Caravans Bill
EXPLANATORY AND FINANCIAL MEMORANDUM
INTRODUCTION
1. This Explanatory and Financial Memorandum has been prepared by the Department for Social Development on behalf of John McCallister MLA, the Bill’s sponsor, in order to assist the reader of the Bill and to help inform debate on it. It does not form part of the Bill and has not been endorsed by the Assembly.
2. The Memorandum needs to be read in conjunction with the Bill. It is not, and is not meant to be, a comprehensive description of the Bill. So where a clause or part of a clause or schedule does not seem to require an explanation or comment, none is given.
BACKGROUND AND POLICY OBJECTIVES
3. The Bill is a private member’s Bill and it has Government support. The Bill has been prepared by Government on behalf of John McCallister MLA, the Bill’s sponsor.
4. The purpose of the Bill is to introduce statutory protections, similar to those which already exist in Great Britain, for those who occupy a caravan as their main residence on sites which have been approved for that purpose.
5. The Bill also creates a level of protection for caravan owners on seasonal sites by introducing a requirement for written agreements to be in place between site owners and caravan owners. No similar provisions exist in Great Britain.
CONSULTATION
6. The consultation process was initiated in June 2008 where in excess of 200 key stakeholders were advised of John McCallister's intention to create a private member's Bill to legislate for the regulation of permanent residential and static holiday caravan sites. The stakeholders included caravan site owners, residential associations, caravan manufacturers, local Councils, recognised industry organisations and caravan owners themselves. A positive response was received which resulted in many follow-up meetings, particularly with site owners and the trade organisations, all of whom provided invaluable insight into the running of caravan sites and drew attention to any financial implications arising from the proposed legislation.
7. A further consultation was undertaken in October 2009 where stakeholders had sight of the first version of the draft Bill. This did create some concern over some of the clauses and as a result the Bill has undergone significant re-drafting. Throughout the various stages of the process, John McCallister has continued to engage with key stakeholders, particularly the British Holiday and Home Parks Association, the National Caravan Council, the National Association of Caravan Owners, the Camping and Caravan Forum for Northern Ireland and the Trading Standards Service in DETI. He has also met with the Human Rights Commission to discuss the implications for caravan sites used by the Irish Traveller Community; the Commission welcomed the Bill and expressed full support.
OPTIONS CONSIDERED
8. A wide range of options has been considered. The option of ‘doing nothing’ has been discounted by the Northern Ireland Assembly which, on 4 June 2007, carried a motion calling for greater statutory protection for caravan owners along the lines of existing legislation in Great Britain.
9. Consultation identified the need to go further than this and include some level of protection for caravan owners on seasonal sites. This is a departure from the statutory position in Great Britain where no similar protections currently exist.
10. The option of providing a level of protection for caravan owners on seasonal sites, akin to that which the Bill provides for permanent caravan residents on protected sites, was considered. However, there is already a considerable body of consumer protection law which, in conjunction with the Bill’s requirement for written agreements, can provide a significant level of protection for caravan owners on seasonal sites.
COMMENTARY ON CLAUSES
The Bill has five parts, totalling seventeen clauses, and a Schedule (in three parts). A commentary on the provisions follows. Comments are not given where the wording is self-explanatory.
Part 1: Agreements for residential occupiers on protected sites
Clause 1 - Application of this Part
Clause 1 clarifies to whom and for what purpose Part 1 of the Bill applies. Part 1 applies to the residential caravan sector and covers any residential agreement made either before or after commencement of the Bill relating to owner-occupiers of caravans who are entitled to station their caravan on a protected site, and occupy it as their only or main residence, for more than three months. The inclusion of this time period is intended to ensure that sites used to provide temporary accommodation are not inappropriately brought within the scope of Part 1.
Protected sites are sites for which planning permission or site licenses do not restrict use of the site to holiday use only or the times of the year during which the site can be used.
Clause 2 – Particulars of agreements
Clause 2 places a requirement on the owners of protected sites to provide caravan owners with written statements covering a range of issues within a specific time period. Clause 2 also provides the Department for Social Development with a power to make regulations extending the range of requirements for the written statement.
Clause 2 provides a mechanism for caravan owners on protected sites to seek redress through the courts where a site owner has failed to provide a written statement in accordance with the requirements of this clause.
Clause 3 – Terms of agreements
Clause 3 refers to Part 1 of the Schedule to the Bill which sets out the terms that are to be implied in any residential agreement.
The remainder of clause 3 describes the powers of the court when matters relating to residential agreements are brought for its consideration, including the terms that a court can order to be implied in a residential agreement (these are included in full in Part 2 of the Schedule to the Bill).
