intend to have a set of practical and achievable proposals in place to bring to the Executive for consideration in the early Autumn.

Surplus land at Breezemount Estate
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development why surplus land owned by the Housing Executive at Breezemount, North Down, was offered for sale to North Down Borough Council, rather than to a housing association for use as additional social housing.
(AQW 8607/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The surplus land at Breezemount was not offered to a housing association because the Housing Executive assessment of need in the area showed that there is no requirement for additional social housing.

Housing Executive Applicants
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development how many Housing Executive applicants have been in 'housing stress' in North Down, in each of the last 5 years.
(AQW 8608/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The number of applicants in housing stress in North Down in each of the last five years was as follows:

2003/04 714
2004/05 730
2005/06 842
2006/07 978
2007/08 1,011

Departmental Response to Increasing Fuel Costs
Mrs Long asked the Minister for Social Development what assessment she has made of the impact of the increase in (i) fuel costs; and (ii) fuel duty on the departmental budget and the realisation of efficiency targets; and what action she has taken to mitigate against these increased costs.
(AQW 8629/08)
Ms M Ritchie: Whilst the Department’s fuel costs are regularly monitored, no formal assessment has been made to date of the impact of the increase in fuel costs and fuel duty on departmental budgets or efficiency targets. Staff are made aware – through the Energy Matters section on the local intranet – of the need to conserve energy in all our buildings.

My Department is also committed to delivering on 3 key sustainable development targets in relation to energy usage i.e. sourcing electricity requirements from renewable sources; reducing absolute carbon from fuel and electricity used in buildings; and increasing the energy efficiency of the buildings occupied in terms of fuel and electricity used per square metre of building floor area.

The most recent progress report against these targets indicates that the first 2 are being met, while the 3^rd one is being actively pursued. The pursuit and achievement of good energy saving practices and the above targets, serves to mitigate against increased fuel costs, notwithstanding that increases would, in any case, have to be met from within existing budget baselines. In particular, the implementation of automatic electricity "power down" procedures this Autumn, is intended to help keep overall electricity usage down, thereby absorbing some of the increased costs anticipated.

Achieving Excellence in Construction (Egan Initiative)
Mr B Wilson asked the Minister for Social Development how many instances have occurred where contractors, that have been awarded tenders under Achieving Excellence in Construction (Egan Initiative), subcontracted these tenders to other contractors, since 2001.
(AQW 8638/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Unfortunately the information requested is not readily available and could only be supplied at disproportionate cost.

Achieving Excellence in Construction (Egan Initiative)
Mr B Wilson asked the Minister for Social Development what is the average cost per home for heating replacement in Housing Executive houses under Achieving Excellence in Construction (Egan Initiative) for each year since the scheme's introduction in 2001.
(AQW 8639/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The average cost per home for heating replacement in Housing Executive homes under Achieving Excellence in Construction (Egan Initiative) is:

2001/02 - £3,125
2002/03 - £3,259
2003/04 - £3,694
2004/05 - £3,927
2005/06 - £4,187
2006/07 - £4,753
2007/08 - £4,905

Safety for Deaf and Blind Road Users
Mr Lunn asked the Minister for Social Development what proposals she is bringing forward to ensure the regeneration of town centres enhances the safety of deaf and blind road users.
(AQW 8640/08)

Ms M Ritchie: My Department is responsible for town and city centre regeneration which includes public realm and environmental improvement schemes. As part of the design aspect of these schemes, there is an undertaking to consult widely including Disability Group representatives such as deaf and blind road users. Each scheme must also be Disability Discrimination Act compliant on completion and an Equality Impact Assessment is normally carried out to ensure that the scheme meets guidelines on addressing disability and other equality issues.

The Department for Regional Development’s Roads Service manages the implementation of a significant proportion of the public realm and environmental improvement schemes funded by my Department.

They ensure that the project is designed and implemented to conform to the required specifications including road safety for the blind, partially sighted and other disabled people.

In order to assist the visually impaired, Roads Service has an ongoing programme of installing tactile paving, tactile cones and also the use of audible signals, at pedestrian crossings, where this is deemed appropriate.

New Social Housing at Upper Crescent in Comber
Mr Hamilton asked the Minister for Social Development when it is anticipated that (i) construction of new social housing at Upper Crescent in Comber will conclude; and (ii) the Housing Executive will begin allocating these new homes.
(AQW 8646/08)

Ms M Ritchie: This 50 house social housing scheme is scheduled for completion in February 2010. Houses will be handed over by the contractor on a phased basis with each phase pre-allocated some four weeks in advance.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development for details of the original terms of the vesting order with which the Andersonstown barracks site was acquired by the British military.
(AQW 8718/08)

Ms M Ritchie: My Department acquired the land from the Police Service of Northern Ireland under the Disposal of Surplus Land and Buildings by Public Sector Bodies Procedures. I am not aware of the details of the terms of the original acquisition of the site for policing purposes. This is a matter for the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development to detail any legal arrangements that accompanied the original vesting order to return the Andersonstown barracks site to public ownership; and to outline any subsequent changes in the legal framework.
(AQW 8719/08)

Ms M Ritchie: My Department acquired the land from the Police Service of Northern Ireland under the Disposal of Surplus Land and Buildings by Public Sector Bodies Procedures. Following acquisition by my Department, and on legal advice, the land was subjected to a vesting order to provide clear title to the land. I am not aware of the legal arrangements that accompanied the original acquisition of the site for policing purposes. This is a matter for the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development what impact falling land prices, particularly in relation to marginal urban land, are having on the current value of the Andersonstown barracks site.
(AQW 8720/08)

Ms M Ritchie: My Department acquired the site from the Police Service of Northern Ireland in February 2006 at a value determined independently by valuers in the Department of Finance and Personnel’s Land and Property Services. I have not sought to have the site revalued.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development to detail the process, including precedents, by which the Andersonstown barracks site could be gift-aided to the local community.
(AQW 8721/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The process covering gifting is set out in Government Accounting Northern Ireland (GANI) and this stipulates that DFP and Assembly approval is required for any gift exceeding £100,000. There may be circumstances in which the Department has in the past agreed to transfer land at a nominal or nil value. This however was for areas of residual land of little worth, for the creation of recreational land or when supported by the Land and Property Services. Under current GANI regulations the Department has an obligation to ensure that the consideration received for development land is the "best that can reasonably be obtained".