Clause 4 – Power to amend implied terms
Clause 4 provides the Department for Social Development with a power to amend the terms that are to be implied in any residential agreement (Parts 1 and 2 of the Schedule) by subordinate legislation.
Clause 5 – Successors in title
Clause 5 makes provision for residential agreements to continue in effect when ownership of the caravan is lawfully assigned or inherited on the death of the owner. The aim of the provision is to protect the rights of those who lived with the caravan owner. Sub-section (4) covers the rights of succession where the caravan owner lived alone. In these circumstances, there is no automatic right or requirement on the successor in title to live in the caravan as their main or only residence.
Clause 6 – Jurisdiction
Clause 6 provides the county court covering the area in which the protected site is located with the jurisdiction to hear and make decisions on matters relating to residential agreements and other issues included in Part 1 of the Bill. Arbitration is also available as an alternative to court proceedings where the relevant parties have agreed, in writing, to this course of action.
Part 2: Agreements for occupiers of seasonal sites
Clause 7 – Application of this Part
Clause 7 clarifies to whom and for what purpose Part 2 of the Bill applies. Part 2 applies to the seasonal (holiday) caravan sector and covers any seasonal agreement made either before or after commencement of the Bill relating to caravan owners who are entitled to station their caravan on a seasonal (holiday) caravan site for a period exceeding 28 days. The inclusion of this time period is intended to ensure that touring caravans are not inappropriately brought within the scope of Part 2.
Clause 8 – particulars of agreements
Clause 8 places a requirement on the owners of seasonal sites to provide caravan owners with written statements covering the terms and conditions upon which their agreement is based within a specific time limit. Any express term of the agreement not given in writing will be unenforceable by the site owner. The intention is to provide site owners with an incentive to comply with the duty to provide a written statement and protect occupiers from the application of terms that have not been given in writing.
Part 3: Protection of residential occupiers from eviction and harassment
Clause 9 – Application of this Part
Clause 9 clarifies to whom Part 3 of the Bill applies. Part 3 applies to the residential caravan sector and covers both owner-occupiers entitled to station their caravan on a protected site and those who rent a caravan on a protected site, where, in both cases, the caravan is the person’s only or main residence.
Clause 10 – Protection of occupiers against eviction and harassment
Clause 10 protects those living in caravans on residential (protected) caravan sites from eviction (other than through court proceedings) and harassment. It is an offence for the owner of a protected site or their agent to intend to cause the caravan occupier to abandon the caravan, remove it from the site or prevent them having access to their rights or a form of redress by withholding or withdrawing services or doing acts likely to interfere with the peace of comfort of the caravan occupier or anyone living with them.
Sub-section(8) sets out the penalties for a person guilty of such an offence.
Clause 11 – Provision for suspension of eviction orders
Clause 11 establishes the powers of the courts in relation to proceedings for eviction and the factors the court should take into account in such proceedings. The court can suspend the enforcement of an eviction order for up to 12 months providing the relevant caravan is on a site which has a valid site license.
Clause 12 – Supplementary
Clause 12 defines ‘the court’ for the purposes of Part 3 as the county court and clarifies the operation of related legislation in light of Part 3.
Part 4 – Meaning of ‘caravan’
Clause 13 – Meaning of ‘caravan’ in this Act
Clause 13 updates the definition of ‘caravan’ for the purposes of this Bill in line with the current definition of ‘caravan’ which applies in England and Wales.
Clause 13 also provides a power for the Department of the Environment to amend the maximum dimensions of a caravan by subordinate legislation, subject to consultation with those persons or bodies who appear to the Department to be concerned in the matter.
Clause 14 – Definition of ‘caravan’ in Caravans Act
Clause 14 applies the new definition of ‘caravan’ in clause 13 to existing Caravans legislation: the Caravans Act ( Northern Ireland) 1963 (c17).
Part 5 – Supplementary
Clause 15 – Interpretation
Clause 15 defines a number of the terms used in the Bill.
Clause 16 – Commencement
Clause 16 brings all the provisions of the Bill into operation six months after it receives Royal Assent.
Schedule: Agreements under Part 1 of this Act
Part 1: Terms implied by Section 3
Part 1 of the Schedule sets out the terms to be implied in any residential agreement.
Paragraphs 1-2: Duration of agreement
Paragraphs 1 and 2 establish that residential agreements last until they are legitimately ended by either the caravan owner or site owner (in line with the requirements in paragraphs 3 to 6). In cases where planning permission or the site owner’s right to the land are time-limited, residential agreements will be similarly time-limited.