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development to detail the development proposals for the Andersonstown barracks site which were rejected in favour of the Carvill group's proposal; and to outline any further consideration she has given to these proposals following the withdrawal of the Carvill group from the project.
(AQW 8722/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The development brief process for this site resulted in six development proposals being received for a variety of mixed use developments including commercial, community, office and hotel developments. All proposals included an element for residential use. In October 2007, following the withdrawal of the private sector proposal for this site, I indicated my intention to consider the matter further before making a decision on the way forward. On 20 November 2007 I announced that I intended to explore the development opportunities for a commercial hub in the Andersonstown area including the former Barracks site. A feasibility study into establishing this gateway has been commissioned and is currently underway.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development how much was paid by the Department for the acquisition of the Andersonstown Barracks site.
(AQW 8726/08)

Ms M Ritchie: My Department acquired the site from the Police Service of Northern Ireland in February 2006 for £400,000.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development how much has been spent by the Department on the development of the Andersonstown Barracks site since its acquisition.
(AQW 8728/08)

Ms M Ritchie: No monies have been spent by the Department for Social Development on the development of this site since its acquisition. All demolition and site clearance works were carried out by PSNI in advance of purchase.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development to detail the value of the tender awarded by the Department to Deloitte and Touche to undertake the community engagement process in the vicinity of the Andersonstown Barracks site.
(AQW 8730/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The cost of the Deloitte MCS Ltd consultancy for community engagement on the Andersonstown Gateway Feasibility Study is £37,698, excluding VAT.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development how she has encouraged and facilitated the submission of the widest possible range of development proposals for the Andersonstown barracks site within the commercial and social sector.
(AQW 8731/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The development brief process for the Andersonstown barracks site involved local consultation and advertisements in the three local daily newspapers seeking development proposals for the site.

The purpose of the Andersonstown Gateway Feasibility Study is to examine a range of site intervention opportunities in the Gateway area that will determine the feasibility of a commercial hub in this part of West Belfast. An output of the study, which will include community engagement as well as consultation with key stakeholders, will be a set of options for action in the Gateway area. This will help inform future decisions on both individual and assembled site development including the former Barracks site.

Andersonstown Barracks Site
Mr P Maskey asked the Minister for Social Development how the map that was submitted to Deloitte and Touche, to determine the boundaries of the consultation process in relation to the development of the Andersonstown barracks site, was generated; and the decisions underpinning the imposition of those boundaries.
(AQW 8733/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The map contained in the terms of reference for both the Andersonstown Gateway Feasibility Study and the community engagement strand set indicative boundaries as a starting point for the Andersonstown Gateway Project Steering Group which has representatives from the statutory sector as well political and community representatives. Following the first meeting of the steering group it was proposed that the geography of the ‘face to face’ element of the community engagement be expanded outside the area described in the initial map. This has been agreed and is now within the terms of reference for Deloitte MCS Ltd.

Properties Offered by the Housing Executive
Mr McKay asked the Minister for Social Development how many properties the Housing Executive has offered to (i) Ballyloughan Community Initiative; and (ii) Durlston Pastoral Care Centre; how many offers the Housing Executive has withdrawn; and what action she is taking to ensure that this service remains in the Dunloy area.
(AQW 8752/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The Housing Executive offered two properties to Durlston Pastoral Care Centre. Both were withdrawn when planning change of use was refused. It has been agreed that the Centre can remain in Durlston House until the lease expires in August 2010. Meantime, liaison will continue to identify alternative accommodation.

Communications Posts in North Belfast
Ms Ní Chuilín asked the Minister for Social Development why she will not support the maintenance of the two communications posts in North Belfast despite unanimous support from the Community Empowerment Network that they remain.
(AQW 8757/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The North Belfast Community Action Unit is currently in discussion with the Community Empowerment Network as to how to sustain the 2 communications posts in North Belfast.

Reallocation of Housing Funding
Mr Brady asked the Minister for Social Development what departmental funding for housing has been relocated to other areas within the Department, such as the Warm Homes Scheme.
(AQW 8769/08)

Ms M Ritchie: There has been no reallocation of funding for Housing to other areas within the Department. The Warm Homes Scheme has been allocated £21.4m for the 2008/09 financial year.

Warm Homes Scheme
Mr Doherty asked the Minister for Social Development how many Warm Homes Scheme applications are (i) currently being processed; and (ii) awaiting assessment, broken down by District Council area; and (iii) what the average timescale is for the completion of a Warm Home Scheme application.
(AQW 8779/08)

Ms M Ritchie: In an attempt to address the Warm Homes Scheme waiting list I asked Eaga to prioritise applicants so that those most in need get help first. Applicants with no central heating, solid fuel or Economy 7 heating will be treated as a priority and this makes it difficult to estimate the average timescale for a completion of an application as any new applications meeting this criteria will be completed first.

The information is not available in the format requested. Eaga collate information from geographical areas which can be subdivided into postcode area. There are a total of 4,867 live applications in the system. This figure can be broken down further; 1,619 referrals are currently with surveyors and 3,248 referrals are waiting to be allocated to surveyors. The information in the attached table shows the number of referrals waiting to be allocated to a surveyor.

AREA 1

AREA 2

AREA 3

AREA 4

AREA 5

TOTAL

Works in Progress

798

537

676

495

742

3,248

AREA 1

AREA 2

AREA 3

AREA 4

AREA 5

BT60

BT45

BT1

BT3

BT2

BT61

BT46

BT13

BT4

BT7

BT62

BT47

BT14

BT5

BT8

BT63

BT48

BT15

BT6

BT9

BT64

BT49

BT29

BT16

BT10

BT65

BT51

BT36

BT18

BT11

BT66

BT52

BT37

BT19

BT12

BT67

BT53

BT38

BT20

BT17

BT68

BT54

BT39

BT21

BT24

BT69

BT55

BT40

BT22

BT25

BT70

BT56

BT41

BT23

BT26

BT71

BT57

BT42

BT30

BT27

BT74

BT81

BT42

BT33

BT28

BT75

BT82

BT43

BT31

BT76

BT32

BT77

BT34

BT78

BT35

BT79

BT80

BT92

BT93

BT94

Pricewaterhouse Coopers and the Co-ownership Housing Scheme
Mrs Hanna asked the Minister for Social Development for an update on the work carried out by Pricewaterhouse Coopers as specialist advisors on the Co-ownership Housing Scheme.
(AQW 8788/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Responsibility for the day to day financial management of co-ownership, rests with Northern Ireland Co-ownership Housing Association (NICHA).

Although I have allocated £15m direct grant to the Association in the current year, in order to meet targets set, the Association will also need to borrow from financial institutions. NICHA has appointed PWC to advise on their borrowing configuration and future financing model and that work is progressing satisfactorily.

Homeless Figures
Mr Simpson asked the Minister for Social Development how many people are classed as being homeless for more than six months (i) in total; and (ii) broken down by district council area.
(AQW 8809/08)

Ms M Ritchie: As these two questions are linked I will answer them together. The table below shows the number of people at the 31 March 2008 classed as being homeless for more than 6 months and in total, broken down by district council area.

Council area

Homeless for more than 6 months

Total Homeless

Belfast

2,877

3,426

Antrim

231

284

Ballymena

496

566

Ballymoney

87

114

Carrickfergus

188

251

Coleraine

274

345

Larne

97

117

Moyle

66

91

Newtownabbey

406

505

Armagh

104

132

Banbridge

161

197

Craigavon

186

265

Dungannon

169

218

Fermanagh

182

232

Newry

413

476

Ards

340

426

Castlereagh

280

324

Down

284

366

Lisburn

697

854

North Down

442

538

Cookstown

38

53

Derry

528

697

Limavady

74

96

Magherafelt

128

158

Omagh

14

30

Strabane

44

72

Total

8,808

10,835

Homeless Figures
Mr Simpson asked the Minister for Social Development how many people are classed as being homeless (i) in total; and (ii) broken down by district council area.
(AQW 8810/08)

Ms M Ritchie: As these two questions are linked I will answer them together. The table below shows the number of people at the 31 March 2008 classed as being homeless for more than 6 months and in total, broken down by district council area.

Council area

Homeless for more than 6 months

Total Homeless

Belfast

2,877

3,426

Antrim

231

284

Ballymena

496

566

Ballymoney

87

114

Carrickfergus

188

251

Coleraine

274

345

Larne

97

117

Moyle

66

91

Newtownabbey

406

505

Armagh

104

132

Banbridge

161

197

Craigavon

186

265

Dungannon

169

218

Fermanagh

182

232

Newry

413

476

Ards

340

426

Castlereagh

280

324

Down

284

366

Lisburn

697

854

North Down

442

538

Cookstown

38

53

Derry

528

697

Limavady

74

96

Magherafelt

128

158

Omagh

14

30

Strabane

44

72

Total

8,808

10,835

Integrated Housing
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Social Development for her assessment of the desire for mixed, shared or integrated housing.
(AQW 8814/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The Housing Executive undertook a Public Attitude Survey in 2006 which confirmed that for Northern Ireland as a whole:

50% of households expressed their desire to live/remain in a mixed religion area.

25% of households stated that the religious mix of the area where they lived was unimportant.

24% of households stated that they would prefer to live in an area of predominantly one religion, or the other.

1% of households stated that they didn’t know.

The Housing Executive proposes conducting a survey of residents within the first Shared Future housing scheme at Carran Crescent, Fermanagh in late 2008 and will publish the findings when the research is completed.

Integrated Housing
Dr Farry asked the Minister for Social Development for her assessment of public views on her Department's performance in the delivery of mixed housing, based upon the Northern Ireland Life and Times Surveys and other reports.
(AQW 8818/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The Housing Executive undertook a Public Attitude Survey in 2006 which confirmed that for Northern Ireland as a whole:

50% of households expressed their desire to live/remain in a mixed religion area.

25% of households stated that the religious mix of the area where they lived was unimportant.

24% of households stated that they would prefer to live in an area of predominantly one religion, or the other.

1% of households stated that they didn’t know.

The Housing Executive proposes conducting a survey of residents within the first Shared Future housing scheme at Carran Crescent, Fermanagh in late 2008 and will publish the findings when the research is completed.

Disability Living Allowance
Mr Storey asked the Minister for Social Development how many people were in receipt of Disability Living Allowance in total, in each of the last 3 years, broken down by (i) parliamentary constituency; (ii) District Council area; and (iii) Social Security Office.
(AQW 8820/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The information requested is set out in the attached tables. The numbers shown reflect the number of claims where an amount of Disability Living Allowance is in payment.

Table 1: Disability Living Allowance recipients by Parliamentary Constituency

Parliamentary Constituency

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Belfast East

7,228

7,322

7,302

Belfast North

12,198

12,287

12,263

Belfast South

7,182

7,248

7,238

Belfast West

16,092

16,114

16,117

East Antrim

6,458

6,624

6,751

East Londonderry

6,851

6,977

7,095

Fermanagh and South Tyrone

8,692

8,612

8,748

Foyle

13,482

13,586

13,763

Lagan Valley

7,712

7,873

7,996

Mid Ulster

9,002

9,171

9,375

Newry and Armagh

11,322

11,369

11,416

North Antrim

7,644

7,880

8,027

North Down

5,481

5,653

5,750

South Antrim

7,761

7,966

8,114

South Down

10,551

10,718

10,918

Strangford

7,558

7,714

7,842

Upper Bann

11,571

11,723

11,926

West Tyrone

11,763

11,775

11,966

Unallocated Postcode*

641

1,128

1,078

Total

169,189

171,740

173,685

In producing this analysis, individual records were attributed to Electoral Wards and Parliamentary Constituency on the basis of their postcode. Not all records can be correctly allocated to a ward using this method, and some cannot be allocated at all.

Table 2: Disability Living Allowance recipients by District Council area

District Council Area

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Antrim

4,033

4,151

4,190

Ards

5,836

5,998

6,074

Armagh

5,189

5,237

5,314

Ballymena

3,849

3,961

4,087

Ballymoney

2,432

2,536

2,544

Banbridge

3,965

4,056

4,118

Belfast

35,172

35,343

35,352

Carrickfergus

3,011

3,095

3,170

Castlereagh

5,047

5,125

5,136

Coleraine

3,835

3,945

3,999

Cookstown

3,929

3,999

4,053

Craigavon

9,179

9,263

9,448

Derry

13,482

13,586

13,763

Down

6,466

6,574

6,722

Dungannon

5,622

5,665

5,706

Fermanagh

4,996

4,893

5,021

Larne

2,256

2,341

2,398

Limavady

3,016

3,032

3,096

Lisburn

9,739

9,913

10,019

Magherafelt

3,147

3,226

3,343

Moyle

1,363

1,383

1,396

Newry & Mourne

10,016

10,071

10,080

Newtownabbey

6,529

6,641

6,707

North Down

4,676

4,803

4,905

Omagh

6,249

6,275

6,401

Strabane

5,514

5,500

5,565

Unallocated Postcode*

641

1,128

1,078

Total

169,189

171,740

173,685

In producing this analysis, individual records were attributed to Electoral Wards and Parliamentary Constituency on the basis of their postcode. Not all records can be correctly allocated to a ward using this method, and some cannot be allocated at all.

Table 3: Disability Living Allowance recipients by Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office boundary

Social Security Office / Jobs and Benefits Office

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Andersonstown

7,606

7,548

7,574

Antrim

4,918

5,042

5,165

Armagh

4,575

4,600

4,646

Ballymena

4,335

4,448

4,582

Ballymoney

3,580

3,707

3,721

Ballynahinch

2,261

2,353

2,429

Banbridge

4,083

4,182

4,248

Bangor

5,080

5,255

5,324

Carrickfergus

3,016

3,101

3,176

Coleraine

3,836

3,941

4,002

Cookstown

3,365

3,424

3,450

Corporation Street

8,717

8,730

8,720

Downpatrick

3,235

3,276

3,342

Dungannon

5,193

5,231

5,265

Enniskillen

5,396

5,293

5,442

Falls Road

6,521

6,605

6,636

Foyle

8,877

8,877

8,968

Holywood Road

6,901

6,957

7,023

Kilkeel

1,505

1,526

1,540

Knockbreda

5,688

5,755

5,705

Larne

2,262

2,347

2,403

Limavady

2,712

2,726

2,784

Lisburn

6,087

6,228

6,305

Lisnagelvin

4,976

5,086

5,169

Lurgan

6,258

6,356

6,509

Magherafelt

3,389

3,482

3,605

Newcastle

2,021

2,052

2,088

Newry

8,190

8,234

8,220

Newtownabbey

5,474

5,532

5,484

Newtownards

4,719

4,820

4,883

Omagh

6,106

6,130

6,254

Portadown

4,173

4,195

4,272

Shaftesbury Square

4,299

4,361

4,385

Shankill Road

3,644

3,685

3,679

Strabane

5,510

5,493

5,562

Unallocated Postcode*

681

1,162

1,125

Total

169,189

171,740

173,685

Disability Living Allowance is a centralised benefit and therefore has no Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office indicator. Table 3 is a breakdown of customers whose postcodes fall within each of the 35 Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office boundaries. "Unallocated Postcode" in this instance refers to those postcodes which cannot be referenced on the Geographic Information System and therefore cannot be assigned to a Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office boundary.