Paragraph 3 – Termination by occupier
Paragraph 3 entitles a caravan owner to terminate a residential agreement as long as they provide the site owner with at least four weeks notice in writing.
Paragraph 4-6 – Termination by owner
Paragraphs 4-6 establish the grounds on which a site owner can seek, through the court, to terminate a residential agreement.
Paragraph 7 – Recovery of overpayments by occupier
Paragraph 7 entitles the caravan owner to recover any payments made to the site owner for the period following the end of any residential agreement.
Paragraph 8 – Sale of caravan
Paragraph 8 establishes the process for the sale of a caravan on a protected site. A caravan owner is entitled to sell a caravan and assign their residential agreement to a person approved by the site owner. The site owner’s approval cannot be unreasonably withheld and must be notified to the caravan owner within 28 days of a written request being made. If this does not occur, the caravan owner can apply to the court for an order approving a person.
The site owner is entitled to receive a maximum commission of 10% on the sale.
Paragraph 10 – Re-siting of caravan
Paragraph 10 allows the site owner to move a caravan to conduct essential or emergency repairs or to apply to the court to move a caravan to another comparable pitch on the site. All costs associated with such moves are the responsibility of the site owner.
Paragraphs 16-20 – The pitch fee
Site owners are entitled to charge a pitch fee and paragraphs 16-20 set out the conditions for changes to and payment of the pitch fee.
The pitch fee can only be changed either with the agreement of the caravan owner or by order of the court.
Paragraph 17 describes the process associated with the annual review of the pitch fee, including mechanisms for dealing with disputes.
Paragraphs 18, 19 and 20 establish the factors that can be taken into account in determining the new pitch fee.
Paragraphs 22-25 – Owner’s obligations
Paragraphs 22-25 establish the site owner’s obligations. These include providing written information on a range of issues, such as charges payable under the residential agreement, and requirements to consult caravan owners and any qualifying residents’ association on site improvements and pitch fees.
Paragraphs 26-27 – Owner’s name and address
Paragraph 26 requires the site owner to provide caravan owners and any qualifying residents’ associations with an address in Northern Ireland. Caravan owners can, in certain circumstances, reasonably withhold pitch fee payments until such information is provided. All notices from the site owner must also include an address in Northern Ireland.
Paragraph 27 similarly requires site owners to provide an address in Northern Ireland on any demand for payment. Caravan owners can, in certain circumstances, reasonably withhold payments until such information is provided.
Paragraph 28 – Qualifying residents’ association
Paragraph 28 establishes the circumstances in which a residents’ association on a protected site becomes a qualifying residents’ association which the site owner must consult on matters such as changes in pitch fees.
Part 2: Matters concerning which terms may be implied by court.
Clause 3 of the Bill allows the court to order that certain terms are implied in a residential agreement. These terms are set out in full in Part 2 of the Schedule.
Part 3: Supplementary provisions
Part 3 of the Schedule relates to paragraphs 8 and 9 (sale of caravan) of Part 1 of the Schedule and provides for circumstances in which a caravan owner makes a request to someone other than the site owner to approve a person to whom the caravan owner wishes to sell their caravan and assign the residential agreement. Part 3 places a duty on the person who receives the request (providing the tests in sub-paragraph (2) are met) to take reasonable steps to ensure the request reaches the site owner in a timely way and a form of redress where this duty is not fully exercised.
FINANCIAL EFFECTS OF THE BILL
12. It is not anticipated that the Bill will give rise to any significant additional expenditure.
HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUES
13. The provisions of the Bill are compatible with the Convention on Human Rights.
EQUALITY IMPACT ASSESSMENT
14. The Bill does not give rise to any issues selectively affecting any groups listed in section 75 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998.
SUMMARY OF THE REGULATORY IMPACT ASSESSMENT
15. The main purpose of the Bill is to introduce statutory protections, similar to those which already exist in Great Britain, for those who occupy a caravan as their main residence on sites which have been approved for that purpose.
16. The Bill also creates a level of protection for caravan owners on seasonal sites by introducing a requirement for written agreements to be in place between site owners and caravan owners. While, no similar statutory provisions exist in Great Britain, the proposals are in line with existing industry standards in the UK.
17. Given the above, it is anticipated that the Bill will create limited additional costs for business.
LEGISLATIVE COMPETENCE
John McCallister MLA had made the following statement under section 9 of the Northern Ireland Act 1998:
“In my view the Caravans Bill would be within the legislative competence of the Northern Ireland Assembly.”