Incapacity Benefit
Mr Storey asked the Minister for Social Development how many people were in receipt of Incapacity Benefit in total, in each of the last 3 years, broken down by (i) parliamentary constituency; (ii) District Council area; and (iii) Social Security Office.
(AQW 8821/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The information requested is set out in the attached tables. The numbers shown reflect the number of claims where an amount of Incapacity Benefit is in payment at the date of extract.

Table 1: Incapacity Benefit recipients by Parliamentary Constituency

Parliamentary Constituency

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Belfast East

2,989

2,859

2,789

Belfast North

4,536

4,408

4,306

Belfast South

2,820

2,752

2,705

Belfast West

4,722

4,601

4,477

East Antrim

3,184

3,104

3,058

East Londonderry

3,495

3,382

3,394

Fermanagh and South Tyrone

3,522

3,313

3,242

Foyle

5,455

5,315

5,169

Lagan Valley

3,383

3,368

3,315

Mid Ulster

4,101

3,966

3,948

Newry and Armagh

4,705

4,421

4,330

North Antrim

4,003

3,936

3,859

North Down

2,521

2,450

2,439

South Antrim

3,460

3,399

3,349

South Down

4,455

4,347

4,310

Strangford

3,640

3,482

3,472

Upper Bann

5,605

5,283

5,203

West Tyrone

4,722

4,475

4,462

Unallocated Postcode*

457

584

548

Total

71,775

69,445

68,375

* In producing this analysis, individual records were allocated to Electoral wards and Parliamentary Constituency on the basis of their postcode. Not all records can be correctly allocated to a ward using this method and some cannot be allocated at all.

Table 2: Incapacity Benefit recipients by District Council area

District Council Area

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Antrim

1,766

1,722

1,697

Ards

2,843

2,742

2,778

Armagh

2,489

2,287

2,231

Ballymena

2,061

2,049

2,033

Ballymoney

1,282

1,243

1,202

Banbridge

1,989

1,903

1,905

Belfast

12,292

11,925

11,659

Carrickfergus

1,474

1,432

1,411

Castlereagh

2,272

2,163

2,073

Coleraine

2,025

1,971

1,939

Cookstown

1,678

1,648

1,619

Craigavon

4,405

4,168

4,101

Derry

5,455

5,315

5,169

Down

2,586

2,549

2,508

Dungannon

2,285

2,157

2,109

Fermanagh

1,959

1,825

1,825

Larne

1,156

1,141

1,137

Limavady

1,470

1,411

1,455

Lisburn

3,741

3,746

3,669

Magherafelt

1,701

1,649

1,637

Moyle

660

644

624

Newry & Mourne

3,927

3,749

3,724

Newtownabbey

2,898

2,829

2,762

North Down

2,182

2,118

2,098

Omagh

2,444

2,278

2,296

Strabane

2,278

2,197

2,166

Unallocated Postcode*

457

584

548

Total

71,775

69,445

68,375

In producing this analysis, individual records were allocated to Electoral wards and Parliamentary Constituency on the basis of their postcode. Not all records can be correctly allocated to a ward using this method and some cannot be allocated at all.

Table 3: Incapacity Benefit recipients by Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office boundary

Social Security Office/Jobs and Benefits Office

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

Andersonstown

2,148

2,117

2,080

Antrim

2,188

2,165

2,159

Armagh

2,113

1,920

1,870

Ballymena

2,322

2,315

2,312

Ballymoney

1,827

1,775

1,717

Ballynahinch

1,084

1,059

1,039

Banbridge

2,058

1,969

1,970

Bangor

2,327

2,271

2,262

Carrickfergus

1,478

1,436

1,415

Coleraine

2,042

1,984

1,942

Cookstown

1,398

1,383

1,368

Corporation Street

3,135

3,033

2,983

Downpatrick

1,260

1,243

1,227

Dungannon

2,106

1,989

1,941

Enniskillen

2,155

1,996

1,992

Falls Road

1,803

1,781

1,720

Foyle

3,276

3,197

3,081

Holywood Road

2,901

2,758

2,671

Kilkeel

587

586

577

Knockbreda

2,447

2,340

2,291

Larne

1,157

1,144

1,140

Limavady

1,291

1,237

1,269

Lisburn

2,661

2,651

2,593

Lisnagelvin

2,375

2,310

2,289

Lurgan

2,948

2,820

2,747

Magherafelt

1,792

1,733

1,701

Newcastle

817

789

795

Newry

3,159

3,001

2,970

Newtownabbey

2,389

2,283

2,188

Newtownards

2,329

2,249

2,265

Omagh

2,378

2,219

2,238

Portadown

2,114

1,982

1,980

Shaftesbury Square

1,586

1,589

1,558

Shankill Road

1,368

1,325

1,284

Strabane

2,284

2,198

2,169

Unallocated Postcode*

472

598

572

Total

71,775

69,445

68,375

Incapacity Benefit is a centralised benefit and therefore has no Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office indicator. Table 3 is a breakdown of customers whose postcodes fall within each of the 35 Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office boundaries. ‘Unallocated Postcode’ in this instance refers to those postcodes which cannot be referenced on the Geographic Information System and cannot therefore be assigned to a Social Security Office/Jobs & Benefits Office boundary.

Complaints of Damp in Housing Executive Homes
Mr Storey asked the Minister for Social Development how many complaints the Housing Executive has received about (i) damp; and (ii) condensation problems, in each of the last 3 years, broken down by District Office.
(AQW 8822/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The table below details the number of repair reports made by Housing Executive tenants regarding dampness or condensation by district office area, for the period requested. It is not possible to disaggregate these figures.

District Office

2005/06

2006/07

2007/08

East Belfast

148

94

70

North Belfast

210

232

164

South Belfast

46

65

58

West Belfast

158

137

81

Shankill

61

50

55

Bangor

33

37

34

Castlereagh

67

40

33

Downpatrick

45

32

23

Lisburn/Antrim Street

45

52

49

Lisburn Dairyfarm

93

69

44

Newtownards

59

91

32

Armagh

41

70

22

Banbridge

31

19

19

Dungannon

10

13

11

Fermanagh

37

35

26

Lurgan

47

41

52

Newry

88

135

180

Portadown

50

67

42

Antrim

36

14

11

Ballycastle

7

5

11

Ballymena

17

41

25

Ballymoney

25

21

17

Carrickfergus

8

18

25

Coleraine

12

18

13

Larne

8

4

8

Newtownabbey 1

26

37

33

Newtownabbey 2

23

18

13

Collon Terrace

73

98

128

Cookstown

14

15

14

Limavady

7

17

25

Magherafelt

7

9

16

Omagh

22

38

22

Strabane

73

70

75

Waterloo Place

163

150

114

Waterside

48

83

45

Total

1,838

1,935

1,590

Alternative Development Organisations Created by Housing Associations
Mr Savage asked the Minister for Social Development what Housing Associations have created alternative development organisations for the purchase of land or buildings in Northern Ireland.
(AQW 8830/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The following Housing Associations have created alternative development organisations for the purchase of land or buildings in Northern Ireland:

BIH
Clanmil
Connswater
Fold
Habinteg
North & West
Oaklee
Trinity

Initiatives in South Antrim
Mr Burns asked the Minister for Social Development to detail any major initiatives being undertaken by her Department in the South Antrim constituency in the next 6 months.
(AQW 8843/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Under urban regeneration my department expects to complete the masterplan of Antrim town centre and commence work on a significant public realm enhancement scheme in Ballyclare town centre. The department will also continue to proactively drive forward the implementation of the Neighbourhood Action Plans drawn up for the Ballyclare and Rathcoole Neighbourhood Renewal Areas and the construction of the Rathenraw Community Development and Health project.

Three social housing schemes at Toome, Crumlin and Antrim, with a total of 27 houses will also complete.

Independent Appeals Tribunal for Equality
Mr Dallat asked the Minister for Social Development what plans she has to investigate the independent appeals tribunal for equality, value for money and competency when adjudicating on appeals.
(AQW 8853/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The appeal tribunals are independent judicial bodies, composed of members taken from a panel appointed by the Lord Chancellor. The Member may wish to write directly to the President of Appeal Tribunals at 6^th Floor, Cleaver House, 3, Donegall Square North, Belfast, BT1 5GA for a response to his question.

Bids for Additional Funding
Mr Lunn asked the Minister for Social Development what bids she has submitted for additional funding for improvements to housing under the management of the Housing Executive.
(AQW 8872/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Bids were submitted to the June Monitoring Round but were not met. I will continue to bid in future monitoring rounds.

Shortfall in Funding for the Housing Executive
Mr Lunn asked the Minister for Social Development for her assessment of the shortfall in funding for the Housing Executive, against the expected budget forecasts for the 2008-09 and 2009-10 financial years.
(AQW 8874/08)

Ms M Ritchie: I was able to secure an additional £205m for the Social Housing Development Programme over the next three years to deliver 5,250 new social houses.

The Housing Executive is facing a potential shortfall in its budget for 2008/09 due to a forecast reduction in capital receipts from house and land sales. Action is being taken to seek alternative sources of income

I will continue to make bids for additional funding in future monitoring rounds.

Saleable Housing Executive Assets
Mr Lunn asked the Minister for Social Development what assets the Housing Executive can release through sales of land and housing.
(AQW 8875/08)

Ms M Ritchie: The Housing Executive has undeveloped land assets valued at some £197m which will be either sold to housing associations to provide social housing or where there is no social housing need, sold on the open market. In addition, sales of properties to tenants will continue.

Warm Homes Scheme
Mr Lunn asked the Minister for Social Development what the timetable is for a review of the Warm Homes Scheme.
(AQW 8876/08)

Ms M Ritchie: My officials have been working for some time on a review of the Warm Homes Scheme, based in part on the emerging findings of the Northern Ireland’s Audit Office Value for Money report published on 23 June. A new scheme document is currently being drafted and it is planned to publish this for consultation in the Autumn.

Benefit Uptake by Pensioners
Mr Weir asked the Minister for Social Development what action her Department is taking to increase benefit uptake by pensioners.
(AQW 8879/08)

Ms M Ritchie: In May 2008 I launched the 2008/09 Benefit Uptake Programme to increase awareness of social security benefits. This will build on the previous successful uptake programmes which have been in place since 2005. These programmes have resulted in £15 million of additional benefit paid to the most vulnerable in our society, £11 million of which was paid to pensioners. This Programme includes:

three targeted exercises delivered by Citizens Advice focusing on over 18,000 clients, aged 60 years or over. Each client will be contacted by the Agency and encouraged to have a full benefit assessment through Citizens Advice;

a client focused mail shot to approximately 80,000 households advising them of State Pension Credit and directing them to the Pension Service prior to the reduction of backdating of State Pension Credit from 12 months to 3 months in October 2008; and

contact with up to 10,000 new State Retirement Pension clients who will be advised of their potential eligibility to State Pension Credit. Those deemed more at risk will receive follow-up contact to further encourage the making of a claim.

This is in addition to the range of services provided on a daily basis to ensure that people are advised of their potential entitlement to benefits.

Co-Ownership Housing Association
Mr McClarty asked the Minister for Social Development if she has any plans to announce a new Co-Ownership Scheme.
(AQW 8897/08)

Ms M Ritchie: Northern Ireland Co-ownership Housing Association is the only provider of co-ownership housing in Northern Ireland and there are no plans to duplicate the scheme. However, I remain concerned at the growing affordability gap, exacerbated in recent months by the cost of borrowing. I am, as recommended by my independent panel of experts, looking at how we could bring forward further affordable housing opportunities such as developer-led shared equity schemes. I hope to be able to provide further details on such initiatives in the coming weeks.

Assembly Commission

Use of Blackberrys in the Assembly Chamber
Ms Ní Chuilín asked the Assembly Commission what consideration it has given to allowing the use of Blackberrys in the chamber, for e-mail use only.
(AQW 7590/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): The Assembly Commission has not, as yet, received a formal request for the use of Blackberrys or any other electronic devices in the Chamber. If it were to do so the Assembly Commission would take advice from the appropriate Directorate with regard to any potential technical implications for implementing such a change.

Office of the Keeper Staff
Mr Attwood asked the Assembly Commission (i) how many staff are employed in the Office of the Keeper; (ii) the job titles of the Office of the Keeper staff; (iii) whether there are proposals to revise the staff structure in the Office of the Keeper, including any proposals for new positions; and (iv) how recruitment for any new positions will be conducted.
(AQW 8070/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): (i) The total number of staff currently employed in the Office of the Keeper (Properties Directorate) is 80.
The current staffing breakdown is as follows; (Please see attached organization chart)

1 x Clerk** (Acting/Grade 6 Director)
3 x Deputy Principals (Head of Security, Head of Business Services and Head of Estates)
5 x AAC (Deputy/Head of Security, Project Officer, Building Management**, Facilities Branch** and Health and Safety Officer**)
5 x Clerical Supervisor (Security Branch, Estates, Facilities Branch**, Building Management** and Stationery** – no specific job titles))
5 x Clerical Officer* (Security Branch x 2, Stationery x 3 – no specific job titles)
2 x Principal Doorkeeper (Managerial role, 1 Principal door keeper on temporary promotion)
4 x Senior Doorkeepers (Supervisory role, 1 Senior Door keeper on temporary promotion)
43 x Doorkeepers* (22 permanent and 21 agency, responsible for internal door keeping duties at Parliament Buildings and annexe ‘C’)
12 x Security Guards* (responsible for control room duties, search facility and external security)

*Includes Brook Street agency staff.
** Includes staff on temporary promotion
A number of vacant posts also exist as follows:
1 x Clerk (Project Manager – Accommodation, staff member to be appointed)
5 x Assistant Assembly Clerks (Health and Safety Facilities Branch and Building Management, Sustainability Officer and New Accommodation project.
3 x Clerical Supervisor – Stationery, Facilities and Building Management)
6 x Clerical Officer – Security Branch, Facilities Branch, Health and Safety, Building Management x 2 and Accommodation project
7 x Door keepers
4 x Security Guards
ii) As above
(iii) From 4^th August 2008 a new Director post at Grade 5 level will be appointed, this post was filled by open competition. This new post will replace the existing Acting/Grade 6 post. As mentioned above a new Clerk post at Grade 7 (Project Manager, Accommodation project) has been created however; no appointment has been made to this post.
(iv) Recently the Assembly has been giving consideration to the possibility of moving to filling posts through a mix of external recruitment and internal promotion. The Assembly Commission has recently agreed, in principle, to consider a relaxation from its policy of filling all posts through external recruitment. Furthermore, it was agreed that the Commission would be consulted on the proposals for each competition including any associated legal and/or equality issues and risks.

Properties Directorate Present

*Temporary promotion

Organisation chart includes current staffing in black with vacant posts in red.

Team-Building Exercises
Mr Weir asked the Assembly Commission how many staff hours have been taken up with Commission or cross-directorate away days, involving the Commission, or team-building exercises, in each of the last five years.
(AQW 8605/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): With reference to your question, a total of 92 staff hours have been utilised during the three away days which the Assembly Commission has held from their appointment on the 9^th May 2007.

Facilities in Parliament Buildings for People with Hearing and Visual Difficulties
Mr Durkan asked the Assembly Commission what are the facilities provided in Parliament Buildings for people with visual and hearing difficulties.
(AQW 8732/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): While the Northern Ireland Assembly strives to ensure there are sufficient facilities for all building users and visitors to Parliament Buildings, due to the layout and nature of the building there are certain constraints.

The available facilities for people with visual difficulties are limited as current arrangements require visitors to the building to be escorted at all times. However, recent improvements to the building include the provision of contrast strips and continuous hand railing to all staircases. In addition to this, the existing lifts were upgraded, this included improvements to the internal lighting and colour contrasts, the addition of voice indication of the floor reached and the installation of tactile identification on all floor levels.

The facilities currently available for people with hearing difficulties include deaf alerters which are available at Reception. The deaf alerter will vibrate when the fire alarm is activated to warn the holder that they must leave the building immediately. For all building users who feel that they need assistance during a fire evacuation there is a Personal Emergency Evacuation Plan (PEEP) which is to be completed in conjunction with the Fire Precaution Officer. The completion of the questionnaire and associated PEEP will ensure that building users requiring assistance will know what the emergency procedures are, how they will be alerted, who will assist them to evacuate the premises, what additional equipment, if any, is required and give precise details of the evacuation procedures and safe routes to use during practice and real evacuations.

There are deaf loop systems installed in the Great Hall, the Long Gallery, Committee Rooms 135, 144, 21 and 152, the Assembly Chamber and Senate. The Assembly Commission has recently upgraded the deaf loop system in room 152 and due to its success plans to upgrade the systems in the remaining committee rooms. This work is due to take place in conjunction with other planned work for the committee rooms. In addition to this there are portable deaf loop systems at Reception, in the Members’ bar, the shop and the basement restaurant available for use.

The Assembly Commission has provided text phones to several offices within Parliament Buildings and there are plans to purchase additional ones as required.

The Assembly Commission has also produced a disability action plan and is keen to consult with interested organisations. Details of the plan are available on the Northern Ireland Assembly website: http://archive.niassembly.gov.uk/disability.htm

Team-Building Exercises
Mr Weir asked the Assembly Commission how many away days and team-building exercises have been organised by the Commission for Assembly staff in each of the last five years.
(AQW 8824/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): In response to your question, there have been 6 away day exercises organised for members of senior management within the Secretariat. The table below displays the information by the year in which they occurred:

Year

Number of Away Day / team building exercises

Staff Involved

2008

1

Senior Management Team.

2007

2

Senior Management Team and Directors.

2006

2

Senior Management Team, Directors and Heads of Business.

2005

1

Senior Management Team, Directors and Heads of Business.

2004

0

Legal Proceedings Initiated Against the Commission
Mr Attwood asked the Assembly Commission to detail the nature of any legal proceedings initiated against the Commission by (i) current; and (ii) former, members of Commission staff.
(AQW 8884/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): The details of legal proceedings initiated against the Assembly Commission by current and former members of staff are provided in tabular form attached.

(i) Cases initiated by current members of staff

Nature of case

Outcome

Equal Pay - Discrimination on the grounds of Sex

Outstanding

Harassment on grounds of race

Following a formal investigation of the complaint, the perpetrator was dismissed and settlement reached with claimant

Unfair treatment on grounds of disability discrimination

Claim withdrawn

Discrimination on grounds of age, disability, gender and religion

Claim withdrawn

(ii) Cases initiated by former members of staff

Nature of Case

Outcome

Harassment and Victimisation on grounds of Religious and Political Discrimination

Outstanding

Unfair dismissal

Claim withdrawn

Discrimination on grounds of Religion and political opinion

Claim withdrawn

Sexual harassment

Harassment complaint not upheld. The claim was settled and met jointly with Brook Street UK Ltd.

Application for judicial review of decision to seek termination of three secondments

Withdrawn

Unfair treatment on grounds of Religious and Political Discrimination and Sex Discrimination

Outstanding

Unfair treatment on grounds of Religious and Political Discrimination

Outstanding

Unfair treatment on grounds of Religious and Political Discrimination

Outstanding

Unfair Dismissal and discrimination on grounds of Sex, Age and Disability

Outstanding

Judicial Review
Mr Attwood asked the Assembly Commission if it intends to lodge in the Library, for the information of MLAs, copies of affidavits filed by, or on behalf of, the Commission by (i) Members of the Commission; (ii) Assembly staff; and (iii) other persons, in relation to the Judicial Review initiated against the Commission by former members of the Assembly Secretariat.
(AQW 8899/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): The Assembly Commission has not been asked to consider using the library to house copies of any material in relation to the judicial review. The Commission would be prepared to consider such a request, at the earliest meeting, following summer recess.

Judicial Review
Mr Attwood asked the Assembly Commission if it consulted its legal advisers on the advice provided by the Speaker to the Assembly on Tuesday 17 June in relation to the judicial review against the Commission initiated by former staff of the Secretariat.
(AQW 8900/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): The Assembly Commission holds no responsibility in relation to what the Speaker says in the Chamber. The Commission, as a general rule, does not confirm whether it has or has not taken legal advice.

Recruitment of Assembly Staff
Mr Attwood asked the Assembly Commission how many people successfully completed all stages of the recruitment processes for the posts of Clerk and Assistant Assembly Clerk respectively; how many Assembly Clerk and Assistant Assembly Clerk posts the Commission intended to appoint; how many people have accepted offers of employment in respect of each post; and a breakdown in respect of each post between persons who have previously worked as Assembly Clerk and Assistant Assembly Clerk and those who have no such experience.
(AQW 8985/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): To date (16 July), eight candidates have successfully completed all stages of the recruitment process for the position of Assembly Clerk and eleven candidates have successfully completed all stages of the recruitment process for the position of Assistant Assembly Clerk. Pre-appointment enquiries are continuing in respect of three further Assembly Clerk candidates and it is expected that offers of appointment will issue when completed.

At the time the recruitment competitions began the Commission envisaged filling nine Assembly Clerk and thirty one Assistant Assembly Clerk vacancies respectively. However since then two further Assembly Clerk vacancies have arisen which are expected to be filled from the list of successful candidates.

To date three candidates in the Assembly Clerk competition and seven candidates in the Assistant Assembly Clerk competition have accepted offers of appointment. A further five Assembly Clerk offers of appointment and one Assistant Assembly Clerk offer of appointment are still under consideration by successful candidates.

Of the nine offers of appointment made in the Assembly Clerk competition, two were to candidates with previous experience of working as Assembly Clerks; of the eleven offers of appointment made in the Assistant Assembly Clerk competition, four were made to candidates with previous experience of working as Assistant Assembly Clerks (one of whom declined). A further candidate in the Assistant Assembly Clerk competition has withdrawn.

Recruitment of Assembly Staff
Mr Attwood asked the Assembly Commission if persons appointed under the recruitment exercise for the posts of Assembly Clerk and Assistant Assembly Clerk are to be appointed on the same pay, terms and conditions relevant to each post and, if not, on what basis variations in pay, terms and conditions may arise at or after appointment.
(AQW 8986/08)

The Representative of the Assembly Commission (Rev Dr R Coulter): The NI Assembly Commission has committed to the development and introduction of bespoke terms and conditions of employment, including pay and allowances, for secretariat staff by 2010. It is envisaged that this will be a progressive process. Currently, except where specific changes have already been negotiated, NI Civil Service Terms and Conditions of Employment apply to all secretariat staff. Those terms and conditions include limited, regulated, provision for variation on pay depending on individual and organisational circumstances.

Appointments from all ongoing recruitment competitions, including those for Assembly Clerk and Assistant Assembly Clerk, will be under the NICS Terms and Conditions relating to Starting Pay on Appointment and Starting Pay on Transfer to a Substantive Grade. A copy of these procedures is attached for your information.

The only variations which may be applied are in respect of staff currently seconded to the Assembly who have recently been successful in open competition for positions equivalent to their current NICS Grade. The Assembly Commission decided that, in the interests of business continuity and the need to retain relevant experience, these staff should suffer "no detriment" in respect of their current salary, terms and conditions etc upon appointment. They are however required to sever their employment status with the NICS and become permanent employees of the Assembly Commission.}}}}

Primary		Post-Primary		Both
Primary	Nursery	Grammar	Secondary	Peripatetic*	Special*
975	90	157	738	18	186
1065		895		204

DISTRICT COUNCIL	WINDFARMS (No.)
Ballymena	2
Ballymoney	2
Dungannon	1
Fermanagh	3
Limavady	3
Omagh	2
Strabane	3
NORTHERN IRELAND	16

NUTS 3 name	Total GVA £million, 2005	GVA per head £, 2005 #	Population
London*	206,324	27,672	7,456,073
Birmingham	18,038	17,984	1,002,982
Leeds	15,268	20,613	740,689
Glasgow City	14,108	24,375	578,790
Sheffield	8,265	15,823	522,368
Bradford	6,623	13,572	487,975
Edinburgh, City of	13,017	28,432	457,830
Liverpool	7,133	16,321	437,052
Manchester	No appropriate NUTS3 region
Bristol, City of	9,506	23,434	405,641
Belfast	7,180	26,792	267,999

Community Background	People living in SOAs which are:		Total
Community Background	More than 90% Catholic	More than 90% Protestant	Total
Catholic	255,612	8,223	263,835
Protestant and Other Christian (including Christian related)	8,747	202,294	211,041
Other religions and philosophies	401	660	1,061
No community background	1,345	6,976	8,321
Total number of people in areas	266,105	218,153	484,258

Year	2004/2005	2005/2006	2006/2007
Cataract Operations	8,391	9,441	8,718

Trust	Number of People Waiting (Monthly Timebands)
Trust	>3-6	>6-9	>9-12	12+
Belfast HSC Trust	554	0	0	0
South Eastern HSC Trust	24	0	0	0
Southern HSC Trust	29	0	0	0
Western HSC Trust	72	0	0	0
Northern Ireland Total	679	0	0	0

Health and Social Care Trust	2004/05	2005/06	2006/07
Belfast	12	9	11
Northern	30	19	13
South Eastern	7	5	0
Southern	4	13	9
Western	4	3	6
Prison	6	1	2
Total	63	50	41

YEAR	STAFF IN POST (WHOLE TIME EQUIVALENTS)	% PAY AWARD
2005/06	978	3.225
2006/07	1,039	2.5
2007/08	1,076	2.5

Year	No of ‘Deliberate’/ ‘Malicious’ Fires	Cost
2007/08	370	£808,000
2006/07	285	£634,000
2005/06	181	£374,000

Place of Death	Registration Year
Place of Death	2005	2006	2007^P
Royal Group of Hospitals	2	1	5
Belfast City Hospital	3	8	8
Forester Green Hospital	-	-	-
Mater Infirmorum Hospital	-	2	1
Musgrave Park Hospital	1	1	-
All other Hospital	29	51	63
All Clostridium Difficile Related Deaths Registered in all places	35	63	77

Year	Number of staff employed as homehelp/domiciliary care workers
2007/08	1527

Year	Number of staff with days lost more than 5	Number of staff with days lost more than 20
2007/08	112	91

HSS Organisation	Legal Firms appointed to handle compensation claims	Appointment made using pubic procurement processes
Eastern Health and Social Services Board	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	Yes
Northern Health and Social Services Board	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	No
Southern Health and Social Services Board	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	Yes
Western Health and Social Services Board	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	Yes
Belfast Health and Social Care Trust	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency MSC Daly, Solicitors Carson McDowell, Solicitors Fisher & Fisher, Solicitors	Yes No Yes Yes
South Eastern Health and Social Care Trust	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency Carson McDowell, Solicitors	Yes Yes
Northern Health and Social Care Trust	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	Yes
Southern Health and Social Care Trust	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency Carson McDowell, Solicitors	Yes Yes
Western Health and Social Care Trust	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	Yes
Northern Ireland Ambulance Service	Directorate of Legal Services, Central Services Agency	Yes

Year	2003-04	2004-05	2005-06	2006-07
	£000s	£000s	£000s	£000s
Eastern Board	60,946	63,052	66,220	69,022
Northern Board	27,731	34,560	35,081	36,782
Southern Board	28,841	31,457	33,896	34,832
Western Board	19,455	20,676	23,249	24,424
	136,973	149,744	158,445	165,060

Year	Admissions
2002/03	194
2003/04	164
2004/05	183
2005/06	157
2006/07	171

TRUST	PROJECT DETAILS	CAPITAL EXPENDITURE IN LAST 5 YEARS (2003-2008) (£m)
Belfast	Muckamore Abbey Redevelopment	15.4
Belfast	Health & Wellbeing Centres in North & West Belfast (Grove, Carlisle, Shankill, Beechhall)	19.5
Belfast	Community Treatment & Care Centres (Holywood Arches, Bradbury Place, Castlereagh)	18.7
Belfast	Regional Secure Unit, Knockbracken	8.3
Belfast	Regional Acquired Brain Injury Unit, Musgrave Park	9.5
Belfast	Regional Cancer Centre, Belfast City Hospital (inc car park)	52.4
Belfast	RVH Redevelopment - including Imaging Centre, Receipt & Distribution Centre, Critical Care building)	53.1
Belfast	RVH Central Decontamination Unit	11.6
Belfast	Victoria Pharmaceuticals	0.7
TOTAL BELFAST TRUST		189.2

Southern	Mental Health Inpatient Unit at CAH (Bluestone Unit)	13.3
Southern	Trauma & Orthopaedics Unit at CAH	5.7
Southern	Portadown Health & Care Centre	3.5
TOTAL SOUTHERN TRUST		22.5

Western	Stradreagh - replacement hospital based facilities for people with learning disabilities	5.1
Western	South West Hospital (inc land purchase, enabling works, project mgt costs)	24.2
Western	Omagh Local Hospital (inc land purchase, enabling works, project mgt costs)	16.5
Western	Altnagelvin Hospital	43.9
Western	Altnagelvin - Laboratories & Pharmacy Unit	18
TOTAL WESTERN TRUST		107.7

Health & Social Care Trust	Qualified Nursing Staff		Nurse Support Staff		All Nursing Staff
Health & Social Care Trust	Headcount	WTE	Headcount	WTE	Headcount	WTE
Belfast	121	109.0	98	89.0	219	198.0
Northern	73	68.7	26	18.7	99	87.5
South Eastern	23	17.4	3	1.5	26	18.9
Southern	61	53.6	17	14.1	78	67.7
Western	21	19.5	1	1.0	22	20.5
Other Organisations	4	4.0	0	0.0	4	4.0
Total	303	272.2	145	124.4	448	396.5

Electoral Ward	June 2008
Ballynafeigh	2
Beechill	2
Blackstaff	1
Botanic	4
Malone	17
Musgrave	9
Newtownbreda	5
Ravenhill	8
Rosetta	6
Shaftesbury	6
Stranmillis	11

Health Social & Services Trusts	2003	2004	2005	2006
Altnagelvin Hospital	17	22	21	11
Belfast City Hospital	55	47	39	32
Causeway	9	9	10	9
Craigavon Area Hospital	25	24	20	19
Down Lisburn	12	17	7	5
Green park health centre	5	2	3	5
Mater Infirmorum	25	9	23	29
Newry & Mourne	10	5	3	3
Royal Group of hospitals	42	44	49	49
Sperrin Lakeland	15	16	6	9
Ulster Community & Hospitals	23	34	25	37
United Hospitals	46	41	37	37
Totals	284	270	243	245

Health & Social care Trusts	2007
BELFAST
Belfast City Hospital	33
NICCO (Formerly at Belvior park)	3
Foster Green Hospital/Green Park	0
Musgrave Park Hospital	2
Mater Infirmorum	21
Royal Victoria Hospital	45
RJMH	0
RBHSC	4
Total	108
NORTHERN
Antrim Area Hospital	20
Mid Ulster Hospital	2
Moyle Hospital	0
Braid Valley Hospital	2
Whiteabbey Hospital	13
Causeway Hospital	8
Dalriada Hospital	0
Robinson Memorial Hospital	0
Total	45
SOUTH EASTERN
Ulster Hospital	32
Ards Hospital	0
Bangor hospital	0
Downe Hospital	3
Lagan Valley Hospital	4
Total	39
SOUTHERN
Daisy Hill	4
Craigavon Area Hospital	7
Lurgan	3
South Tyrone Hospital	0
Mullinure	0
Total	14
WESTERN
Altnagelvin Area hospital	11
Waterside	0
Earne Hospital	7
Tyrone County hospital	5
Total	23
Overall Total 2007	229

Assessments for Traffic Calming Measures in Larne Borough Council Area
Current Priority Ranking	Location	Score
1	Linn Road	140
2	Upper Cairncastle Road	125
3	Ballygalley Village	100

Area	Central	Northern	Southern
Gender
Female	200	106	104
Male	575	754	791
Total	775	860	895

Perceived religious affiliation
Protestant	523	415	472
Catholic	235	424	393
Other	17	21	30
Total	775	860	895

SURFACE DRESSING FOR THE 2008 SUMMER SEASON
Division	Amount (Issued as at 30 June 2008)
Northern Division	£800,000
Southern Division	£440,000,
Eastern Division	Nil
Western Division	£570,000
Total	£1,810,000

Local Area Office	All Interruptions >3hrs (1 Jun 07 to 31 May 08)
Antrim	47
Ards/Bangor	108
Armagh	82
Ballykeel	54
Clogher/Ballygawley	61
Coleraine	78
Downpatrick	80
Enniskillen	29
Londonderry	67
Lisburn	43
Magherafelt	52
Newry/Seagoe	151
Omagh/Strabane	97
Belfast/Carrickfergus	149
TOTAL	1,098

	All Interruptions >3hrs (1 Jun 07 to 31 May 08)
NORTH	77
SOUTH EAST	730
WEST	2
TOTAL	809

GRAND TOTAL	1,907

2003/04	£1,815
2004/05	£600
2005/06	£2,103
2006/07	£165
2007/08	£2,200

Programme	2007/08	2008/09	2009/10
Concessionary Fares Scheme	£22.05m	£28.95m	£30.02m
Rural Transport Fund	£3.75m	£3.75m	£3.75m

LISBURN ROAD	LOWER MALONE ROAD	STRANMILLS
Adelaide Avenue Ashley Avenue Ashley Drive Ashley Mews Belgravia Avenue Brookland Street Chadwick Street Donnybrook Street Edinburgh Street Ethel Street Fane Street Great Northern Street	Cussick Street Eglantine Avenue Eglantine Gardens Eglantine Place Malone Avenue Malone Road Wellesley Avenue Wellington Lane Wellington Park Wellington Park Avenue Wellington Park Mews Wellington Park Terrace	Chlorine Gardens Colenso Parade Elaine Street Landsleer Street Lennoxvale Mount Pleasant Pretoria Street Ridgeway Street Riverview Street Sanhurst Drive Sandhurst Gardens Sandymount Street
LISBURN ROAD	LOWER MALONE ROAD	STRANMILLS
Lisburn Avenue Lorne Street Lower Windsor Avenue Meadowbank Place Meadowbank Street Melrose Street Mount Prospect Park Northbrook Gardens Northbrook Street Rathcool Street Rathdrum Street Rathgar Street Sandringham Street Sloan Crescent Surrey Street Tates Avenue Ulsterville Avenue Ulsterville Drive Ulsterville Gardens Ulsterville Place Windsor Drive Windsor Road	Windsor Avenue Windsor Avenue North	St Albans Gardens St Ives Gardens Strandview Street Stranmillis Court Stranmillis Gardens Stranmillis Mews Stranmillis Park Stranmillis Road Stranmillis Street